Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

Posts

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#2

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

John Lucas

>So if this process were to become feasible we would simply place the tip of the gouge in some fancy device and it would build up the edge with atoms until it's super sharp. This might take a while so you have two gouges. One you use and other is being sharpened electronically. When the first one gets dull you just change places with the tools. I like this conept. Could we then program it to change the angle?

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#3

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

Don in Central Illinois

>Will this replace my Ellsworth gauge?

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#4

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

cagey59

>And tools would last forever with no grinding required! Would they get longer and have to be ground back after some time?

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#5

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

Rick Davenport

>Or would the sharp edge be so fragile as to be knocked off by wind resistance?

Rick

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#6

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

Thad

>So would a single-atom-edge eliminate the need for sanding?

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#7

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

Jim

>Unless this technology gets much less expensive, we won't see this anytime soon.

Do you know how what equipment and conditions it takes to spray on single layers of atoms?

If you have to ask you can't afford it. This is cutting edge (pun intended) stuff....

Course now, I wonder, if a more crude apparatus might work for building up knife edges. It wouldn't take atoms at a time to do what we need. But it might still be too expensive.

I guess it doesn't hurt to dream tho...

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#8

As long as you don't have tool marks :)

John Lucas

>

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#9

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

Russ Fairfield

>I saw Electron Microscope in the description. That's too expensive for me. Maybe I could get one of those AAW Grants to explore new trechnoloqy.

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#10

Steven Antonucci

I had access to a Scanning Electron Microscope...

steve antonucci

>in college. IIRC, the techs who operated it all wore radiation suits and bands that told them when they were done for the month.

Thanks anyhow, I'll stick to sanding.

steve

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#11

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

Craig Daymon

>There are FREE plans for an electron microscope on the internet. I think it is a dutch university. The plans are in english. I think I have a copy somewhere, let me know if you are planning to build one.

-Craig

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#12

Don't test this edge with your thumb

Tom Libby

>

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#13

Re: I had access to a Scanning Electron Microscope

john lucas

>A lot has changed in the years gone by. We have an electron microscope on campus and Ive photographed it many times. There aren't any radiation warnings that I know of. Now talk about a way to see sanding scratches. That would guarantee you don't have any. Of course you have to slice your bowl into little pieces to scan it but you could reassemble it later. It would look a lot like chip board but what the heck.

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#14

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

gary s clarke

>why not get all cutting tools coated with diamonds?

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#15

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

john lucas

>Gary I read the other day where they can now grow diamonds. So we could just grow our own on the edge. Now that would be cool.

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#16

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

Craig Daymon

>At a cost of about $10/carat and they are PERFECT! No flaws! (Debeer's is very upset.) They grow them just like silicon wafers for the semiconductor industry, which is how some of the companies doing it are intending their diamonds to be used. (They can withstand the heat better than silicon.)

It's an odd thing, but what made diamonds so desireable for jewelry was their ability to bend light and the closer to perfect, the better. Now that man can make diamonds for cheap, the diamond merchants are trying to convince you that a perfect stone is not as good as one dug from the dirt even though it has all the qualities of the best that can be found in nature. As I understand it, diamonds are one of the most common minerals on the planet and it is only the consortiums hoarding them that drives the prices up.

I have an interesting article on the subject in PDF format somewhere. If I could link it, I would. It was originally a web news article.

-Craig

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#17

And I thought this would involve honing!

David

>

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge *LINK*

#18

Re: OT - Getting a REALLY sharp edge

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>I'll stick to my Tormek for now I think ...