Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Sanding question

Posts

Sanding question

#1

Sanding question

Jim Rutten

>Hello all,

I have a request from my wife's sister for "something turned" for Christmas. I have decided on a walnut platter/plate and a mahogany bowl. So here is my question. These two items, for reasons I cannot go into here, need to be perfect (or a fairly close proximity). In the past sanding has been my bane. So, on those things that you make that have to be high quality what is the sanding prodcedure that work best for you. I usually power sand with Steve Worchester disks. What speed do you sand at? Do you sand with the lathe in reverse? Do you spray water on it to raise the grain? What are your steps to get a superior sanded piece? Thanks for your help.

Re: Sanding question

#2

Re: Sanding question

Carole Valentine

>You mean you don't like sanding, Jim? What's wrong with you? ;))) For what it's worth, here is my proceedure:

The obvious first step is to get as good a finish as possible with the tools. (On the inside of bowls and plates, I use a really sharp teardrop scraper for the finishing cuts. You can adjust a teardrop to conform to the exact curve you want. On outside curves I use my gouge to shear cut.) Then get some GOOD side lighting (incandescent) and good glasses if you need them! Start sanding with the lowest grit necessary to remove any remaining tool marks. I use a power sander and the lowest speed on my lathe (100)and a soft pad. Others prefer different pads. Keep the sander moving and don't use a lot of pressure. You don't want to generate a lot of heat - this seems to harden the wood and makes it harder to remove scratches. I sand forward and reverse with each grit, stop the lathe and sand with the grain by hand, blow off the grit and dust with air, then move on to the next grit. Usually at about the 220 stage, I will wet the piece with warm water to raise the grain, let it dry then move on through the remaining grits (usually 600 to 800, but maybe up to 12000 micro-mesh depending on what I am doing) I generally skip the hand-with-the-grain part after about 320. Be very carefull when power sanding not to let the edge of the disk hit the wood - you can end up with deep scratches that are almost impossible to remove! Another thing I do - I run each disk across the corner of my lathe ways before mounting it to knock down any random "giant" grit particles. One thing that drives me nuts is imperfections I could not see at the 180 stage are glaringly obvious at the 320+ stages. Can't tell you how many times I have had to drop back several grits and come back up. :(

Re: Sanding question

#3

Re: Sanding question

Jim Rutten

>Thanks, Carole. This is exactly what I was looking for.

Re: Sanding question

#4

Re: Sanding question

eliot d

>Of course , everybody has their own sanding rituals. I can't see any reason for your not getting excellent results if you power sand through all your grits -- say 80, 120, 180, 220, 320, 400, 600, 800, and 1000. Blow off the piece between each grit, and blow off your power sander , too. It's not a bad idea to reverse your lathe, if you can for each grit; i.e sand twice for each grit with the lathe running in each direction. Most turners sand with the lathe turning fairly slowly and with the sander turning quite slowly, but I often violate this "rule" and haven't had any problems with heat checking, etc. (Once, though, I got aggressive, overheated a piece that was glued up, and it flew apart , injuring me slightly.) If you see sanding marks as you sand that don't sand out easily with the next grit, then you may have to stop the lathe, go back a grit, and power sand just the problem areas. This is important: sanding problem areas forever with the lathe spinning is a waste of time and materials. Sometimes you may have to stop the lathe and HAND sand WITH the grain. I don't wet anything, but it's not a bad idea to wet the piece to raise the grain for some woods. Use just one brand of sandpaper, and always use fresh sandpaper. (One cliche is to sand like you're using the other guy's stuff!.) There's practically no end to all this, like using micro mesh, paper bag. material, etc. Probably the most important advise is to turn very carefully in the final stages under a good light with good technique( like shear scraping,)and sharp tools before you begin to sand. Good luck, and let us know how you made out.

Re: Sanding question

#5

Re: Sanding question

eliot d

>I posted before I saw Carole's post. It's interesting, I think, that we said pretty much the same things. And , yes, I forgot about running the sandpaper over something hard to knock off the odd oversize grit particle.

Re: Sanding question

#6

Re: Sanding question

Jim Rutten

>Thanks, Eliot. It is interesting that you and Carole said practically the same thing.

Re: Sanding question

#7

Re: Sanding question

John Lucas

>Jim Carole and Eliot covered it pretty well. The trick is in learning to look. Blow and/or wipe out the dust between each grit and move the light around to see if you can see any scratches that are deeper than the others. If there are sand lightly at that point. All the scratches should look uniform before you go to the next grit. Some areas and some woods just fight you more than others. These are the times you sand with the lathe not running or you hand sand. spend as much time as necessary in the early grits to get everything looking uniform. Then the finer grits go very quickly.

Re: Sanding question

#8

Re: Sanding question

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Another thing I do - I run each disk across the corner of my lathe ways before mounting it to knock down any random "giant" grit particles.

This is useful and important advice that I've never heard before. Carole, how exactly is this done? Do you drag the grit side across a corner, or the backside?

Re: Sanding question

#9

Re: Sanding question

RussFairfield

>Don't forget lighting. Avoid the "Fluorescent Surprize" by using bright incandescent lighting when sanding. The shadows from the light bulb accent the sanding scratches. The flat light from the flourescent don't.

The "Flourescent Surprize" is all of those sanding scratches that aren't seen until after the wood is finished and you take it into the house.

Re: Sanding question

#10

Re: Sanding question

Jim Rutten

>Thanks, John and Russ. I have done stuff that looks awesome down in the basement and when I get it upstairs my wife finds the inperfections. I have a flourescant light and a halogen but the bulb burnt out a while back and I just got around to replacing it. I think I will add the incandescant light in one of those clamp lamps.

Re: Sanding question

#11

Re: Sanding question

robo hippy

>My main advice is to sand, at each grit, until you think you have all the marks out and then hit it again. I will usually start by sanding at slow speed (50 rpm) to see what problem areas are there, and will then stop the lathe and work on problem spots. Most of the time I can sand the outside without finding any problem spots, but the inside needs more work. Usually I only have stop the lathe with the coarsest grit. Once all of the marks are out, it is smooth sailing. I find myself a lot of the time letting the power sander move the wood with the lathe turned off.

I never rub the sandpaper over anything to knock down the bigger pieces of grit, I never noticed it being necessary.

After each grit, I will usually wipe off the piece by hand to remove dust, and see if there are any scratches from the previous grit that need removing. This is done with the lathe stopped. I don't stop it with each grit (at least not any more), but every other grit or so. The finer dust will go into the deeper scratches, and show them off. I used to hand sand at 150 grit because the straight line scratches would show off the lower grit circular scratches that I missed. I don't do this any more. Do stop to check for scratches that you have missed a few times during the sanding.

I don't reverse sand. With hand sanding this is necessary because if you just go in one direction, the fibers will lay down in that direction. With power sanding this isn't necessary. If you have the pad fairly flat (as opposed to working on an edge) the circular motion will do the same thing as reversing. If you are working with the pad at an angle, you can still do this by using the 3, 6, 9, and 12 o'clock parts of the pad (I don't know if this translates or not, but I never work with the pad at the same angle all of the time).

I like the blue sanding discs from VincesWoodNWonders. They are cut over sized (3 3/8 and 2 3/8 inch) so there isn't a problem with the edge of the disc scratching the wood, and the discs are very flexable. With the disc being bigger than the pad, there are no scratches from the hooks on the pads either. They also seem to outlast anything else I have used about 2 to 1.

Keep one of the crepe (I call them eraser) sticks handy to clean you paper often.

I prefer the slow speed angle drills best. Sanding at higher lathe and drill speeds doesn't speed up the sanding process. Your paper and pads will last longer also.

I don't sand my utility bowls past 400 grit. I did sand one bowl to 2000 grit once, and it was a bit nicer, but not worth the effort. I do apply the oil (Mike Mahoney's) with the grey pads which is kind of like using one last grit.

robo hippy

Re: Sanding question

#12

Re: Sanding question

John Lucas

>Jim I just had a friend come over to the house. His wife complained about his sanding scratches. I think women can see better than men. Just ask Carole. I did what Russ just suggested. We put his pieces on the lathe and I had him move my overhead light around until he could see the scratches.

In my case I have to make sure I have the right glasses on. One pair of glasses doesn't focus at the right distance to see really small scratches. That and the flourescents and I can't see the scratches at all.

Re: Sanding question

#13

Re: Sanding question

Barry Irby

>I can't disagree with anything here and have learned a few things.

I step through the grits and I reverse the lathe between each grit.

I power sand and particularly pay attention to the interior of the bowls. I get tear out at those posts where the grain reverses cue to the curve of the bowl. I need better technique, but until then, I sand them into submission. I start with whatever my coarsest grit is and when almost all of the interior is good, I stop and lock the shaft and sand out the tear out. Then I run the lathe again and sand it, probably with the same coarse grit to "fair" out the depressing I caused, If any, by grinding on the tear out.

Once you reach this stage, It does me a lot of good to keep in ming that the coarse sanding is to remove the tool marks, but after that, each grit only removes the scratches left by the previous grits. Two somewhat different processes. I keep reminding myself to get rid of all the tool marks before I start "sanding" with the finer grits.

I sometimes wet coarse woods to raise the grain, but I look closely while it is wet to check for imperfections. I have been known to spray on a very light coat of finish and sand it off for the same reason.

I remember which way the bowl was turning when I sand the outside, so that when I reverse chuck it to clean up the foot, I either sand the entire outside over with the "last" grit or at least make sure its spinning in the same direction. I have had some bowl with a strip around them from being sanded in opposite directions.

I sometimes let the power sander drive the work on the lathe, but I find my pieces are "rounder" and less "lumpy" if the lathe spins the wood and the sander does its work.

Re: Sanding question

#14

Re: Sanding question

Malcolm Tibbetts

>A lot of great tips here in this post.

Just a couple more tips...

Power-magnification can be a real asset. If it looks good under 4-power magnification, then it's likely to look great to anyone's naked eye.

One thing that I've learned to do with my segmented work is to do some very light shear-scraping with a handheld cabinet style scraper before starting any sanding. This step allows me to usually start sanding at 220-grit (sometimes 180). I actually recently finished a small piece with "no sanding" using this technique. Here's a photo of that piece.


img

Re: Sanding question

#15

Re: Sanding question

Bob Fawcett

>Malcolm,

Are you using one of "french curve" shaped scrapers?

Re: Sanding question

#16

Re: Sanding question

Malcolm Tibbetts

>Bob, I use a French curved scraper on the concave surfaces and a straight edge scraper on the remainder.

Re: Sanding question

#17

Re: Sanding question

Jim Rutten

>That might be my problem too as I have to take my glasses off to see close up and on to see distances. Maybe the lathe is halfway in between.

Re: Sanding question

#18

Re: Sanding question

Carole Valentine

>I have the same problem, Jim. I can't see squat. I usually take the piece off the lathe at about the 220 stage and take it outside into bright sunshine. Nothing reveals flaws in wood and old skin like sunlight! LOL

Re: Sanding question

#19

Re: Sanding question

Jim Rutten

>Thank you all for all the great responses. I hope to show the final results before Christmas.

Re: Sanding question

#20

Thanks

Bob Fawcett

>

Re: Sanding question

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Sanding question

Keith Tompkins

>ONe last tip...your hand can feel what your eyes may not see. Run your hand inside your bowl or platter with your eyes closed...you will detect every bump or ridge. They must be dealt with before any proper sanding can be done.

I am predujiced here...from my years as a furniture maker. A bowl that requires 80 grit to start will almost never look as good as a bowl that needed very little sanding in the first place. I attempt to put a fine-furniture surface on my pieces before any finish is applied, so good tool work is a must. If 80 grit is a must, be prepared to spend the extra time to remove the scratches while still keeping crisp lines.

I do dampen my pieces....the moisture raises scratches that lay beneath the surface, then they can be sanded off when dry.

I think attitude has a lot to do with final results. If sanding is a hang-up, then slow down a bit. Most turners I know focus far too much on QUANTITY, not QUALITY. For your platter that has to be flawless, forget about the time it takes to sand, your schedule, or any other distraction, and strive for stunning results on just this one piece. And, then the next one.

Re: Sanding question

#22

Re: Thanks

Barry Irby

>I forgot to mention the cabinet scrapers. I just started using them and I like them, they reduce sanding dramatically.

That is a really good looking piece Malcolm. Just a shame you did not have a whole piece of wood and had to make it out of them itty bitty pieces.

Re: Sanding question

#23

Re: Thanks

Bob Fawcett

>Do you use these with the lathe turning?

Seems like that could be dangerous.

Re: Sanding question

#24

Re: Sanding question

Allen Neighbors

>Malcolm, this is an awesome piece! And it hasn't been sanded?

How fast is your lathe spinning when you use the scrapers?

Re: Sanding question

#25

Re: Thanks

Barry Irby

>Yes I do, and I move the tool rest and banjo back out of the way and tape the edges I am not using. Its my version of a negative rake scraper.