Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Cachunk cachunk

Posts

Cachunk cachunk

#1

Ellis Walentine

Cachunk cachunk

Ellis Walentine

>I've been turning for 47 years now and I admit I am still wondering how to reduce a big gnarly piece of lopsided wood to something round without just standing there getting pounded by every knobby protrusion. Here is the piece du jour, one of the nicest pieces of yew I've ever seen, but at the rate I'm going, it will be a week before I have this vase rounded, if I don't break my tool rest before then.

I can't bandsaw the blank round, I don't feel comfortable carving it with a chainsaw, I don't own an arbortech wheel, and my monster bowl gouge is taking forever. Any suggestions?

Ellis Walentine, Host


Re: Cachunk cachunk

#2

Re: Cachunk cachunk

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hmm....Ellis, I think if it were mine I would stand it on end and carefully trim it up with the chain saw. It wouldn't take much and it would really cut down on the cachunking. Looks like it's going to be a nice hunk of yew when you get it in the round. Make sure you do a followup pic of the finished beaut when you're done!

Jen

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#3

Re: Cachunk cachunk

Dave Belser

>At times I use a power plane. I have a crappy little Black&Decker one that I paid $20 for. I set it on max depth. The process is brutal on the plane but it actually dosen't take very long to make improvements on the hunk of wood.

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#4

Re: Cachunk cachunk

Carole Valentine

>ROFL! Sorry, Ellis, but that really is funny as heck! I know exactly how you feel. I agree with Jen - stand that sucker on the big end and whittle it down with the chainsaw. At least get the biggest knobs off it.

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#5

Re: Cachunk cachunk

Lan Brady

>a hatchet would work on that big piece.

Good Luck, Lan

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#6

German Spindle gouge? *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>How about a German Spindle Gouge? I don't think this is the only name for it, but that is what Packard calls it. I think Cutting Edge has a somewhat heavier version designed by Rud Osolonik? It's sort of like a 1.25" roughing gouge ground with a spindle gouge tip. Anyway, I have one from Packard and have used it and like it...though not always used as intended. It is meant for roughing down large blanks. I suspect someone else here could describe it better, I'm pretty new to the tool.

Just checked Cutting Edge. They call it their 1-3/4" Osolnik-style Roughing Gouge under the Henry Taylor Diamic Brand group. (301-HS152H $83)

Here's the Packard link, $77 for 1-1/4". (If I did it again, I'd probably go with the Henry Taylor version.) Reasonable description on the Packard page.

http://www.packardwoodworks.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=CTGY&Category_Code=tools-pkrd-gsg

-Craig


Henry Taylor Osolnik Roughing Gouge @ Cutting Edge

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#7

Re: Cachunk cachunk

Hooligan

>Lay the big gouge on its side, and take arcing cuts into it. That's about the best technique that I use. It goes quite fast, and allows you to keep the gouge on the rest. Its somewhat an adaptation of Raffan's technique to rough bowls.

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#8

Re: Cachunk cachunk

Brodie Brickey

>Ellis,

I'd vote for standing it up and trimming with the chainsaw.

If you ever get another fine stump like that, please consider pressure washing the outside and hollowing the inside with a fitted lid on top. As large as that piece is, you could have a very unique stool for the parlor. Sort of an anti-Morris chair.

Regards,

Brodie

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#9

Looking At The Tools Behind You

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Are you planning a trip on the Pequot? Some of those things look like you have a thing for the Great White Whale.

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#10

Re: German Spindle gouge?

Thad Parker

>Seems like a very valid reason to buy a new tool for several reasons.

1- You already said chainsawing is not what you would be comfortable doing, and it's never the safest thing to do what you are not comfortable doing.

2- I once heard it said that power planers are responsible for the most injuries in the shop (not saying it's valid, just that I heard it)

3- This gauge seems to be designed for just this task, and it's always best to have the right tool for the job.

So if I were you, I would have reasoned it out and just told SWMBO that it's the safest thing to do (above mentioned points) and that if she loves me and does not want to see harm come to me she will et me buy the new tool...but that's just me.

Looking forward to see how it turns out ~ Thad

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#11

Re: German Spindle gouge (correction)?

Thad Parker

>The gouge is the right tool, but I suppose one could never have too many gauges either.

~T

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#12

Get creative

Jake (SoMN)

>I saw a program once where they mounted a router motor, (1/2 straight shank carbide spiral bit), to a custom tool rest and fired it up. This can hawg out lots of material in hurry if the rpms on the lathe are slow and the router is cruising.

Custom welding an adjustable tool rest for one job is a lot of work. All depends on how often, and how bad it is....

Anybody could turn something the easy way. With all the chunk, chunking, you will feel like you have really earned the resulting piece. ;)

Jake

(Remove the 2 for email

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#13

Re: Cachunk cachunk

John Lucas

>That's the technique that I use. Go from a smooth area out onto the rough area. When I get to the cachunk area I anchor the tool with my left hand and arc it through the cut. This reduces the cachunk a little also allows you to take a very controlled depth of cut which makes the cachunks a little more bearable.

On really bad pieces I use a bigger gouge (5/8") and have a really long handle. This takes away some of the vibration.

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#15

Re: Cachunk cachunk

Barry Irby

>I have used the power planer for this. I turn the lathe on and get a couple of cachunks onto the block, identifying the high spots. I then plane those off and try again.

I have also used and electric chainsaw with the block on the lathe. I just carve away the high spots.

The other approach is to turn the lathe up to about five thousand rpm. This completely eliminates the cachunk effect. Turns it into a buzzzz. You just run around behind the lathe and cut away the blur.

(For any of you who have not been turning 47 years, this was a joke. Lathes don't have a 5000 rpm setting to keep fools like me from trying it. I'm too old to run that fast anyway.)

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#16

Re: Cachunk cachunk

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I would use a smaller tool like a 1/2 or 5/8 bowl gouge with Johannes Michelsen's grind or a fingernail grind. Start at the tail stock and rough it in sections, 1 inch deep and say 2 inches along the length. Do this along the entire length then speed up the RPM's and do it again.

In the future make a heavy duty tool rest from 1 inch round stock just for roughing... they won't break like a cast iron rest.

Have fun,

Doug

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#18

Re: Cachunk cachunk

Hooligan

>I just use my 1/2" Glaser, and let it ride. Rarely have I broken out the big dog. (3/4" Glaser)

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#19

Re: Cachunk cachunk

bob oswin

>I build a gantry for jobs like this and use my router with a straight bit with the lathe turned off.

I have pics somewhere if you need them.

If you get fancy with the jig you can even run it on slant where necessary by hingeing one end.

Bob

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#20

Hand Held Bandsaw

Ron in Drums PA

>4-1/2" capacity


img

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#21

Ellis Walentine

My big gouge...

Ellis Walentine

>...is an Ashley Iles 1" gouge, ground to a medium length fingernail grind. It's very hefty, yet maybe not hefty enough.

It occurs to me that what I'm asking might be impossible. Bigger gouges would only require more strength and a heftier tool rest, not to mention higher rpms. In other words, for a piece this big, chainsaw or hatchet trimming might be the only way to shorten the process.

Ellis

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#22

Re: My big gouge...

Hooligan

>Nah, not at all. If you drop down to a 1/2" gouge and lay it over, and pivot the gouge on the rest, rather than sweep it through, you should be just fine. It should take less time than you would ordinarily.

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#23

Ellis Walentine

:-) At 5,000 rpm,....

Ellis Walentine

>....a 90-lb. lopsided piece like this would hurl the whole lathe right through the shop wall. (Well maybe not if it isn't one of the resonance frequencies, but getting there would be a thrill ride. This chunk starts making my lathe dance at about 200 rpm.

Ellis

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#24

Ellis Walentine

Re: Hand Held Bandsaw

Ellis Walentine

>Interesting idea, Ron. That would definitely be quicker than my stupid Sven saw. The capacity might be a bit small for something this size though.

Thanks.

Ellis

Re: Cachunk cachunk

#25

Ellis Walentine

I'd have considered that...

Ellis Walentine

>...but I want to get a flared trumpet shape out of this piece, and make the best use of the natural ridges and buttresses of this stump. I don't think I could swoop that with a router jig. Good thought though. I have used jigs like this to rout flutes and dovetails into spindle work in the past.

Ellis