Re: Absolutely
Dinyar Chavda
>Keith:
Now I'm annoyed.
You started off with this unrestricted statement in your article:
How it Works
If we take a right triangle (containing one 90 degree angle), and create a mirror image of it, a symmetrical triangle will result (isosceles). This flexible approach can be used to �stretch� the triangles to fit nearly any configuration; the resulting forms will be well proportioned and well balanced
I interpret this as saying that placing a form in any isosceles triangle would give a pleasing shape.
Then, when some triangles which resulted in bad forms were posted by various people including myself, you said that the forms had to fit the triangles efficiently (without that ever having been defined). Subsequent examples of bad forms got the response from you that the forms did not fit the triangles well, again, without any explanation of fit. Now when TD posts an example of a triangle with 80 degree sides, you claim that this is absurd, and, somehow validating his point that you cannot use any triangle upsets you.
Every question that has been raised regarding the dimensions of the triangle has been unanswered by you, but, any time that someone posts a bad form, you dismiss it because they are somehow using a triangle that is bad! Based on what?
You claim to have invented something---great. But your "proof" that it works is either "trust me", or that students think that it is a great addition to existing form guidelines, and that it has helped them. Have you considered the fact that the reason you have had success with it among your students is due to the fact that they are consciously applying rigor to their design? I'd suspect that you could have them draw a shape in an irregular octagon, and, just the fact that they are paying attention to it may be enough to make them come up with shapes that are more pleasing than their past attempts.
Or another "proof" of the validity of your approach is the fact that you have had lots of requests for the article, and that other teachers have asked for permission to use the technique. Unfortunately, textbooks, newspapers, science journals, symposia, etc., are replete with examples of things that are flat out wrong! Some are due to fraud (the Korean scientist who recently claimed success in cloning comes to mind---everone thought it was great, or terrible, depending on your religious beliefs, until it was shown to be a fraud---but until some skeptics proved that he was falsifying data, everyone accepted it, including the scientific community). Take another example, which is still in news reports, "common knowledge", and even textbooks, i.e., that water goes down a toilet in one direction in the Northern hemisphere, and the opposite one in the Southern! People will even say that it is due to the Coriolis effect (not that most of them know what it means). Hogwash. It cannot possibly be! And yet people believe it.
So, if you can't provide answers that address questions that people have about a technique, then the number of people who jump onto that technique is quite irrelevant. People are always looking for the magic bullet in all walks of life, but that does not mean that every idea that comes along is a valid one.
I think that you have fallen into the following syllogistic trap:
- I can draw a triangle around any pleasing form.
- Ergo, any form that "fits" in any triangle is going to be pleasing.
I have a suggestion---you refer to all these people who are enthusiastic fans of the triangle approach and think that it works. Why don't you expose some of them to this thread, and ask them to provide answers to the questions that we have raised? Maybe they'll be able to convince us.
To summarize for them, the issue is simple. If I follow the rule of thirds or the golden mean, I will get a pleasing shape in almost every case. If I follow your triangle method, while it is possible to occasionally get a pleasing shape, I will be likely to draw far more non-harmonious shapes, unless I put other restrictions on the triangle or the shape. And we'd like to get some objective definitions of those restrictions.
Keith, as I had said to you earlier, you may have an approach that helps people visualize a good form---art textbooks are replete with diagrams of golden triangles as applied to famous paintings (one oft-quoted example being Da Vinci's "last Supper"). You may have an alternative approach to showing the golden mean in a manner more meaningful to turners. But right now, I think it is just the beginning of an idea---whether or not it is a valid one, and under what circumstances, is not proven in any way. You can choose to let it be, and bask in the adulation of those who accept it (in my opinion, uncritically), or you can choose to work on it more, and give it rigor, so that it truly is a guide to developing good form.
Alternatively, your suggestion that you bang your head against the wall may also be a good one.