Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Let me try this again....long

Posts

Let me try this again....long

#1

Keith Tompkins

Let me try this again....long

Keith Tompkins

>I have been thinking about my recent post with Dinyar and TD. I'm afraid I didn't handle that one too well..I hope they will both accept my apologies. I also want to thank Russ for his thoughtful and logical response.

I have been working on part 2 of the article, and have been trying to come up with a better way to illustrate how the triangle method could work. The following image is what I came up with so far.

The focal point of the image is a conical shape, or a long, narrow triangular form. Why start with this shape?...I think it's a realistic starting point, and it forces the student to focus on just one specific area; or as Russ stated, it FRAMES the object we desire to draw. Again I didn't measure the angles, all I want the viewer to see is the shape of the cone...and then attempt to draw a pleasing shape, using the cone as a guide. This is intended as an exercise to teach a student to THINK about shapes and forms on their own, without books, drawings, or photos of other work.

Can a pleasing form be derived from this cone? the next image shows a simple goblet form based on the cone. Notice the organic curves in the bowl of the goblet.

Now, go back to the first image..you will notice the cone is surrounded by a yellow semi-circle. Now, imagine the cone as being flexible...we could open it up to any point in the yellow area. I show just a couple of options: AA,BB,CC, etc. I chose these points at random; again, I didn't measure the angles. WE could use these points, or anywhere in between. This is why I refer to my method as a flexible approach. Could we (or the student) again base an attractive form on the new triangle we chose?

I have been thinking about my decision NOT to give limits to my approach...say 35-45 degree limits. AHA! ...because they are LIMITS. I don't want to limit my approach, nor the approach of a turning student. For instance ..." this is a box. you can only work within the confines of this box. you may not exceed the boundaries set by this box." To my way of thinking, rules such as this are merely another set of self-imposed limitations. While they may help create some pleasing forms, they also severely limit the creative process...and prevent us from exploring the multitude of attractive shapes that exist beyond these artificial limits.

Anyway, does this help clarify my triangle approach? If anyone wants to give it a try, and respond, either here at WC or privately, feel free.

The last image is the initial sketch for a new finial I am working on..based on the same steep-sided triangle I have been discussing. I pulled it from my sketch book, and scanned it into my computer.

Thanks for reading this. Keith


img

Re: Let me try this again....long

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re:second image..goblet 

Keith Tompkins

>


img

Re: Let me try this again....long

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: a finial

Keith Tompkins

>this is a rough sketch of the series of finials I am currently working on. It is based directly on my triangle ideas, as were many of my previous pieces. No, they don't look like traditional finials; but then, I don't want them to.


img

Re: Let me try this again....long

#4

JL

Re:Looks like a classic champagne flute to me..

JL

>which I consider a reasonably pleasing form (especially when full ;)). I see it's use as a starter for designs or design elements (such as your finial).

Re: Let me try this again....long

#5

Re: Another use for the triangle

Russ Fairfield

>Keith,

I would suggest that sometimes the shape of the frame itself can be used. The cone is one of those shapes that can look pretty good by itself.


img

Re: Let me try this again....long

#6

Show me how to make one of those Keith

OB O'Brien

>

Re: Let me try this again....long

#7

Re: Let me try this again....long

John Lucas

>I think imposing limits helps a student think harder I'm not really sure a triangle guarantees a good form. The triangle coupled with something else probably does, such as putting the form in the triangle and then imposing the catenary curve or golden rectangle proportions or rule of thirds on this shape.

Although your goblet shape and Russ's shape do work you have impossed another design problem by putting the foot on it. The curves going from the vessel shape to the foot could easily be right or wrong as well as the size of the foot and the length of the stem. Applying the golden rectangle to these shapes and lenghts might help to solve this dilema.

I think as teaching tool the triangle is good because it takes a student with absolutely no design theory and it tries to give them some direction. You have to start somewhere. When you teach 3D or 2D design you have to give the students limits and train them to work within those limits. Once you've worked with the other design elements and tried to show them how most art falls within these design ideas you can release them to break the rules. I had one assignment in college to purposely break some design rule. This really forced you to think about why and how that particular design element worked.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#8

Re: Let me try this again....long

Rick Davenport

>Keith,

Different wines/spirits traditionally call for different shaped goblets.

Granted, some forms are more pleasing to the eye than others, but do these all fit the formula?

Rick


img

Re: Let me try this again....long

#9

Re: Let me try this again....long

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Keith,

I bowed out of that original discussion early, as it became somewhat frustrating to me. I then decided to give your triangle idea a try, which is all anyone had to do--I still cannot understand what all the fuss was about. It took me only a few minutes to find out whether or not your idea could be useful to me.

In a 3D graphics program, I drew a series of Isosceles triangles ranging from very acute to obtuse. I didn't bother to measure angles, but simply used a square grid as a guide.

Then, using a bezier curve (a common tool in most graphics programs) I freehand approximated a catenary curve within each triangle. My 3D program has a "revolve" or "lathe" feature, so it was simple enough to render each bezier curve into a full 360 degree form just for the heck of it and for better visual effect. Text cont'd below pic.



I have never been much of a "pre-designer" in woodturning, I've always let the wood design the outcome on the fly. It's probably about time I change that, and become more intentional in the design process. Your triangle idea is a great design aid when one desires or needs to break away from the standard rules such as the Golden Mean, and the Rules of 3rds. For bowls, it seems to give pleasing proportions for the base/foot size in relation to the piece's size. In my renditions, the feet are represented by simple rectangles but on the real thing that might be a flat/slightly concave bottom, a beaded foot, or whatever.

Anyway, it's not something I'll use everyday, but may come in handy on occasion and I'm sure it's quite helpful as a previsualization aid for many folks.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Another use for the triangle

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Russ, you are quite correct...I spotted a set of silver candle sticks at an antique store yesterday...long, slender cones, such as you described in your earlier post.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Let me try this again....long

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Rick, For the goblet shapes you have shown, yes I think the triagle will work quite well. Here is one example...don't forget, we can invert the triangle.


img

Re: Let me try this again....long

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Let me try this again....long

Keith Tompkins

>Wow, thanks Ken! You certainly catch on quick! thanks for taking the time to illustrate so many forms. Your post shows pleasing forms can be created without adhering to strict rules.

I was hoping that I wouldn't have to draw a lot of forms, hoping people would draw a few forms for themselves, then see if it was a useful concept.

On the other hand, I think you are correct; you really don't need my triangles....you already understand the concept and can visualize forms, so you are past that stage.

It's the beginner who is having trouble who will hopefully benefit the most. Thanks so much, Keith

Re: Let me try this again....long

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Let me try this again....long

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks John, as someone who teaches as well, you can understand the problems associated with teaching design to a new turner. Here is another was to arrive at the same conclusion, and a pleasing goblet.

Here I used TWO golden rectangles, one for the bowl, and one to determine the length of the stem.

The thing BOTH goblets have in common is they both employ organic curves. They both have good proportion, yet two different methods were used. One advantage of my triangle, I think, is the taper effect, which helps size the foot in many cases.


img

Re: Let me try this again....long

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re:Looks like a classic champagne flute to me..

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks JL, I just can't resist tweaking forms just to see what happens. Next time, I'll show how the triangle will work for hollow forms.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Show me how to make one of those Keith

Keith Tompkins

>Hi OB! It's the same technique as I use to create a rose...I DID see you at my rose demo?! :(

If you email me with your address, I can send you a copy from the demo....just in case you missed it. (LOL) thanks, Keith

Re: Let me try this again....long

#16

Let me answer this again

TDaniel

>I can draw a triangle around a pleasant shape or an ugly shape. Not defining the triangle leaves everything to the imagination. If you can imagine a good shape in the triangle it works. If you imagine a bad shape in the triangle it does not work. Where's the beef?

Re: Let me try this again....long

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Let me try this again....long

Keith Tompkins

>I included a surprise in this image; I don't know if anyone picked up on it. If you flip this image, the yellow semi-circle fits very closely into a golden rectangle. Now, imagine all the shapes within that rectangle we normally would not even see!

Re: Let me try this again....long

#18

sorrry, it won't work

TDaniel

>Sorry Keith, but unless you define the triangle this just will not work. I can put all kinds of ugly shapes in this triangle. If you want to make the Tomkins Triangle into something we can all use you must define the angles or the limits. Framing a nice shape with a triangle is one thing but showing how a triangle will guarantee a good shape is another. Your technique seems to have no rules, no limits and no parameters.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#19

Re: sorrry, it won't work

Dinyar Chavda

>For the record, I agree with Terry, i.e., if I have no eye for form, and try to fit a bowl into a triangle/cone, I am more likely to come up with ugly shapes than with nice ones, unless I use additional restrictions regarding proportions or angles .

I think that Terry hits it on the head when he says that while you can put a triangle around a good shape, just drawing a triangle before you put a shape in it does not guarantee a good form.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#20

Re: Let me try this again....long

Ed in Leaside (Toronto, Ontario)

>Ok, you've lost me here. By definition, a semi-circle fits into a rectangle that has a ratio of 1:2. Curious fellow that I am, I took your image into Illustrator and dropped a circle on it (to see if it was perfectly round, close enough), then drew a rectangle on top of the yellow semi. Flipped or not the ratio is about 1:1.95. How does this relate to the Golden Rectangle?

Ken Grunke seems to have a pretty good "handle" on the use of bezier curves (pun intended). Have you considered using them to teach form to those who can't draw or visualize objects?

Re: Let me try this again....long

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Let me try this again....long

Keith Tompkins

>Ed , I said "close". I did not say "exact". If it took your computer program to show how far off I was, then I would say it was close enought to make my point. Do you really think a student who has never studied this subject would know what a bezier curve is? I use a chain to demonstrate the catenary effect. Simple and effective. As simple as I can make it.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#22

Re: sorrry, it won't work

Arch

>Terry, Triangles will work if you use M.C Escher's and R. Penrose's impossible triangles. At least on paper if not on wood. :)

Maybe 'forms of artistic acception' could be drawn inside other impossible two dimensional graphic 'forms of deception'. Why limit we design challenged, but otherwise reasonably intelligent turners to triangles as we struggle to design two dimensional bowls? Other polygons can surround a bowl and might comply with the silver pentagon or even the platinum octogon. Silly? Yes, but then just maybe I'm not alone. :)

Re: Let me try this again....long

#23

Re: sorrry, it won't work

Bill Crommett

>I have avoided this one for two days, but I have to admit that the triangle give some insight to the shape and size of the foot, but not much more.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: sorrry, it won't work

Keith Tompkins

>HI Bill, you gave it a shot. That's all I asked. Thanks.

Re: Let me try this again....long

#25

Re:second image..goblet

Stephen Mushinski

>Where did common courtesy go in our wonderful turning forum? I am shocked at the manor in which a few people have chosen to get their point arccoss. If the triangle method isn�t for you, then forget it. If you cannot use the idea or method then walk away. This way, we would have no hurt feeling, and other will not think any less of anyone.

I sat (stood as the room was overflowing) in the demo in Louisville and one point most are missing is the catenary effect. During the demo Keith used a chain to fill the area in the triangle. Easy, simple and it will produce a very pleasing form EVERY time. Read the whole document and apply all of the principles presented, not just what you wish to disagree with. No where do I read, draw an ugly shape in the triangle.

Ken Grunke�s post above, shows in picture form, exactly what Keith�s method can produce. There is no arguing the above pictures have produced nice turnings.

Should you wish to use another drawing aid, try a set of French curves within the triangles? Again, you will find success.

If you are one of the gifted turners that put a hunk of wood on the lathe and produce the perfect form, then I tip my hat to you. Most of us require some help (guide lines).

Which I thank Keith for putting forth his ideas and concepts.

Steve