Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Artist v craftsman

Posts

Re: Artist v craftsman

#26

Keith Tompkins

Re: Classifications

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Jim, I agree completely! If you have followed my posts on this subject, that's the point I'm trying to get across. Many crafts people dismiss the artist's point of view, and many artists look down on "mere" craft as the work of the lower class.

Try this...pick up an art textbook. Study the contents with an open mind...read it several times if necessary. Even read the parts that have nothing to do with turning. It will have an affect on your work. Sometimes a very profound effect.

Take a class with a world-class turner. Mimic what they do....sharpening, tool handling, etc. Look at your work before and after the class....sometimes there is a dramatic difference. A good instructor can save a student several years of learning by trial and error.

If someone is happy with the work they are producing, there is no need for either. However, most turners ARE NOT happy with their results....they want to improve. Just look at the sales of videos, the numbers of turners attending classes, and the attendance of symposiums.

I think combining art theory with good turning technique is a good, balanced approach.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#27

making a statement

john lucas

>Brian Excellent point. If your going to produce what we call Art then it should be something from the heart and as you said we should not be afraid to publish it. It's not meant to affend. It's called Fertility Experiment #29. It's like a mad scientist trying to invent stronger fertility drugs.

The reason I made this piece is response to a conversation with some friends who were having fertility problems. They told me all the tests they had to go through and all the hassles, sympathy from friends, sadness during the ordeal followed by the joy of having a wonderful child. We joked and kidded about it and somehow during the conversation the we joked about needing more verile or macho sperm. What could me more macho than a viking so I came up with this piece. I laughed the whole time I was building it and so did the couple who inspired it.


img

Re: Artist v craftsman

#28

Nope, this record will be played again and again

Raymond Overman in SC

>

Re: Artist v craftsman

#29

Keith Tompkins

Re: making a statement

Keith Tompkins

>John, you are a bad, bad, boy! We had some good conversations in Orlando about this one!

Re: Artist v craftsman

#30

That's a great piece!

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Thanks John. That piece really made me smile.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#31

Keith Tompkins

Re: Artist v craftsman

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Dinyar, I think you have asked some questions that are very appropriate. There is a movement to elevate the status of wood from "craft" to "art". Some of the motivation may be simply economic; art sells for more money than craft.

I became interested in the work of Frank Lloyd Wright while in junior high, while taking an architecture class. I still study architecture, it's a subject I find facinating. (We live in an organic world; we are told there are no straight lines in nature..yet, we insist on building structures that are straigt, true, and plumb. What's up with that?)

FLW has become legendary...the architect who has never studied his work probably does not exist. Along those same lines, I think Mr. Ellsworth will be remembered as a legendary turner as well. Future turners and historians will refer to his work. A great artist? Not for me to say, but a legendary turner..Yes.

What qualifies someone as an artist? A card they carry in their wallet? A degree in fine art? I know if I Google the term "artistic wood turning" I will discover some turnings that are anything but artistic. Too many people are using the term so loosely that it has lost most of its meaning.

I recently attended SOFA NY (The Internation Exposition of Sculpture Objects and Functional Art). The world's finest artisans are represented there....sculptors, glassblowers, potters, even painters. There were some turners represented there as well, including William Hunter. I think the thing that impressed me most was the degree of skill exhibited in the turned work. The turnings didn't take a back seat to anyone. AND they were a bargain. An astute collector could buy several pieces for a fraction of the cost of one piece in any other media.

Turnings that make a statement? I'm going to stick to turning here...I've been in enough hot water already. :)

Re: Artist v craftsman

#32

My "house artist" ...

Bob Fawcett

>is hard at work on the deck at this very moment, and it looks great!

Re: Artist v craftsman

#33

Re: Why does it matter?

eliot

>Steve,

I believe you are a wise man. The question about art vs. craft is the wrong question.

Eliot

Re: Artist v craftsman

#34

Re: Classifications

eliot

>Keith,

Now there's an intelligent post!

Eliot