Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Posts

Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#1

Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Greg H. from Wisconsin

>I have been turning for a little over one year and I have come across a few questions, mainly one. Artist or Craftsman is one inferior, or just not as popular? When I started to notice others I was probably the same as others, those who had videos or books are the "big names." That was it, one thing to seperate the masses. But then I met people like Don Derry and Bob Rosand, no videos (at least within the decade) or books, but man they knew their stuff. Being that I live in WI, a little more than an hour from the Lacer's, I have been to Alan Lacer's house, more than once, he has become more of a mentor or a "friend" figure than a woodturning god. Now after meeting more people personally, I'm noticing a slight difference in people perception of them. Is it more respected to turn a 4,000 dollar hollow form or to be able to turn 50 matched table legs or 100's of ornaments?? Is the natural progression in turning craftsman then artist? Or are they equals in their own standards, one maybe more mainstream and hyped through galleries than craftshows? Do you have to be one or the other? Is it more advanced to turn a massive bowl or hollow form compared to turning tiny finials or ornaments? Is a oneway 2436 the master's lathe instead of a 1224?

I have full respect for all turners in all walks of life. People that I would consider my friends are some of the "biggest, well-known artists" in the industry, but some of my friends are the craftsmans of the industry also and I notice a huge difference in the public perception of them.

Just was wondering about it as a discussion, nothing to get anybody's feathers flying.

thanks

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#2

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Russ Fairfield

>Simple answer. You have to be both. The "art" is in having the vision of the form that we want to create. The "craft" is in the tool skills that are required to make it a reality.

As for all of those other things you mentioned, they are a matter of personal preference, or which one pays the best if you are in this for the money.

The "Compleate Woodturner" is the one who does everything well, and I have only met 2 or 3 of those in the last 40-years, and none of them were famous.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#3

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Greg H. from Wisconsin

>Excellent response, Thanks alot Russ. See you in Oct in La Crosse, WI.

Greg Haugen

La Crosse, WI

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#4

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

George Van

>See you in Oct in La Crosse, WI??

Is there more information available Greg?

Thanks, George

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#5

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

don in central IL

>I agree with Russ. You have to be both. You not only have to have the vision (artist) but the ability to take a hunk of wood and turn a hollow form, bowl or identical spindles (craftsman).

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#6

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Greg H. from Wisconsin

>We will be hosting Russ in Oct. (third sat. of the month, I believe) in La Crosse, WI for a two day demo, sat. and sun. We're working on fees, etc. this weekend and will have it available on Mon. Email me if you would like for any more info, I'm on the program committee.

greghaugen@crwoodturner.com or gregory_haugen@yahoo.com

thanks

Greg

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#7

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

John Lucas

>It is really all about marketing. Certainly one isn't inferior to the other. If you want to market your work in the art arena then you have to present that image both in your work and your attitude. If you want to be purely a craftsman such as an architectural turner then that would be where you market your work. I greatly admire both craftsman and artist if the work they do is done well. I don't think you can even narrow it down all the time to a simple artist or craftsman. You can have art without craftsmanship and you can have craftsmanship without art. Fortunately most have both to some degree or another.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#8

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Great question Greg, and I love Russ's response. This is a question that I think most of us have pondered more than once or twice. When we are just starting out...and even more so after we've been turning for several years. It would be fantastic to be both the artist and the craftsman. A huge challenge for most of us. My thoughts are that you don't need a Oneway lathe or the tools du jour either. You need to have a passion and you need to try....and really that's all you need. Perhaps then we'll all become the artist or the craftsperson we aspire to be. Regardless of whether you reach that status, enjoy the journey and have fun. That's really what it's all about.

Jennifer

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#9

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Carole Valentine

>Good question. I like Jen's and Russ's responses. I would change one word in Jen's: "become the artist AND craftsman" because as Russ said, you have to be both. The artist in the person has the vision and the craftsman in the person has the skills to implement that vision. If you have one without the other, I don't think you get exceptional turnings, either architecturally or artistically speaking. Artistic turnings most often stand on their own merit while architectual ones are often a part of a larger whole and receive less of the spotlight. Then you have the area of functional/utility turnings, which while they are not as often displayed as "art", still require the same craftsmanship skills but perhaps not quite as much artistic vision. I'm rambling. Bye! :)

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#10

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

George Van

>Thanks Greg, I will check on Monday!

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#11

I Am A Craftsman-(Not Sears)

Ken Oakley- Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I believe the artist has the vision and not always the skill. A craftsman has the skill but has a problem with the vision. I can make anything anybody can give me a picture, drawing, sketch, or description. It could be a work of art but I did not create it. I made it.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#12

I beg to differ

Ron in Drums PA

>While the craftsman has the skill (craft), the artist has the vision (art) and the skill (craft).

In my book, neither is inferior, they both have a valued place.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#13

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Raymond Overman in SC

>There are some great answers to this in the thread already. I'd like to add that a lot of large installation artists employ craftsmen to implement their vision. For a work to be labeled as a "piece by:" doesn't necessarily mean that their hand was in every aspect of the craftmanship.

Dale Chihuly for instance is considered an artist, (a very well marketed artist) yet he employs numbers of people to implement an installation such as that found in the Bellagio. It's still considered his work.

With that in mind, a man with no hands can be a sculptor if he has vision and a willing craftsman that will listen. Both are important to the task but usually the person with vision has their name put on the piece in the end.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#14

Artisan

Rick Davenport

>

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#15

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Rick Allen

>Artist, Craftsman, Hobbiest.

I think there is a big difference between folks who make their livelyhood from turning wood and folks who turnwood without much concern for putting food on the table.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#16

Yes, one is inferior.....................

Ruth Niles

>If a contractor needs 220 quality, matching Victorian porch spindles, the "artist" is inferior.

If Del Mano needs a new, unique (useless) artistic turning, the craftsman is inferior.

**** the word "useless" is not used to insult any of us, it's a proven fact that if you turn a fantastically shaped hollow form that has no use, it's a work of art. Make that exact same piece, the exact same way and call it a utensil holder (or in the case in miniatures, a toothpick holder (example))and the price just dropped 150%.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#17

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Raymond Overman in SC

>Without putting more information in your statement I'm not sure where you stand on the original question that was posed.

Yes, it's easier for someone that doesn't need to put food on the table to be an artist and implement thier vision instead of turning out what will sell. Being a popular visionary day after day, year after year is hard, thus the starving artist. Is that what you meant?

Or did you mean that the professional woodturner who produces picture perfect work of the same type form every year and is able to sell it as an established name is an artist?

Where does that put the craftsman who produces 1000 salad bowls this year that have the same shape and size and who is able to sell them as a commodity?

What about the hobbiest who has vision and low self esteem but only produces 1 amazing piece a year, which he immediately stores in his extra bedroom? Many artists aren't revered until after they've passed away and their work is discovered in the attic. Is he still an artist? Does he have to be discovered to obtain the title?

I'm sorry if this sounds negative towards your comment. I just feel that labeling someone based on whether they depend on the income of their work doesn't fit this particular discussion. There are a lot of painters that paint as a hobby who can be considered artists. They just don't market themselves as such.

Either way, if I need chair legs by the hundreds I need a craftsman. If I need a unique piece to evoke a feeling, to be admired, or to decorate my corporate headquarters, I need an artist. If I have a friend that wants a bowl for a gift on the cheap, they need a hobbiest. I wonder if that's why they call me?

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#18

I agree

TDaniel

>well stated Ray.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Keith Tompkins

>I think it really does not matter. We need all kinds of turners: the artists and the craftsmen.

Consider one group....the craftsmen. Names like Bob Rosand, Nick Cook, and Alan Lacer come to mind. These people are highly skilled turners, and have contributed greatly to our craft by teaching thousands of others how to turn. They may not be known for their "signature" pieces, but their contributions are invaluable. We would be poorer without these great turners and teachers. We need them.

Before we label all the artsy types as flaky, esoteric, academic types, consider their contributions as well. For example, I would certainly consider David Ellsworth a true artist. When he pioneered the hollow-form, it was considered a radical departure from the norm. Today, it is commonplace; nearly all turners produce them. We can trace the development of deep hollowing tools, captured laser systems, etc. directly to these early hollow forms. The simple hollow form has affected and influenced the way we all turn.( Not to mention the Ellsworth gouge.) Just for fun, next time you get a chance, take a peek inside an Ellsworth hollow form.....what you will see are toolmarks. Toolmarks so well executed that they appear to be produced by machine. An artist can be a craftsman as well. That's only ONE example. There are many more.

Many turners who we consider artists didn't start making art pieces overnight. Many of them started out as craftsmen, already posessing a high degree of skill. Gradually they began to develop their own sense of style, and began to allow own "voice" to be reflected in their work. Many of them have influenced us as well....this was very evident in Louisville as I studied the pieces in the instant gallery. There were pierced, burnt, textured, segmented, and dyed pieces everywhere. Many influences could be traced directly to the pioneers of that particular style. Don Derry's name was mentioned, for example. Before Don ever turned one of his colorful masterpieces on the lathe, he had developed and honed his finishing skills while making custom musical instruments. The finish he produces didn't just happen, it took years of work to develop.

There is a story, a history, behind any turning we encounter. Whether it is a chair spindle, a bowl, or a piece of art, each piece is a reflection of its maker. Is it art? is it craft? does it matter? They are all worthy of our respect.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#20

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Whew! I just read this great thread and have to say, I agree with everyone. Russ says we must be both...Ray makes an excellent point about the master artist that surrounds him/herself with craftspeople to create his/her vision...Jen says it doesn't matter what tools you use, you must have the passion...then Keith says it doesn't matter which is superior or inferior, we need all turners.

IMHO, every opinion is right. I began this wonderful activity we call woodturning from an exclusively artistic point of view. My formal background is Art History and I have studied the masters of the ages. My own work has evolved from painting to photography, where I have achieved a small degree of satisfaction.

As in these other artistic formats, success requires that one MUST learn the craft in order to execute the vision. This is not negotiable. I had to do it with painting, I had to do it with photography, and I definitely have to do it in woodturning.

Art cannot live without craft, however, as Ken stated, craft can exist without the art. These are the people that make the things of daily life. Without them, life as we know it would not exist.

Hooray for all turners, we are all to be praised.

Sorry for the ramble.

keithz

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#21

Richard Allen

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Richard Allen

>I invoke rule #32

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#22

Leo Van Der Loo

All the paint and brushes and know how to use them *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>Does not make a Rembrandt,

As to superior or inferior, that is for you to answer, but why would a painter that does a beautiful job painting a house, or a painter painting a beautiful scenery, or one that paints an abstract be inferior to the others.

As for craft, you can learn, and art you have as a gift, and all can be improved upon by work and learning IMO.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum4.html

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#23

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

Ed Moore

>There is an underlying tone that no one seems to want to express outright. Sometimes I get the sense that there are those who regard themselves as artists who project an aura that they are a little superior to those who are very skilled technically. And by the same token, I think that some very skilled spindle turners may wonder a little about the skills of some artistically gifted turners. My take on this is that we are all human, subject to a little excess pride on occasion, and sometimes just plain wrong.

Just for fun, let's choose offset turning and forget the rest for the sake of this discussion. There are the technically skilled turners who can make all the cuts, but some won't live long enough to make an artisically pleasing offset piece. And there are some who understand the the intricate cuts and the necessary sequence of operations, but couldn't perform them on a bet so as to produce the offset piece that they have in mind. Then, there are a few, such as J-F Escoulon who excel on both sides of the ledger.

Fortunately, there is room for us all, we are each an interesting mix of skills and ideas, and NONE of us belong on a pedestal.

JMHO,

Ed

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#24

Ok, I'll bite...

Raymond Overman in SC

>Is that the "Never get involved in a land war in Asia" rule or is it another rule #32.

Re: Artist or Craftsman-is one inferior?

#25

See FAQ # 11 ;)  *LINK*

Ed in Leaside (Toronto, Ontario)

>


http://www.woodcentral.com/newforum/faq.shtml