Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Posts

Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#1

Keith Tompkins

Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Keith Tompkins

>Last Wednesday's chat, which was a critique of two artistic turnings, got me thinking about the history of turning, and what influence traditional turning methods are having on the turning revival we are experiencing.

Based on turning's rich history, one could expect to see a multitude of well executed, classic turnings on display at the various symposiums held across the country. Yet, they are conspicuously absent. Have you noticed the same thing, and wondered why?

There was a time when the craft of woodturning was almost lost. Opportunity for employment in the field disappeared as skilled craftsmen were replaced by automated equipment. Demand for highly embellished turnings dwindled as sleek, modern styles of furniture became fashionable. Schools dropped their turning programs in favor of more appropriate ones, such as computer technology classes.

Against these overwhelming odds, turning has suddenly made a remarkable comeback. Today, turning is enjoying a popularity that far exceeds any other form of woodworking. What can we attribute this to? What is the driving force behind it? One simple word can explain it...ART.

The resurgence of turning can be traced directly to a handfull of turners who were not content to turn the usual fare; rather, they focused their attention on pieces they considered to be works of art. Turners with names such as Moulthrop, Stocksdale, or Lindquist began to raise the status of the turned bowl from a utilitarian item to an art form. These pioneers set the stage for the likes of David Ellsworth, whose hollow forms have changed forever the way we look at turnings. The work that these turners produced was innovative, bold, and exciting.....it was the catalyst that sparked a whole new wave of turning innovation. Suddenly, the lathe was seen as a mode of self-expression, as a way to explore form, a way to find one's "voice".... the possibilities seemed unlimited. Contrary to the beliefs of many, the artsy crowd did not highjack the turning movement, they started it! Does this help explain the absense of traditionally turned spindles, balusters, and chairs at the various symposiums...and the explosion of art pieces?

Am I saying that traditional turning has no place in today's world? No, I am not. I believe every aspiring turner needs to study and learn from the tried and true methods and techniques. They are an absolute requirement if one is to build a solid foundation from which to build upon. There will alway be a place for traditional work. Many pieces, such as the Windsor chair are timeless classics, and will never be improved upon. Few will ever master the techniques required to create one...

What I am saying is that if anyone aspires to make a name for themselves in the turning world , they need to understand and master the fundamentals, and then move on, looking forward, not back. It is no longer enough to copy a classic design or emulate a master turner. There are simply too many good turners now. The successful turner must draw from something within, from their own life experiences, and then bring their ideas to life. The future belongs to the innovators.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#2

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Tom Libby

>Thank you, well done. You've got me mentally composing a piece of my own. I'll be running it thru what apparatus I have left for the rest of the day, hopefully to make it into print at some point.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#3

Brief statement for thought along Keith's line

john lucas

>I wonder how the turning movement compares to the scroll saw movement in the 20's. Was this a hobby because people needed something to do and had more free time or was this a need for ART. I think the current trend in woodturning is follow in those footsteps.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#4

an explanation

TDaniel

>Year after year the pieces chosen by those who are doing the critiques at woodturning events have been the highly enhanced forms, super nice traditional works have been passed over, therefore no one even brings a traditional turning anymore. This is the result of having an unbalanced jury. In the real world, (what sells, what does not), is quality of craftsmanship. This varies around the country but in my area the buyers are not overly impressed with the "far out" stuff. I cannot speak for the rest of the nation but here in my area the independent art judges of various open art events where woodturnings have to compete with other art forms are picking quality workmanship, good form and flawless finish over works that are too "complicated". Don't underestimate regional differences; a piece that might beat me in Chicago will not stand a chance aganist me in Atlanta. People in this area still understand that a turning is done on a lathe.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#5

Re: an explanation

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>If selling your work is your objective then turn for those who will buy. If turning to please your own appreciation then please yourself. If turning to please other turners then forget it. Go back to one of the first choices. Just don't expect the turning world to stay where you think it should stay.

Every art form takes different directions and changes over time. I think to compare a Rembrandt and a Picasso certainly exemplifies this. To argue this question with a right or wrong answer is fruitless as there will never be the answer you seek. To discuss without pointing fingers can be beneficial and interesting for a limited amount of time.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#6

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Leslie S

>Hi all,

I have been thinking alot about this kind of thing due to some of the conversations here. I have come up with this: If trees stop growing they die. Along those lines if turning stops evolving it also "dies". Some trees grow along traditional growth patterns, but there are those that grow in unique places, host fungi or insects or grow a burl. Eitehr way the tree keeps growing. Forgive the leap in metaphors, but I appreciate them all; the turners who grow along the traditional path and those who grow burls. (My apologies to my fellow turners if I have ruffled feathers in any way)

Leslie

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#7

no ruffles feathers at all

TDaniel

>There are many ways to grow; you can grow by becoming better and refining skills; you can grow by exploring new techniques, etc. Jumping too far ahead and trying to discover new techniques before mastering the needed skills to accomplish good works is a mistake. Treating any group of turners in an unappreciative way is also a mistake. We all have areas that we enjoy pursuing, be it something totally new or just a refinement of something we have attempted before. Any group that wants to take an ego trip and pretend that their opinion is more valued than the opinions of other turners or collectors is wrong. There are many roads to take, pick one that suits you. If you want to build your own road that is ok too, just don't tear mine up to get there.

TD

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#8

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Frank of Mantua

>good thoughs, its well known concept. Grow and evolve or wither an die.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#9

Excellent analogy

John Lucas

>

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#10

no argument here.

John Lucas

>I can't sell "art" work here. Other areas it does sell.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#11

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Leslie S

>I also think that Rembrandt and picasso are a great way to think about this and craft vs art. They both pushed the envelope of thier times. I further maintain that without Rembrandt Picasso could not have accomplished what he did. I agree you need a solid foundation to build on, for just aobut anything! I love these discussions!

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#12

Beating a dead horse.

Stuart Johnson

>Keith, I'm sorry but in my opinion this is just beating the same dead horse. I doubt if any opinions will change and it seems like we have had the same discussion from just about every angle. Some want to find their "voice" and regard every piece they produce as a piece of their soul and want to shout it to the world. There is one that posts on WoW that in my opinion is producing hate filled garbage. Yet every item posted is treated as if he was producing a new book in the Bible. My feelings about his work don't amount to a hill of beans and they shouldn't.

On the other hand there are many traditional style bowls, HF and spindle work posted by no name folks that are terrific. They don't stir the pot but do receive the proper praise and comments. Are these turners the true artists? They are taking a piece of wood and making something beautiful. Are they just craftsmen? After all they didn't create the wood grain they just shaped it.

I'm not so certain the surge in woodturning is the result of turners being able to express themselves. I think it might be more the result of a whole bunch of middle aged folks that have worked most of their lives and have never seen any physical results. Oh, the accounts balanced and maybe the program ran smoother, the part added to the auto fit, but it wasn't something that could be held the hands. They see Norm turning a table leg or see a demo at a craft show and realize they can take a raw piece of wood and make something. At some point they might want to try more complicated turnings but I doubt if the numbers would be the same if the early exposure was only "artistic" items.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#13

Barb Siddiqui

'Tradition' itself evolves

Barb Siddiqui

>Your points are well expressed, Keith. What was 'traditional' in the past most certainly has changed as new ideas advanced the craft. I was thinking of an article out of The Guild of Master Craftsman's 'Woodturning' (collected from Woodturning magazine) on Robin Wood, who replicated bowls and platters found aboard the Tudor warship Mary Rose. From solidly functional pieces in the past, turning evolved in form and the 'traditional' took on a whole new meaning. Now, apparently, traditional is defined as wholly completed on the lathe, no matter what the form, and 'art' is defined as 'embellished' after the fact. Sometimes, that is. Fifty or one hundred years ahead, the current embellished work may have been left behind for something else. Recognizing the greater scheme of things allows innovation, as does just plain not giving a **** about what others think, and doing what one wants to do anyway. The cream will always rise to the top. The quality of the cream is for each generation to judge, not the maker of the cream.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#14

Re: 'Tradition' itself evolves

Leslie S

>Well put Barb, Chagne can be a lot of things, but basically it is what it is, change. Just something different. Like so many things change is what you make of it. You can go kicking and screaming, embrace it or watch from the sidelines, but the only constant is that change will happen.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#15

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>At one of the early AAW symposiums the late James Prestini was the speaker at the banquet. He is credited by many to be the first to turn pieces that were recognized as works of art. His pieces were mostly of straight grained wood, they were open vessels, turned very thin. No adornments which many of todays turners feel are needed to create art. He started turnimg in 1933. His work is in many major collections and in museums including the Smithsonian. In the 50s he went on to other materials to work with.

Prestini's talk was about art in turning. The part that impressed me the most was how he stressed the fact that Craft precedes Art. Learn your craft before you even think about turning work that you consider art.

In my classes I've had who students who, after turning their first bowl want to know when my next class on hollow forms will be. I tell them to go home and spend time mastering the bowl gouge before even thinking about HF's.

I can remember back in the 70's looking at photos in Fine Woodworking magazine of Ellsworth's hollow forms. He was doing things that no one had ever done. I determined that I would learn how to do that. I did but it took awhile because first I had to make a tool to do it. At the time, I don't think that I even thought about what I was doing as being anything but craft.

Wally

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#16

Re: The variety of turned works is.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...what adds vitality to the field today. Contrast the formal structured forms of Prestini with the natural edged burls of Rude Osolnik, and neither would fit the narrow definition of traditional turners. I recall my jump from school "shop" class in 1959 when I turned my first bowl, laminations of kiln dried and glued shop scraps, to my first encounter with a turner making natural edged vessels with bark inclusions. That difference is why I turn today- the joy and freedom of using "imperfect" wood as a component in the creative process. As the son and grandson of architects, I was surrounded with structured form and symmetry, and I don't reject that background, but rather believe it served as part of my education and understanding of process and creativity. We are free to adopt or reject aspects of the world around us, but shutting out part of that environment limits the resources that contribute to the learning process.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#17

Yes, BUT..................

Ruth Niles

>I think every area has within itself and "area" where high-end art works sells and where plain bowls sell. Within a 50 miles radius of all of us there is a furniture store where you could not afford to shop or an art shop with $1,000 min. paintings. There is also a Wal-Mart and a $1 Store.

I think everyone has to first decide what they want to produce or who they want to deal with and then find that audience.

My stainless steel stoppers are an excellent example and where I've learned how much this attitude or fact applies. There are tons of turners who come to my booth, admire the stoppers, sigh and say "people in my area won't pay more than $xy for a woodturning, I'll stick with the cork (or chrome or whatever)". I understand but YES, there are people in their area who will buy ART or a more expensive item, you just have to go where they shop.

There is a market for everything and everyone can make a living selling just about anything on this planet. Don't believe it? do a search on eBay for something stupid and see how much it's going for!

John, this isn't aimed at you in particular because I've seen enough of your work to know you can sell from the middle to the top!

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#18

Re: Beating a dead horse or as Andi

Ruth Niles

>Andi Wolfe has my favorite saying, "It's WOOD, go have fun!"

If you're trying to get recognized as an artist, bravo, go for it.

If you're turning as a hobby, great, you'll learn a lot along the way.

If you're turning utilitarian, production work, what are you doing reading this, get busy!

If you're turning because you're retired and want to be active and creative, I'm proud of you.

If you're turning to become rich and famous, get in line and you better either be extremely talented or very patient.

If you're turning because you want to, you have "the answer".

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#19

Re: Beating a dead horse.

TDaniel

>I'm with you Stuart, this subject comes up far too often and never gets settled.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#20

Re: Beating a dead horse.

John Lucas

>I don't think we actually have to settle anything. I'm not trying to start anything I just think we can learn by simply discussing what has come before, what is today, and where might we, as individuals go. hopefully each person learns form this kind of discussion and takes something of value with them in this fine hobby. I hope it doesn't disolve into and art vs craft thing because we already know that can't be answered and it really doesn't matter anyway.

We simply want to discuss where turning has been and where it might be going so that each person can decide which part they want to be in. I like the art end of the movement but in practicality I'm with Terry in the that I make what sells in my area. That's real life. If you manage to find an art outlet that will sell the other work then that's fine also. Or as Ruth said, if you don't want to sell at all, no problem there either.

I simply like to look at woodturning from all levels and see where my work might go.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#21

Re: I know you've all been

Allen Neighbors

>waiting for the old gray dummy to chime in. :o) I want to tell you about something that I saw with me own eye!!

I saw Ruth Niles using a skew on a piece of scrap wood. She cut that wood so smooth it didn't need any sanding. She had mastered her craft to the point that, as I watched her, I thought, "She's an artist!" To me, it was a work of art.

I saw TD shape the bottom on a fairly large bowl, with a 1/2" bowl gouge, in just two moves. That was a work of art! To me, anyway.

When Rembrandt mastered the craft of handling his brush so that it did exactly what he wanted it to do, it became art. To some folks, anyway.

To me, a crude picture of a horse, drawn by a ten-year-old with crayons, with a caption that reads, "To Al. I love you, and so does Jesus", is a piece of art.

When I looked at those hollow forms that Don Turner, and later, Carole Valentine, had spun out of chunks of wood, I said, "I want to learn to do that." To me, they were all pieces of art.

I think that art is in the eye of the beholder, same as beauty. To me it's all art, traditional and far out... some of it's just better than others.

I sure do like to turn wood, don't you? :o)

BTW, I enjoyed your op-ed piece.

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#22

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Ed Karch

>I turn and sell everything from a $5 piece on up to some very edgy arty stuff. Most of the return is in the middle. Question: I want to be a famous turner. Do I have to croak first like all the flatwall artists?

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#23

Re: I know you've all been

Carole Valentine

>Why Al, I'm flattered! ;) Flattery will get you everywhere...if you email me your address, I have something I want to send you. To be honest, I had been planning on sending it to you for a long time...the flattery had nothing to do with it! LOL

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: Beating a dead horse.

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Stuart, I think you're on to something with the "middle aged" turner concept. After all, this is the "me" generation. The generation who rejected the values of the older generation, boldly questioned authority, and stated "Hell no, we won't go"!. It's no surprise to me that we've taken a different path in turning. Just listen to the music our generation created....certainly not based on classical. I can assure you, my Dad despised the Beatles, whom he considered the personification of Satan himself. ( Funny, I included the music analogy in my original outline, but decided to delete it)

We may be aging, but not gracefully!

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Op Ed Piece: What about Tradition

Keith Tompkins

>I want to thank everyone for the thoughtful responses...just what I had hoped for! The real reason I posted this was not to bring up the same old debate, but to look at the way we turn from a slightly different perspective. It's not easy to look at something from someone else's point of view. But, if the traditional turner and the art turner can find some common ground, then maybe a bit of understanding and mutual respect will begin to develop. Then, maybe the tired old debate will slowly fade away.

Thanks for reading my op ed....YOUR TURN!