Re: You are right, Gary
Brent English - Robust Tools
>Ellis, as I stated in my email to you, my apologies. I never intended to violate your rules. Kindest regards, and thanks for your professionalism and consideration.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: You are right, Gary
Brent English - Robust Tools
>Ellis, as I stated in my email to you, my apologies. I never intended to violate your rules. Kindest regards, and thanks for your professionalism and consideration.
Re: I take offense.
Gary Evans Tallassee, TN
>Hi Ed,
Sorry if you thought I was whining. I was just trying to point out the guidelines that I had gotten from Ellis some time back. I knew that would be difficult without sounding like a case of sour grapes.
When dealing with the issue of how to determine whether a post is commercial or not, the intent of the poster seems to be the defining factor. In this case, Brent states pretty clearly that he wants to know whether he should change the design of his product. That seemed to me to be market research, which Ellis had indicated to me fell under the no commercial posting rules.
Personally, I had suggested creating a page where those in the woodturning business could post general questions of this nature. I don't think they could actually be construed as advertising, but could certainly be useful for tailoring our products to better serve the woodturning public. In fact direct advertising ought to be banned, just as it is on the other forums.
Again, I'm sorry for getting you stirred up.
Gary
Re: You are right, Gary
Rick Davenport
>Brent,
My opinion?
Much ado about nothing.
You should have posed your question under the name of Lefty MacDougal.
He's the famous one-handed turner who lost his right hand while trying to turn a 24" bowl on a 24" lathe.
If only he had a Robust lathe at the time.
But then he wouldn't be famous.
Rick
"Life shouldn't be dull."
Re: I take offense.
Craig Daymon
>I don't know Brent and I don't know Kevin and I have seen enough such messages to be suspicious when I do. I think that's what I said in my message. When I say it looked like, I was not saying I knew one way or the other his intentions, simply my perception of the post. It is an opinion and as such is reflective of how the post appeared to me.
I think if Brent wants to solicite such information he would be better off to simply post that Robust is looking for input on design considerations and direct folks to their site (the specific page where folks could enter such input, not the sales page or even the main page, although a link to the main from the survey page would certainly be acceptable).
-Craig
Not to worry!
Ed Moore
>Gary,
I'm just a tough old bird having some fun. For some reason I have a hard time singing the party line and I saw a chance to argue the opposite side -- and I took it. ;^D
Ed
Re: I built mine to swing 86" But,
Donna Banfield
>I have to agree with Keith's observations, with a couple of added issues. I have a Oneway 2436 with the outboard extension. Without a doubt, I love the lathe and all the toys that go with it.
However, I have turned a few large pieces, which required using the outboard. Keith is right - the market is very limited in larger sizes. I have no problem selling bowls up to 16" in diameter, but larger than that, I hear one or more of the following: where would I put it?...what would I use it for?...it really wouldn't go with my decor/furniture/you name it/(when it's a wall hanging)...
I turned a 26" bark-on natural edge black walnut crotch bowl, that had many admirerers, (sp?) but no buyers because of the size. I had it priced very reasonably considering I had over 100 hours of time (it had a bark inclusion which I packed over a 6 month period as it dried - and I know I can't really charge for my time on a piece like that). It finally sold at a show over the Memorial Day weekend, but that was after hauling it to 6 previous shows.
People who are excited about large lathes with a large swing capacity forget, or are unaware, of the other problems: where do you find turning stock that large? And if you find it, how can you get it home? Do you have a wench or lift on your truck? Do you have a truck? Do you have a saw large enough to handle that mass? How do you get it attached to your lathe? Block and tackle? Engine hoist? 3-4 large burly friends (hopefully they're guys ;^). When you solve all those problems, do you have a market for the piece? Or are you hoping for the turning gods to smile on you and it sells at the first showing/week in the gallery.
Like Russ said, talk is cheap, but until you have answers for all those questions, or contingency plans, large swing capacity is a lot of money.
Glad to hear it, Ed.
Gary Evans Tallassee, TN
>I was afraid I might have to be looking over my shoulder at the various symposiums for somebody sneaking up behind me with a big piece of wood. 8^]
Gary
Men vs Women
Ed Moore
>Gary,
Men who have played athletics learn to "leave it on the pitch" (World Cup vernacular)and forget about it once the game is over.
Women who did not have similar athletic experiences may well carry a grudge to the grave. Now it's women who have told me this, it's not just me picking on women. I've watched a situation in woodturning and there's a woman carrying a grudge against someone and at every opportunity I see evidence of "the burn" as little barbs emanate.
I cracked up about your concern of being bopped on the head because I just may be carrying around a 1/4" round skew at Louisville that I hope to give to someone if I see them. ;^D
In light of my academic background I offer a quote that I have mentioned before: "Academic arguments are so heated because the stakes are so small." 'Tis true, 'tis true.
Ed
I agree
TDaniel
>and I think One-way recognized this too which is why they came out with the 1640. Probably 80% of work being sold can be made on a 1640. I have turned several 30" plus bowls and they are a lot of work, they take up a lot of space while drying and since they are rough turned to 10% of the diameter that means a lot longer to dry, and as you said, they get a lot of attention but they don't sell quickly. The market is pretty much commercial but I did sell one that was going to be made into a coffee table. All the support equipment you mentioned is necessary and it doesn't get used often.....and it has to be stored until you need it. The one thing that a really big piece will do for you though is bring people into your booth. They may not buy the big one but chances are they will buy something else while in your booth. A 36" bowl will not fit into any vehicle except an SUV or pick-up so getting it to shows can be a problem too.