Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

Posts

Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#1

Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

Will Williams

>Hi All,

I'm trying to decide on getting a roughing gouge and don't want to make an uninformed "beginner" mistake.

The reason I am looking into getting a roughing gouge is that I have been using a shallow spindle gouge which is about 1" wide for bark removal & rounding out square stock. The shallow gouge works OK but seems to be a bit "light" for the job; seems a heavier tool would be more comfortable.

Anyway I've checked out the catalogs & am undecided which is the best one to get. Seems the 3/4" is the most popular (according to the catalogs)& the price is very good ($55.99 Craft Supplies, Henry Taylor) as compared to a wider 1 1/2" version at $87.99. I have been leaning towards the Henry Taylor brand because I have had good luck with them so far.

Guess my question is: What size / brand roughing gouge do experienced turners really prefer & is it worth the extra $32.00 for the 1 1/2" gouge. My budget is on the tight side.

Any advice or opnions would really appreciated.

Thanks,

Will

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#2

what lathe do you have?

TDaniel

>A roughing gouge for a mini lathe would be smaller than one used on a 3 hp lathe. Tell us more about your equipment and what you plan to turn and we will be happy to help you spend your money.

TD

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#3

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>I use a 3/4". I would recommend Sorby, Hamlet, Henry Taylor, Crown, most any major brand. I do use a 3/8 continental gouge when I do pens but for spindle roughing on my 20" lathe and my mini I use the 3/4". Just remember the roughing gouge is for use on spindles only.

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#4

Re: what lathe do you have?

Will Williams

>TD,

Sorry bout that........

I have the 16" Delta Steelbed lathe.

So far my recent turnings have been limited to some vases that are about 4-5" in diameter & around 8" tall, been using those glass test tube liners.

My wood supply is salvaged tree limbs around 8-10" in diameter, been mostly cherry & ash.

As far as what I will be turning, that's sort of the dilema as I haven't found my niche yet, but the midi lathe realm isn't in the picture at this time.

Hope this helps.

Adios,

Will

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#5

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed *LINK*

albertabob

>I use a P&N 32mm roughing gouge .

Lee Valley sells them.

It's a very beefy piece of excellent steel and the flute drops right back to the handle which gives much more stock to sharpen than other types on the market.

You can turn your own handle but in my case I drilled a 16" piece of 1" aircraft aluminum and set the shank with a couple of set screws.

This mother does not bounce when you step up to a blank.

Bob


P&N gouges

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#6

JL

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

JL

>Sort of what Alberta Bob said.. 1 1/4" is a nice size for most stuff. Crown, Sorby, Henry Taylor - they are all probably as good for a roughing gouge. You may want to go for the P&N as they are supposed to have a beefier tang. (Not that anyone ever snapped a tool from getting a catch...)

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#7

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

Craig Daymon

>Many of the turners demoing at the AAW Symposium were using P&N roughing gouges and those that commented on it mentioned the beefier tang as a reason.

I have a 2.5" roughing gouge that I bought from Penn State Industries for about $25. It works well, but is a bit clumsy near the headstock and, less so, near the tailstock. I usually hold it by the flute about halfway back rather than by the handle. I think about a 1.5" roughing gouge would be ideal for me, though I still might hold it by the flute.

Eli Avisera, I think, grinds back the corners of the roughing gouge in a way that makes it very useful for cutting a quick tenon on a piece without picking up another tool. I've used one like this and found it very useful, though I haven't ground one back yet.

At the symposium, I saw some roughing gouges that were very shallow. I think 'The Cutting Edge' and 'Craft Supplies' sold this type. Sort of like very wide detail gouges. I was told Rude Olsolnik used these for roughing large logs, though I don't know why they wouldn't work for smaller stock. The nose is rounded, unlike a traditional roughing gouge. Maybe someone with experience can explain the pros/cons of this type. (It may be a european or more specifically, german, roughing gouge.)

-Craig

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#8

Steven Antonucci

why do you need a roughing gouge?

steve antonucci

>Personally, I rough most items with a large bowl gouge (5/8") If the blank is mounted face grain, I start at the tailstock and cut normally. When I get 1/2 way, I switch to the headstock side, and cut in until round.

If it is an end grain vessel, I might grab my roughing gough or just use the bowl gouge in the same manner. I'd save my money on a "rough" tool and spend it on finishing tools... you can rough with anything, and you'll end up recutting that area anyway.

my 2 pennies.

steve

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#9

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

bowlman

>I'll echo what albertabob said about the P&N roughing gouge. Get one and you'll never need another ... unless you get bitten really REALLY hard by the turning bug.

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#10

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

Bill Neddow

>Get the P&N gouge. Beautifully made (strong!) excellent steel, and inexpensive. You will be many, many, years wearing that tool out.

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#11

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed *LINK*

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi Will -- Ashley-Iles makes a round-bar roughing gouge in 3/8" and 1/2". Bob Rosand spoke highly of the 1/2" (it's actually 5/8" diameter; the 3/8" is 3/8" -- go figure) and was using it at a workshop for our group, and a bunch of us, of course, got them. I used mine today to rough down some ash and cherry blanks for handles, and have pretty much abandoned the 3/4" Sorby I started with, as well as the 1-1/4" I got later on.

US source is Tools for Working Wood in NYC, link below, no affiliation.


Tools for Working Wood -- Ashley-Iles roughing

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#12

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

clem390@belllsouth.net

>Take the roughing gouge and hang it on the wall when you are doing faceplate turning. Get yourself a Ellsworth gouge. You don't need any other tool to completely do a open faced bowl.

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#13

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

david

>I currently am using a 1-1/4-inch Robert Sorby with 2060 steel and is serving me well with a minor complaint that the tang seems to be bending from all the beating I give it when roughing out. My next roughing gouge will be the P & N and I will turn a big handle for it like TD does.

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#14

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

Glenn Hodges, Nashville, GA

>Will, get yourself a big P&N Roughing Gouge, the big tang shows they care about their customers. You will like it.

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#15

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

Craig Daymon

>Once you go to faceplate turning, rather than getting an Ellsworth, get a regular grind bowl gouge and reshape it to an Ellsworth grind or Irish grind. I ordered a Crown Pro-PM 5/8" bowl gouge with a regular grind for about $70 and reground it. I could have ordered the same steel with an Ellsworth grind for about $130. Of course, I'd still have to eventually learn how to grind it with the Ellsworth grind, so why not save $60 and learn from the start. Great gouge.

-Craig

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#16

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

clem390@belllsouth.net

>No matter what gouge you get or how much money you can save, put the ellsworth profile on it and leave the roughing gouge on the wall.

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#17

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

clem390@belllsouth.net

>Just for informational porposes, the ellsworth gouge runs about 75.00, with a handle

Re: Roughing Gouge Advice Needed

#18

Thanks for all the advice "NM"

Will Williams

>