Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long)

Posts

Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long)

#1

Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long)

Dinyar Chavda

>Most of the denizens of this board are aware of the recent discussions re aids to design, which covered golden rectangles, golden triangles and the rules of 1/3rds. (Some of you may have said, "Enough already!!!!" several times, as the threads went on and on, sort of like a Bollywood movie.)

I want to share a couple of recent experiences that were influenced by those discussions.

I had some pieces of decent-sized dogwood, which I love to turn. It exemplifies the true joy of turning, with beautiful shavings, a tool finish that requires very little sanding, colors that range from white to cream to pink to brown, plus beautiful bark that, for some reason, seems to retain the moss on it for a long time in the humid weather we have in Philly. The only problem is that the wood moves--heck, it doesn't move, it strides along. Makes cherry look stable. But I don't mind that, given the kinds of things I make.

Anyway, I was turning one of the pieces, it was nicely shaped, and then the gouge made a bad cut (notice how it was the gouge that made that cut, not me), and I had jagged edges at the rim of the piece. So, I had to clean it up, which meant that the rim ended up smaller than originally planned. And the piece looked wrong. I knew that I had to make some of the other dimensions smaller, but I was not sure exactly how to do it, and I did not want to experiment on the wood, as there wasn't a lot of it.

I remembered Russ' rule #4, which had said something about the ratio of rims to other dimensions, so I got it off the computer, printed out all the rules (they are now taped onto the wall behind me in the shop), and it told me what I had to do in order to get a decent shape. I had to change multiple aspects of the piece, but I knew the direction I had to move in, and the end result was extremely gratifying to me.

So, thank you (once again!), Russ.

Yesterday, I took a piece of pink birch to make a hollow form. I slapped it on the lathe--I had a vague idea as to what I wanted to do with it, roughed it into an approximate cylindrical shape, and was getting ready to start shaping it, when something that Keith had said popped into my head, quote: 'I cannot, and refuse, to tell a student "put this piece on the lathe, and see what happens." ' (This was about midway through all the threads)

Now the reason it stuck with me is because that's pretty close to what I do--slap it on, and "let the wood talk to me". Unfortunately, what the wood often says to me is "Ow! Ow! That hurts!" Or it speaks in one of those American accents that Steve Mushinski was talking about, and I can't understand a large part of what it says!!:-)

Anyway, despite the fact that it goes against my grain to do so ("goes against my grain"---get it!!! Groan!), I put down the gouge, and measured all the dimensions, marked where the tennon was going to be, and then did something very simple, i.e., divided the piece into thirds, and imagined what the shape was going to be like. As soon as I did that, I realized that the piece was too long for the place where the maximum diameter would hae been. Decision time--do I give up on the shape, or do I give up on the wood. I hate to waste anything! It killed me to do so, but I made the piece much shorter than I would have otherwise. Because I was doing something I did not want to do, it also slowed me down (I tend to be impatient!), and made me think more about what I was doing at every step.

The net result is a shape that I absolutely love---even Janet said, "That's a beauty".

Does that mean that I wil now sit down and draw out what I intend to make before I attack the next piece of wood? Maybe, although most of the time I will go directly to the wood. But the point is that changing what I habitually do will result in a better end-result.

So, thanks, Keith. I still disagree on the Triangles, but you have expanded my way of approaching turning.

What's the moral of all this? Yes, Virginia, there is a moral behind this rambling!!!

It's easy to learn from someone that I agree with. I am open to what that person says, I find myself nodding to what I hear, and I can process the information and make it part of my knowledge base, and act on it. In consulting, we used to call it moving the information from the head to the gut.

It's much more difficult to listen to what someone has to say when I disagree with them. My lips become one thin line, my arms are folded across my chest, and, even before the person has finished their sentence, I am formulating a comeback to it. A very common human response, but one that ends up hurting me most of the time--with some exceptions that I won't go into now to avoid making this political! :-) But every once in a while, I realize I am in my 50s, and the mommy in me overcomes the child in me. That's when I can grow. (Without getting into it, I think it is a way of using the Hawthorne Effect to my advantage.)

So, thanks Russ, for once again riding to my rescue. And thanks Keith, for hanging in there and arguing in the face of opposition. While I still don't understand the triangles approach, I have walked away with something unexpected, and far more valuable.

Dinyar

Re: Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long)

#2

Re: Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long

john lucas

>Dinyar You made me laugh out loud with your statements on the wood speaking to you. I don't do that often. I always enjoy your responses. This one was both delightful and informative. I could not agree more with your assesment of people getting tight lipped and formulating a response before they even finish reading something they disagree with.

I also have a hard time stopping in the middle of a piece and changing it radically. I usually want to just modify the heck out of it trying for a better form. Sometimes however you are simply better off making it much smaller and changing the shape radically.

A piece of wood spoke to me this morning. It said "I don't want to be anything but firewood" and it fought me until it won. I hate to waste wood and even more precious it my time but I finally reached the decision that this piece simply wasn't going to be anything but a mediocre piece no matter what I did so I bowed to it's whim and put it in the firepile.

Re: Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long)

#3

Re: Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long

David Galloway

>I think your insights about how to be open to the insights of others is profound. It was helpful for me. Thanks.

By the way, where are Russ' rules found?

Re: Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long)

#4

Found Rules in Russ' Corner(nt)

David Galloway

>

Re: Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long)

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long

Keith Tompkins

>Thank You, Dinyar. That post turned pretty ugly indeed...we had some major disagreements both online and privately. The same thread left me feeling deeply discouraged and more than a bit shaken. Most of all, I am disappointed in myself for the way I reacted to some of the posts.

You are correct, it is human nature to dismiss ideas, cultures, or concepts we may not understand or simply disagree with. The next time I find myself in that situation, I will remember this post and try to follow, and learn from, your example.

Re: Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long)

#6

Re: Learning. Thanks Russ. Thanks Keith.(Very long

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Dinyar,

I have followed this thread from the beginning and I have thoroughly enjoyed your lenghty replies to both Keith and Russ's post. All three of you have helped to put some light on the subject of 'The Golden Triangle". Thanks for the humorous approach that you take and for spending the time to also increase the knowledge base that makes Wood Central such a nice place to visit.

Mike