Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Turning DVD's

Posts

Turning DVD's

#1

Turning DVD's

W.C. Turner

>I don't have a DVD player yet, but, the way things are going, it appears that I'll be forced to make the switch, sooner, rather than later. And, when that happens, I didn't want to have to buy my turning videos a second time, on DVD.

Has anybody backed up their VHS Turning/WWing videos, by transferring them over to longer lasting DVD's?

Also, I'm not sure you can do this, for the Copyrighted material. I have the impression, that the DVD Mfg. pre-program their machines, so they will not make a copy of any CR material.

Thanks,

W.C.

Re: Turning DVD's

#2

Re: Turning DVD's

Ron McKinley

>I converted all my VHS tapes to DVD using a recorder I bought at Costco. However, it won't work on tapes that have copy protection. But, none of my VHS tapes had the copy protection so I can take my laptop to the shop play the DVDs while at the lathe........Ron

Re: Turning DVD's

#3

Re: Turning DVD's

W.C. Turner

>Mine are ones I bought at Places, such as Packard, etc., and they give a don't copy warning at the beginning of the tape. So, I assume you can't transfer them to DVD.?

I would like to only back up mine, so I don't have to buy them a second time, in case the tape breaks(from constant use),or if the VCR eats one,etc. It's not for re-sale.

Is there any way to tell if they'll transfer or not?

Re: Turning DVD's

#4

Re: Turning DVD's

Russ Fairfield

>The question is not whether or not it is possible to copy a VHS or a DVD. The question is whether it is legal or ethical. Clearly it can be done if the video has not been altered to prevent it. Whether it should be done is the question that should be asked.

Adding copy protection to a VHS was impossible, but it can be added to a DVD at a substantial cost. Those of us who are making woodturning videos don't do it because there will not be enough copies sold to recover that cost. We have to trust the honesty and integrity of the individual not to make a copy. Just remember that every copy is one less video sold, and one step closer to our not making another because it isn't worth the cost of doing it.

Re: Turning DVD's

#5

Re: Turning DVD's

Fog Tanner

>I know of a woodturning club that converted its VHS library to DVD. They have alomost all of the available tapes, including some of those that aren't worth having. To date, none of the VHS tapes have presented a problem with copyright. If you have the right video attachment card for a PC, you can copy almost anything from a VHS tape. The DVDs will not have any copyright mechanism on them. And if you have the right DVD burner and software, you can make backup copies of your commerical DVD's - up to a point. There are some copyright mechanisms that cannot be copied at this point. You are still "allowed" to make backup copies of you VHS/DVD materials as long as you don't sell of give them away. The key being "a" backup copy, in the sigular sense.

If you are looking into investing in DVD coping, it will pay to visit some of the CD-R and DVD-R forums and follow some of the threads on media. There is the good, the bad, and the ugly. I have used all three in CD-R recording, but the DVD media is much more sensitive due to it density. The dye used is also a concern in DVD-Rs, more so than CD-Rs. It is best to stay with a known quality brand rather than a no-name special. I have used those in CD-R with no problem, most of the time they are made by the same lowrent company that makes some of the "big name label", UMC. While I don't put data on them that I care about, music is another story. With DVD-Rs its the life of the dye, there are some lowrent brands that have the dye fade in six months or so. So, it is best of you don't trash those VHS tapes when you make your DVDs - remember Murphey made DVDs too.........

Re: Turning DVD's

#6

Re: Turning DVD's

Bill Howatt

>In my opinion, if I have bought the right to view the content of a video and all I want to do is put it in a different format then I have the right to do it as long as I keep the original. If I sell or give away the original then I have to give the owner any copies or preferably destroy them.

I do not advocate piracy in any form but in this case I am just adding convenience or the ability to view something I have paid for.

Bill

Re: Turning DVD's

#7

Re: Turning DVD's

Russ Fairfield

>A couple of your messages have poked me with a sensitive issue. Some clubs and individulas make copies because they see nothing wrong with doing it, and others don't because they see it as being unethical. I had no opinion until I got on the other side and started making woodturning videos. I also understand those who believe that they have purchased the content and they can do with it as they please.

There is an unintended consequence to everything we do. That consequence in the case of the copier is that is that there might not be any more videos to copy.

I have recently started having a lot of problems with DVDs not playing, and I started asking that people who were having problems return their copy to me. The amazing thing is that none of these copies are the originals that I sold, and most of them are copies from an earlier DVD which was slightly different from the DVD version. I chased after the one I received yesterday and got the guy to admit that it was a 3rd generation copy that was made from a copy of a copy that was made from a club VHS as a backup file. He expected me to make it right when it didn't play on his computer because the club bought the viewing rights to it, and it was up to me to make sure that he could view it. That pisses me off.

When woodturners start jacking me around like that, I am rethinking whether I will ever make another video for you to copy. I have discussed this with others who are making videos for woodturning and other arts and crafts, and they are having similar problems and having similar doubts about future videos.

So, if you want to continue making your copies, that is your choice. But, it is also my choice that you have nothing to copy.

Re: Turning DVD's

#8

Re: Turning DVD's

bob davis

>AMEN

Re: Turning DVD's

#9

Re: Turning DVD's

W.C. Turner

>I feel I'm as legal, and ethical, just as much as the maker of a video is. I paid good, hard earned, money, for my copy of these videos. My meaning was not to sell, or give away copies.

<<<"He expected me to make it right when it didn't play on his computer because the club bought the viewing rights to it, and it was up to me to make sure that he could view it.">>> I wouldn't even consider doing something like that!! Now, that could be labeled as not legal and not ethical!!

DVD's are making VCR's extinct, & all I was wanting was to have a DVD copy that I could view, when that happens. But, it sounds like it's too much trouble anyway.

When it's just for my use, I can't see anything wrong about it, even if I want to make myself 10 copies.

How many times should we have to purchase the same video?

Re: Turning DVD's

#10

I agree...sorta...

BubbaBob

>As a published author, I see your point, and agree, to a point.

In the book world, and under publishing copyright law, if I buy a book and wish to use a photocopier to copy it chapter by chapter so I can read it at work without getting the book greasy, that is legal, and it is akin to VHS to DVD copying. However, when I give that copy to another while keeping the book, I've broken copyright law and acted in an unethical manner.

I just figure if someone wants to be a scumbag, they will find a way to do it...sorta like locks only keep honest folks honest...they don't really deter crookc\s.

BubbaBob

Re: Turning DVD's

#11

Re: Turning DVD's

Dinyar Chavda

>I don't know if it is necessarily true that VCRs are going to become extinct. Even if pre-recorded material comes only in the form of DVDs rather than VCR tapes, there is still a market for tapes that are going to be used for time-shifting, i.e., taping a TV show to watch at a more convenient time. So, I doubt if the machines for playing back VCRs are going to become extinct anytime soon.

Why not buy a combined DVD/VCR player--that's what I did when my last VCR died. When they go on sale, I don't think they cost much more than the DVD-players do.

Re: Turning DVD's

#12

Re:Copyright laws allow.......

JamieDonaldson

>... the original purchaser to make copies in any format for their own personal, PRIVATE use. The copies cannot be publically displayed such as at club meetings unless the club has a non-exclusive license for such public use.

Re: Turning DVD's

#13

Re: Turning DVD's

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Russ,

In a previous post you mentioned that you had no opinion on this matter until you got on the other side and started to make videos. Unfortunately this is the case for just about everyone.

I don't make videos, but I owned a Magic store for 25 years and the local Magic club had a video and book library that members used for their copying purposes. They used to make copies of the club's videos and come in the store and brag about it. They acted like I somehow had free rent and no overhead. All clubs that do this take money out of not only the Makers pocket but the whole industry. If everyone who has watched one of your videos paid for it, you'd be clamoring to make more. All your time, effort and knowledge would be justifiably compensated for. Unfortunately this will never happen beause nobody cares until it affects them. But please don't let this get you down, you are a great wealth of knowledge and I for one appreciate all that you do.

Mike

Re: Turning DVD's

#14

Re: Turning DVD's

Bill Howatt

>You don't seem to be aware of DVD recorders. They are available now for US$200 or less. You can record on DVD-RWs and reuse them just like tapes.

Bill

Re: Turning DVD's

#15

Re: I agree...sorta...

Ron in Drums PA

>Actually it's not legal to copy a book like that.

Re: Turning DVD's

#16

Re: I agree...sorta... *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>"Under the fair use doctrine of the U.S. copyright statute, it is permissible to use limited portions of a work including quotes, for purposes such as commentary, criticism, news reporting, and scholarly reports. There are no legal rules permitting the use of a specific number of words, a certain number of musical notes, or percentage of a work. Whether a particular use qualifies as fair use depends on all the circumstances. See FL 102, Fair Use, and Circular 21, Reproductions of Copyrighted Works by Educators and Librarians."


copyright

Re: Turning DVD's

#17

Re: Turning DVD's

Dinyar Chavda

>Bill:

When it coems to electronics, I go for the cheapest stuff that gives me the most flexibility and meets my requirements. The cheapest, because these things do break as they have moving parts, and I'd rather get rid of something that costs less than $100 than something that costs 200. (Plus I'm frugal, and I know that the price on these things is going to come down---the first VCR I bought cost me $800!) Also, I've found an annoying habit of some DVDs (and music CDs) to either get stuck or to skip ahead, and nothing that I do seems to be able to stop this problem. When a similar problem happens with tapes, I can usually clean the head, and it seems to work after that.

Finally, I like the flexibility of being able to play both tapes and DVDs, and our library still has a decent collection of tapes, particularly the oldies. After I reached a certain age, I found that the oldies are just as fresh and new as they were the first time I had seen them on the big screen! :-)

Re: Turning DVD's

#18

Steven Antonucci

DVR's are killing VCR's for short term recording

steve antonucci

>No tapes, no setting the channels, no blink 12:00...

VCR's are dead.

Steve

Re: Turning DVD's

#19

Re: Turning DVD's

Bill Howatt

>Hi Dinyar,

Can't argue with waiting for the price to drop and in the DVD recorders have really started to fall in the past year.

I have never had a commerical CD/DVD where skipping and stuttering was nothing more than dirt on the surface. My success with DVD+-R home recorded has been excellent but the DVD RWs are not as reliable IMO. I don't buy Memorex anymore.

Bill

Re: Turning DVD's

#20

Re: DVR's are killing VCR's for short term recordi

Dinyar Chavda

>Estimates of current penetration of DVRs ranges between 7 and 13%, and is expected to grow to 30 - 40% in 5 years, while current penetration of VCRs is about 90% of households. Even if only a quarter of those households use the VCR for taping (conservative estimate based on media data), that still is over 20% of households with VCRs being used for short-term recording.

The reports of the demise of the VCR would seem to be somewhat exaggerated.

Re: Turning DVD's

#21

Quality of TV is killing both VCR/DVD recording...

Stuart Johnson

>

Re: Turning DVD's

#22

Re: DVR's are killing VCR's for short term recordi

Ron in Drums PA

>My DVD recorder has a 80 gig hard drive. Depending on the speed I choose, that's 30 to 80 hours of recording time. If I wish, I can edit out commerical and copy to DVD+R(W).

I recorded a great old Sci-Fi movie the other night "The Day The Earth Stood Still"

Re: Turning DVD's

#23

Two interesting links to check out

Craig Daymon

>Recently, while reading Slashdot, there were 2 articles posted that related to this subject.

One was a comparison between the video quality of a DVD played using 2 different computer video cards in a computer and several different DVD players ranging in price from $200 to $2000. The computer using either of the display cards (about $200 cards) blew the DVD players out of the water! Their ability to handle fast refresh and, most importantly, upscale the video cleanly to the maximum resolution helped them win.

DIY Linux Home Theater PC

http://www.linuxdevices.com/news/NS6365551074.html

The other was about a Home theater PC (looks more like an audio component) that gives you full DVR capability, with DVD recording and the ability to handle your entire electronic music (and video) collection. (Plus, with options, the ability to send that content to pretty much any other room in the house.)

ATI and nVidia crush high-end DVD players

http://www.hardware.info/en-UK/articles/am9nY2pqZA/ATI_and_nVidia_crush_2000_DVD_players

-Craig

Re: Turning DVD's

#24

If looking for old movies, check... *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>...the Internet Archive. They have a large selection of older films that are now in the public domain. Most are available in several formats and quality levels. Some moderately big name films, like "Charade" with Cary Grant and Audrey Hepburn, "His Girl Friday" with Cary Grant and Rosaland Russell, "My Favorite Brunette" with Bob Hope and, I think Dorothy Lamour. "Nosferatu" (silent) is also there and..."Plan 9 From Outerspace" (all-time worst movie ever, and funny for that reason).

I'll put the link below.

-Craig


Internet Archive - Movies, Music, Books and more

Re: Turning DVD's

#25

Steven Antonucci

Same thing as film cameras...

steve antonucci

>Everyone still has one, but who is actually still using it? Trust me, the VCR is a dead format. The last time I put a tape in, it made me nauseous (it was so fuzzy and wiggly...)

Granted DVR's aren't everywhere yet, but they should be. Ask anyone who has one if they'll give it up. Then ask them if you can have their VCR. See what the stats say about that one :-)

It still blinking 12:00 at me, and I should probably just unhook it and put it downstairs with my LaserDisc player...

Steve