Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Who gave me this wood?

Posts

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#26

PS:

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Disregard the line of depressions. They are not part of the distinctive grain pattern of elm. They resulted from an unexpected dismount of the bowl from the lathe. 8^]

Gary

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#27

Re: Who gave me this wood?

Roger Smith

>Allen, It is a piece of red elm that I swaped with you. Great job turning it.

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#28

Piece from the other side of the block

Roger Smith

>Allen, Here is a picture from a piece I turned while I was at John C. Campbell from the other side of the block. You did a better job and I hate to post my picture.


img

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#29

Re: Who gave me this wood?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Allen that is a really nice looking piece. You are turing some great work! I agree with the others...some sort of locust is my guess. Very nice form and collar too!

Jennifer

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#30

This is Honey Locust for sure but

Ruth Niles

>you real "wood" guys will have to make the comparison. This picture was taken inside with different lighting than Allan's so keep that in mind because mine looks grayer or duller but in the sun, it has the same glow.

Also the piece is upside down because AFTER I turned it, I decided it would have looked a lot better oriented this way!


img

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#31

AHA Gary was right! : )

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#32

Re: Sorry to disagree, Allen

Bill White

>I gave it to you, and I want it back....RIGHT NOW. My shipping address is______________________.

Just kiddin'! Great piece.

Bill

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#33

Re: Roger said it was a piece

Allen Neighbors

>of Red Elm that he had swapped me at the Gathering. That's good enough for me. Red Elm it is. :o) Gary was right, all the rest of us were wrong. :o( But it sure does look like locust... Sorry. Didn't mean to cause such confusion, but it was a good test, huh? :o)Thanks, Jen, for your nice compliments. They're much appreciated.

Roger Smith, thanks for coming online and letting me know the type of wood, and who I got it from. :o)

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#34

Re: LOL, Bill.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#35

Keith Tompkins

Re: Roger said it was a piece

Keith Tompkins

>Well, not exactly ALL, Allen.........LOL!

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#36

Re: Roger said it was a piece

Allen Neighbors

>That's right! I forgot about your standard answer, didn't I? :o)

How often does that answer prove right? ......

Allen

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#37

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Take a look at this one

Leo Van Der Loo

>You sure have better eyes than me Gary to be able to see the exact grain in Allen's picture.

As for red elm, I have turned some, and don't find it hard wood at all, a little stringy perhaps, and softer than American Elm

And yes I'm quite familiar with the Elm grain pattern, but the look of Allen's HF does to me not look like Elm, I do have a scanned picture of a red elm bowl, and yes it has a reddish color, but looks not like Honey Locust at all.

However trying to identify wood species from a pic. is not easy, but I do try my best to help out, and do know some/most of the wood species we have around here.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img