Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

Posts

Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#1

Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

Ray Carson, New Jersey

>I bought a set of basic turning chisels when I purchased my lathe just a couple of months ago. A gouge, a round nose, a parting tool and a skew.

I've been making some wood chips trying to get back the feel for the lathe and ..........quite frankly I'm ready to upgrade to something better.

I did sharpen the chisels once, and I know I didn't do the best job but they never seemed right from the beginning.

So......

Questions:

1) What's a decent brand name of chisels to buy.

2) What can $200.00 bucks buy that's decent. Maybe $300.00 if needed.

I haven't done any fancy work yet, probably never will but I think a basic set would suit my needs.

Ready everyone..........what would you recommend?

This outa get interesting. :-)

Thanks,

Ray

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#2

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

Rick Allen

>

I would recomend a sharpening system.

An 8" half spped grinder with AO (Aluminum Oxide) wheels (the one Woodcraft sells will work).

And a sharpening jig (the Oneway Wolvorine will work) with a fingenail grind accessory.

A diamond wheel dresser (Item C in this link).

Please note that you can buy this stuff from many places and I only picked on Woodcraft because they were an easy target.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#3

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but.......... *LINK*

Peter Charles Fagg

>For more years than I care to remember, after trying several different makers of turning gouges I would personally recommend "Robert Sorby" as my favourites.

As for prices over the pond, I will have to leave that to our other friends "Over there"!

Regards Peter.


Robert Sorby (UK)

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#4

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

don in central illinois

>My wife bought a 'set' of spindle turning chisels a few years ago and when I asked some knowing turners about a 'set' of bowl chisels, they advised me, and rightly so, to stay away from sets. Buy the one or two or three that you need. It seems in a set, at least in my case, I have one or two that I never use. Now I buy them one at a time, as my expertise increases, for what I need at the time. Just my $.02 worth. And remember, free advice is worth every penny.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#5

Re: Buy one at a time.

Ray Carson, New Jersey

>Yeah I was thinking along those lines too only because of the expense. Good point.

Thanks,

Ray

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#6

How bout Henry Taylor brand? *LINK*

Ray Carson, New Jersey

>I just looked at Lee Valley and they had a set of three chisels for $95.00. Is this a good buy?


HSS Starter Turning Set of 3 Item #58B17.01

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#7

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

Dave Belser

>It's not clear from you post how much experience with turning or sharpening you have - although you do mention that maybe you could have sharpened them better.

I got my first lathe an old Delta with a cobbled together collection of tools that had been used with it (by the owners grandfather). I knew nothing about sharpening or turning and it seemed to me that the tools didn't work good at all. I now realize that I didn't know how to sharpen or present the tools to the work and have gone back and found many of the original tools to be quite useful/good.

Sets are a compromise, the tools tend to be smaller than you might want. I needed a Spindle roughing gouge, I looked at buying a Sorby. I then realized that I could by a set of Pinnacle gouges that contained a roughing gouge for less than double the price of the Sorby. The set gave me a small detail gouge, skew and a small round nose scraper, all of which have come in handy at times.

Ultimately you will want to by your gouges one at a time or make your own tools. The only sets that aren't worth the money are the super-cheepies you find on EBay or Harbor Freight, the ones that go for less than $50.

So it depends on your budget and where your at on the learning curve. Definitely get or make a sharpening jig, you need to be able to put a good edge on quickly and repeatably. I started with an upside-down hand held belt sander that I built a plywood holder and fixed bevel guides for. It worked well enough to get me hooked on tuning :)

- Dave

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#8

El Cheapo Chisels

Thad Parker

>Would it be accurate to say that, typically, the cheaper the chisel the shorter the edge-life? It seems to me that even cheap chisels work well with a nice edge on them, it's just a matter of the edge not staying sharp long enough to spend more time turning than sharpening.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#9

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but.......... *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>I bought this set when I started in January. I haven't regretted it. At the time it was on sale for $150. It also had a CD included with beginning instruction in the form of a computer mpg video.


Sorby tool set

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#10

I Think...

Ron in Drums PA

>It is not the tools, but the way the tools sharpened.

Do you know any one near you who know how to sharpen that can teach you? A club maybe?

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#11

I agree

John Lucas

>Most turners who come to me with the tools they either bought, found or inherited go away with tools that are usable. Most of the time they just have a really bad grind but a few have odd shaped flutes which make them a little harder to use. Find someone knowledgeable to help sharpen those tools and then buy a few more as needed. You will probably want to upgrade but even new tools are sometime ground poorly or even not ground at all.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ray,first off, join a turning club. Your learning curve will lessen dramatically. There should be a club near your home. Find the best turner in the club and take lessons from them.You will save much time and frustration. For tools, I would suggest: parting tool, which you have. Detail spindle gouge. 1" skew chisel. 1/2" bowl gouge. With those tools alone, you can do almost anything. You must learn to sharpen consistantly.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#13

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>Before you get too involved with tools you should consider a sharpening system, I would recommend an 8 inch grinder with the Wolverine jig.

For Tools I like Sorby, Hamlet, or Henry Taylor.

Like has been mentioned already find a AAW chapter club in your area, they are more than willing to off advice.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#14

Steven Antonucci

Here's what you need:

steve antonucci

>5/8" or 1/2' bowl gouge

1" skew

a parting tool

and a 3/8" spindle gouge

brand doesn't really matter, as long as it's good steel. You can save a few bucks by buying them unhandled and turning your own.

Thank being said, I have like 50 tools... but I don't use lot's of them!

Steve

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#15

Re: El Cheapo Chisels

Dave Belser

>Absolutely. You can get good results with a well sharpened screwdriver! but I wouldn't recommend it. I'm sure that someone here could go on an on about the various types of steel and there merits.

The problem I see with the ultra-cheap tools is not the steel but the size of the handles and how well they are attached/made. Cheap steel just means you have to sharpen more.

In the not so distant past, there were few if any manufactures of turning tools. A lot of old timers made due by finding an appropriate hunk of hard metal and make a tool out of it. One of the "tools" that came from my friends grandfather is a scraper made from an old file. This was pretty common practice as I understand. The problem is that the metal is pretty brittle and can snap making it dangerous on a bad catch. At this point it make no sense to use old files because of the abundance of better tools and available metal stock.

- Dave

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#16

Opinion

W.C. Turner

><<<"The only sets that aren't worth the money are the super-cheepies you find on EBay or Harbor Freight, the ones that go for less than $50.">>>

I beg to differ. I first bought an 8 piece set from Harbor Freight, about $30, HSS. They're still in use. The main requirement is "HSS". Also, bought an 6 piece set of Benjamin's from Penn State, also, HSS. This set included my first bowl gouge.

Since then I've bought 4 individual Bowl gouges. And, that's my arsenal. After that, as others mentioned, learn to get them sharp. Dull tools quickly dulls turning enthusiasm! I'm still learning.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#17

Yep *LINK*

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>You are right Thad. Even a cheap tool will usually take an edge they just won't keep it very long. Due to Ray's statements, about lack of experience and that he could have sharpened them better, I don't think the brand of tools he is using is the biggest problem. Ray we have all been there. First you need to learn to sharpen and learn how to control your tools. It is a continuous learning process. Even the most experienced turners still refine their technique. Get some instruction, from books, video, or better yet live. Check and see if there is a turning club in your area. They will help you out. I think clubs are a good way to advance more quickly. Of course wood working schools are probably the fastest track to learning. They are a not cheap to attend however. Here is the link to the AAW website. Look at the local chapters list and see if there is one in your area.

Have Fun!

Tom


http://www.woodturner.org/

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#18

Re: I agree....BUT..

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>But John, can you fix my golf swing?!?!?!

:-)

I agree, the quality of the edge is the key characteristic that needs to be addressed.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#19

Re: I agree....BUT..

John Lucas

>Jim I happen to be watching the long distance driving competition while I was eating lunch. I figure I could win easily if they could actually measure the curve to my slice. I know it goes as far to the right as it does down the fairway.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#20

Re: I agree....BUT..

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Good one John,

I recently had a round of golf in Arizona, on one hole I hit the same house twice with my slice......I was glad it was a long distance from the tee, I did not want to hear what the house owner was thinking of me....

It's all in the wrists buddy, isn't it always the truth!!

take care,

Jim

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#21

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

Walter Ahlgrim

>You need to sharpen a tool more than once before you replace it.

When I started I thought new tool were sharpen correctly I then I got a new gouge that was blunt. Next I took a Ray Key Coarse There he was spending 5 minuets reshaping every brand new �Ray Key signature gouge� Now every new tool see the grinder before it sees wood.

Buy the Harbor freight set ok steel learn to sharpen with cheap steel 39.00- 59.00. when there are to short to use replace them one at a time.

http://www.harborfreightusa.com/usa/itemdisplay/displayItem.do?itemid=35444

I have not seen any cheep (less than 10.00 ) bowl or spindle gouges http://www.cuttingedgetools.com/default.htm

This set from cutting edge tools, are all good and useful tools. Most set are 1/ 3 useless tool that will just gather dust. If you pay vary much for the set it will be to painful to grind them into something useful.

301-Kit3 Bowl Turner's Starting Kit $99.00

� HS40H or HS85H (your choice) 1/2" Bowl Gouge

� HS65H 3/4" Bowl Scraper

� 1/16" HSS Parting Tool

Having more or better tools is not a short cut to being a better turner.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#22

Sharpening

Bob Fawcett

>Lots of good advice in the above posts.

If you can't find a local who can teach you to sharpen, look on the web for videos. Woodcraft has a lot of them here.

http://www.woodcraft.com/videos.aspx

OneWay has several on using their sharpening system.

Darrell Feltmate has several a number of postings here that show you how to build your own sharpening system as well as how to use some tools here:

http://aroundthewoods.com/

You need a grinder. If you don't have one, get one, or try your belt sander or access to one. Read the stuff on Russ Fairfield's site starting with the FAQ here.

http://www.woodturnerruss.com/FAQ.html

Many of the woodturning books and videos have a section on sharpening, get one and read it or view it. I like the videos best. I learn more from seeing it done.

Good luck.

If you still don't have the answers you need, post more questions here on WC. Everyone here is very helpfull, and I have yet to see anyone fault us beginners.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#23

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

eaglesc

>You didn"t say WHAT you were trying to turn.

As a pencrafter I use a lathe and chisels but don't consider myself a turner.

I get by very well with a 12 piece $10.00 set from harbor freight.

I hone the chisels with a diamond stone from Lowes, 2 grits ,about $25.00.

I "turn" glue ups , acrylics and antler.

Before I buy a "wolverine type" system I would make one.

Also a belt sander is sureful for sharpening.

Try the least expensive route rather than thnking that throwing money into the situation will help it.

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#24

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

eliot

>I believe the best advice you have been given here is to invest in a good sharpening system, You said you sharpened them ONCE. Most turners sharpen several times in 20 minutes -- even more for some kinds of wood. I'll bet that if you go for the sharpening system instead of new gauges, you'll be amazed at how much better you are turning and enjoying the tools you already have.Once you are really proficient with what you have, then start getting some better tools, such as Sorby, Taylor, etc. The best of all are Glasser. He sold his tool-making business, but I think you can still get Glasser tools(expensive). But take some advice: learn how to sharpen what you have. You'll be a happy camper. Trust me!

Re: Maybe I shouldn't ask but..........

#25

First of all, they are not chisels!....

Jamie Donaldson

>It really helps communication to use proper terminology, like bowl gouge(meaning deep flute), spindle roughing gouge, etc. Buying a set of tools guarantees a certain number will be useless for most turners, especially novices, and dealers such as Packard and Craft Supply have house brands at a reduced cost that are top quality. Don't waste your time and money on cheap tools, unless they are for grinding practice. Buy only what you need to get started, and invest in turning and sharpening lessons.