Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

Posts

Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

#1

Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

Spence in Rhode Island

>Would anyone like to give me their opinions on the Jamieson and Kelton hollowing rigs? At the moment I'm leaning towards the Kelton setup mostly because I can use the boring bars I already have. Cost is another factor too. The laser set up on the Kelton appears to be more steady. Is the true?

TIA

Spence

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

#2

Suggest you read Lyn Mangiamelli's report...

David

>which I believe is available from Fred Holder's More Woodturning publication and website.

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

#3

Re: Suggest you read Lyn Mangiamelli's report...

Kevin Gerstenecker

>I use the Kelton setup, mostly because I already had the Stinger/Scorpion setup and the bars can be (and are) used with the Kelton. I really like the laser rig on the Kelton system too. It IS very stable, and easy to setup and adjust. The entire system is very impressive to me, and I really like it.

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

#4

Re: Suggest you read Lyn Mangiamelli's report...

Paul Hammer

>Hello,

I have the Jamieson setup. It has is pros and cons. Yes the laser set up is a little light weight. If u r boring in a hard wood or deep is will shake the laser. Sometimes the laser will flicker on and off. It also is hard to work in a hole much smaller then 2 inchs as the head piece is large. On the other hand is does give u many options with the adjustable head. I find it works beter on tall pieces then wide short 1s. I also have the bigger bar 4 mine. That works great 4 tall pieces. I would say it is a very safe setup. I have not tryed the other 1 so i cant compare. Hope this adds to ur info.

Happy turning

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

#5

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

robo hippy

>I have the whole set of Kelton hollowing bars, and made a Jamieson style handle for the bars. The Kelton bars will work in their bowl coring handles, but the Jamieson handle makes it a lot less work. I also got the Sorby hooker tool for the scraper tips. Now all I have to do is about 1,000 hollow forms to learn how to use the tools. I do have a home made laser pointer (wood dowels and hose clamps) which works fine.

robo hippy

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

#6

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

eliot

>I have experience with three hollowing rigs: the Kelton, the Spin Doctor and the Don Derry. I sent back the Kelton because it would hang up on me. If you look closely at the design, there's only a single point of contact where the triangular bar rides on the crossbar. So, oddly enough, that creates a hang up situation You want some flat area or at least two riding points like the Jamieson. I called Kelton, and they suggested I use cabinet sliding tape, which more or less worked, but I didn't like the idea that I needed it. Kelton was very good about it and refunded my money including shipping. I then bought the Spin Doctor (Keith Clark -- he really is a physician(ENT)). I've been cooperating with him for over a year now -- sort of his beta site. His rig is really massive, beautifully constructed, and will hollow deep vessels. He sells a massive , three axis, steady rest for it, too, with which you can really get big! Also his personal attention and support is amazing. But there are still a few kinks to be worked out, and if you're interested, you should talk to him and discuss it. My third rig is the (much smaller) Don Derry. It's amazingly light and easy to use -- without question the easiest to use that I have tried.His laser adjustment is absolutely perfect; there is no "lashback' when you position it. It stays put -- precisely where you point it. The others all creep when you tighten the wing nuts. But a "gallon" size is about all you can do. Don told me that he is working on a bigger model.

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

#7

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

Mark Wollschlager

>I also have the Don Derry rig and am very happy with it.

For smaller vessels ( around 10" ) it is very easy to use and as noted, the laser is steady and easily adjustable.

I also use Al Basham type forked tools for smaller turnings. Not laser but very simple.

mark.

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

#8

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

Ed Karch

>Im another satisfied Don Derry customer. It is very easy to dial in your wall thickness and easy to operate.

Re: Opinions wanted on hollowing rigs

#9

Lota food for thought here

Spence in Rhode Island

>Thanks guys for the help. At this point I'm still leaning towards the kelton. A little modifing to make it work better doesn't bother me too much. The spin doctor rig looks very interesting and I'll do some more research on it before I make a decision. 36" urns, anyone? LOL

Thanks again,

Spence