Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Turning ???

Posts

Re: Turning ???

#26

Re: Minorities

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Bill,

I spent a fair amount of time in the Instant Gallery in Louisville, informally and as a formal volunteer. There were any number of very finely done "traditional" turnings on display. But the items around which people (both AAW members and general public walk-ins) tended to "cluster" were those "augmented" and "gee wiz" pieces that stepped outside the bounds of bowls and jars (um, hollowforms |;-} ). Those were the pieces that drew the comments and sparked discussion as people talked. In walking around the Gallery and the Symposium, I heard very little "You see those great Mahoney bowls?", but a lot of "Did you see the incredible Bin Pho piece on the wall?" or "How'd he do that fish piece?" kinds of comments.

Clearly there must always be a place in the AAW for "craft" and "traditional form" turners. Whether they or the "art crowd" form the majority will, no doubt, be a fluid, ever-changing ratio that has little to do with what happens to get put in the Journal. I'll hazard a guess, however, that the AAW hasn't grown to over 12,000 members and the largest wood-working organization on the planet because of salad bowls.

Re: Turning ???

#27

Re: American Woodturner Magazine

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Outdated in the art world does not exist. What becomes "outdated" becomes part of the history of the medium. There is a continuous evolution going on in the art world.

In our medium, future turners will use this history to learn what came before them. I enjoy seeing past works. One of the highlights of my trip to Louisville was the fabulous show at the craft museum.

ketihz

Re: Turning ???

#28

Re: Turning ??? My 2 cents

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Over the relativly few years I have been turning, my ideas about woodturning and wood art have changed, as have my views on the AAW Journal.

When I first started, I wanted to learn about basic "How to turn a bowl", and the use of different tools. At that time, I could watch a basic bowl turning demo in facination. I was not ready for a Binh Pho presentation. As I became competent at those basic skills and tools, I wanted more advanced tools and techinques. Eventually, I came to enjoy Demos on subjects that I was quite sure I would never use, but found small things of interest - tools, techniques, comments - that sparked an idea or filled a hole in a problem I was trying solve in my own work.

I now find that basic turning techique demos do not hold my interest. Example: Last October I was lucky enough to be asked to be a one demo at the end of the day demonstrator at the Ohio Valley Woodturning Symposing (Turning 2005). I say lucky, because they had a Who's Who of turners - Richard Raffan, Ray Key, J.Paul Fennel, John Jordan, Chris Stott, and a new guy I had not heard of, Jimmy Clewes - as well as other good turners Jamie Donaldson, Chris Ramsey, etc, etc. I just could not wait to watch demos by these masters and Icons of wood turning.

You know what, I did not sit all the way through a single one of the famous woodturner's demos. To the beginning wood turner, I am sure that they were fasinating. But but I have seen a basic bowl turning (Richard Raffan) or a small wooden box (Chris Stott). Their demos were the same old stuff, just famous guys doing it. Nothing particularly illuminating. So I left the Raffan Demo (which was not full), and went over to the Demo by Jimmy Clewes - it was jam packed - standing room only. He was doing exciting things with wood, as well as being very informative about hows and the WHYS. Taking the techniques we all already know, and doing exciting things with them. He and Stuart Batty are now my favorate demonstrators.

When I schedule demonstrators at our club, because of the ratio of new turners to experienced turners, I have to have more "How you attach a piece of wood to the lathe and turn it round" demos, that "Russ Fairfield Laminated Platter" demos. You have to have both. But as the ratio of experienced turner grows, you have to have more and more of the advanced subjects.

This it goes for the AAW Journal as well. I beg to differ with someone's previous comment to the effect that if you keep having more "Wood Art" in the journal and at the symposiums, you will have fewer members. I think it is the opposite, evidence that fact that at the most recent symposiums, for example, you could hear the echos in rooms demonstrating basic stuff (David Lancaster, for example - as good as he is), and you could not get a view from the door, because of the crowd in a Stuart Mortimer carved spiraling demo.

What I am getting to is, I love to look at David Lancaster Nested Bowls for example - wood selection is second to none, but they are still just basic bowls. Jacques Vesery's work, for example, everyone is different. I defy anyone to tell me that the colaberative top donated by Jacques and Bonny Klein to the auction in Louisville is not turning or Turned Wood, Turned Art or Wood Art or Art.

I tell people all the time when I see some of the things in the instant galleries "Just because you can do it, does not mean you should do it", but to each his own.

I do think that it is funny that the basic bowl side of the argument is always saying that the artsy stuff is not turned wood, but the artsy guys never claim that the basic bowl is not art.

Just my opinion.

Mark

Re: Turning ???

#29

That's

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Way more than 2 cents worth, and right on the money!

m

Re: Turning ???

#30

BALANCE, IS ANYONE LISTENING?

TDaniel

>Every post is the same. Why can't we have some of each? No one is asking for a ban on artsy stuff. No one is asking for a ban on carved items, or burned, or dyed, or anything. The mere suggestion of having some focus on the basics seems to get feathers all raised up. Why?

Re: Turning ???

#31

Re: TD- the only ruffled feathers ....

JamieDonaldson

>...I have seen in this thread seem to be yours?! The diversity within woodturning today is what attracts most turners to the arena, new and old, neophyte and curmudgeon alike. There must always be an evolution within any endeavor that adds life to the process, otherwise it becomes stagnant and dies. Styles and trends come and go, that is a basic and necessary fact in human endeavors.

Re: Turning ???

#32

I do both

Ed Karch

>round and brown for the craft shows where utility stuff can fetch a fair price, and push the envelope arty stuff for the galleries where it can click for some customer who will pay astronomical prices for something they like. I much prefer the technical and creative processes required for the art pieces to the technical processes required for the utilitarian/classic pieces. I think we can all fit under the same tent without pushing and shoving.

ps:TD I think your stuff is great but is a little too artsie for the plain bowl buyer:o)

Re: Turning ???

#33

Re: TD- the only ruffled feathers ....

TDaniel

>Jamie, what is wrong with having some classical turnings featured occasionally? What is wrong with trying to achieve some balance? Why should every issue be dedicated to the far out?

Re: Turning ???

#34

Re: Minorities

Bill Crommett

>Mark : Stop trying to cloud the issue . The whole point is one of nomenclature. The gee-whiz factor is completly tangent to the subject.

If a mostly naked chorus girl walked through the hall she would get a lot of "gee-whiz" coments, but would you be risque enough to call her "a turning"? The point is : At what point does one define how much embellishment still fits in with the catagory as defined. A wood bowl completely covered with beads could just as well be made from a clay pot or a tin bucket because the beads are the only thing visable. And what if the tin bucket were dented and covered with beads; would you call it carving ? The parameters are blurred, and at some point there has to be a distinction made as to what to call something that is 1% turning and 99% carving (beading, piercing, burning, embellishing) or 99% turning and 1% embellishment. My question still stands regarding the carved totem pole with a turned button nose, in spite of John's clouding of the issue with his mention of the Arrowmont totem which I agree is a tremendous piece of work.

Re: Turning ???

#35

Re: Don't Beg To Differ

Ron in Drums PA

>Mark Said:

"So, if you argue for your limits, they're yours. But don't try to make them mine."

Here is where I beg to differ. I never tried to argue my limits.

Re: Turning ???

#36

Re: Nomenclay-chur

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Don't think I'm clouding anything, Bill. As an art history major, I spent lots of hours figuring out the hows and whys of putting most any object into any number of nicely defined slots, each with an appropriate label. That's a basic and proper academic endeavor. As an artist, I conciously reject the pigeonholes. I don't need some external definition or formula to relate to a piece in the Instant Gallery of the AAW Journal.

I don't need to put a piece inside of a definition, and so I'll disagree with you that "at some point there has to be a distinction made as to what to call something . ." I'll simply call it a "piece" and move on to what it's really about, whether pure form, piercing, carving, painting, beading, and any combination of the myriad processes available for use today.

With regard to your dented and beaded bucket, since it's metal, I'd call it what it is, repouse.

Now if your stripper were wearing that button nose . . . . .

|;-}

Re: Turning ???

#37

Re: TD- you are making an ....

JamieDonaldson

>...incorrect general statement when you say you don't see some examples of many different examples and levels of turning within the AAW, and being an ex-member doesn't show much effort on your part to affect change in the organization. The most effective way to change an organization is working from within, not outside casting stones from a solitary soapbox.

Re: Turning ???

#38

Re: Begging Differences

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Didn't think you were, whatever they may be. I wasn't speaking about your limits, but rather of those who often wish to place language and formula fences around activities that are, by their nature, creative. Changes make many people uncomfortable, and they don't like their comfortable definitions shaken up or taken somewhere they think they can't or shouldn't go.

Never said you need to be able to write a contata before you can appreciate one.

I was responding to John and his post seeking to shrug off contrived limits on the general activity we call woodturning. Bill thinks I "cloud" the issues, but actually it's more like a fugue.

m

Re: Turning ???

#39

What imbalance???

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I check my recent issues of American Woodturner and every issue has several articles on basic turning projects. Sounds like a pretty good balance for an organization that covers all levels of woodturning.

Re: Turning ???

#40

Re: Of Course!

Ron in Drums PA

>Just because there is work in a medium that I don't like doesn't mean it shouldn't be considered art. My head is not that inflated.

But all good art has balance and proportion. Wahol 's Campbell's Soup Can has both.

Picasso's cubism has balance and proportion. I would disagree with anyone who said cubism is not art.


I never cared for any of Picasso's cubism works and like his blue period better. Just my personal preference.


When I look at Van Ness work, I see objects that are out of proportion to each other, the same way a display would be for a student's science fair project. He tries to associate pieces to convey a disassociated message. Seeing a condom package along with the Tin Man is not art and by far, it is not turned art. He tries to achieve a balance with his narrative and without that narrative, Van Ness's work would fall flat, because his work lacks both balance and proportion. Just to set the record straight , I was never offended by his messages. There where times I chuckled when getting what he was trying to convey. I just never thought it was good art.

I enjoy reading Malcom's narratives. But if he decided not to include one with his work, his pieces would still stand up on it's own as art, because it has both proportion and balance.

That's the difference between good art and poorly executed art.

Re: Turning ???

#41

Re: Of Course!

Mac

>Interesting discussion,again! I'm going to keep turning what I want to turn and doing whatever I want to do to it...so there!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Turning ???

#42

Re: Of Course!

Allen Neighbors

>Me, too, Mac... :o)

Plain stuff for a plain guy (with no talent) :o(

But it sure is fun!!! :o)

Allen

Re: Turning ???

#43

Re: Of Course!

john lucas

>Mac That's the best Idea, and we all will probably do just that anyway. I just don't want anyone telling me I can't be in a turning club because my pieces are too imbellished. Where's the line. It's a very fuzzy line.

Re: Turning ???

#44

Re: TD- the only ruffled feathers ....

john lucas

>TD almost every issue has a basic turning project. Bob Rosand has done a bunch and so has Nick Cook. American Woodturner is the Journal of the AAW and consequently they will also run articles on elections and other business with the AAW as well as advanced articles on ART and other techniques. This is the only way they can achieve a good balance for the readers.

Re: Turning ???

#45

And you do them well Ed.

john lucas

>

Re: Turning ???

#46

Re: American Woodturner Magazine

john lucas

>I agree Keith. I stood for 10 minutes in front of Rude Osolnik's candlesticks. Even though I've seen several sets these were subtly different. Thier were 2 sets. Amazing stuff.

Re: Turning ???

#47

Re: Turning ???

Stephen Mushinski

>Many choose to see only what they want to see. Seems a few in this thread have chosen to be very critical of the AAW and of some artist. I am not an artist but a hobby woodturner. I very much enjoy seeing all the different items and idea's we are presented with from all over the world.

My take on why turning is popular, is how cheap a lathe and a set of basic tools are to begin with. You can be turning with pretty fair equipment for $300. Remember a bowl can be made by anyone with a scrapper and a piece of wood, no lathe needed. The difference between bowl "A" and "B" might be the quality and the time it took to make it. Now, much of the art (a bowl can be art) we see takes much longer plus the time and vision to see it before it ever is touch by a tool. My hats off to the talented.

I didn't know art from trash until three years ago. My eyes and mind were opened from a week at Arrowmont School of Art and Craft. The beauty of mixed media is something else. After dinner each night they have slide of the teaching artists. Some turners did not go and after I thought how much they are missing out. To learn about vision, the how's the why's gives a person insight. The world isn't black and white but wonderful colours. If you choose to see things as only black and white you just might be wasting a wonderful gift God gave you.

Unless a bowl is made out of the finest of figured wood I could care less if I seen it in the AAW magazine. I do not want to see a pen turned in the AAW magazine. The magazine should be up scale in quality and difficulty. Now when I see a beginner posting a first on a forum I will take notice of their achievement. That is my opinion which doesn't make it right but it is the way I feel. Note, I will still read the article on pen turner, since with an open mind I just might learn something.

None of us will like everything that every person will make. No one here likes every type of music that is made either. This is what makes each of us special.

Re: Turning ???

#48

OUCH!!!

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Stephen,

Awe man, Right through my heart buddy�.OUCH!!!!

:-)

I�m not much of a bowl turner, but I Love The Team!

Take care,

Jim


img

Re: Turning ???

#49

Re: OUCH!!!

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>You are a MASTER Pen Turner. I know I have 4 of yours. I have never ever seen better.

Mark

Re: Turning ???

#50

Re: OUCH!!!

Ed Karch

>He wasn't talking about you Jim. You are a true artist. He was talking about pen turners not PEN turners.