Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Turning ???

Posts

Turning ???

#1

Turning ???

john lucas

>Several people seem to be really upset about woodturning that is being highly embellished or highly carved. I really don't understand it. When you are making a bowl don't you sometimes visualize adding a bunch of beads to the side. Then after you make this one you turn another and it has a crack in the side. You think, what if I cut this crack up and made this bowl look like a bird (remember the post a few days ago,beautifully done by the way).

OK now you decide it might be fun to make an offcenter piece. It turns out really cool so you do another and move it on 2 centers. Then you think I wonder what would happen if I move the centers to the side. Then a few dozen more of these and you have a Stony Lamar piece. Many people objected to Stoney's work because they say it doesn't look like it was on the lathe at all. So? It just an idea that took off and kept evolving.

Then thier are the people who have artistic talent inside. They start out making bowls but soon decide that this makes a good palette for thier artistic minds and the wood becomes just that. A palette, taking on all sorts of forms, telling stories, and expressing ideas.

I'm just saying that each individual is different and we will go in different directions with our turning. Everything doesn't have to be a beautiful bowl or hollow vessel with classic form. In fact there are those people that would look at the spinning wheel in the post below and say it's too gaudy with too many spindles that do nothing. A spinning wheel should be purely functional. You can't possibly please everyone.

Todd Hoyer is a perfect example of this. He started out making beautiful bowls and hollow forms and took the wood in a different direction. He is extemely knowledgeable about wood and how to work with it but chose to go in the direction that he has. When you see his slide show you see how the work evolved. It started by simply wondering what would happen if you worked with a cracked piece of wood. Then he buried some in the ground to make it crack more and it evolved from thier. I'll be honest I didn't like his work when I saw it in books. I thought exactly the same things some of you are thinking, that it was ugly. Then I saw it in person. Even burned, cracked and wrapped with wire you can see how well the forms work together. He is a master of his medium and simply chose to go this direction.

I don't have any problem with those who want to make pretty pieces just don't think you should be putting down those who don't. You say tomato I say tomaaaato ( I'm still trying to decide if it's fruit or vegatable). Anyway that's just my 2 cents (plus a little)

Re: Turning ???

#2

I Agree John

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>John, I am in complete agreement with you. It is a shame if anyone is made to feel restricted by the opinions of others. Everyone should feel free to explore any direction in woodturning or any other art form without censure unless it is pornographic. Let's not get into a discussion about what is and what isn't pornographic please.

Re: Turning ???

#3

Balance

TDaniel

>John, in the past few years there has been a gross imbalance in what has been shown in the AAW mag and what is chosen at turning events. I do not say that there is anything wrong with some of the way out pieces or the highly enhanced pieces.....I just think we are forgetting the horse that brought us here. There is nothing wrong with creating a piece of "wood-art", just don't call it a "wood-turning" unless it is one. There are many ways to work a piece of wood....carving, turning, slicing, whittling, whatever....and combining several of these arts is fine. We have people in our turning club that also belong to a carving club and they combine what they learn from both arts. They do not get turning lessons at their carving meeting and we don't give carving lessons at our turning meeting....(yet). My buyers tell me that they don't like the way out stuff. The way out frequently gets dated, like flipper hub caps, fender skirts, spotlights, blue dots in the taillights, etc. Classical forms remain, year after year, so they should be included regularly in the turning mags, along with a few of the way out stuff.

Re: Turning ???

#4

The Garden Party

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>John,

Remember Ricky Nelson's song?

"It's alright now. I learned my lesson well. See you can't please everybody, so you got to please yourself."

Most whining about exceeding some alleged limit in any activity ["that's not turning" etc.] is actually an argument for the whiner's personal limits, lack of ability, or both. So, if you argue for your limits, they're yours. But don't try to make them mine.

The last line in the song? "If you have to play a garden party, I wish you a lot of luck, . . . . . I'd rather drive a truck."

|;-}}

Re: Turning ???

#5

Of Course!

Ron in Drums PA

>But there is a big difference between the artistic abilities of Malcomm and Andi (both of which I would love to own), and works like Van Ness's (which to me looks like child's toys) that would fall flat without his narratives.

The carved "insects" and such that pop up here and on WOW is also a far reach from both art and turning.

Re: Turning ???

#6

It's all in the name

TDaniel

>AAW...American Association of Woodturners or American Association of Woodartists? Choose one.

Re: Turning ???

#7

I beg to differ

Ron in Drums PA

>I enjoy classical music.

I can't compose it, copy it or play it, but that doesn't stop me from appreciating it for the art that it is.

Re: Turning ???

#8

Re: The Garden Party

adrien

>That's a bit strong, Mark. "Whining" is not the same as a critique. You might if you're Phillipino enjoy Balut. Personally, (whining?) I don't consider it edible. Is it food? Yes, but it belongs in a specialized small category. I agree with John that there's not enough focus on the basic "foods" of woodturning at these judgings. With the focus on the esoteric and extreme there's also a loss. It's good to push the envelope, but it's also importand to stress the basics.

Re: Turning ???

#9

Re: Balance

john lucas

>Terry I think the reason there is a percieved imballance in the work shown in the AAW is that there are so many advanced turners in the AAW. It is now 20 years old and many of the 12000 turners have been turning for more than 5 years. Consequently many of them will look for other things to do to the turning to keep it exciting to them.

If you turned 2 pieces, a nice bowl with great grain and good shape and an experimental piece with some nice carving, which piece would you send to a magazine to get published. My guess is the carved one because you are learning carving and it took a lot of skill to make and your quite proud of it. This helps create the image that everything is imbellished. I turn a lot of things that are just functional and designed to sell easily in my market. I don't post those photos or send them to the magazines because they are simply too ordinary to grab attention.

I sell everything I make (that I don't purposely hold on to) and so do my friends who embellish thier work. That shows that there is a market for this work as well. Garret Van Ness sells his work also as well as Christian Burchard, Clay Foster and Malcolm Tibbets. Fender skirts and fins won't sell in every market and neither will bowls. I know you can't go to the local craft fair and sell a piece like Malcolms, or Garrett's. I'll also agree that there is a much larger market for functional pieces. However if that's not what you want to make then that's your choice.

Re: Turning ???

#10

Re: Of Course!

john lucas

>Personally I love Garret VanNess's work. Even before I ever read one of his narratives (which are usually short because he want's us each to interpret it the way we want). Malcom's narratives on the other hand are quite lengthy bit not always necessary to the work. It takes a lot of skill to make either one and I will readily admit it's not to everyone's taste but that's the way art is. I never have liked Andy Warhol's soup can even though after reading why he did it I can understand how he got there. It just wasn't my kind of art.

That's what I'm trying to say is that in every medium there is a huge variety of work, some you like, some you don't, and some you just don't understand but it all affects the art form as a whole.

Re: Turning ???

#11

Re: Don't Beg To Differ

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Because my point was that IT'S ALL MUSIC, and what one particular artist does with a progression of sounds puts no obligation or limit on any other artist to do likewise or risk being denegrated as doing something other than music. You don't have to be able to play or compose it to appreciate it, just don't go on about blues, rock, or violin concertoes being the only "real music."

Re: Turning ???

#12

Same Here Barb

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Barb,

I agree with you completely as well.....

But honestly when we get into these discussions I feel like we all are standing here watching a dog chase it's tail....I am so over this.

I feel that you should Turn what you like and enjoy what you do... Ta dah!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Turning ???

#13

Re: Strong

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Adrien,

I think one of us has misread what John said. I read him as stating there should be no limits on how a lathe is used as a tool to shape wood, and imposing such limits based upon the final piece is inappropriate.

If I do a piece by turning a large bowl, breaking/cutting it into 506 pieces, and then, working with the curved pieces as my basic design element, reassembling it into something that bears no resemblence to a bowl, what gives anyone the right to kick me out of the turners' club? A lathe is a tool that may be used to shape the material at hand. My hypothecated piece is every bit as much a turning as it would be if I had left the bowl intact. You are free to disagree with me and certainly free to dislike the piece I've created for any number of reasons, but kindly don't whine to me that I'm "changing the rules of the game." The essence of art is that there are no rules and limits. If you put a fence around creativity, you kill it.

Most of J. Paul Fennel's work involves maybe 1% turning and 99% carving. Is he still a turner only because his piece retains the original shape of the jar that he made on the lathe? Betty Scarpino in the same boat? Peter Rand? Art Leistman? Tania Rada? Keith Tompkins? In my view, we need to stop trying to pigeonhole turners and their work based upon whether it fits within our preconceived notions and artificial definitions, our aesthetic "comfort zone", and simply enjoy (or walk away from) what's presented.

Anything edible is food. Live termites, maggots, and midges are considered delicacies in some places. Just because I have no interest in eating them doesn't give me the right to brand them as disgusting, not food, or people who eat them as weird or subhuman.

Peace.

Re: Turning ???

#14

Re: Of Course!

eliot d

>About all I will say about all this is that in the History of Art there have always been those who have broken with tradition and almost always were ridiculed for it. Edvard Munch comes to mind, and, of course, Van Gogh. Some of their works now sell in the $100 million range. Their critics have long been forgotten.

Re: Turning ???

#15

Re: Choices

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"Woodturners" by all means.

That term encompasses both the craftspeople who do familiar items which, although very well executed along conservative lines, are boring, as well as high craftsmen (and women) of outstanding technical ablity that lift otherwise boring shapes to a higher level, together with those who seek to create and express new visual ideas by using a lathe as part of their repertoire of tools and methods.

Re: Turning ???

#16

Re: Same Here Barb

john lucas

>I agree Jim but somedays I just feel like chasing my tail. Probably why it's so small.

Re: Turning ???

#17

Re: Strong

john lucas

>Well said Mark. I also think that if we try to stick with purely traditional work then shouldn't we be doing it on a foot powered lathe. I'll bet someone 100 years ago probably said "that ain't turnin' it was done on one of them nefangled motor driven things" Next thing you know we'll be using that durned High speed steel instead of good ole carbon steel.

Re: Turning ???

#18

perceived imbalance is costing

TDaniel

>the AAW a lot of members. Everytime someone posts wanting more classical turnings represented in the mag others immediately jump on their case. No one is saying forbid any turning, no matter how far out. People are trying to say to the AAW "there are 11,500 of us normal turners and 500 of the far out artiste, we are tired of not seeing things that are within our ability to make". I dropped out of the AAW for this reason and I know a lot of others who have done likewise. If some balance isn't put in the mag then in due time the AAW may have only 500 members. I don't mean to be rude or harsh but someone needs to wake up.

Re: Turning ???

#19

Re: perceived imbalance is costing

bob davis

>another case of the minority in charge

Re: Turning ???

#20

Re: Of Course!

Bill Crommett

>Just to add more confusion : There is turned art; carved art; glued art; hamered art; clay art; painted art; sculptured art; and a few more.

Each should have it's place and each should have its own catagory.

Please don't try to tell me that a totem pole is a woodturning piece because someone turned a button nose to put on carved face.

Re: Turning ???

#21

Barb Siddiqui

American Woodturner Magazine

Barb Siddiqui

>I've now had a year's subscription, and have no familiarity with an 'old' AAW magazine. These recent issues have given me many insights into the organization, its founders and mentors, along with advice and tips, beginners projects and "20 Ways Not To Turn A Bowl." The extreme pieces presented have been eye-openers as to Possibilities in the medium, and also an update on what is currently popular (read that 'soon outdated.') There is nothing wrong with that, and I think the magazine is doing a good job of presenting a full range of ideas, which is, after all, the point.

Re: Turning ???

#22

Re: perceived imbalance is costing

john lucas

>I see your point Terry but the AAW has grown from 8000 to 12000 in the last 6 or 7 years. That should say something. I'm definitely not an expert on this and I know there are people who feel like you. Most turners in our club are not members of the AAW. Not because of the magazine but simply because woodturning is a hobby and they don't have the hunger to read everything about it like I do. It's definitely not for everyone.

Re: Turning ???

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Turning ???

Keith Tompkins

>A couple of thoughts on the subject....first, there are lots of talented people getting involved in turning. In fact, turning is growing far faster than any other kind of woodworking. I think one huge factor is the ability to be creative. We are not limited to router-bit profiles to determine what we create. We don't have to stick to drawings or plans. NO wonder so many people are becoming turners...and, many of these new turners are bringing other skills with them.

There is room in the AAW for us all; in fact, skimming throught the latest issue, I studied each piece presented in the magazine. Each and every piece showed evidence of being on the lathe. There is an article on segmented works, all are obviously turned with great emphasis put on form. One piece in the Instant Gallery article was a turned bowl void of ornamentation...which was refreshing to see.

There are opportunities for all turners in the AAW as well. The recent success of Bill Grumbine's DVDs is a great example. I know Bill doesn't consider himself an artist, but he certainly is a teacher. Obviously, many AAW members are in need of a good teacher. Many others have found a place in the AAW as well...Alan Lacer, Bob Rosand and Richard Raffan turn many ordinary pieces, yet are known throughout the world as great turners and teachers.

Terry, for what it's worth, I would ask you to reconsider your stance on the AAW. I think you have much to contribute, and articles or turning tips submitted by you would be well-received. There are many turners who would benefit from your experience. However, if one is not part of an organization, then they cannot affect change in that organization. Hopefully, we can generate a feeling of mutual respect between the artists and craftsmen of turning.

One last thought, all of the artistic pieces shown in the magazines don't make other forms of turning less relevant. A well-turned bowl is still something to be admired. Whether a piece is carved or not, the overall form will decide success or failure. If you create well-turned pieces, submit good photos to the AAW editor. Hey,who knows?

Re: Turning ???

#24

Re: Don't Beg To Differ

john lucas

>Well said Mark. I know Keith would go with that analogy. He's into music as well.

Re: Turning ???

#25

Re: Of Course!

john lucas

>Bill You need to see the totem pole at Arrowmont. It is turned.