Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Help me Choose * Pics*

Posts

Help me Choose * Pics*

#1

Help me Choose * Pics*

Ron in Drums PA

>Help me choose which finial you think works best. BTW - It's ok to say they all stink.

The box is about 3.5" tall

Also, these are just quick snapshots and there is no finish yet.

1

2

3

4

5

6

Thanks for your input

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#2

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

dwr

>1,5,6

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#3

one

TDaniel

>

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#4

one

Mike Nelson

>

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#5

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

Allen Neighbors

>One, but I think it's a little tall.

#6 would be my choice if the top teardrop and lower gizmo were smaller, and if it was a little shorter. The center piece echoing the shape of the HF is neat. :o)

But what do I know?....

Allen

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#6

One

George Van

>

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#7

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

Ken Oakley- Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>#5

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#8

JL

Re: #1, #3 or #5..

JL

>Though #1 looks fragile.

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#9

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

Gil Jones

>one

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#10

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

Ian

>one

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#11

Steven Antonucci

Uno

steve antonucci

>

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#12

Thanks

Ron in Drums PA

>Looks like "One" is it.

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#13

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

Bill Stehman

>Ron,

You have put a lot of work into each of them but I gather you are not happy with any?

Maybe a little taper in the stems and few of them would be outstanding... just a thought.

Beautiful box....

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#14

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Ron,

Here's my humble opinions. #1-is the best but is too tall. #2-Too many beads and coves, and they should get progressively smaller. #3-no rhyme or reason #4 Way too clunky #5-This would be nice if you thinned it down by 50% and make it get smaller towards the top. #6 way too top heavy. They are all good practice and I think you will soon be knocking them out

before you know it.

Mike

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#15

one or five

John Veerkamp

>

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#16

One

Don Henthorn

>

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#17

You're right

Ron in Drums PA

>I'm not really happy with any of them.

#1 does have a slight taper, 3/32" to a little less than 1/16". I guess you really have to look close to notice it though, even if you are holding it in your hand.

Thanks.

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#18

Two Centavos

Jim

>Here's my two cents:

1) Nice shape, too tall.

2) Almost too tall, but too "busy"

3) Almost the right size, but also kinda busy

4) I agree that this is a bit "clunky" but of all the _shapes_ I like it best. It's simple. If it were just a tad taller, the base a little wider and the top a little smaller, I think it would be a winner. In other words it needs that taper that the above poster mentioned.

5) I like this one because it has a nice transition between all the elements. If it had just a little more taper I think it'd be perfect.

6) Ok.. I think this one is a bit "Dr. Suess-y" Or maybe something out of Alice and Wonderland? Or a formal garden topiary? It's a bit on the whimsical side.

Just my opinions of course...

I think that when we make finials we should pay attention to the "direction" it generates. If we think about this, then our finials would flow better. Not that I've made any finials mind you.. but I'll be trying to make one on Monday, and I'll probably post a similar thread....

Number 5 gets my vote.

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#19

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

Ron in Drums PA

>Thanks for your input!

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#20

Re: Two Centavos

Ron in Drums PA

>Thanks for your input!

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#21

Re: Help me Choose * Pics* well........

Ruth Niles

>Ron, the base is beautiful, first off.

If you're presenting this or showing it to woodturners or at a woodturning show, do #1. It's thin and long, a woodturners challenge.

If you're planning on selling it or giving it as a gift, do #5. It looks like it won't break super easy (I'd make it a bit thinner, maybe 25% off), it conforms with the size of the form on the bottom.

One woman's opinion.

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#22

Uno

Jorge Castaneda

>

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#23

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

Merv in BC

>No question here No 1. It is the only one with propotion and balance

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#24

One

Colin Spencer

>

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Help me Choose * Pics*

Keith Tompkins

>HI Ron, here's my take on the finials:

1. This one is best, main problem is the stem is too straight, would benefit from a taper from the beads to the tip.

2. and 3. Too busy, so many different details and shapes are confusing. No sense of unity.

4.Nice, simpler shape, but overpowers the form...too massive.

5. Good, tapers up toward the tip, but details need to be better proportioned (smaller) toward the tip, focus should be on the tip.

6.Top heavy, too many details at the top of the finial.

You've got some good bead shapes, and some good overall ideas here. It's just a matter of refinement. Coves separating the shapes will greatly add to your "repetoire". Definitely on the right track!