Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Let me try this again....long

Posts

Re: Let me try this again....long

#26

WELL SAID & Done!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Thank You Steve and Ken Grunke.

Keith Tompkins attempted to share a point of view and design aid with his friends. What he got in response here amounted to sharpshooting and ad homiem attacks that were so out of character for this board as to be very disappointing.

Keith, it appears that your ideas may be better shared with your students, but thanks anyway for the attempt.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#27

The question that was asked was...

TDaniel

>are the side angles important; please define. He was told that the side angles did not matter. When I then asked if 80 degrees would work I was told my question was "absurd". The triangle may work perfectly but I think the side angles must be defined. If 80 degrees is absurd then what is not absurd. If the side angles are 37 to 42 degrees then we are talking about the 3000 year old "rule of thirds".

Re: Let me try this again....long

#28

Keith Tompkins

Re: Let me try this again....long

Keith Tompkins

>Initially, I felt this post had the opportunity to become a wonderful sharing experience. A springboard leading to the exchange of ideas and design concepts; possibly exploring some new territory.

Sadly, that is not the way it worked out. In the interest of keeping the peace, I have decided that I will no longer post my design theories or concepts here on the turning forum. There are more appropriate places,and the subject is just too volatile for this site.

Despite our many differences, our love for turning has been the one thing that has brought us all together, and given us an appreciation for one another. I regret that my design posts have had just the opposite effect. That was not my intention.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#29

Nooooooo!

RK in Milw

>Keith, I personally think that you have generated a good deal of positive discussion. Okay, so a couple of folks got a little cranky; maybe a lack of fiber in the diet, who knows? Look at the number of readers of these discussions. Over 600 to begin with and falling off to 200. That's alot of people who are interested in an exploration of design principles. And it is an exploration, is it not?

You have taken on a tough subject where no one else has, and if your theories aren't perfect. what does it matter? They are theories. I never got the impression that you were trying to put yourself on some kind of high horse. All I see is a very sincere effort to bring some thinking and stimulus to the subject of design. Please don't give up just because you caught a little flack. Flack is good. It means you are approaching the target. Remember the other 600 of us who enjoy your posts.

Thanks for your efforts.

Ron Nelson

Re: Let me try this again....long

#30

Brad Vietje

Here, Here !

Brad Vietje

>I agree completely. I can see some of the merit of the critics of this design construct, since I can draw a triangle around a pretty hideous form, but using a caternary curve within a given triangle is a great guide to a pleasing form.

I think Keith's efforts at a web discussion of design criteria is an excellent effort to be applauded, however diffucult. The tough part is when someone has only heard or seen part of the process, then comments to negate the whole. It happens, but that's just an unfortunate part of the process.

I also have never seen Keith try to appoint himself the high priest of woodturning design -- just an honest and open discussion of what factors contribute to good form, and what methods might be useful for teaching these concepts.

Keep 'em coming, Keith !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Let me try this again....long

#31

Re: Here, Here !

John Lucas

>Me too and that was my point. It's just a discussion. No one had to adhere to it and no one had to take it as gospel. It was just a something to look at, take it or leave it. If you take an art appreciation course they take a painting and draw circles and triangle and s curves all over the painting to try and show you how the artist wants your eye to travel through the print and also why this print works and that one doesn't. In this case the triangle might have 3 uneven sides but it shows how your eye travels through the photo.

Another use for triangles we didn't discuss. If you draw lines down the planes of a bowl they intersect somewhere. It cold be a foot below the piece. These imaginary lines give the impression of a firm solid base or give the appearance of left depending on where they meet. This is something that you percieve as a viewer, your mind draws these lines and you are not aware of it but it's something that can really change a piece. Architects have explored this for 1000 years.

Well if it's my turn to get bashed so be it but we can learn a lot from other art forms and studying how and why we find things good or bad is a good thing. This may mean looking a trying things that don't work. However if you don't try it how do you know it doesn't work. I'm a hands on person. I don't accept or reject anything until I've tried it myself. I've been proven wrong too many times.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#32

Anything is worth a try

TDaniel

>I agree John, anything is worth a try. This entire thread torments me because I honestly try to help students to obtain good shapes. I rely on century old rules to help them train their eye. I see some good things with this approach but I have confidence in age old methods that have stood the test of time. I honestly have tried to apply the things taught here but all I get is one shape, a drooping chain. What am I missing?

Re: Let me try this again....long

#33

Re: Anything is worth a try

john lucas

>TD I know you care about teaching and we each discover our own ways. Some work, some don't and each student is different so you are sometims forced to try something radically different to get through to them.

Sometimes you only use a part of the drooping chain. For example you could use the bottom curve upside down under a lip and then connect it to the sides. You can of course change the curve by moving the hanging points wider. Mostly what the chain does is teach the student to see a fair curve without any flat spots. A lot easier to see than do of course. I think we could introduce all of the various methods of developing good forms and let the student decide what works for them.

Some may find the triangle method totally useless and some may find it interesting to try. The same with the Golden rectangle proportions and the Catenary curve. Sometimes it's as simple as just showing them these things exist. Then later in thier turning career when they are trying to solve a problem they might remember that darn chain and pull it out and suddenly they have an idea to help them with this problem. Who knows.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#34

Re: Let me try this again....long

Bob Fawcett

>I have followed this and the previous thread. The various illustrations in this thread go a long way to making this much clearer.

As one of the beginners, these discussions are a great benefit to me. I know that teaching design is not easy, nor is learning it unless you have some natural talent. I am not one of those with natural talent. I can't draw or sketch.

I truly believe that everyone here is trying to help. Please don't let this prevent you from sharing. Many of us depend on this to find our eye, and learn this craft.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#35

Re: Anything is worth a try *LINK*

Peter Hyde

>I read this thread with a lot of interest and for those who would like to check it out here is a site that really gets into design and the Golden mean and PHi and all the good stuff.


http://www.goldennumber.net/

Re: Let me try this again....long

#36

Fantastic Resource!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thank you Peter. I just skimmed the surface of this page but will delve into it tonight at work. It looks very interesting. And relatively simple to understand....bonus!

Jen :)

Re: Let me try this again....long

#37

Re: Anything is worth a try

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole Georgia

>Thanks Peter, it sure does look interesting.