Re: Artist v craftsman
Dinyar Chavda
>Keith:
I reread the prior thread, as well as your new posting, and one thought keeps coming back to me.
There is an assumption being made, and that is that there are turners out there (either dead or alive) who are artists. Is this a valid assumption? I'd like us to stop looking at it from our viewpoint, but from that of the general public, the cognoscenti and the collectors. And is the last group collecting turned objects as art, or craft?
I think if you look at museums, we are classified as a craft (no ifs, buts or maybes!)---you find turned objects in a craft museum like the Renwick, or, in the craft gallery of an Art Museum.
If you look at prices (yeah I know that's crass, but it is a final, absolute measure), well, I took a quick look at Bill Hunter's prices at Del Mano (as I believe that he is one of the highest-paid turners), and the prices were in the low to mid 20,000 range. Not to be sneezed at, but a far cry from what the master painters and sculptos command. And if you say that the reason why the old painters are worth so much is because they are dead, well, we certainly haven't seen comparable price appreciation for turners who are dead.
Another common criterion of art is whether or not the piece moves you. I think the turning world is limited here for two reasons. We are hogtied by rules and the reason we have the rules is because of the 2nd limiting factor, which is that we generally try to produce pretty stuff. There is relatively little out there that is deliberately in your face, that makes you go "Yikes. What was that?", while a lot of great art in other mediums (I know it should be media, but that sounds like the press) will do just that.
I am not going to get into what defines someone as an artist, except to say that, IMO, several of the comments in the last thread really don't work well for turnings. For example, several talked about the vision in the piece. Well, what is this vision in a turned piece, given that most pieces are not titled, and there is a strong tendency to stick with pretty objects--in fact, a shunning of things that do not conform to accepted norms.
In this and other threads, what started as a joke, i.e., if it does not hold water, it must be art, seems to have become doctrinaire, i.e., if it is non-utlitarian, it is art. Not so, IMO.
Some comments differentated on the basis of one-of-a-kind vs production turners---sorry, but Frank Lloyd Wright was a production machine of an architect, and was a true artist (actually, not a great craftsman---many of his roofs leaked!).
With all due respect to David Ellsworth, why is he an artist just because he pioneered the hollow form? He may have other valid claims to being an artist, but how does technical wizardry make him an artist? Was the person who made the first butterfly joint an artist?
I don't claim to have the answer as to what makes an artist. But what I do know (and object to) is the implicit devaluation in the term "artist". I don't know what makes someone an artist, but it is not just the creation of something unique, or useless, or pretty.
I know that I have made some provocative statements above. My intent is not to be a troll, but to make people aware of, and question, implicit assumptions, and get some fierce (but civilized) discussion going. And, perhaps, to generate some answers, even if they are not complete. If you don't ask challenging questions, chances of your getting answers that change the status quo and create progress are slim.
Dinyar