Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Dinyar...new thread

Posts

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#26

Keith Tompkins

Re: Training the eye

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Terry, What a difference a new day makes...MAN, I was getting tired and cranky last night! You are correct, your triangle method of teaching will work very well. However....someone such as myself will tire quickly of making the same form time after time. I want to experiment and explore. I want to push the limits..I don't want to cut all my blanks to the same shape. How do you make other shapes work that do not fit this basic shape? That's why I started looking for other alternatives to the "golden rectangle" in the first place...it's very limited in its use as a turning aid.

I think the secret to making my method work is to: 1. use as much of the triangle as possible. 2. Draw with organic curves. (the catenary is a way to envision these organic curves). Before you dismiss my idea completely, humor me for a bit. Draw a few triangles as shown in my "Triangle" sheet, and hang the drawing on a wall. Random triangles, from shallow to deep. Now, suspend the chain from each hand, allowing it to sag and fill each triangle. If you desire, you can tape the chain in place and trace around it. The result will be a very simple, flowing form. THAT'S what I want my students to visualize. Last, sketch in a foot that stays within the triangle. Then, explain to me why it does not work. I am not being a smart@$$, I'm asking you to look at things a bit differently than you may normally do.

Before I published my article, I tried this literally hundreds and hundreds of times. So far, I have only shown the results on bowl forms. It works amazingly well for hollow form shapes as well, including forms with no foot at all...but that's a whole new article.

Yes, it is very possible to draw ugly, nasty, forms within a triangle, or any other shape you choose. A straight sided bowl with a flat bottom will fit if you want it to. If you re-read my article and my handout, you will find I emphasize smooth, flowing forms without drastic changes in their line in each case.

If you try what I suggest, would you let me know the results? I would be most interested. Thanks, Keith

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#27

Keith Tompkins

Re: Absolutely

Keith Tompkins

>No formula fits all circumstances... but using a triangle with 80 degree sides as an example is absurd. Lets put a limit as what we may realistically expect to mount on the lathe.

Please understand, I'm trying to help people. And, many who have tried my method are doing better work. By their own reckoning, not mine.

Instead of actually trying it to see if it really works, some would rather come with any reason at all why it will not. Not much I can do about that.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#28

The chain works great.....

TDaniel

>the triangles don't. In my opinion instead of making things simpler for a beginner we are making it more complicated by introducing triangles with no minimum or maximum angle. Hanging a loop of chain will give you a nice shape, but, only one shape. Del Stubbs used a mirror very effectively in seeing how different designs might look by just drawing one side and using the mirror to "project" the other side. It has been many years since I have had any need to draw anything before making it. I have studied shapes that I thought were pleasing and I have effectively used the thirds rule for years to the point that I can shape a bowl to the thirds rule without ever using a ruler. Occasionally I make a vessel that does not conform to the thirds rule but when I attempt that I know there is a 50/50 chance that it will go into my stove. If a student learns the thirds rule well and practices regularly and studies work that he/she sees and likes then in due time that turner will start producing nice shapes and they will be surprised at how many shapes can be made with the thirds rule. If a student does not respect the thirds rule or tries to replace it with any new rule then he/she can expect a high percentage of rejects as they flounder in confusion.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#29

Re: Absolutely

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

Your statement that "some would rather come with any reason at all why it will not (work)" and calling an objection absurd are absolutely uncalled for. Sounds to me like you are still feeling cranky.

Just because someone says that an approach or a theory works, and claims that others agree with him, does not automatically mean that the theory is valid. If we adopted such an approach, mankind would still believe that the sun goes around the earth.

No one is questioning your intention. In fact, as the person who started this question, my original assumption (which I repeated several times) was that the fault lay with me in my inability to understand.

However, at this stage I am forced to conclude that, based on everything said by you and others, the triangles do not add anything of use to me.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#30

Keith Tompkins

Re: Absolutely

Keith Tompkins

>If I create a triangle with 80 degree sides, this is the form I can expect to obtain. Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm going to go bang my head against the wall.


img

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#31

Re: Absolutely

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

Now I'm annoyed.

You started off with this unrestricted statement in your article:

How it Works

If we take a right triangle (containing one 90 degree angle), and create a mirror image of it, a symmetrical triangle will result (isosceles). This flexible approach can be used to �stretch� the triangles to fit nearly any configuration; the resulting forms will be well proportioned and well balanced

I interpret this as saying that placing a form in any isosceles triangle would give a pleasing shape.

Then, when some triangles which resulted in bad forms were posted by various people including myself, you said that the forms had to fit the triangles efficiently (without that ever having been defined). Subsequent examples of bad forms got the response from you that the forms did not fit the triangles well, again, without any explanation of fit. Now when TD posts an example of a triangle with 80 degree sides, you claim that this is absurd, and, somehow validating his point that you cannot use any triangle upsets you.

Every question that has been raised regarding the dimensions of the triangle has been unanswered by you, but, any time that someone posts a bad form, you dismiss it because they are somehow using a triangle that is bad! Based on what?

You claim to have invented something---great. But your "proof" that it works is either "trust me", or that students think that it is a great addition to existing form guidelines, and that it has helped them. Have you considered the fact that the reason you have had success with it among your students is due to the fact that they are consciously applying rigor to their design? I'd suspect that you could have them draw a shape in an irregular octagon, and, just the fact that they are paying attention to it may be enough to make them come up with shapes that are more pleasing than their past attempts.

Or another "proof" of the validity of your approach is the fact that you have had lots of requests for the article, and that other teachers have asked for permission to use the technique. Unfortunately, textbooks, newspapers, science journals, symposia, etc., are replete with examples of things that are flat out wrong! Some are due to fraud (the Korean scientist who recently claimed success in cloning comes to mind---everone thought it was great, or terrible, depending on your religious beliefs, until it was shown to be a fraud---but until some skeptics proved that he was falsifying data, everyone accepted it, including the scientific community). Take another example, which is still in news reports, "common knowledge", and even textbooks, i.e., that water goes down a toilet in one direction in the Northern hemisphere, and the opposite one in the Southern! People will even say that it is due to the Coriolis effect (not that most of them know what it means). Hogwash. It cannot possibly be! And yet people believe it.

So, if you can't provide answers that address questions that people have about a technique, then the number of people who jump onto that technique is quite irrelevant. People are always looking for the magic bullet in all walks of life, but that does not mean that every idea that comes along is a valid one.

I think that you have fallen into the following syllogistic trap:



  • I can draw a triangle around any pleasing form.

  • Ergo, any form that "fits" in any triangle is going to be pleasing.


I have a suggestion---you refer to all these people who are enthusiastic fans of the triangle approach and think that it works. Why don't you expose some of them to this thread, and ask them to provide answers to the questions that we have raised? Maybe they'll be able to convince us.

To summarize for them, the issue is simple. If I follow the rule of thirds or the golden mean, I will get a pleasing shape in almost every case. If I follow your triangle method, while it is possible to occasionally get a pleasing shape, I will be likely to draw far more non-harmonious shapes, unless I put other restrictions on the triangle or the shape. And we'd like to get some objective definitions of those restrictions.

Keith, as I had said to you earlier, you may have an approach that helps people visualize a good form---art textbooks are replete with diagrams of golden triangles as applied to famous paintings (one oft-quoted example being Da Vinci's "last Supper"). You may have an alternative approach to showing the golden mean in a manner more meaningful to turners. But right now, I think it is just the beginning of an idea---whether or not it is a valid one, and under what circumstances, is not proven in any way. You can choose to let it be, and bask in the adulation of those who accept it (in my opinion, uncritically), or you can choose to work on it more, and give it rigor, so that it truly is a guide to developing good form.

Alternatively, your suggestion that you bang your head against the wall may also be a good one.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#32

Exactly

TDaniel

>I used 80 degrees as a starting point. If we continue to restrict the angles further to say 70 degrees and then 60 degrees, etc we will eventually define what the side angles must be which is what Dinyar is asking. My guess is that when we get to 37 to 42 degrees we will get pieces that look proportional and pleasing. It also means we will be properly applying the rule of thirds. You had better hurry though because I hear Dinyar is about to come out with a Dinyar Triangle that defines the triangle side angles.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#33

I have followed this thread ...

Bob Fawcett

>from the beginning. As a beginning turner it is important to me to try to figure out how to create forms that I like and hopefully others will like. So far, most of what I have done could be considered copies of something else I have seen. Probably good practice, but not much for finding my own eye.

Would one of you explain how the rule of thirds fits turning. I have a basic understanding of as it relates to photography, but don't exactly see how it fits turning.

Thanks to all for this discussion.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#34

Re: I have followed this thread ...

Dinyar Chavda

>Bob:

One place where the application to turning is illustrated in a concrete manner is at http://www.woodcentral.com/russ/russ2.shtml , in an article by Russ.

Dinyar

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#36

Bob. in a nutshell...

TDaniel

>If you rough out a blank to round, then measure the diameter at the top you will find that the most pleasing dimension for the diameter of the bottom will generally be one third of the top diameter. I will not get into the exceptions here. You will also find that the bowl will look best if the height equals the base diameter (height is one third of top diameter). You can fudge on the height to about one half the top diameter. Once the height exceeds half the max diameter there is an area where your eye/mind doesn't know if it is a bowl or a vase and that gray area is difficult to deal with. When you go deeper then it is a vase and there are no problems. With this formula the side of a bowl will normally slope out at about 40 degrees. Let me emphasize that these are starting points to help train your eye to good form. From here you can add flared rims, reverse curves, and all manners of different but pleasing shapes. By the way, there is a new lay turner in our club whose measurements are 38-23-36; would you like to meet her? Actually that should be 34-32-38, still want to meet her? lol

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#37

Keith Tompkins

Re: Absolutely

Keith Tompkins

>Dinyar, I will apply the same reasoning to the Golden Rectangle as is being applied to my triangle method. Here is the Rectangle, complete with a bowl form that fits the criteria extremely well.

If I turn this form with my drawing as a guide, and post it here, I will be told that my form is poor. Yet, I used the infallible golden rectangle as my guide. How can that be?

Using the logic presented in this thread, I find it's entirely possible to create all sorts of poor forms using the golden rectangle;indeed, I can draw poor forms all day using this method. Therefore, I must conclude that the Golden Rectangle is totally useless as a guide for producing pleasing forms.

The rule of thirds? I guarantee you...I can draw ugly forms using the rule of thirds as well. It will only work as well as I want it to.

I never said my method would work in all cases. It is simply meant as a guide to help new turners. In my Wood Turning Design article, I show examples at both ends of the spectrum...a platter, and my piece "Tango". I am still waiting for an explanation of how the golden rectangle would apply to either.

I intentionally do not use precise angles and formulas...what new turner could deal with that? If they assure me they cannot draw or visualize shapes, do you really think complicating things with equations or precise rules will be of any value? Adulation? I first presented my idea of triangles right here at WC. It has resulted in a useful magazine article, and I was invited to present the idea at national level by the AAW....Maybe you can explain to me what is wrong with that? I have put my ideas out there for the world to see... For every negative comment I have received, there have been hundreds of positive ones...I believe that is called success.

I will say this one more time..if you feel the method is useful, use it. If not, don't use it.


img

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#38

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bob. in a nutshell...

Keith Tompkins

>Td, that comment is not appropriate.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#39

sit on it :)

TDaniel

>

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#40

Re: I have followed this thread ...

Bob Fawcett

>Thanks everyone.

This has been an interesting discussion.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#41

Re: Absolutely

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

I'd like to end this specific conversation, as I think we are speaking past each other. It is apparent to me that you and I process information and respond to it very differently. As a result, the conclusions we draw or the arguments we marshall to support conclusions are also different--we might as well be speaking different languages.

If we continue on this, it will only become acrimonious. And that would be unfortunate, as it might preclude our talking at some time about your Rose and the precursor to it (for which you won the Niche Award), and that would certainly be my loss.

So, on this very important day in history, let us honor the old American tradition of amicably agreeing to disagree.

I hope that you and your family have a good 4th.

Dinyar

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#42

Keith Tompkins

Re: Absolutely

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Dinyar, It's ok to disagree....we can still be friends, and I'd be glad to discuss things with you any time. Happy 4th to you and your family as well, Keith