Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Posts

1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#1

1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Ruth Niles

>These are pictures of my 3-car garage, I want to close in 2 bays for my shop. If I do it the way I want, I can only afford to close in 1 bay, that's silly because next year I'd only want more room.

Had 2 guys come for estimates but I need to know a little more of what I want, how I can cut expenses and what not to bother with. I can't do the framing, since there are walls, just need insulation, I figure 24" centers and maybe do an 8' ceiling. What do I do about the garage door, it's 10'(?). There's a great barn door in the back that I do want to utilize (I love it!). I can do the insulation and put up 1/4" plywood for walls, spray paint white. I would like a ceiling fan and will have a vented wall propane heater.

It's the actual construction I'm having trouble with: should the walls go to the trusses at 12'? Do a drop to 8' but frame around the garage door? Frame out the barn door to 8' ceiling? Anyone live real close and can come draw me a picture????? Newville, PA, 9 miles south of Carlisle, I don't cook but I buy a mean hogie!


img

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#2

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop #2 

Ruth Niles

>


img

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#3

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop #3 

Ruth Niles

>


img

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#4

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop Main Pic 

Ruth Niles

>


img

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#5

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Hooligan

>Ruth, I have a friend that is in Heberling, a carpenter. I'll have him get in touch with you, see if he can get over see it up close and personal, maybe give you some advice.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#6

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

gary s clarke

>Ruth, do you want to do flat work or just turning? I do both in my 3 car garage and have everything that I can on wheels(except the lathe and cabinet saw). When I move the car out of the 3rd spot I expand the planer and drum sander and sharpening cabinet out of the turning area. I still do not have a lot of room to store wood. I also have the jointer and miter saw on wheels. I left the garage door on and disconnected the door opener so it wouldn't be accidentally be opened in the shop area.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#7

Dick Hines

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Dick Hines

>Ruth I too am looking into deviding my 2 car garage. I have 10' ceilings and am going to keep them so. I am going to keep one side of the garage to put my motorcycle in. I also want to get my dust collector and compresser out of the shop proper. Way to much noise.

If I were you I would leave the ceiling as and keep the doors. They can be insualted. They would be nice to have in hot weather. You could use thin plywood instead of dry wall and then you could hang thing on the walls.

I have be thinking of going the job for 2 years but shows keep me turning. I have one show this year so this may be the winter the shop is turned into a SHOP.

Good luck with your shop.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#8

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Ruth,

I operate under the Keep It Simple principle. I'd frame up to the 12' joists if possible. As a quick solution, how about using that heavy duty plastic hung from the joists to do a quick and dirty partition?

As for the garage door, I'd leave it as it is. You can never tell when having two large entrances to your shop will come in handy (like during the summer months). But I'd insulate the living hell out of it. Home Depot and Lowes sell a type of light weight insulation (a type of styrofoam) that is meant for garage doors. You apply it to the back of the garage door with construction adhesive. My buddy Gordon Sampson (he frequents the Main Message board from time to time) used this on his shop. Only his problem wasn't cold air, but hot air. It stays well over 100 deg F in Houston Tx (where he lives) for weeks at a time during the summer. So far it has helped keep his shop nice and cool.

With the 12 foot ceilings, I'd install one or two Ceiling Fans. They will help to drive the heat down towards the floor during the winter, and vice versa during the summer.

You probably know this trick already. Get some horse stall mats for your shop floor. They're great for insulating your feet from the concrete (it does have a concrete floor, doesn't it?), and they really help to reduce back pain.

I hope this helps.

Dominic

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#9

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Allen Neighbors

>Ruth, keeping the ceiling at the height of your present joists will possibly be better in the long term. 8' is too low for a shop ceiling, if you ever want to move anything large in to work on. I wish mine was 10 or 12 feet high.

I would discourage the ceiling fan, due to the way they keep the dust always in the air, unless you put in some heavy duty exhaust fans. An air cleaner suspended from the ceiling will keep the air circulated, winter and summer, and serve to keep the air clean while it's moving. :o)

The door? If you think you might want it later, Dominic had a good idea about the insulation. If you don't want it, sell it, and close the hole. Use the money to buy another tool!! :o)

I saw a photo on this forum where there was clear plastic hanging around the lathe area, to keep the shavings contained. It's an idea I'm rolling around in my mind. Clear vinyl at Wal-Mart is 1.77 per yard, 54" widths. I think I'm going to use some around my lathe.

Blessings to you as you try to figure all of it out. Do it your way, you'll be happy when it's done! :o)

Allen

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#10

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Ruth Niles

>Thanks, where is Heberling?

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#11

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Ruth Niles

>Gary, I do mostly turning but do have a drill press (very big, very OLD, very heavy), a table saw and a jointer/planer (very OLD, very heavy). I also have another outbuilding that could be a low 2-car garage for storing all my wood.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#12

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Ruth Niles

>Gary, why do you think I should keep the 12' ceiling? I was figuring 8' would be one sheet of plywood high. Also I wouldn't need more than 1 ceiling fan. I'm curious as to the advantage of the higher ceiling, I might change my mind if it's a good one.

I'm definitely keeping the big doors.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#13

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Ruth Niles

>Dominic, you said the same thing Gary did about keeping the 12' ceiling and I'm really curious as to the reason. I figured 8' was the height of a sheet of plywood and 12' studs are going to be a lot more plus extra insulation. There's got to be something I'm missing about the extra 4'?

I don't think that heavy duty plastic will keep me warm in the winter.

Thanks for the tip about the garage door insulation at Home Depot and Lowes. And, no, I didn't know that little trick about using horse stall mats. I'll get a few for sure.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#14

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Ruth Niles

>Allen, I really love all those big doors. I was working out there this evening with both the barn door and the 2 garage doors open and cool breeze blowing through was invigorating. I understand what you're saying about possibly needing more height, but honest, I'm too old to be moving anything more than 6' high! Of course you're right about having it because you "might" need it someday. Isn't that why we have so many tools?!?!

Oh, I'll do it all my way, I'm just not sure what my way is right now.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#15

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Mike Brazeau

>Ruth - I am two concessions north of Carlisle, but in Ontario. Couple of comments. I have a three car garage that is 2x6 exterior construction and well insulated with an 11 foot ceiling also insulated to same degree as house. Instead of the wall vented heater go radiant. With a 10 foot U-tube radiant heater about 1/3 the way across the one bay I work in and set at 60 degrees F, I am cooking. That is with three cedar uninsulated doors. No ceiling fans are necessary. You can also use a long single tube heater. I leave garage set at lowest thermostat setting of just under 50 F and I figure it costs about $250-$300 to heat for the winter.

I don't think 1/4" plywood on 24" centers is going to look too great or hold much if you want to use wall space for odds & ends storage. Why lower the ceiling when you can attach the ceiling to the trusses? You can get plywood or oriented strand board in longer sheets. Go to a supplier that supplies builders, not Lowes or HD.

To keep lathe shavings in check, I strung vinyl coated clothesline using eyebolts and turnbuckles to get taunt and bought white shower curtains at the dollar store. Pin them together with clothes pins and works great. Wish I was closer to help you out more.

Mike

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#16

Opinions on Shop

Mike Nelson

>Hi Ruth, I am a carpenter/remodler/cabinet maker. Believe me and the others, keep the high ceilings. My shop is 18' at the peak with a laminated beam that suports the roof (no trusses, only rafters insulated and sheetrocked). I see you have trusses on what looks like 4'? centers, that is not enough for plywood or anything else. You will have to use firring strips, 2X4s laid flat, 90 degrees to the trusses, on at least 24" centers(I would go 16" on a ceiling). Dropping the ceiling would also be more expensive. For the partition wall use 2X4s on 16" centers it is stronger and for a 12'long wall you only need 3 more, (10) at 5$ ea. The cheapest and simplest walls are sheetrock, almost 1/4 the cost of plywood, then waferboard. If you decide to do this yourself, I can fax you easy to understand drawings on the wall and cieling construction. You might want to hire a sheetrocker but the rest anyone can do if they have the 'directions. :)

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#17

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

gary s clarke

>Ruth, I think you have my message mixed up with others about keeping your 12 ft ceiling, mine is 9ft which is nice because if reflects light well and allows for the 6 inch dust collection ducts. If you have have another building which works for a small garage why not keep your car there and use the entire 3 car garage for your shop? Good luck, I am sure you will have a great shop when finished.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#18

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

robo hippy

>I took out my shop's 16 foot wide door, and replaced it with a framed insulated wall, 2 windows, and a double wide door which also has windows. This insulates better than any garage door. I agree with using sheet rock on the walls as being cheaper, and more fire resistant than plywood. Get it taped and the screw holes plastered then paint it. I have 9 foot ceilings in my shop, and they are a bit short for moving plywood sheets, even if you don't do that. There is a heavy duty white vynal type of stuff (4 foot wide on a roll) that the insulators put on the rafters in my shop to hold up the insulation that is cheaper than sheet rocking the ceiling. It looks like you could just roll up your garage door and leave it there if you want, then frame in a door and/or windows. Looks like you will have enough room. I have also heard of putting up shower curtains to help contian all the flying shavings.

robo hippy

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#19

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Hooligan

>Maybe 10 miles west of Newville.

He lives off Brandy Road, or Whiskey road...something like that... I'll give him a shout in the morning.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#20

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>I don't know what kind of work you do, but if it is anything that will involve eight feet or longer stock from time to time you will be amazed at how LOW an eight foot ceiling can be. After a few loud pops followed by the rain of broken glass from hitting a florescent tube with a board or sheet of plywood on its way to the tablesaw you will wish for at least a 10 foot ceiling. My shop ceiling is 8 1/2. It was an existing building and there was no way I could have it higher but there is not a week goes by that I don't wish it WAS higher.

If you really go crazy eventually and install a cyclone DC the higher ceilng will really come in handy.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#21

oops, sorry Gary

Ruth Niles

>You're right, I did get the messengers mixed up with regard to the height of the ceiling.

With all the suggestions here and the ones in emails, I've decided to lower the ceiling for the reasons you mentioned and others.

Thanks

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#22

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

Ruth Niles

>Thanks, Randy. What I'm really trying to do is collect as much advice from experience as possible to avoid "wishing I'd done...." or the opposite. But you know whatever I do, I'm still going to be "wishing I'd ....." !

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#23

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop: Mike

Ruth Niles

>Thanks for some great suggestions.

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#24

Yes, Mike!

Ruth Niles

>I like what you said and, please do email instructions. I think I had dillusions of grandure when I thought I could just hire a contractor to build me the perfect shop! I am most suredly going to have to do most of the work myself.

Thanks

Re: 1/2 OT: Opinions on Shop

#25

More good advice..........

Ruth Niles

>Thank you. Now I have to take my list to the lumber yards and get comparison prices.