Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Critique Please

Posts

Critique Please

#1

Critique Please

Barbara Gill

>I turned this little (2 1/2" wide 3" tall) dogwood hollow form. Today I decided to try another collar which I made out of holly, dyed black and burnished ala Mac. The last time I posted, the majority felt the collar was too small. Please critique the form and collar.


img

Re: Critique Please

#2

Re: Critique Please

john lucas

>Barbara I like it. See how the lines from the sides flow up and continue the arc of the collar. It's also smaller than the base which I think helps. You have a good form on the piece and I like it.

Re: Critique Please

#3

Re: Critique Please

Lan Brady

>Barbara,

I do not fell artsy enough to give it a crique, but I really like the shape. All of mine have a holes in the side(unintentional)!

My favorite part is the size. I would not have know except for you statement.

Good Job, Lan

Re: Critique Please

#4

Re: Critique Please

Bill Howatt

>Very nice. If I had made it I would be very proud of it.

The slope of the collar blends very well with the curve of the side but it it were a little lower it might blend a little bit better (this is real picky, I know). However, this may or may not be desireable in the actual piece because with the photo we are looking dead on the center of the side of what looks like a large piece whereas if it were on a shelf the viewing angle may be quite different.

I can't decide whether or not a slight curve at the bottom would be more appropriate than the sharp interface.

Regardless, I think it is great.

Bill

Re: Critique Please

#5

Re: Critique Please

Carole Valentine

>Hi Barb,

You have an absolutely lovely curve on this piece! Makes yyou want to touch it. I think it would be even better if you continued it in a tad more at the base - right now it almost appears as if the collar and the base are the same size. As for the collar, I like the convex style but it could maybe be just a tiny bit thinner (shorter). Just my two cents worth, which won't get you far! LOL

Re: Critique Please

#6

Re: Critique Please

Ed Moore

>Barb,

I like the collar and feel that it is "just right".

I can't tell if it is the photo, my monitor, or if there is a hint of a knuckle about 7/8" up from the bottom. Only you can tell, but the lower half of the curve looks like it could be smoother. And it may be my imagination.

Good job, overall I like it.

Ed

Re: Critique Please

#7

Re: Critique Please

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Barb, I like this very much. I'll offer one suggestion. The very nice curve flattens out near the bottom. If it had continued, the foot would have been smaller, and that would be an improvement. Using the 1/3 rule, for a piece that's 2 1/2 in. wide, the foot could be about 3/4 in.

I'll sssume that the sidewalls are 1/16-inch and it's sanded to 600 inside.

Wally

Re: Critique Please

#8

Re: Critique Please

GaryG in MD

>Barbara,

It's a lovely piece -- way beyond my skills, and I would be extremely proud to have made it.

Only because you asked, I'll go into the "picky" mode to mention a few very subtle things.

First, I agree with both of Carole's comments and want to reemphasize them: the curve goes flat in the bottom 15% of the piece (I used a straight edge on the screen), and the base is, indeed, the same size as the collar, at least by measurement on the screen. Both of those factors might be considered to be minor problems. Second, my only original comment is that my eye is wandering around a bit looking for a "feature". If it were mine, I'd probably consider adding a shadow line or edge to the collar -- it seems just a tad plain to me.

Again, just my opinion; very picky and only because I believe you really want to hear it.

...Gary

Re: Critique Please

#9

Re: Critique Please

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>I am not a skilled turner ( I am working hard on it) but have spent many years in the design industry and also photograpy!

The shape is very pleasing to the eye and you should be proud to put your name on it!

I feel that the last inch or so near the bottom , the curve flattens out and loses the symmetry. The collar might be a smidgeon less pronounced in height?

Nit picky but I felt like commenting.

Best regards,

Wayne

Re: Critique Please

#10

Re: Critique Please

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.

>Barbara, you have turned a very attractive hollowform! The collar is fine, and I like the shape. The only part that I would change is the diameter of the base (smaller), and a curve leading to it.

Re: Critique Please

#11

Excellent--wouldn't change a single thing!

David

>

Re: Critique Please

#12

Re: Critique Please

Philip Duffy

>Barb, It looks much taller and that is a testimony to your photo. Well Done. Actually, I do not think anyone could have done it better and the beauty of the curve testifies to art. Phil

Re: Critique Please

#13

Thanks John

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Critique Please

#14

Thanks Everyone

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I started to answer everyone individually but that would take up too much space.

I can see all of the flaws pointed out, the slight flatening of the curve at the base which would have affected the size of the foot and the thickness of the collar. I whish I had been able to see them when the piece was on the lathe.

Wally, of course it is 1/16th of an inch thick and sanded to 600 inside. LOL :-)

Re: Critique Please

#15

Re: Thanks Everyone

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Hi Barbara,

I just looked now and I can say that I find it a very pleasing form and design...great work on it!!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Critique Please

#16

Re: Thanks Everyone

Carole Valentine

>Barb,

Next time try taking it off the lathe (chuck and all) and placing it at various levels to look at it. Sometimes it helps to visualize if you can prop a sheet of white cardboard or something to hide everything below what is the actual baseline of the piece. I have found that if I look at a piece while it is on the lathe, it always looks like the base is smaller than it actually is.

Re: Critique Please

#17

Basic Rule

Bill Howatt

>Pieces always look better mounted on the lathe.

Bill

Re: Critique Please

#18

Re: Basic Rule

John Lucas

>Bill I think we should start mounting pieces horizontally on the wall. That way they will look as good as they look when on the lathe.

Re: Critique Please

#19

Re: Thanks Everyone

Bob Elliott

>Here, here. I have just started to take these type pieces off the lathe, as suggested / demonstrated by Phil Brennion. It really helps!

I like this piece Barb. But I'm with Wally on the diameter of the base.