Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Artist v craftsman

Posts

Artist v craftsman

#1

Keith Tompkins

Artist v craftsman

Keith Tompkins

>Some thoughts on the previous thread....As Russ stated, the successful turner should be both artist and craftsman. WHY?

The craftsman who only focuses on the technical aspects of their craft while ignoring the artisic side will reach a certain level of proficiency and then fail to progress past it. This a trap many flat workers fall into...as long as they are working from a set of plans, they can produce a decent product. The problems begin when they attempt to venture into new territory, their lack of design skills becomes very evident. Without a set of plans, they are lost, they don't have the design experience to fall back on. They realize their designs don't work, but cannot figure out why. They are resigned to producing unattractive pieces or copying the work of others.

the "artist" who does not take the time to master his craft usually suffers a similar fate. He may visualize glorious masterpieces, yet cannot bring his vision to life. His lack of skill is obvious; tool marks from improperly sharpened tools, poor sanding, poorly fitting pieces, etc. Like the craftman with poor design skills, he is stuck...he cannot overcome his lack of technical skill.

The person who is able to combine the qualities of the craftsman with the vision of the artist has a far greater chance of creating successful work. They aren't limited by their technical skills or their design skills. They can rely on both.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#2

Re: Artist v craftsman

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

I reread the prior thread, as well as your new posting, and one thought keeps coming back to me.

There is an assumption being made, and that is that there are turners out there (either dead or alive) who are artists. Is this a valid assumption? I'd like us to stop looking at it from our viewpoint, but from that of the general public, the cognoscenti and the collectors. And is the last group collecting turned objects as art, or craft?

I think if you look at museums, we are classified as a craft (no ifs, buts or maybes!)---you find turned objects in a craft museum like the Renwick, or, in the craft gallery of an Art Museum.

If you look at prices (yeah I know that's crass, but it is a final, absolute measure), well, I took a quick look at Bill Hunter's prices at Del Mano (as I believe that he is one of the highest-paid turners), and the prices were in the low to mid 20,000 range. Not to be sneezed at, but a far cry from what the master painters and sculptos command. And if you say that the reason why the old painters are worth so much is because they are dead, well, we certainly haven't seen comparable price appreciation for turners who are dead.

Another common criterion of art is whether or not the piece moves you. I think the turning world is limited here for two reasons. We are hogtied by rules and the reason we have the rules is because of the 2nd limiting factor, which is that we generally try to produce pretty stuff. There is relatively little out there that is deliberately in your face, that makes you go "Yikes. What was that?", while a lot of great art in other mediums (I know it should be media, but that sounds like the press) will do just that.

I am not going to get into what defines someone as an artist, except to say that, IMO, several of the comments in the last thread really don't work well for turnings. For example, several talked about the vision in the piece. Well, what is this vision in a turned piece, given that most pieces are not titled, and there is a strong tendency to stick with pretty objects--in fact, a shunning of things that do not conform to accepted norms.

In this and other threads, what started as a joke, i.e., if it does not hold water, it must be art, seems to have become doctrinaire, i.e., if it is non-utlitarian, it is art. Not so, IMO.

Some comments differentated on the basis of one-of-a-kind vs production turners---sorry, but Frank Lloyd Wright was a production machine of an architect, and was a true artist (actually, not a great craftsman---many of his roofs leaked!).

With all due respect to David Ellsworth, why is he an artist just because he pioneered the hollow form? He may have other valid claims to being an artist, but how does technical wizardry make him an artist? Was the person who made the first butterfly joint an artist?

I don't claim to have the answer as to what makes an artist. But what I do know (and object to) is the implicit devaluation in the term "artist". I don't know what makes someone an artist, but it is not just the creation of something unique, or useless, or pretty.

I know that I have made some provocative statements above. My intent is not to be a troll, but to make people aware of, and question, implicit assumptions, and get some fierce (but civilized) discussion going. And, perhaps, to generate some answers, even if they are not complete. If you don't ask challenging questions, chances of your getting answers that change the status quo and create progress are slim.

Dinyar

Re: Artist v craftsman

#3

Re: Artist v craftsman

Jim Swank

>I've been a part of so many discussions on this subject in the past that I'm entering here somewhat reluctantly. It is indeed unfortunate that the term craft has been so cheapened in recent years that many of us are anxious to repudiate it. It is indeed the best term for useful objects created with skill. Thank you Country Living, Martha Stewart, and Hobby Lobby!

As others have said, art usually implies a original vision or message that transcends execution of the piece itself. While some of us are creating art by that criteria, I think that number is a small minority indeed.

The old saw - if it won't hold soup, it must be art - is usually uttered with tongue firmly planted in cheek.

There is another term - artisan - that is somewhere in between. Artisan implies execution of a primarily utilitarian craft with exceptional skill and vision. While some may view this as a compromise between craft and art, I view it more as a bridge between the two. It describes the place I see our best turners, and to which most of us aspire.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#4

Re: Artist v craftsman

John H WIlliams

>I can�t believe I�m getting into this one�.must be the heat.

There are some wonderful works created by Michael Brolly a confessed scraper as is there great stuff by Michael Hosulak an accomplished turner. In general, I agree that one is more likely to create pieces which will win contests or be sold if they exhibit fine workmanship. I think this is true in turned objects as well, so taking the time to develop turning skills should be a benefit. On the other hand, some �artists� take the jump (Brolly) and create, and use the lathe only as means to an end. Also if we look at what is going on in our AAW instant gallery, one cannot help but notice the embellishments. It seems the lathe is more often used to create just a canvas. In a lot of cases, there is 5-10% lathe time and the rest is carving, painting��you name it. It is what is found more and more in galleries too.

I recently heard the statement(can�t remember where) �.�What is an artist without an audience.� Hummmm, does that mean you just can�t get up one morning, face the east and say �I is an artist� ? I think not. At the very least, you better understand the market for your work, get it out there some how, and pray somebody buys it��.often! Oh boy, now we must learn to turn, carve, paint AND be marketeers! Some of the really successful �artists� have done an outstanding job of marketing, and in some cases, their work is very good.

Did you ever notice that �great� art is great to some but not necessarily great to others.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#5

Steven Antonucci

Why does it matter?

steve antonucci

>If people are woodturning with the need to be categorized as an artist, artisan, craftsman, whatever... there is something fundamentally wrong.

I am a turner because I enjoy it. I post very little of my work because I don't need others' approval or categorization.

Turning is a means for me to have quiet time in my life, where the only disturbance is a shower of shavings hitting my face shield. 100 years from now, no one will remember my name (99.999999% of us), but hopefully some of my work will still be around in garage sales for $0.25

Steve

Call me whatever you want, just don't call me late for dinner...

Re: Artist v craftsman

#6

Classifications

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Keith,

I feel that classifying any skill or talent is limiting in the eyes of the person making that distinction of the area of evaluation and also for the person reading it. I think that seldom does anyone truly want to be classified for the sake of a name, but for the effects that it might help propel them into something they want to be.

Truly though it is my believe that the people who care about such things are not focused on the elements of woodworking or any element that they enjoy. Labels mean little, the enjoyment and perception of one�s talents mean more than any classification, unless you are a bird or a mineral.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Artist v craftsman

#7

Re: Why does it matter?

Jim King

>I think Steve hit it on the head exactly. If a work is art the world will let you know without you asking.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#8

Totally agree, Dinyar.........

Ruth Niles

>The term "artist" really is a bit of a burr with me.

A chef creates an eye-appealing and tasty dish: he's an "artist".

A landscaper plants the right shrubs, trees and perennials: he's an "artist".

Anyone who does something we have difficulty achieving, and does it with eye appeal we now call an "artist". I think it's just a new jargon like saying something's "cool", "rad" or "groovy" (just trying to cover a few decades here). Woodturners are now using "artistic" and calling themselves (or being called) "artists" that's all.

Ellsworth is a famous master turner and, as you pointed out, there's nothing artistic (IMO) about his hornet's-nest hollow forms. They are the height of technical challenge but in no way artistic. They demand a high price because they have his signature.

I would rather see words like "highly technically challenging", "most unique" or "very original" used instead of "art" or "artistic". When I hear the word "art", I expect to see an oil painting (pencil, charcoal or such). This is all my humble opinion, and it is real humble as I am in awe of people who can paint or draw. Schools and colleges call it "Art" classes when they are using a canvas not a potter's wheel, lathe, weaving loom or anvil.

But it's just a word and I think we're all giving it a lot more attention and disecting it more than is necessary. If you like the word, then whatever pleases your eye is ART, if you're more conservative and (IMO realistic) it's AWESOME. I really think that term is more intense, more flattering and denotes a greater amount of achievement in a skill be it woodturning or piano playing.

I may be way off base here but I firmly believe I'm right! : )

Re: Artist v craftsman

#9

Great response! : )

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Artist v craftsman

#10

An interesting quote....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I read this quote by Steve Loar last night and found it very interesting. Even taken out of the context of the article it perked myself to take note. From the Summer 2005 issue of Turning Points-

-EDUCATION. What is it Good for?.....

"Easy success has made us self-satisfied. This has been compounded by an aversion to true critique along with an early, and very unfortunate, willingness to describe ourselves as artists."

Something to think about.

Jennifer

Re: Artist v craftsman

#11

not true if it never leaves your garage

John H WIlliams

>

Re: Artist v craftsman

#12

That's what I've been doing wrong!Thanks, John!

Dinyar Chavda

>

Re: Artist v craftsman

#13

Re: Artist v craftsman

Bill Crommett

>Dinyar : What is the disgrace in being a Troll ? The traditional job of the Troll was to guard the bridge, and whatever bridges there are left in society, they ALL need guarding !

I know that this does not address the argument of "craftsman vs. Artist" but as long as I am neither I am well qualified to express my philosophy.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#14

Re: Why does it matter?

bob davis

>steve is absolutely correct..use the discussion time for turning

Re: Artist v craftsman

#15

Re: Artist v craftsman

Dinyar Chavda

>Interesting observation, Bill. Never thought of it that way, perhaps because the moderd-day trolls on the Internet are more likely to inflame us into setting fire to the bridges that connect us than to guard them from harm.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#16

I agree Steve

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Who are we to label others... If they want to be called an artist or a craftsman let them. Some people enjoy a label to identify with and play the role. Who are we to judge. If a artist calls his work ART and I think it's junk who cares. That's his opinon and I have mine... who's right?

Someone should start a post on how you would label yourself.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#17

Re: Artist v craftsman

john lucas

>I have an interesting thought. (probably not intelligent but interesting) Would a painter ever ask if they are an artist or craftsman? All of the painters in our area would accept the term artist when asked what they do. There is obviously an huge difference between Vincent Van Gogh and my neighbor who paints but both are considered artists.

My sanding sealer is probably dry so I'll get back in the shop. Not sure if I'm creating art but I'm sure as heck trying to be the best craftsman I can be. In 50 years or so someone may call the piece I'm working on Art. That may be the only way to know.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#18

Re: Artist v craftsman

Dinyar Chavda

>John:

Not to be argumentative (that was a joke!), but in the comparison you make, the word "artist" has almost become synonymous with "painter". If you asked someone who paints on a canvas, they would describe themselves as an artist, and not as a painter---the latter term being reserved for the person who paints a house. The more apt analogy may be to ask them to describe what they create---is it a painting, or is it art?

Re: Artist v craftsman

#19

Re: Artist v craftsman

Arch

>It is written that, "art should never be held hostage to craft." For woodturning, perhaps the converse is also true? Funny that being termed by others as crafty or artful is to disparage. I reckon the devil is in the words. :)

Re: Artist v craftsman

#20

Re: Artist v craftsman

Arch

>Bill and all, please take no offense. I'm absolutely joking & foolishly OT about a serious question that has been widely discussed, but I wonder if it's Fruedian or just good punctuation that "Artist" is capitalized and "craftsman" is not. Maybe for some it should be Craftsman v artist, but for the rest of us does it really matter? :)

Re: Artist v craftsman

#21

Re: Artist v craftsman

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Art, Craft, who really cares....

My work sells for a fair amount of money. I don't really give a damn whether it's art or craft as long as somebody likes it well enough to buy it, and enjoys it when they do.

Wally

Re: Artist v craftsman

#22

Re: Artist v craftsman

Dinyar Chavda

>Interesting, Arch. The similar quote that I had heard, attributed to a Japanese, was "Beauty should never be held hostage to perfection."

Re: Artist v craftsman

#23

Re: Artist v craftsman

Mac

>Ditto:well put,I agree.....now lets give it a rest for a couple years.....

Re: Artist v craftsman

#24

Art vs. Turning

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I really liked the section on the limitations that woodturners work towards, that is a pleasing and pretty object. I've seen very little that made me sit up an take notice of the content rather than the technique. Some of Todd Hoyer's pieces do, but that's about it.

Another aspect is the fear of offending -- i.e cultural appropriation. My feeling is that true Art has no "sacred cows", that everything is fair game. And if a viewer is offended, well that may very well have been the intent of piece -- that is to get an active response rather than a passive ("that's nice") response.

How many woodturners would be willing to make a piece like that, and what would be the response if they tried to post it in a forum like this?

Are we encouraging the bland and pretty at the expense of the bold and expressive?

Just something to think about.

Re: Artist v craftsman

#25

Any chance we can bury this horse?

Gerry Meekins

>