Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Posts

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#26

Re: Email sent.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#27

Keith Tompkins

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Wally, I wonder how many people YOUR work has inspired? (applause)

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#28

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

John Lucas

>Ed I thought about faking my death to increase the value of my work but decided it would just make too many people happy and like them when they are irratated better.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#29

Brad Vietje

Becoming a Famous "XYZ"

Brad Vietje

>This made me chuckle...

Back a few years ago I was a very active amateur astronomer -- no "L" in that word -- and wanted to be famous in my fantasy world. Famous astronomers are those that discover planets, have multiple comets named for them, or even an asteroid. I figured I would have to live to be about 1500 years old to accomplish that, so I decided one day that the easiest way to become a famous astronomer was to die at the telescope -- after being hit by a 5-lb meteorite travelling at 30,000 mph -- no pain or suffering at all !

So it occurs to me that maybe I could be a famous turner if I died at the lathe -- heck, one of my my T-shirt's says I'll still be turning wood as a skeleton after that, so I could continue to make what the customer wanted, but at a higher price !

Just for fun,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#30

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Wilford Bickel

>From Wally:

"Prestini's talk was about art in turning. The part that impressed me the most was how he stressed the fact that Craft precedes Art. Learn your craft before you even think about turning work that you consider art.

In my classes I've had who students who, after turning their first bowl want to know when my next class on hollow forms will be. I tell them to go home and spend time mastering the bowl gouge before even thinking about HF's."

________________________

I think Wally has hit the nail on the head here - you must know the craft before it becomes art. I am seeing way too many turners that have grown up in our modern instant gratification society that do not want to "pay their dues" to learn how to turn. They want to turn immediately without spending the time it takes to learn. Once they realize that this is not a skill that can be accomplished without lots of time and work - they then start making "art".

I see pieces that are obviously traditional failures that then were carved, burned, cut, glued, etc. to make a piece of "art". In this case most of theses pieces just make a failure a bigger failure. I see a lot of "turners" that started out with flat work but were unhappy with the time it took to complete the projects and switched to turning with no intention of spending time learning the skills.

I have personally had "new" turners tell me there is no problem turning one of my 32+ inch tapered cane shafts and yet when questioned they will admit that the longest spindle they ever turned is an ink pen! We need AAW to push the "craft" more than the art. The art will follow. We as turners need to impress on people with interest in turning that there are skills that must be mastered if you want to become a turner. I believe we need to have a separate display at the instant galleries that separates out the traditional from the modern art thereby putting an emphasis on learning the skills to make traditional pieces and rewarding the learning of said skills. If our organization is going to survive my opinion is that we will have to define a turning and the difference in that and blank prepared on the lathe whose work more appropriately fits the classification of carving.

Looks like it is my day to give my $0.02 worth!

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#31

Re: It would be pointless and irrational

JamieDonaldson

>....to attempt to divide turning between art and traditional- there is no defined place to draw the line. Attempting to define and sequester either in their own box would squelch the diversity that makes contemporary turning so vital and enjoyable. There is no threat that would necessitate limiting turning in scope- its doing great, and the numbers support the growing interest.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#32

Re: My Word

Russ Fairfield

>I think that judging the "state of woodturning" by what we see at the Symposiums is an elitist viewpoint.

The reason there are no "traditional" turnings at the Symposiums is because we take our turnings to a Symposium and place them in the Instant Gallery to be "noticed". We want it to be selected by whoever is doing the critique for their comments and praise. This is our personal "15 minutes of fame". (Whether this fame is translated into dollars is another matter.) Since I have never seen anyone who was doing an Instant Gallery critique pick up a table leg, I would be a damn fool to take a table leg or piano bench to a Symposium, regardless of the skill and beauty it represented.

To be "noticed" at the Symposium, the work has to be "noticeable". That means that the more artistic it is the more likely that it will be critiqued. There is nothing at all wrong with that. That is how the "art" part of woodturning is advanced.

If you want to see "traditional" woodturning, that is the realm of the Show-and- Tell table at the local club. What I see at all of the club meetings I have attended proves to me that the "traditional" is still alive and well at the grass-roots of woodturning - the local clubs. And, there is nothing wrong with that either, because that is where the skills are learned to make the "art" that you see at the Symposium.

If you want to see what sells, go to the art fairs and galleries. Visit the booths of those who are selling their turned wood, as opposed to just displaying it. You will see that there are a lot more people buying "traditional" bowls and other things than the "art" of turned wood.

If you want to find the people who are turning architectural and furniture parts, you need to go where they are. There are a lot more of them than you realize. They just don't belong to the AAW, and they don't attend the Symposiums. They just turn wood, and some of them are very good at what they do. I wish that I had their skills.

I see no problems with these different venues and their different kinds of woodturning being under the same tent. Woodturning is one of the few things we can do where there are no boundaries. We are free to sample both the "traditional" and the "artistic". We are free to make choices of what we make on our lathe or what we do to the wood off of it; and we are free to change our mind whenever we want. Let's not make any rules or artificial boundaries to prevent that.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#33

Re: My Words about Your Words!

Jamie Donaldson

>If the reason to place a piece in the Instant Gallery is to be noticed by an Elitist, then you are striving to be recognized as an Elist as well!! There are always a few great examples of traditional and/or spindle turning, but what challanges the imagination of most participants is the work that is stretching the boundries of the process- what is new and different! And few turners of any skill level attend a Symposium just to see the IG- that's just part of the experience. Much of what you say is an accurate observation, but made thru your eyes, and there are many other sets of eyes making differing observations for their own interpretation.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#34

Totally With You Russ

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Russ,

What can I say, your words are clear and side with your view here. I think I have read three posts in this string, ....sometimes I just avoid these things (posts), I am not about debating definitions or defining boundries either, make something and enjoy it!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Am I alone but I enjoy this forum a little less lately