Turning Sitting Down
Jack Lagers
>I am unable to stand at my lathe because of back problems (herniated disc resulting in sciaitic).
Can I turn sitting on a stool and still perform the proper tool movements?
Ideas? Advice?
Thanks.
Jack
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Turning Sitting Down
Jack Lagers
>I am unable to stand at my lathe because of back problems (herniated disc resulting in sciaitic).
Can I turn sitting on a stool and still perform the proper tool movements?
Ideas? Advice?
Thanks.
Jack
Re: Turning Sitting Down
Tony Reynolds somewhere near Newark, Ohio
>I don't have any ideas or advise but I would think so. I just read an article in a back issue of American Woodturner of a guy who turns from his wheelchair. I'd say have at it and have fun!
Tony
Re: Turning Sitting Down
Bruce
>I think it boils down to which is the more dominant of the two diseases; degenerative disc(s) or wood turning. I suspect wood turning will prevail in the end. At one time, I had my JET mini mounted at a level I could effectively use while sitting on a rolling office chair. I had no issues with getting the job done.
Bruce
Re: Turning Sitting Down
john lucas
>Jack Yes you can. It's nicer to be able to move your body with the tools but you can definitely turn with just your hands. You just need sharp tools and a steady hand. I worked with a student last year who could stand but couldn't move his body. He'd had several back operations and couldn't move his head and couldn't move sideways. He didn't have any more trouble than the other beginning students.
Re: Turning Sitting Down
Barry Irby
>A member of our local club is in a wheel chair. I have seen his turnings, but have not seen him turn. I have thought about it, but have never tried. If you have dust collection, MAYBE you can keep the shaving cleaned up to a level the wheels on a chair would work. I even thought about using a one legged stool with a seat belt on it so it would act a a third leg and I could sit back on it like kangaroos sit on their tail. Never mind, I think I've said too much. Must have lost my mind, just for a minute.
Re: Turning Sitting Down
Frank of Mantua
>I have the same problem but more advanced.I can turn from my wheel chair or using my forearm cruches to lean on, this has been the best. or you can use a tall bar stool that lets you twist and turn your body as you need to. I would say try all three ways and see what works for you. IT CAN BE DONE YOUR ONLY NEED TO TRY..
I somting use all three ways in a long day in the shop. 12 + hours.
Re: Turning Sitting Down
griesbach
>Jack,
I have a turning buddy that nearly always sits on a bar type stool when he turns because of a back problem. He is able to slide the headstock of his lathe to the end of the ways and this makes it a lot easier and since the stool is mainly for support he is also able to swing his body a fair amount as well. I'm seriously considering trying it myself.
Cyril
Re: You betcha!
Allen Neighbors
>I have a friend in California, who turns from a wheelchair. His turnings are awesome! He would tell you to go for it!
I've even tried to turn from a stool, just to get an idea what he goes through. It can be done.
Allen
Re: Turning Sitting Down
tm
>Its good to see other turners mentioned here that have similar issues
to deal with. Jack, I do all my turning from a chair, as Al mentioned. I have a few thoughts I'd like to share.
The height of the spindle center in relationship to my elbow is very important.
My Craftsman variable speed lathe is mounted on a bench and the surface of the bench works as a support / stabilizer for my right elbow. The bench vs. the manufactured stand also allows me to wheel directly beneath the work so I don't need to lean out to reach it.
It also helps function as a woodchip guard, keeping some of it
off your legs and lap.
I think the height from benchtop to spindle center should equal
the distance from the bottom of your elbow to the palm of your hand
with the palm upward. I'm not sure how I arrived at this formula but
it works for me. My balance is comprimised and the right elbow prop helps compensate.
I get in very close to the work that way and I gain even more stability by leaning my left shoulder against the housing of the headstock.
Being this close gives me better tool control but also exposes me to more dust when sanding and I find that a Trend airshield along with a box fan placed behind me do well at keeping the dust out. A faceshield at all times & a cartridge type dust
mask at the minimum would be the next best in my opinion.
A few days ago I bought myself a Nova DVR XP . I did a fair amount
of research and it has a number of gimp friendly features such as
the rotating headstock and no belts & pulleys for fast easy
speed changes. I'm in the process of setting it up.
I found these tips at another turners site where someone posted a similar question
1. Use a chair that you can sit comfortably in for long hours at a time while leaning forward. The seat height is probably the most important there!
2. Modify the bench height of your lathe so that the toolrest is the correct height in relation to your elbow. Exactly the same principle as adjusting the lathe height when standing up.
3. It helps a lot if you have a low table about the same height to one side of the chair or the other. Some clear space to lay out your tools, penkits, blanks, plans or whatever... 'cos when seated it's awful hard to take a step to one side or the other to reach for things. I don't recommend using the lathe bench for this as everything gets lost in the shavings.
4. When spindle turning, it takes a slightly different technique to turn than when standing up. Most people "sway" when they turn, whether consciously or not, which keeps the tool at a constant angle. If you move just your hands/arms, the tool swings in an arc and more fine adjustments (hand-eye co-ordination) are needed to keep the tool at a constant angle. However, when they sit down it feels odd to rock from side to side... so they don't. WRONG! Use the sway, Luke! Use the sway! After a while you it becomes habit and you won't notice. Trust me, it does make a difference!
All pretty sound advice.
One thing I haven't figured out and I'm guessingits a fairly universal malady is how to keep woodchips from
getting inside my clothes. I use a smock and seal the ends of my sleeves with masking tape but theres always a little wood along
with me wherever I go.
Its a small price to pay for the amount of satisfaction I get from
turning.
If you think of something in particular post it here or send me an
email.
Most importantly turn safely.
Peace,
tm
Re: Turning Sitting Down
Steve in NC
>What a great response with lots of good advice. While I can still stand I often wondered if I could do it sitting down. (planing for the future I guess.) AS to your wood chips problem, I have a Lee Valley turners smock. It is great. It has a velcro flap at the neck and nice elastic cuffs at the wrists. It is long enought to keep chips and finishes off my clothes.
Steve
Re: Turning Sitting Down
OB O'Brien
>Sure you can sit and turn Jack; I have leg problems that prevent me from standing very long at the lathe. So I have a Delta Midi on a low bench that I can turn on while sitting on an office chair. I find the ones without arm rests work best for me. I also use a hollowing system adapted to the mini lathes that allow you to hollow while sitting down. I also have a Stubby full size lathe that I turn at while sitting on a shop stool. You just have to develop your own style. Spindle height is still at elbow height for me. tm gave you some excellent pointers. Get to turning and don't look back. OB
Re: Turning Sitting Down
Jack Lagers
>Thanks to all for helping me make the decision to begin turning sitting down. Great advice and may good ideas.
I'm seeing a neurosurgeon this morning for a second opinion about having a microdisctomy procedure to relieve the pain of standing.
Whatever the outcome, I'll be joining you guys as a turner!
Jack
Re: Turning Sitting Down
MountainMan
>Hey OB!
"I also use a hollowing system adapted to the mini lathes that allow you to hollow while sitting down.
Do you have a brand or URL for these hollowing tools??
Regards
The MountainMan
Re: Turning Sitting Down *LINK*
david
>At the Utah Symposium last June, I attended a rotation by Jim McPhail. One of the most well-prepared, organized, and thoroughly documented presentaions I have been to. His topic was layered bowls. He mentioned that he turns while sitting at his lathe, but I don't remember if he mentioned why. Does outstanding work:
Jim McPhail's Website
Re: Turning Sitting Down
tm
>Mountain Man, OB makes his hollowing rigs and I happen to have one.
It preforms very well. If he doesnt respond here try emailing him.
tm
Re: Turning Sitting Down
eliot d
>I saw a video of David Ellsworth turning while astride his lathe bed. He was sort of sitting and shifting his weight from one foot to the other; so his feet were sometimes supporting some of his weight. But it looked as though much of his weight was on the lathe bed. This appeared to be his usual method for hollowing.