Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Maple Cherry Hollowform

Posts

Maple Cherry Hollowform

#1

Maple Cherry Hollowform

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have been trying to get these hollowforms right. I can see a flat spot on the top of this one now that it is off the lathe. If I were to do it over, I would round the top down a little more toward the shoulder. What about the rest? Comments please. 4"w x 3"t base 1 1/8"


img

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#2

Steven Antonucci

A couple of ideas...

steve antonucci

>I think that I would move the widest point up a smidgeon. I think it's a bit lw in the form.

I'd also make the base "tuck" in a little more by following the curve through to the bottom. The vase should "spin" but not fall over.

Other than these small things, you're doing great...

steve

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#3

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

bob davis

>you might look at moving the widest part doun slightly

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#4

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Ed Moore

>Barb,

I am reading down the list and I saw the other form first, and commented. For me, that one was a 10 and this one is a 7. It may only be my perception, but I think I see what Ray Key calls "knuckles", which means that the curve does not change as smoothly at some places as it might, so there are places where a smidgeon might come off to advantage. I like the proportions of the other form better, also.

Ed

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#5

Re: A couple of ideas...

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I see what you mean. If I had moved the widest part up some then the flat spot on the shoulders may not have happened.

I will try to tuck into my bottom better. Thanks. :-)

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#6

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Hmmm, that is a thought.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#7

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Thanks Ed.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Barbara, personally, I like the proportions the way they are. I think the biggest problem is the "line" changes in three places, rather than a long steady curve. One easy way to check your progress is to dismount the piece from the lathe, and set it on a shelf. then, see how it looks.

Back on the lathe, you can put a pencil against the turning while spinning, marking the high spots. Then, remove the pencil lines with light cuts and re- check your progress.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#9

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Allen Neighbors

>Hey, Barbara.

Both of these are some pretty forms. I like the collar on this one better, but I like the other, taller form, the most. I see the "knuckle" on this one, and had it been rounded a little more, the widest part would have moved up a skosh. (referring to the other comments, here.)

Neither of them should be sneezed at. They're nice. :o)

By the way, postage is less to Childress than it is to Washington. :o)

Allen

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#10

Kieth, Please Do Me A Favor

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have looked and looked at the picture and gone over the piece. The only bump I can find is up at the top. Could you put a ruler against the image and give me an idea of where to look? For some reason I just can't see it.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#11

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Barb, I think that this form is closer to being "just right" than the other. In my opinion the widest part is in exactly the right place. The bottom doesn't want any more "tuck" than it already has. There is a small hump in the curve as it approaches the rim. Also, I would like to see a a little sharper curve in the collar to better define it.

When you're developing a form it's a good idea to remove the piece and view it upsidedown. Often a small, needed corection can be spotted that way. When looking for the "perfect curve" it helps to hold a piece of contrasting paper behind the piece. Black or white.

A very nice form...I like it.

Wally

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#12

I am in agreement with Ed

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Kieth, Please Do Me A Favor

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Barbara, I'll try to do it tomorrow, and post it. Not so much bumps, but changes in the line. Seems more obvious on the left side, maybe just the photo. Not big changes, but enough to notice.

I am being very picky here, this is a nicely turned piece.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#14

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Ron in Drums PA

>Barbara, This one looks really good! I think you just about nailed it.

I think some of the distortions I see are from the "ribbed" background you used. Next time, try to use a smooth background.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#15

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>That might explain why I can find the ribs on the vessel. I will get a more smooth roll of paper the next time. Thanks for pointing that our.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#16

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Thanks Wally. I will take your advice.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#17

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Hooligan

>I see where Keith is talking about, and I think it is just in the picture. I pulled it,(Hope you don't mind) and blew it up. It appears that the curve is VERY continual, with little or no deviation. The line really doesn't change, throughout. I believe that it is just the size of the photo.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#18

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Of course I don't mind. :-) One a picture is posted here it is fair game. I am flasttered that you would take the time to fool with it.

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#19

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Allen Neighbors

>Barbara, after reading the other posts, I took another long look. I think they're right about the ribbed background, and I think the shaddow area on the left contributes to the 'knuckle' look. I can't see it on the right side.

It's better than any of mine, and...

If Wally likes it, it must be good. No joke. :o)

Allen

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#20

Brad Vietje

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

Brad Vietje

>Pretty gosh-darned nice the way it is, Barbara !

I think you have taken this one to the point where it has to be held and felt to really be sure of the fairness of the curves. For me, I think the widest point has a slightly tighter curve than I would have done, and I might have given up a 1/16" - 1/8" in total width to get a rounder, fuller curve there. the photo does suggest a slight curve change between the widest part and the collar, but that could be more photographic than actual. Its a nice piece as is.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Maple Cherry Hollowform

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Kieth, Please Do Me A Favor

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Barbara, I loaded your image into one of my programs, and when I enlarge the image, the lines seem to straighten out....I think the others are right, the background is the problem. Sorry about that!