Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

Posts

Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#1

Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

Brent English - Robust Tools

>Hi: Need your help. Before I designed the Robust lathe, I surveyed almost 200 woodturners. One of the things many of them said is that they wished they had bought a lathe that was just a little bit bigger than the one they had. With that in mind, I made the big Robust lathe a 25" swing machine instead of the normal 24" swing that many other manufacturers offer. Now that we've been in business for a year, I have heard a couple of turners express concern about the perception that accessories designed for a 24" machine won't work (bowl savers, steady rests, etc.) Even though they will, or can be quickly made to work, it is still an obstacle to sale.

So my question to you all is: Should I continue to offer the big Robust lathe as a 25" machine or convert to a 24" and why do you thinks so?

Thanks in advance for your input, if you want individual replies, please feel free to email me at brent@turnrobust.com, otherwise, I'll just set back and read your comments - Thanks again.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#2

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

Gary Ljostad

>Brent, it seems that the industry has settled on 12",16", 20", and 24" as industry standards for swing over bed. Unless you are willing to make adaptors for the many after market accs. it seems to make sense to keep to these sizes. It would be a hassle to have to always make or search for adaptors for the many additional tools and jigs for my lathe. Just my $.02.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#3

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

Bob Fawcett

>I agree with Gary.

I have a hard time imagining a situation where 1 more inch matters on a 24" lathe.

I bet your survey respondants were people who bought a 16 and wished for one more inch, not a 24 and wished for 25.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#4

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

Russ Fairfield

>Lathes are like boats and other things in life. No matter what we have, there are times that we wish it were bigger. I would guess that 1/2 of those people who have a 16" lathe wish it were 20", and I know that there are times when everyone with a 24" lathe wishes that it were 30". Oneway solved this problem through attachments that provide a larger swing on the outboard side, while Powermatic and Jet opted for a sliding headstock so we can work off the end of the lathe with a tool rest on a floor-stand.

Talk is always cheap. Whether any of us are willing to pay the price for a larger swing, or whether we wwould use it if we had it will always be the unanswered questions. I would think the better business choice would be to pick the lathe dimension that sells the best, and send those who want to practice wishful thinking about bigger lathes to the VB-36 dealer. The alternative is to start designing a custom bowl lathe and see if there is a market for it. Personally, I would be more interested in the bowl lathe alternative than I would be in another conventional bed lathe with a bigger swing.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#5

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

TDaniel

>I think what people want is more basic than 25" vs 24". We want banjos that stay where you lock them and toolrests that don't spin when you take a heavy cut, a tailstock that locks firmly, smooth machined morse tapers that give max surface area to the bit, plenty of adjustment capability in the toolrest height, strong metal handles instead of plastic, etc. Many lathes are built to be spindle lathes and bowlturning is more of an afterthought. Most of us do far more bowlturning or hollow-form turning than spindle turning so we would like to have a lathe that does not restrict us too much. Bowlturners put far more pressure on a toolrest than spindle turners. Also the trend is a lower handle position when shaping the outside of a bowl which means we need the toolrest to go lower than many on the market. To answer your question though, I have never had any need to go 25" instead of 24" although I have had a need to go 36" a few times.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#6

I was typing at the same time as Russ

TDaniel

>I agree Russ. You typed quicker than I did but we both said the same thing, more or less. We want a lathe built for bowls and hollow-forms primarily but with the ability to mount a piece between centers when that is needed. Very few vessels above 20" diameter will sell.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#7

Mine is 26"!

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>My Vega is 26"! I guess that means I don't qualify, right? ;-) Most accessories are things like chucks, faceplates, live centers, etc that fit into or onto the spindles. Tool rests can be had from many sources in custom sizes. My two big lathes need 30mm and 1 1/4" for the post, and while I can't go to a lot of the big catalog places, there are plenty of people doing quality work from whom to choose. I chose Randy Privett at monster-wood-tool.com for that, and he takes very good care of my needs.

About the only thing I can think of off the top of my head (and there is not much left there) that is specific to swing is a steady rest, or perhaps the captured part of a hollowing rig. Is there something I am missing?

Bill

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#8

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

Jim Swank

>Brent - As the new kid on the block, you'll have a bit of a tough go for a while in any case. Your lathe looks darn good, but it's not priced that far below Oneway, which has become the de facto standard for many. If the lathe and banjo will accommodate tool rests, etc, for the Oneway, you should say so. Ditto for your spindle accomodating chucks, etc. You should also consider an adaptor block to fit your ways to the Oneway coring knives, steady rest, etc. You might consult an attorney before actually using the Oneway name in your advertising though.

One specific area I hope you will address in the near future is outboard turning, for truly larger capacity. You need to sell an attachment for that.

As for actual swing dimensions, I don't see 25" vs 24 to be worth the possible trouble of compatibility questions. Now if you went up to 30 inches swing....

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#9

Steven Antonucci

So what did you learn?

steve antonucci

>Never ask for a comittee to make a decision...

But more to your point, I don't see any reason that extra inch will work against you (or for you for that matter...) Most people will argue that bigger is better, but how many people really use "bigger" on a regular basis?

I've turned (successfully) a 22" bowl on my 16" Nova, which was a one time effort. As long as people perceive that they can do big things on your lathe, you will find your market.

My next lathe needs to be rock solid, vibration free, variable speed, and should allow me get a comfortable stance for cutting inside a bowl or hollowform- sliding/swiveling headstock or whatever means necessary. It should have enough motor to "max out" the swing if I feel like it without affecting the cut. It should come apart into manageable sections so I can move it.

Keep your focus on quality over size and you'll deliver a high end machine.

Steve

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#10

Re: Mine is 26"!

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>My Nichols bowl lathe is 26 inches. I have and use a Oneway steady rest. Fortunately, they made the post long enough to just work with a 26 inch swing.

Wally

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#11

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

john lucas

>It obviously becomes a marketing question. Everyone says they want a bigger lathe but the vast majority of turnings out there are quite small 12" or less. I remember one guy saying he was amazed at how small all the turnings were in the instant gallery at the AAW symposium. I guess that's because there isn't any real size judgements on the internet. I think 24 vs 25 is like buying a boat with 5 more horsepower. You'll probably never notice you have it but when comparing apples to apples at the time of purchadse this one had one more inch so than that one so I bought it. In your case there are many other selling points for your lathe so I don't think 1 inch would make that much difference. The top selling lathe right now is the Oneway for 2 really big reasons, quality and service, not necessarily size (they sell a 10, 12, and 16). Prove to people that you build a quality lathe, can get it to them quickly with no shipping damage, and that you offer top of the line service if anything does go wrong and they will beat thier way to your door.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#12

No offense, but...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>A number of years back I asked Ellis about using the turning forum to do market research for my wood turning business. I understood his position that this violated the no commercial posting rules and didn't push the issue.

How is it that this post is acceptable under those guidelines? Don't get me wrong, if it's O.K. to make this kind of post, then I have some questions regarding dimensioning, species, etc. that I would like to ask for the benefit of my business.

Gary

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#13

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

Ed Moore

>Brent,

I have made no secret of my interest in the large Robust lathe. It makes absolutely no difference to me if the swing is 24" or 25".

And since I read a later post in this thread, because you provide the main object we all use, I think this is exactly the place that this discussion should take place.

See you in Louisville!

Ed

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#14

Re: No offense, but...

Jim Swank

>I'll defer to Ellis on what is allowed and what is not. If my opinion were sought, a legitimate inquiry like this is both welcome and refreshing. I'd also have no quarrel with questions about dimensioning and species of lumber either, provided it was unique or directed at a particular audience known to frequent this board.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#15

Brad Vietje

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

Brad Vietje

>Brent,

Seems the only real difference is that one can actually turn a 24" diameter between centers on a 25" lathe, but not really on a 24" lathe, as it would scrape the ways, and would have to be sawn perfectly round (and mounted perfectly on-center).

Besides that, 24 or 25 is no real difference. I agree with the clan that well made, rock steady, and reliable is more important than a secific size, and that a bowl lathe with a tailstock assembly (removable) is what a lot of turners really want. Originally I planned to have a dedicated bowl lathe, and another lathe for larger spindle work, but finances dictated that I try to get both functions from a single machine. I went for the 3520-B as a machine that can function as a bowl lathe for bowls and hollow forms (turner standing in front of the piece), but still be extended for larger spindles. Oneway's solution is a selection of very well made but pretty darned expensive accessories for outboard turning -- I just couldn't swing the extra $2500 or so to get both functions from a Oneway product.

Now a 24" - 25" Robust Bowl Lathe might be a great new offering...

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#16

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

George Van in WI

>Brent, I would leave it like it is. When I turned on Phil�s I liked it very much. We used the McNaughton bowl saver without a problem. The advantage to the extra inch is it lets me be a little lazy when cutting blanks with the chainsaw and adds a little more clearance above the banjo when coring which helps offset the torque of the knife.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#17

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

Phil Powell

>Brent, What George said, "Don't change a thing". I really enjoy working my lathe. I've used

the OneWay coring system and the the McNaugton on my 25" Robust and had no problems

with either tool. The 25' designation sets your lathe apart from 90% of all the lathes on the

market. During the time I've owned and worked with my lathe I've never been heard saying

I wish the lathe swing was shorter.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#18

Ellis Walentine

You are right, Gary

Ellis Walentine

>I sent Brent a nice note explaining our non-commercial policy. WoodCentral, as you know, relies on advertisers to help foot the bill to keep us strong and growing. I'm glad Brent was able to get a lot of good information from the group, but posts of this type are not allowed.

Maybe Brent will decide to join the ranks of our paying advertisers. :-)

Thanks,

Ellis

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#19

I take offense.

Ed Moore

>I understand that the interests of the advertisers must be protected. That's just common sense. How is any advertiser affected negatively by answering the basic question: "Does it matter whether a lathe has a 24" or 25" swing?"?

There are constantly remarks here like "I prefer Sorby gouges and Crown scrapers." Do these people get censored? Certainly other toolmakers are negatively affected by such remarks if someone chooses to buy one of the aforementioned tools due to that sort of endorsement. People are always recommending finishing products, and that certainly violates the "no advertising" clause.

I think a double standard has been applied, and that offends me. Be consistent. This is a great forum and I would hate to see whining destroy it.

Ed

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#20

Re: I take offense.

Russ Fairfield

>No double standard at all. There is a difference is in why the question was asked. One is a consumer, with no commercial interest in the product, asking for an opinion on the product. The other is a manufacturer asking for information that can be used to gain a competitive advantage over their competition or to promote that product among the readers.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#21

Re: I take offense.

Ed Moore

>In other words if you asked the question instead of Brent asking it, that's fine? So, as a manufacturer he gives up the right to ask questions? It's not like he asked for ten reasons why a Robust lathe is better than ..., which would be over the top a little.

Every time someone posts a gloat and a picture of their new lathe are they violating the standard of fair play? Many of us participated in a thread about Stihl chainsaws recently. It wasn't started by a Stihl dealer, so that's fine. Sorry, but there IS a double standard here.

As a former academic, I guess I see it as "A question is a question is a question." And if it's a question, then it needs an answer more than it's motive needs an analysis.

Ed

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#22

I see your point Ed

TDaniel

>There is always an area of gray in any attempt to set standards or limits. I assure you that I never feel that I must endorse those companies that advertise here. I feel that honesty is the best policy and I always recommend products that I have had good luck with. If a company asks a legitimate question of our body with the intent to make their product more suitable to our needs then I personally welcome that; sometimes though it is obvious that they are only trying to keep their name in front of us at no cost. Just keep in mind that if everyone was allowed to post frequent free ads then there would be no incentive for any company to pay for ad space.

This site could not exist for us without financial support.

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#23

Re: I take offense.

Craig Daymon

>I disagree. I don't think it is a double standard. I also was very suspicious about this original post because I thought it was just a misleading post to draw attention to the Robust lathes. Even if it wasn't and was perfectly innocent, such postings are a frequent and common tool of manufacturers. Personally, I think it makes very little difference whether the lathe has a 24" or 25" swing. VERY few accessories are going to be so dependent and wood is such a natural variable in what size you are going to get that 24 vs. 25 doesn't make a difference. Because of the trivial value of the feature I am suspicious of the intention of the original post.

-Craig

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#24

Re: I take offense.

Ed Moore

>Craig,

I think that impugning the motives of Brent English is walking on thin ice at best and assuming that you know his mindset is possibly poor judgement. If Kevin Clay from Oneway wrote and asked if they should offer Oneway lathes with 1 1/4 x 8 spindles would you accuse him of trying to keep Oneway's name before us? People would be tripping over themselves to kiss his ring and no one would accuse him of anything. Double standard.

The basic question was "Does it matter if the swing is 24" or 25"?" EVERY lathe manufacturer benefits from knowing the answer to that question and it promotes no particular lathe. If every answer was "I won't buy a lathe with less that 25" swing" then you can bet that other manufacturers would sit up and take notice.

Ed

Re: Survey: 24" vs. 25" swing lathes

#25

I built mine to swing 86" But,

Keith Newton

>I have not found much of a market for large turnings.

Almost anyone can find a place for something under 12" on a shelf in their personal space, but when you get on up in size, you are expecting them to work it in like furniture or sculpture, and the market is much more limited.