Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

Posts

Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#1

Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

Raymond in Trenton, NJ

>Hi all,

I have a novice question on the length of the drying stage in green turnings. My question is not "How soon can I turn" which has been answered in the archives six ways from Thursday. I'm trying to find out "How long can I wait". Is there a limit?

The plan is to rough turn, seal and place in a closed paper bag with shavings. (marking date, species, color of socks, etc) A friend gave me some fresh cut holly and walnut. They are about ~12 in diameter and 20 " long. I sealed the ends as soon as I got them.

My problem is I don't have a lathe (yet). I have a short term ability to use a lathes and will try rough turning some bowls while that's available. After that, they'll likely sit for a good, long while :o)

Thanks for your indulgence,

Raymond

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#2

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

Gary R

>Do a search in the archives. The "alcohol" soak method seems to be very reliable. Quick version:

-- Pail with good lid, and a few gallons of Denatured Alcohol from Big Box store

-- Rough turn bowl

-- Soak in alcohol overnight

-- Remove and let sit on drying rack for 30 min

-- Wrap backside of bowl with brown paper bag, using masking tape to secure

-- Store upside (unwrapped side) facing down

-- After two weeks, bowls a re ready to turn, or store, and have very little moisture content.

This is my quick interpretation from reading posts - anyone with more experience, feel free to add.

Downside to paperbag method is "more" cracking than alcohol method, and the need to place in fresh bags every few days.

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#3

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

adrien

>You are "seal"ing the turnings--with anchorseal? If so, you don't need the paper bags...

Weigh the item after turning it. When it stops losing weight, it is dry. This will range, depending on the wood, humidity, etc. from 3 to 9 months. the book says a year per inch of thickness, but that is too conservative.

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#4

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

GaryG in MD

>Raymond,

The simple answer is "when they're dry, they're dry". You should be able to keep them for years with no problem.

A more complete answer would mention that the environmental conditions in which you store the blanks are important, as well as how you process them prior to storage. You may want to read in the Archives about the use of alcohol and boiling as venues for increasing the drying speed and perhaps retarding cracking. Many of us will just put on a coat of a wax sealer or shellac over the end grain or the entire object before bagging (and not everyone uses bags).

While the blanks are in early stages of drying in a brown paper bag, you should check them weekly for mold. I use a little alcohol wipe to surpress any mold that forms. (See the Archives about the holly -- mold will quickly ruin the nice white color.) If you weigh them periodically, you will know when they are "dry" -- they will stop losing weight.

They should be stored out of the sun, in a relatively limited temperature range, and importantly, in a limited moisture (humidity) range. In your context, "dry" means "equilibrium moisture content". That varies with the storage conditions. They should be kept above freezing (a freeze/thaw cycle would wreck some because they're not really bone-dry). Since you're in a four-season climate, your relative humidity will vary from very low in the winter (indoors) to very high in the summer (w/o a/c). This variation can cause some pieces of wood to crack even after you think they're stable. So don't store them in the furnace room!

I generally leave rough outs in brown paper bags even after they're "dry" to try to limit the speed of temperature and humidity variations. It's a case of the differentials being more important than the absolute values. It's not necessary for all pieces, but you don't know which ones will crack, a priori, and it beats losing one of you favorites unexpectedly.

Have fun with that holly and walnut. (You may want to use a mask and gloves with the walnut -- many people are or become allergic to the dust -- see Archives.)

...Gary

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#5

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

don in central illinois

>I've had good luck boiling the rough turned bowls. I boil for about and hour per inch of thickness (3/4" gets 45 minutes, etc.) I loosly wrap them in a towel for a day or two, wrap in old newpapers and tape it shut. Write the information on the paper and let them sit. You can usually turn after about 90 days, but I don't know any reason they wouldn't stay indefinitly. Just my $.02 worth.

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

Brad Vietje

>Hello Raymond,

If I understand your question, you don't want to know how long you will HAVE to wait, but if there is such a thing as too long. Answer is no. In fact some people, including real famous sorts like Richard Raffan, say the longer the better -- as in wood from very old buildings that's hundreds of years old.

The oldest piece of wood I've turned was a chunk of a 2-1/2" thick American Chestnut sub-floor plank from a house built in Southern Connecticut in about 1756. Pretty cool plank, too -- probably hand cut with a pit saw (now there's a job where being on top is key !) or some sort of reciprocating saw. It turned fine, though it's the only bowl I've ever made from old-growth Am. Chestnut. From ring counts, and other visual evidence, I'd say the wood I was turning was actually laid down by the growing tree in the late 1500's ! Bowl's nothing special to look at, but special to me (PIC).

On your rough-turning plan, you may be going a bit overboard, especially with the Walnut. Black Walnut is pretty stable stuff, and much less likely to crack than the Holly. If you wax it, you should be able to store it in a box, or in any cool place away from sun and wind, like the cellar floor or on the floor of the garage. You can either use a paper bag with some shavings, or the wax (Anchorseal or equivalent), but there's probably no need to do both. If you lock in the sap to that degree, you'll really have to keep an eye on it so it doesn't get all moldy and/or spalt beyond its useful stage.

BTW: Spalted wood is beautiful (well, most spalted wood -- Walnut is no prize when spalted in my book), but more difficult to turn with good results than sound wood (harder to get a real nice, smooth finish off the tools, and harder to sand, as well), so it's not a good way to go for your first few bowls.

Good luck, and congrats on the wood score...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


img

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#7

Not my bowl, Brad, but I think it's special...

david

>to look at. The shape is graceful and the rim adds a nice touch. Nice regular grain and great natural color. The history just adds to the piece.

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#8

Are you asking ... how long to leave in log form?

Randy Miller

>From reading your post more carefully, I get the feeling you are saying "I don't know if I'll even be able to rough turn these, how long can I leave them as slabs?"

The only answer to that question is, it depends on...

type of wood...

where on the tree did it begin life ...

how big ...

how much humidity is in the air ...

You get the point. There are no sure bets or quick answers on this one. A slab of apple will check if you breath on wrong ;-0 The only defense is to keep the slabs as long as possible so when they do check (and they will) you'll be able to cut off the ends when you're ready. Checking will start at the ends and work it's way in so a 6 foot slab will yield more than three two foot slabs.

Hope I'm reading this right.... maybe others can give you a better answer.

Good luck,

Randy

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#9

If I am Reading You Right

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>You have a temporary use of a lathe to rough turn the blanks. I would suggest you follow the denatured alcohol route for the holly. From experience I have found that it is the best way to preserve the white color, especially this time of the year. The heat will blue the holly quickly and IMHO blue stained holly is not very pretty. I have never been able to get holly to spalt without getting the blue stain also.

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#10

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>My method of drying rough turned bowls and vessels is to rough turn it to a thicknes of 1/2 inch to 1 inch, depending on the wood, what size it is, how it's cut and how wet it is. I then apply a very liberal coat of Johnson's Paste wax. Two coats if I think that it needs it. I then put it on an open shelf where there is air circulation. I do use a paper bag for a short period of time if it's a wood that's prone to crack (Holly is one of them).

Paper bags are seldom necessary and I've never figured out why people put the piece in wood shavings.

The photo is of about 70 rough turned pieces in various stages of drying. None are cracked and I live in hot, dry Arizona. I never rough turn wet wood in the summer however.

Wally


img

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#11

Wall, my assumption is that

david

>you do not live in an earthquake-prone area of the country ;-).

We have a lot more humidity, and I just put most of my rough-turned pieces in a paper bag with no other treatment. Eucalyptus has been a minor problem with cracking and I don't get to turn many types of fruit trees, so have not resorted to end grain sealers or waxes.

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#12

Steven Antonucci

Some help from Northern NJ...

steve antonucci

>Read all of the opinions, and I've never turned holly, but a fair amount of walnut.

Here's my recipe in NW NJ. Turn to about 10% thickness of the diameter. In a 12" log, you might leave in the creamy sapwood, or you'll lose 2" in width, so assume about 3/4" to 1". I'm a firm believer with the alcohol protocol, but I don't use it on walnut because I don't need to. After roughing, I just bag them to slow the drying down. Seems to work.

Best walnut tip ever: when your done roughing, your hands will be a black mess from the tanins. Cut a lemon (or use the plastic lemon juice) and it will disappear. Stings like h*ll in little cuts, but works great!

Steve

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#13

Re: Wall, my assumption is that

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>David, you're right...if the earth shook I'd have bowls bouncing all over my shop!!!

Wally

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#14

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

Raymond in Trenton, NJ

>All,

Thanks, I really appreciate the info and suggestions. My apologies if I wasn't very clear in what I wanted to do, though everyone still managed to understand and guide me. Being without a wood lathe, I'll be using up some 'favor' chits and try rough turning as many bowls as I can before the chits run out and I over stay my welcome :o). Because of this I know I wouldn't have a chance to finish turn during the "normal drying period". I now have the reassurance that there is no harm in waiting 'longer than normal' to finish turn.

Based on all your responses, I've reformulated my plan. I'm going to start with the holly, that way if I run out of time, I can slab the walnut, seal it up and let it sit. Though not (locally) in abundance walnut is much more common than holly. It also sounds like it's a more forgiving wood. This is the second time I've heard of the bluing in holly and I'm going to look into that. I'd like to stop it if I can. Maybe I'll try the DNA soak for some.

I'm having some success drying some similar pieces of apple I got almost two years ago. I resawed it for tool handles and small (non turning) projects. A turner in my wood club (Central Jersey Woodworkers' Association) convinced me to slab (with guidance) some larger pieces for turning. I'm now glad I did. It's down to roughly 17% MC and pretty tight.

This is a very nice forum indeed! Until recently, I participated solely on the Hand Tool Forum (The Pond and then here). This turning slope is pretty exciting. It'll probably be more so once I get a lathe, huh? :~D

Thanks again and I'll let you know how it turns out (pun intended)

Raymond

who's only turned two chisel mallets and a burnisher handle and can't wait for more �

Re: Drying green turnings - The 'other' end

#15

D'OH! Subj should be "Thanks for your responses"

Raymond in Trenton, NJ

>