Re: Critique Please
GaryG in MD
>Barbara,
It's a lovely piece -- way beyond my skills, and I would be extremely proud to have made it.
Only because you asked, I'll go into the "picky" mode to mention a few very subtle things.
First, I agree with both of Carole's comments and want to reemphasize them: the curve goes flat in the bottom 15% of the piece (I used a straight edge on the screen), and the base is, indeed, the same size as the collar, at least by measurement on the screen. Both of those factors might be considered to be minor problems. Second, my only original comment is that my eye is wandering around a bit looking for a "feature". If it were mine, I'd probably consider adding a shadow line or edge to the collar -- it seems just a tad plain to me.
Again, just my opinion; very picky and only because I believe you really want to hear it.
...Gary