Re: Turning ??? My 2 cents
Mkauder, Phenix City, AL
>Over the relativly few years I have been turning, my ideas about woodturning and wood art have changed, as have my views on the AAW Journal.
When I first started, I wanted to learn about basic "How to turn a bowl", and the use of different tools. At that time, I could watch a basic bowl turning demo in facination. I was not ready for a Binh Pho presentation. As I became competent at those basic skills and tools, I wanted more advanced tools and techinques. Eventually, I came to enjoy Demos on subjects that I was quite sure I would never use, but found small things of interest - tools, techniques, comments - that sparked an idea or filled a hole in a problem I was trying solve in my own work.
I now find that basic turning techique demos do not hold my interest. Example: Last October I was lucky enough to be asked to be a one demo at the end of the day demonstrator at the Ohio Valley Woodturning Symposing (Turning 2005). I say lucky, because they had a Who's Who of turners - Richard Raffan, Ray Key, J.Paul Fennel, John Jordan, Chris Stott, and a new guy I had not heard of, Jimmy Clewes - as well as other good turners Jamie Donaldson, Chris Ramsey, etc, etc. I just could not wait to watch demos by these masters and Icons of wood turning.
You know what, I did not sit all the way through a single one of the famous woodturner's demos. To the beginning wood turner, I am sure that they were fasinating. But but I have seen a basic bowl turning (Richard Raffan) or a small wooden box (Chris Stott). Their demos were the same old stuff, just famous guys doing it. Nothing particularly illuminating. So I left the Raffan Demo (which was not full), and went over to the Demo by Jimmy Clewes - it was jam packed - standing room only. He was doing exciting things with wood, as well as being very informative about hows and the WHYS. Taking the techniques we all already know, and doing exciting things with them. He and Stuart Batty are now my favorate demonstrators.
When I schedule demonstrators at our club, because of the ratio of new turners to experienced turners, I have to have more "How you attach a piece of wood to the lathe and turn it round" demos, that "Russ Fairfield Laminated Platter" demos. You have to have both. But as the ratio of experienced turner grows, you have to have more and more of the advanced subjects.
This it goes for the AAW Journal as well. I beg to differ with someone's previous comment to the effect that if you keep having more "Wood Art" in the journal and at the symposiums, you will have fewer members. I think it is the opposite, evidence that fact that at the most recent symposiums, for example, you could hear the echos in rooms demonstrating basic stuff (David Lancaster, for example - as good as he is), and you could not get a view from the door, because of the crowd in a Stuart Mortimer carved spiraling demo.
What I am getting to is, I love to look at David Lancaster Nested Bowls for example - wood selection is second to none, but they are still just basic bowls. Jacques Vesery's work, for example, everyone is different. I defy anyone to tell me that the colaberative top donated by Jacques and Bonny Klein to the auction in Louisville is not turning or Turned Wood, Turned Art or Wood Art or Art.
I tell people all the time when I see some of the things in the instant galleries "Just because you can do it, does not mean you should do it", but to each his own.
I do think that it is funny that the basic bowl side of the argument is always saying that the artsy stuff is not turned wood, but the artsy guys never claim that the basic bowl is not art.
Just my opinion.
Mark