Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

Posts

I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#1

I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Anyone who has looked at my work will realize that I use traditional shapes and mostly unaltered wood. I turn what I choose because I like it; other turners turn what they like. It distresses me whenever we do not have tolerance for each others work whether displayed here, on WOW, in the AAW magazine or anywhere else.

The AAW magazine has often been criticized because of its "non-traditional content". I just finished going back through the last 5 issues. In every one there is a variety of styles from the basic, traditional classic work to the bizarre (not a negative). The articles range from basic to advanced. There is something for everyone just as it should be. I have never received an issue that didn't contain interesting, informative material. Just because I may not agree or appreciate everything does not mean there is anything wrong with the content. How boring would it be if every issue was aimed at one group of turners?

Wow has been criticized here for the same thing. This was easier to disprove. I realize using 108 photos is not a statistically defensible study but I feel that it does say something. There was a limit as to the time I was going to spend making talley marks. I used three classifications listed below with results.

#1- purely traditional shapes, solid un-embellished wood except for beads, coves, collars 66%

#2 Moderately embellished including, burning, dying, carving, etc. but still a traditional or close to traditional shape. 30%

#3 The definitely different, most of which had little resemblance to turning in any context of traditional (again, not a negative) 11%

Of course the criteria are mine and not created by committee.

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#2

Re: I agree with your premise, and...

Jamie Donaldson

>... am often disappointed with the illogical and unnecessary criticism here aimed at undeserving targets based on some personal misconceptions. There is no need for individuals preaching personal dogma to this choir, and we should be vigilant about keeping to the facts and topics at hand without acting like voiceless sheep.

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#3

You've got that right!

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I've had exactly the same observations.

Is it a case of people only seeing what they want to see? Or maybe a case of only remembering what they didn't like or didn't want to see?

There are certain forms and styles that don't interest me. Does that mean that they are bad? Most emphatically NO! It simply means that they aren't my cup of tea. (Or coffee since I don't drink tea.)

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#4

Braavo Barb

john lucas

>Every time I hear someone preaching about the AAW being biased toward the "high Hats" and exotic work I go back through several issues and find just the opposite. I'm always confused as to how they arrive at this. You could look through Woodturning Design, Woodturner, and even non turning magazines like Wood, FineWoodworking and American Woodworker and find both traditional and artistic turning.

I think both exist but we choose to follow the things we like. That is how it should be. Turning should be fun and you follow what you want to do be that making the same bowl 1000 times or taking one piece of wood and burning, and carving, and dismantling it until it doesn't resemble wood. As long as you enjoy the process then it great.

We talk about finding a voice, but that's only if you want to find a voice. it's certainly not necessary. I love looking at all styles of turning. I enjoy seeing beginners work and watching them grow. I enjoy seeing the latest advances in turning. I hope the magazines continue to do both. I guess that's why I subscribe to virtually all the magazines that deal with wood. I want to see it all and then I can choose to do what I want. Hopefully I will have gained enough knowledge of other styles to choose a style that fits what I want to do.

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#5

Well Said Barbara

Jorge Castaneda

>agree completely that is the way I feel too, and Brian simple forms that please me are my cup of tea, I don't drink coffe... : )

Jorge

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#6

Thank you, Barb!

Carole Valentine

>All of us should just turn what we like and allow others to do the same. I turn traditional forms for two reasons 1)I like them and 2)I haven't learned how to do anything else yet. :) That doesn't mean I don't want to see non-traditional turnings! I admire them and enjoy looking. Gives me lots of fodder for trying new things when I have gotten the basics down a little better. If WoW and AAW and the turning mags featured only traditional turnings, I would quickly become bored with them. And when (or if) I learn how to do some of that fancy stuff, you can be darn sure I will post it! LOL

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#7

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.

gil jones

>Thank you Barbara, I have not thought of dropping that bomb on anyone in particular, but it is pretty much the way I feel. I will continue to turn in my own way, mainly because I do not know any other way (yet). I enjoy seeing other styles, and try to learn from them.

Gil

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#8

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.

Barry Irby

>I agree. I want to see some basics, because there is still stuff to be learned there and I generally like the beauty of the wood and traditional forms. Sometimes I look at non traditional things or things thoroughly embellished and find one of a couple of reactions. Either I am intimidated and challenged to try it or to remember it for when I feel I have the skills or I don't get it or don't like it and would not consider trying it anyway. But that doesn't mean I object to anyone else doing their thing and stretching their talents and showing it to us. Thank all of you for sharing your work and Ideas. Wonder if it is just as important to look at something and say to yourself, "I'm glad I saw that, now I know I won't have to try it." for whatever reason.

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#9

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.

Mac

>Hi Barbara, Very well said,and high time someone said it.It would be nice if the personal agendas could be left on the shop floor where they belong. Lets all get on with the fun!

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#10

Not just turning, Barry........

Ruth Niles

>Barry wrote: "Wonder if it is just as important to look at something and say to yourself, "I'm glad I saw that, now I know I won't have to try it." for whatever reason."

I've done that several times, and not just with turnings. It's not just seeing something done that has changed my mind but there are a few techniques I've tried and have no desire to develop further. Why get really good at something you're not crazy about?

"It's not brain surgery, it's wood turning, get it in the proper perspective". That's an old Polish saying I just made up. : )

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#11

not just turning-I agree 100%

john lucas

>Good point Ruth. I see things everywhere that I can use in my turning. I've sketched out 100's of ideas. I'll never have time to make them but I think learning to "look" at the things around you is just as important as learning to turn. You never know when some little detail will show up in a piece.

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#12

I've noticed an increase in attacks on others

Jim Swank

>on this site and other places of late. I don't understand it myself. I'm not talking about honest criticism, even if harshly phrased.

I remember the book burners and censors every time I read certain messages. In most cases, such messages speak volumes about the writer and say very little about the intended target. I'd love to have the imagination and skills that created some of the more controversial pieces I've seen, even if I might use them to convey a somehwat different message.

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#13

The Stats Prove It!

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Barb,

I am glad you posted this, well said. I find turning to be very relaxing and if that is all I get from it then I am totally happy with it, regardless of what it is.

Your sampling study is a good example of what is out there and how once the data is compiled that sometimes our preception is not as clear as the statistical representation.

Take care,

Jim

Statistics means never having to say you are certain

:-)

I am sure between Ed Moore and my self we could rig up a study and do an Multivarient study to look at potential inferences and factor interactions....but then again we can just pass on that.

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#14

I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#15

Re: I agree with you Jim,

Allen Neighbors

>I've seen people attack others and I don't like it. When I first became a lurker on this forum, and others, there was a rapport that I recognised between woodturners that was second to none. I loved it. Now I see posts becoming more caustic. We can change that.

Everytime I see someone come down hard on someone else, most of the time I just ignore it, because I don't want to see strife or contribute to it.

We can return this forum to it's original welcoming state by not contributing to the strife, or by just letting them have their say and not making a retort.

Wish I could exercise that attitude all the time.... :o)

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#16

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Barbara,

Thanks for that posting. I for one would like to see this site get back to just the way it used to be when everyone was sharing, posting, reading and promoting woodturning, that made my day. I've learned so much from you guys that I feel the WC turners and this site should be proud of what has been accomplished and with a little tolerance, some kindness and the never ending abilities of some of you guys, this place will continue to promote the best that Woodturning has to offer.

IMHO, Mike

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#17

Hopefully

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You'll "pass."

|;-}}}

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#18

Re: Not just turning, Barry........

Mac

>Hi Ruth, I knew you were old,didn't know you were Polish tho........

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#19

ReUuuuhh- we're waiting Ron??!!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#20

Something of a Paradox

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The great thing about The Pond was that it proved that a real sense of community with mutual respect and care among a large group of strangers could be fostered through an Internet forum. Ellis has continued that goal.

What may emerge from the resulting personal identification with the that community is first a sense of "possessiveness" that can be followed by a false sense of "license" to use the board to push one's own agenda. It's all too easy to unintentionally turn a group of friends into a captured audience and the opportunity to voice opinions to those whom we may see as having a built-in receptiveness into a "bully pulpit". The more one contributes, even just to help those seen as less knowledgeable, the stronger the "danger" that an individual's style and perception may emerge in a way viewed negatively by others. It's an easy way to lose friends.

Your effort was very worthwhile, Barb. Intellectual myopia can only be helped by those willing to insist on giving us the wider view.

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#21

Re: Something of a Paradox

Dinyar Chavda

>Mark:

I have no idea what you said, but I disagree with it vehemently! :-)

Actually, I came across a quote that may fit in this discussion:



  • Not to be absolutely certain is, I think, one of the essential things in rationality.

  • -- Bertrand Russell


Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#22

Re: Not Understanding

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Um, like, which part?

|;-}

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#23

Right On.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>One of the things that I enjoy the most when I attend a large symposium is the instant gallery. At the very first AAW symposium in 1987 the work in the gallery was nearly all traditional pieces. Mostly open bowls, a few simple hollow forms, very few segmented pieces, lots of spindle work. Now, a short 20 years later, some of the work you see is nearly mind boggling. Some of the pieces I perhaps don't personally care for, and have no desire to copy but I really admire the inspiration, ingenuity and skill that went into creating them.

I think that it would be a great mistake to try to put a damper on any attempts at creativity and the desire to try new things in woodturning.

I think the great majority of turners are simply enjoying themselves in what they do. Most have no desire to go beyond turning the simple, more classic forms. I also think that most also enjoy seeing the work of others who choose to go beyond that.

Wally

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#24

Richard Allen

Bertrand Russell

Richard Allen

>Bertrand Russell! Now there is a name I don't hear very often. Thanks for the reminder of one of my favorite social commentators.

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.-Lon

#25

Re: I Feel I Have Something That Needs To Be Said.

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Well said. Ruth (and Wally).

The recent atmosphere on this matter on both WC and WOW of late has curbed my enthusiasm in participating online (not turning).

I hope that the polarization lessens and the otherwise neighborly and friendly atmosphere returns.

Mark