John, Terry, Brian, Bruce--a final explanation
Dinyar Chavda
>John:
Let me try one last attempt to state the difficulty I'm having applying the triangle method.
The way I see it, all these guidelines (rule of thirds, Golden Mean, etc.) are such that if you follow them, you should be very likely to get a harmonious form---at least, more often than not.
I'll summarize an exchange I had had with Michael Kane about the rule of thirds in your area of photography (ignore the cast in the pictures below). I'm always looking to break rules (probably what enabled me to get to the States in the first place!), and I thought that the first picture that I had taken was a pretty successful violation of the rule of thirds, in that the horizon line is almost in the middle of the picture. Michael sent back the 2nd picture, where he had cropped the top off my picture. I have to admit that it is a much better picture, in that it draws your eye into it. The rule of thirds--simple, and effective.
But, there can still be exceptions, like in the third picture, where the water in the cave is in the middle, and we both agreed that it seems to work better than if it were to follow the rule.
The problem I am having with the Triangle guideline is that with almost any triangle, I can draw a shape that is not pleasing, and the method does not tell me how to improve--in fact, altho' I don't know the math to prove it, I think that Brian Hahn is correct when he says that he "can draw any number of un-pleasing bowls that fit inside any triangle".
Your example where your friend creates a pleasing elongated foot similar to my earlier drawing is, in all likelihood, an application of the rule of thirds, in terms of the width of the foot to the base of the bowl. I'd suspect that it does fit into a triangle like the one that Terry Daniel describes, but his triangle has very specific proportions, and isn't just any triangle. I think that Terry's cut-off triangle with its exact proportions is probably similar to the triangle described by Bruce Wiseman.
So, it's not that one cannot draw a pleasing shape within any triangle. Rather it's that, with most triangles, unless the triangle is specifically defined, or you put additional restrictions on the shapes, or you use aditional devices like a chain, I can draw a lot more displeasing shapes than harmonious shapes. Which is why I still don't get the guideline, or see how it improves on the other methods.
And now, despite the fact that it is morning, I'll end my part in this thread with Murrow's, "Goodnight, and good luck." :-)
