Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Dinyar...new thread

Posts

Dinyar...new thread

#1

Keith Tompkins

Dinyar...new thread

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Dinyar. I modified your pic to explain my ideas more clearly. Yes, a triangle can be drawn around just about any shape if you make it big enough. However, as shown in your pics, the bowl doesn't fit WELL...if we imagine your triangle as WOOD, there would be a tremendous waste of material to arrive at your bowl.

In this modified pic, the bowl form you drew fits easily into a much smaller triangle, but the foot does NOT. Reducing the size of the foot to fit the triangle will result in a more pleasing overall form.

The second pic shows what shape may better fit into the triangle you drew; again the foot should fit within the triangle.

The triangle method can be used in two ways...to design a piece in advance, or to study existing forms to see if they fit well within the guidelines established by the triangle.


img

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Dinyar, second pic

Keith Tompkins

>In this pic, the shape I drew fits fairly well into your triangle, and the triangle serves as a guide for sizing the foot.

If I were to make a piece based on this drawing, the size of the triangle is also the size of the blank I would use.

Let me know if this clarifies things..Keith


img

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#3

Fitting triangles (Keith and Ken)

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

To some extent, your clarification helps---I think you're saying that one should try to draw triangles that "efficiently" encompass the design.

Ken, in my opinion, if a triangle is to fit a shape, that implies that it is tangential to the shape, i.e., the shape fits inside it---neither of the two diagrams you drew in the old thread fulfills this.

Keith, I remember watching/talking to John Jordan and to Bill Smith, both of whom talked about shaving a 1/16 of an inch here, and a 32nd there, i.e., very small changes having a huge impact on design. While your modified example helps, I can still draw a variety of "efficient" triangles that fit a shape, which would lead to different designs. While this would eliminate awful shapes, I'm still have a hard time visualizing how it leads to a good design. For example, below is the first example you gave, with the foot drawn in blue---obviously pleasing.


img

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#4

Re: Fitting triangles (Keith and Ken) continued

Dinyar Chavda

>Now, here is the same bowl with a slightly different triangle in red, which is probably just as efficient in terms of area as your one (in black), and yet it leads to a foot (in red) which is clunky.

This might be one of those things that I have to experience in person for it to synchronize the two (constantly shrinking!) parts of my brain. :-)


img

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#5

Re: Fitting triangles (Keith and Ken) continued *LINK*

Mark Wollschlager

>sorry for butting in, but your clunky red foot reminded me of some other work. I mentally drew triagles on the images and they seem to work out.

They are pieces from Bob Stocksdale in the Mason collection.

mark.


Link to images

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#6

Re: Fitting triangles (Keith and Ken) continued

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Dinyar, I don't know where it is said that a form HAS to fit INSIDE a triangle. You ought to feel free to exercise your artistic license and cross the line a little either way. With that in mind, your second example in this posting I would find useful in designing a pedestal bowl, and you wouldn't necessarily have to make the foot rectangular. The rectangle can be a guideline for a more pleasing curve. It could be a Golden Rectangle.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#7

Re: Fitting triangles (Keith and Ken) continued

Dinyar Chavda

>Ken:

If the form does not fit inside the triangle, then I am TOTALLY at a loss as to what the triangle has to do with the shape.

While, as you suggest, one can certainly break rules, (and some of my posts on WoW tried to discuss how to do that successfully), I think that initially, one should state a rule as precisely as possible, as is the case, for example, with the rule of thirds in photography, or the rule of the Golden Mean. Once you understand the rule, then you can exercise artistic licence and break it.

In fact, look at those two rules, and see how precisely and succinctly they can be stated. There is no ambiguity in the rules, although they can be applied to different parts of the object, AND, you can choose to consciously violate them.

I am not saying that the Triangle rule is wrong, or not useful---that is not my intention at all--in fact, it seems intuitively appealing. What I am saying is that, based on what I have read, there is a level of ambiguity in it, which, in my opinion, needs to be reduced. Maybe, it is to say that the most classically pleasing shape occurs when the ratio of the height of the triangle to the base results in the Golden Mean, or vice-versa. I don't know what it is, but I would encourage Keith to play with it, and see what he can come up with.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#8

Rules? who needs stinkin' rules!

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>*sigh*

Of course there's ambiguity,because we're not talking about RULES here (in my opinion).

:-))

The Golden Rectangle, Golden Triangle, and the newly dubbed Tompkins Triangles are merely ARTISTIC GUIDELINES.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#9

Re: Rules? who needs stinkin' rules!

Dinyar Chavda

>Call them rules or call them guidelines--they still need to be defined if meaningful discussion is to take place. ;-) '-)

Seriously, the number phi is almost more than a rule. It is a natural law, in that appears again and again in nature, which is probably why it forms the basis of what we have subconsciously learned to recognize as pleasing. See evolutionoftruth.com/div/nature.htm and www.mcs.surrey.ac.uk/Personal/ R.Knott/Fibonacci/fibnat.html for examples.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#10

I don't get it.....

TDaniel

>I have watched this entire thread as well as when it ran a few months ago and I still don't get it. I can draw a triangle to fit any bowl, so what am I missing?

TD

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Fitting triangles (Keith and Ken) continued

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Dinyar, the first image didn't load completely , but in your second image, the red foot appears too big. That is because the form no longer fits the triangle as well as it did the first one I drew.

Now, try this.....tape your image to the wall, then holding a length of chain in each hand, hold the chain over the triangle until it fills the triangle as best as you can. You can even tape it in place. It help people visualize shapes and forms. During my demos, this is exactly what I did. My triangle method and the catenary method work perfectly together. (!)

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Rules? who needs stinkin' rules!

Keith Tompkins

>I look at all of these as learning and teaching tools. I don't want to preach a bunch of absolutes; turning is supposed to be fun, after all. If we color outside the lines, it's ok.

A music analogy....musicians practice scales day after day, for hours on end. They don't play wrong notes (on purpose, anyway)or vary from the scales. Even jazz musicians practice scales. They practice until the scales are permanently etched into their mind. Scale patterns over scale patterns, switching seamlessly from one key to another...in any position on the instrument.

When it comes time to perform, throw the scales away...and PLAY from your heart. I look at turning the same way, practice, practice practice. Then,when you decide to produce a finished piece , the same thing applies. The form develops almost by itself. At that point rectangles or triangles are irrelevant, and you are turning from your heart.

I once asked my guitar teacher for the chords to a song I wanted to play. Bad mistake! "Learn to play your instrument...then you can play ANY SONG YOU WANT." I look at turning that way as well.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#13

Re: Fitting triangles (Keith and Ken) continued

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

I have reproduced the two pictures below, as you say the first did not load.

The first picture is the triangle you had drawn, and I just added a foot in blue. Obviously a pleasing form.

The 2nd picture consists of an alternative triangle drawn in dotted red in addition to your triangle in solid black. If I use the dotted red triangle, I can get the red foot which fits this triangle as well as the blue foot in the first picture fit your triangle. Obviously not as pleasing.

What it boils down to is this (just staying within the triangles, and not getting into the chains):

What do you mean by fitting a triangle? What makes one fit better than another? As I see it, the red triangle fits the form with the red foot in the 2nd picture as well as the the black triangle fits the blue foot in the first.

What determines which is the better triangle to use, or, alternatively, what makes a triangle "bad to use"?

And, with deference to Ken, let's call these "guidelines", or even, "possible suggestions"! :-)


img

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#14

Re: Rules? who needs stinkin' rules!

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

You said: I don't want to preach a bunch of absolutes; turning is supposed to be fun, after all. If we color outside the lines, it's ok.

I'm just trying to understand what those lines are in your triangle method. My approach is that in any area, "rules" are there for a reason, and you need to understand them; then you can decide whether or not you want to follow them. To take your musical analogy, good composition does follow rules, and great composition deliberately breaks some of the rules to create excitement, tension, etc.. But, until you understand the rules, all you get is noise (which is also fine, if that's what you want).

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#15

Re: Rules? who needs stinkin' rules!

Bruce Wiseman

>Well my every instinct tells me to stay out of this discussion, but when have I ever listened to instinct.

To use your musical scales example, notes are pleasing to our ear because they have a certain ratio between them. The difference between a major and a minor chord are experienced in the listener. I think the triangle confussion exists because there are so many triangles that fit but it seems that some of them must be sour notes. Any figure that fits well in any triangle will be symetrical and somewhat pleasing. If the generated triangle has a vortex angle of 36 degrees and two equal lengths (isosceles) it will be a golden triangle and the chances of the figure being pleasing to the eye go up. I think we are just looking for a little more understanding of the triangle use and some basic ideas of rules for forming them.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: I don't get it.....

Keith Tompkins

>Terry, the concept is to draw the triangle in advance of turning the piece. Why?

I teach at a well-known school, six students at a time. They come to the school to become better turners. Like your students, most of them have fairly well developed turning skills. Many turners in my sessions had very, very good turning abilities. Their technical shortcomings are easy to remedy, they just watch you, the teacher, and mimic what you do. However, where they fall short is their conceptual or design skills. Most cannot draw a simple bowl or hollow form, and at first, will not even attempt to do so. They believe they cannot draw. Many have never studied design at all; most woodworkers work from plans which include cut sheets.

I cannot, and refuse, to tell a student "put this piece on the lathe, and see what happens." They will usually turn something familiar to them, repeating the same tired form, time after time.As far as I'm concerned, that's a very frustrating way to learn. After all, that technique isn't working , otherwise, they wouldn't need to pay me for help. It shouldn't take years of turning poor forms to begin turning good forms....yet, that's what happens time after time.

So, I give the students guidelines. that is where the triangles come from...they work on almost any shape, the foot size is almost pre-determined, and it's easy to draw a nice form within the triangle..anybody can do it. Before they turn a thing!

In my design class, I won't allow anyone to start a project without a drawing or design. Once a good design is formulated, they can begin turning. And they MUST turn the design they sketched. If they believe their design is the best they can do, then that's what they'll turn. Do all the students enjoy working this way! No, no they do not. Too bad. Sometimes I hear some grumbling "This is not the way Richard Raffan shows how to turn!" Oh well.

However, I can tell you, at the end of the course, almost all the students have told me..." I never thought I could turn something as good as this! Wait til my (spouse) sees this!" I get emails and phone calls, and many students return for additional classes...so I know it is working. I have also been contacted by several other instructors asking for permission to use the triangle method in their classes as well.

I think it works well as a critique tool as well. In Dinyar's image, the intentionally poor shape he drew did not fill the triangle well at all, especially the large foot. Hopefully, my triangles are like training wheels on a bike..eventually, they are no longer needed.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#17

Neither do I.....

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I can draw any number of un-pleasing bowls that fit inside any triangle. (Actually, the set of curves is a second-order infinity, but I don't have all day to spend on this.)

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Neither do I.....

Keith Tompkins

>Brian, If you want to spend all day drawing intentionally unpleasant forms within a triangle, knock yourself out. You are missing the point. All I can say is, if the method works for you, fine. If not , that's fine too. There is more than one way to skin a cat.

I don't have all day to spend on this either.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#19

Training the eye

TDaniel

>Keith, anyone who teaches turning has a method for teaching the student to recognize pleasing shapes. The best guide I have found was an old pottery book. That book explained the rule of thirds and how the thirds rule was discovered. The key to good design in my opinion is proportions, not angles. Your triangle method might be of use in determining the size or height of a foot but what if you don't use a foot? I do not mean to pick on you here but I just can't see a triangle being of any help unless you give some angles for the triangle in which case you are back to the thirds rule. I also use a triangle to teach form; mine is a horizontal line 12" long with a parallel line 4" long and 4" below the first line, both centered. The ends of the lines are connected, forming a cut off triangle. Pretty much any shape that can be put into this triangle will work. This is the "thirds rule". The sides of this triangle will be defined as about 40 degrees from the base.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#20

Re: Fitting triangles (Keith and Ken) continued

john lucas

>Dinyar My friend Brenda Stien make a natural edge bowl similar to your bottom drawing except the foot tapers in. The foot is very long in some cases and her pieces are beautiful. It acts as a sort of pedestal and really accentuates the shape of the bottom of the bowl.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#21

Re: Training the eye

John Lucas

>Terry Many of my students can't draw or see the shapes. I show them glass and ceramic books which helps but I think using triangles, the rule of thirds and golden rectangles or anything else that helps them visulize and then sketch thier pieces will eventually make them a better turner. I see too many straight sided pieces and drawing inside a triangle might help them open up the shape to a more pleasing form.

Don't know who said it but there are no rules only ideas. Rules and formulas are really only meant to make it easier to talk about the forms and how they work together. ONe thing I like about sketching using rectangles, triangle and circles is that you become aware of the negative spaces created by the shapes. These often need to be pointed out because most people don't see them.

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#22

John, Terry, Brian, Bruce--a final explanation

Dinyar Chavda

>John:

Let me try one last attempt to state the difficulty I'm having applying the triangle method.

The way I see it, all these guidelines (rule of thirds, Golden Mean, etc.) are such that if you follow them, you should be very likely to get a harmonious form---at least, more often than not.

I'll summarize an exchange I had had with Michael Kane about the rule of thirds in your area of photography (ignore the cast in the pictures below). I'm always looking to break rules (probably what enabled me to get to the States in the first place!), and I thought that the first picture that I had taken was a pretty successful violation of the rule of thirds, in that the horizon line is almost in the middle of the picture. Michael sent back the 2nd picture, where he had cropped the top off my picture. I have to admit that it is a much better picture, in that it draws your eye into it. The rule of thirds--simple, and effective.

But, there can still be exceptions, like in the third picture, where the water in the cave is in the middle, and we both agreed that it seems to work better than if it were to follow the rule.

The problem I am having with the Triangle guideline is that with almost any triangle, I can draw a shape that is not pleasing, and the method does not tell me how to improve--in fact, altho' I don't know the math to prove it, I think that Brian Hahn is correct when he says that he "can draw any number of un-pleasing bowls that fit inside any triangle".

Your example where your friend creates a pleasing elongated foot similar to my earlier drawing is, in all likelihood, an application of the rule of thirds, in terms of the width of the foot to the base of the bowl. I'd suspect that it does fit into a triangle like the one that Terry Daniel describes, but his triangle has very specific proportions, and isn't just any triangle. I think that Terry's cut-off triangle with its exact proportions is probably similar to the triangle described by Bruce Wiseman.

So, it's not that one cannot draw a pleasing shape within any triangle. Rather it's that, with most triangles, unless the triangle is specifically defined, or you put additional restrictions on the shapes, or you use aditional devices like a chain, I can draw a lot more displeasing shapes than harmonious shapes. Which is why I still don't get the guideline, or see how it improves on the other methods.

And now, despite the fact that it is morning, I'll end my part in this thread with Murrow's, "Goodnight, and good luck." :-)


img

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#23

Absolutely

TDaniel

>Read Dinyar's latest post. There is no argument that anything that helps a person to see good shapes is worth pursuing. Dinyar's question is/was "is the angle of the triangle important or can any triangle be used?" He is asking a sound and basic question. Without some definition of the side angles of the triangle you can put any bowl into a triangle. Dinyar is absolutely correct when he asks for something relative concerning the side angles. As proof try this: Draw a triangle with sides of 80 degrees. Put a bowl in it. Does it work?

TD

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#24

Correct Brian

TDaniel

>unless the sides of the triangle are defined there is no magic triangle for getting a good shape. Good shapes will most often (not always) fit into a triangle with 37 to 43 degree sides. All this is merely re-stating the rule of thirds. There is nothing new under the sun.

TD

Re: Dinyar...new thread

#25

Re: John, Terry, Brian, Bruce--a final explanation

John Lucas

>Dinyar I see your point about the triangles. In Keiths handout the triangles are derived from other geometric forms such as Golden rectangle or pentagons etc. These have definite shapes. You can still draw an ugly bowl or vessel in them but it does restrict your shapes and I think forces you to look at graduating shapes. Apply the rule of thirds to the shape inside the triangle and you stand a better chance of getting something decent. still not perfect but it does get students to thinking about some of the guidlines (not necessarily rules)

We have left out a ton of other useful tools when talking about design such as Line, contrast, negative spaces, symmetry, points of interest etc. The 3rd photo is a good example of symmetry (sp too lazy to look it up today) Sometimes things look better dead center or close to it because there will be more balance to the piece.