Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Removing a sheared screw?

Posts

Removing a sheared screw?

#1

Removing a sheared screw?

Carole Valentine

>I received a blank that has a sheared faceplate screw in it. (Yes, they warned me and circled it, so it was not a booby trap! LOL) Problem is I have been unable to dig it out. I have drilled holes next to it and done everything I can think of to no avail. The wood is VERY hard. Any ideas?

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#2

Chisel around it?

Bob Fawcett

>How large a screw?

Do you have access to an electric welder?

An old mechanic trick is to put the hole in a nut over the screw and weld the nut to the screw through the hole. You can usually remove it then with a wrench.

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#3

Dremel tool

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Carole

If you have a Dremel tool use the cut off wheel and mill a screw driver slot in the broken piece. Another option is to take a piece of brake line or other thin wall steel tubing (providing its a larger diameter than the screw) and file teeth on one end. Chuck this in your drill and cut straight down around the screw. You can then pop the piece out with a screw driver.

Terry

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#4

Re: Chisel around it?

Carole Valentine

>Bob, don't know how long the screw is, but it looks like a #12. Don't have a welder but I will dig out my old cheap chisels. It's tough to hold the blank cause it is cored from another piece and cone shaped which leaves me with visions of a lacerated hand from a slipped chisel! LOL

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#5

Re: Dremel tool

Carole Valentine

>Ah hah! Both good ideas to try. Don't have any tubing but will try the dremel/screw slot thing. Thanks.

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#6

Re: Chisel around it?

Bob Fawcett

>You might be able to chisel out enough to allow a grip on the screw with some vicegrips. You will need a way to hold the piece. Maybe a glue block of some kind or turn a piece of scrap to accept the other end of the piece.

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#7

Re: Removing a sheared screw? *LINK*

joaz

>I am embarrassed to admit I have Had to deal with this situation too many times. More than once I have twisted off screws while removing or installing face plate.

With the piece on the lathe, part out as deep as the screw on each side of the screw. Get as close and as thin as you can with your tool.

Even if you touch it with the parting tool, use can resharpen later.

When you get the wall on each side of the screw thin enough you can tap the wall and it usually breaks off taking the screw with it.

Try to under cut the wall under the screw with a thin parting tool at an angle.

Of course, this method only works on the face (hollowing side) of the piece.

Hope this helps. Joaz


http://www.maine-web.com/woodturning

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#8

Re: Dremel tool

Peter Hyde

>Use a plug cutter or a small hole saw minus the pilot drill in a drill press and then chip out the remaining wood until you can grab the screw with needle nose visegrips

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#9

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

robo hippy

>I have used both the chisel out arund it and then vice grip it out, and the use a parting tool to remove wood on both sides of it (while turning) and then break out the ring and vice grip it out. Both methods work. It works for nails also. The best way to prevent breaking is to not have the clutch on the screw gun set at max torque. I have never understood why some people do this. I set the torque to what is sufficient to drive the screw home. This helps the screw tips last longer also.

robo hippy

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#10

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>It has been said before but Vise grips is the only way to grab on to a broken screw.

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#11

needle nose vice grips and dremel

John Lucas

>

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#12

Are you trying to save the screw or the wood? :)

Barry Irby

>I have tried about every "dig it out approach" I can think of. The steel tube with teeth works pretty well. I have the Craftsman screw remover set that looks sort of like a Left hand drill bit with three "flutes" or teeth. Did not work, It just drilled the end off the screw. My experience indicates the longer the screw sits, the tighter the grip is.

Sometimes I just use a center punch to mark the center of the screw and then drill it out. I just use a bit larker than the screw and drill a hole until it is gone. If I have to I start with a tiny bit and move up to a larger one.

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#13

Take It To Your Dentist..Extraction!!...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#14

Burn It Out!! ;)

Chris DiCiaccio

>

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#15

Screw extractor *LINK*

Phil Joines Krum, Tx.

>This is the comercial version of Terry's tube


Rocker screw extractor

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Chisel around it?

Dick Hines

>Try a set of Vice Grip pliers. Put them on the screw, if it above the service, as tight as you can clamp them. Sometimes you can "unscrew" the screw that way.

If it is below the service get a bigger bowl gouge. LOL

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#17

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Take a propane torch to the screw and wood surrounding it. Chip away the charred remains at the surface around the screw, and spin it out with visegrips. The heat should have loosened the wood's grip on the screw to make that easier.

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#18

Does the screw look like this one.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>A screw in green wood is still tough. I tried to dig this one out with no luck so the lathe was slowed down then I turned a little on eather side. Still needed vise grips. This is dangerous...


img

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#19

Re: Does the screw look like this one. 

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>


img

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#20

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

Jim Swank

>If you don't have a hole-saw type thigie for the purpose, drill the holes around it as close to the screw and as close together as you can. Use a cheap, small flat end screwdriver as a chisel. Drive it into the holes where the grain and tip run the same way and the edge (not corner) is next to the screw. Wiggle the screwdriver to tear out wood between holes and expose more of the screw. At some point you will expose enough screw to grab with a vise-grips or see the screw start to wiggle when you move the screwdriver. At that point you can grab it with something and remove it.

This method is a bit of a nuisance, but has never let me down. I became quite adept at it before I became smart enough not to use drywall scews with faceplates. :)

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#21

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

Carole Valentine

>Did not get to it yesterday, but between all these suggestions, one of them ought to work! Thanks, folks. Jim, I seriously doubt this is a drywall screw since it came from a seasoned turner. :)

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#22

$90 and Pay before you leave

john lucas

>

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#23

Re: The Simple Solution

Russ Fairfield

>I don't understand your problem. Since this broken screw was holding a faceplate, someone obviously chose to give you the problem rather than solve it themselves. Why don't you do the same thing they did? Give it to someone else, or throw it in the firewood pile, which is where it probably belongs.

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#24

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

Jim Swank

>The process works for all screws. I've had good quality screws break off too, just less frequently than drywall screws.

Re: Removing a sheared screw?

#25

Re: The Simple Solution

Carole Valentine

>Cause I treasure every piece of wood I am able to lay my hands on, that's why. I have visions of eventually being back where I was in January with nothing to turn, so I it has to be absolutely unsalvageable for me to put it in the burn pile! Besides, it's pretty wood, whatever it is. :)