Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Maybe it was worth the struggle

Posts

Maybe it was worth the struggle

#1

Maybe it was worth the struggle

Carole Valentine

>I cussed this piece of wood 'til I was blue in the face. It is a piece of spalted maple that had gone beyond spalt in all the light areas and was rock solid in the adjacent areas. The light areas were just crumbly and would fall out in little chunks. I used about a whole bottle of CA on it...soak it, cut, soak it, cut it... Then I started hollowing - darn thing about beat me to death! LOL I finally managed to get a fairly smooth finish cut inside by soaking it with water and putting a good burr on my Keltons. The bark inclusion was dust so that has been filled with my secret formula. :) May redo the collar. It doesn't look right to me. 5.75"x5.5" Not buffed yet.


img

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#2

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

Leo Van Der Loo

>Sorry Carole, but it doesn't show that it was a struggle, (but I do believe you) its just better looking than a straight grained piece of wood, and you're able to make those look real attractive, this one even more so, I sure like the looks of it, thanks for putting in the effort and showing us.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#3

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

gil jones

>It sure enough is pretty, Carole, and the hard time you had turning it is not evident to me. I suppose if I was going to change the collar, I might make it a tad lower, and/or the opening a bit smaller. Still, I like it as is.

Gil

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#4

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

Mac

>Looks good to me kid...................

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#5

Definately worth it!

Dominic Greco

>

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#6

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

Rick Allen

>Quite a masculine shape was my first thought. My second thought was Whoever did this has been paying attention high masculine shoulders and the foot curves in to become invisible.

I read the other comments and noticed that it was Carol who made it.

Then I thought, it must be one of those small hollow forms she is so fond of. Yet on re-reading the prose I see it is larger than I would attribute to Carol.

As much as I like your work, which I find a treat to behold, this hollow form is a delightful surprise for me in several ways.

I am continually amazed at the progress you have made from "How do I get the faceplate off my Jet Mini?" to the wonderful items you are creating now.

As for the collar? You know better than I. the whole thing looks terrific to me.

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#7

I Would Say So.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#8

Wouldn't touch a thing.? Looks great.

Ray Carson, New Jersey

>okay.........go ahead, buff it up. :-)

Ray

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#9

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

Ed Karch

>Oh YES!!! worth the struggle. Spalted is tough to turn well. You did it.

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#10

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

George Van

>It sure was worth the effort Carol, I like spalted anything. I have never made a collar so I will be anxious to see if you can improve on this one for this form. It looks good to me!

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#11

Not buffed yet! Looks finished to me...

David

>If you want some nitpicking comments, and I mean nitpicking...perhaps a less bumpy transition on the collar and a little less rise to the opening would be a suggestion made with a lot of hesitation, because as it is, this is a lovely piece!

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#12

Barb Siddiqui

Beautiful, Carole

Barb Siddiqui

>

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#13

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

Carole Valentine

>Thanks, folks.

David and Gil, my thoughts exactly on the collar - thinner edge, easier transition and less rise. Maybe a tad smaller opening. However, with the cost of Blackwood, I may just leave it as is.

Rick, what can I say - for some reason, I am partial to the masculine form, and not only in turnings! ;))

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#14

It sure was!

Jorge Castaneda

>

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#15

Ummm.. YEAH!

Jim

>I know I'd be proud to have it sitting on _my_ mantle!

Nice looking hollow form! I wish my struggles came out that well!

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#16

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Carole,

You have a wonderful eye for making beautiful shapes!!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Maybe it was worth the struggle

#17

How did I miss THIS!!!?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Carole, I was just scrolling down in the depths of the page and saw this and thought...hmm...did I click on that yet?....yeck No! How did I miss this? It's a beauty! You dealt with that punkwood perfectly. Of course your form is dead on as usual. A beautiful piece Carole.

Jen :)