Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Posts

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#26

Re: See FAQ # 11 ;)

Raymond Overman in SC

>Wow, and I even skimmed the FAQ and did a search on this forum, Google, and Wikipedia for it. Now that I've read this (a second time I'm sure because I read the FAQ long ago) I'll take it that I must have had a lucid moment and typed something meaningful. It's a rare occurence and I promise it won't happen again for a while. I apologize for spoiling everyone's fun, if that's what I did.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#27

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

eaglesc

>A couple of things in this thread caught my attention.

I liked Russes answer though I am not sure I agree with all of it.

I have been accused of being an artist thus giving artists a bad name.

I decided that I am not a turner, but a pencrafter.

I am uncomfortable with the term "artist" because most of the pens I make are the result of curiosity rather than vision.

I let the viewer or customer determine if what I create makes me an artist or a craftsman.


img

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#28

Curiosity, Coooooool

john lucas

>Wow you just stated 95 percent of what I do. It's all starts with Curiosity. What happens if I do this? This is cool, what if I change this? Sometimes it leads toward a well crafted piece. Sometimes it fails. Sometimes it leads to what I'll call an art piece. Curiosity can succeed or fail but it definitely a driving force for me.

I think it might be said that a Craftsman looks to continually refine the piece by working on the form, the cutting techniques, glue joints etc. The artist looks to refine the idea or concept, which may or may not include improving the craftsmanship to achieve the final goal.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#29

Re: Curiosity, Coooooool

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Right on John, I totally agree with your analysis.

Norm