Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Who gave me this wood?

Posts

Who gave me this wood?

#1

Who gave me this wood?

Allen Neighbors

>This piece is from a round blank that was covered in flat brown latex paint. Someone traded it to me for a piece of Mesquite? when we were at the Gathering at TD's in GA. I can't remember what kind of wood it is, and didn't write it down... (my bad)

The collar is Indian Rosewood. Finish is lacquer wash and Carnauba buff.

Sure wish I knew what kind of wood it is. Anyone got an idea?


img

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#2

Re: Who gave me this wood?

gil jones

>Hi Allen,

It rather looks like a lot darker than normal Sycamore, but I am just guessing.

You did an excellent job on it, and the collar!!

Gil

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#3

mulberry?

TDaniel

>

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#4

Re: Who gave me this wood?

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Whatever it is Allen, It`s a beautiful piece.

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#5

Sorta looks like Black Locust

Bart Rhoads

>

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#6

Sycamore maybe??

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Who gave me this wood?

Keith Tompkins

>My standard answer, right or wrong....elm. LOL

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#8

Re: Sycamore maybe??

Bill Stehman

>Allen,

beautiful turning no matter what it is... you did good.

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#9

Leo Van Der Loo

Honey Locust Allen, I'm pretty certain

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Allen

It is first of all a Beauty Allen and it is also Honey locust, pretty solid wood to hollow, but also very stable when dry.

You are getting real good at those, Allen, and I'm sure some others are looking over their shoulders, you're going fast, Thanks for showing

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#10

Re: Honey Locust .... I agree with Leo.

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#11

I have to agree

Mike Cunningham (Cape May NJ)

>I debated between sycamore and honey locust and posted the former but I think you're right, it's HL.

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#12

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Honey Locust, here's a couple pic's of some.

Leo Van Der Loo

>The wood color in these pic's is a little redder and could be camera induced, but Honey Locust does have a distinct reddish look.


img

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#13

Re: Who gave me this wood?

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Gil. I don't think it's Sycamore... it's too hard. This thing gave me more trouble hollowing, than any I've ever done. Almost as hard as Pecancrete. :o)

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#14

Re: Nope. Not Mulberry.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#15

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Honey Locust, here's a couple pic's of some. 

Leo Van Der Loo

>


img

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#16

Re: Who gave me this wood?

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Norm. I appreciate that.

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#17

Re: Almost as hard, but no cigar. :o)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#18

Re: Sycamore maybe??

Allen Neighbors

>Thank you, Bill. It was a job, and I'm glad it's over. :o)

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#19

Re: Good answer... but I don't think so.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#20

Re: Sycamore maybe??

Allen Neighbors

>Thought sure you'd know, Mike. :o)

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#21

Re: I do believe you're right!

Allen Neighbors

>Bart had me going for a minute... but I've turned a lot of black locust, and it didn't have the greenish/blackish tint to it. But it was about as hard as dry Black Locust, and it has the classic grain pattern of the Locust, but it wasn't the right color as any I had seen before.

Leo, when I read your post title, "... Honey Locust..." I said, "That's it!".

Now, I can lable the bottom. But, I still don't know who I got it from. I'd sure like to turn some more of it... GREEN.. :o)

Thanks for the compliments, Leo, and for posting the pics.

The opening began at 1/2", but I broke it out twice, so it ended up at 1-7/8". That called for a collar. I did put it on the tumbler for about 3 hours each direction... but decided on the collar anyway, because the curve just "fell off into the hole", and that reminded me of a critique I got the other day. The collar did make it look better.

Thanks again, everyone. :o)

Allen

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#22

Re: Who gave me this wood?

Jorge Castaneda

>Allen,

You are getting good too fast, must be the Oneway...: )

I like it a lot, Thanks for sharing.

Jorge

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#23

Re: Who gave me this wood?

robo hippy

>Actually, from posts somewhere and an identical wood I had, it is a moraine locust which I believe is a naturally occuring hybrid of the honey locust. I grew up in Missery, and there was a lot of the wild honey locust which had thorns up to 12 inches long, and never got really big. The Moraine locust can get up to 3 ft diameter that I have seen. Very hard, and very beautiful.

robo hippy

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#24

Sorry to disagree, Allen

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>It looks like red elm to me. Look at the W shaped figuring. Some call it feather. You only get that in elm and hackberry because of the configuration of the pores in the earlywood. If you look at Leo's honey locust, you don't see that at all.

If you need more evidence, I'll try to find a picture of a red elm vessel that somebody sent me after I sold them a piece. It may take a couple of days, though.

Gary

Re: Who gave me this wood?

#25

Take a look at this one

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>This is a different variety of elm, but it should show the distinctive grain pattern that you only get with elm. Slippery elm is the same color as the piece you showed.

Gary


img