Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Posts

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#26

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Philip Duffy

>Hi,Dom, I have a Husky, have had a Stihl and the bottom line; buy what you need at the price that meets the budget. Not a big difference in the two. Good care and attention to maintenace will let either saw fill your needs. Phil

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#27

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Dominic,Without reading the other posts, a couple questions:

1.- How often you cut 4" diameter trees to justify using a 24"bar? think on back saving. I think a saw with power to spare and an 16" inch blade is adecuate for most situations, and if you ever get a bigger tree, then you get a longer bar.

2.- Are you really comfortable buying from Amazon? I would not, I much rather find a local dealer where you can walk in a a case of something going wrong, a very rare ocurrence with a Husky, more frequent with the german saw.

So my advice is to decide in a saw powerful enough and think how much longer your back will last if you are not subjecting it to unecessary overloads, and then get the bar that your back is telling you, That one!, don't let your eyes or a macho complex get the best of you.

Mis dos centavos

Jorge

Which has been wielding 16" bars in a Josenreds and now in a Husky for the last 40 years and never felt the need for anything bigger and that in his seventies he can still walk staright, and still is living in and managind a woodlot.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#28

P.S.

W.C. Turner

>Dom,

Did you give up on getting the Electric Saw?

email: Remove 2

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#29

Had to

Dominic Greco in Richboro, PA

>WC,

Yes, the electric chainsaw idea is history. With my POS Homelite chainsaw dying on me, I had to switch focus to getting a replacement chainsaw.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#30

Hi Jorge

Dominic Greco in Richboro, PA

>Jorge,

Thanks for the input. As fas as tree size is concerned; on the average I come across trees in my section of PA that are at least 18" diameter about 90% of the time. Unless it's something spectacular, I don't bother with smaller trees. That is, unless it's meant only for firewood. You should see some of the monster trees PennDOT is taking out on the road near my house! One oak tree had to be about 50" across for it's entire 20' length. Thankfully I heard it went to a local sawmill.

I plan on getting an 18" bar. From past experience, that size works perfect for me. But any chainsaw would hopefully be able to handle a 24" bar should the need arise.

I always try to shop on the internet first, scope out the price ranges, the features, get as informed as I can, THEN I go to a local dealer. That way I can make an informed choice.

I agree with your reservations about buying stuff sight unseen over the internet. I'm not real fond of buying any large power tools without seeing, and holding them in my hand first.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#31

Brad Vietje

Here, Here, Jorge !

Brad Vietje

>I'm with our esteemed turning friend from Downeast Maine. I think this reliance on the Big Box stores or buying everything via the web is killing this country. For the most part, they only have one selling point -- price.

As petroleum products get more and more expensive, these stores will no longer be able to ship goods all over the planet and undersell the local dealers that have been stuck with decreased sales, and having to provide service for XYZ(POS).com. I think the fact that Stihl has enough backbone to only sell through their network of local dealers is commendable.

This also provides them with the opportunity to talk to a potential saw owner and make sure they get equipment that truly fits their needs, and that they are aware of all the safety concerns that accompany chainsaws. We often fall into the trap of wanting to comparison shop on-line, and expect to get expert advice with no delay and no effort. Sometimes we even go into a local dealer's shop and kick the tires and use them for their expert opinion and experience, then slap them in the face and save $15 by ordering on-line from POS.com. I've fallen into this trap, but now whenever possible, I'll buy from a real person who has a handshake, kids, and a mortgage, just like me. Then I know my hard-earned $$$ is supporting a local business, a few families, etc...

As for Dom's question, I'd suggest going to the Husky and Stihl dealerships, and chosing one you like the best, and buying it right there where you money stays in your community, even if it does cost a little more.

Safe Spinning (and sawing),

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#32

Brad Vietje

Re: Hi Jorge

Brad Vietje

>Atta go, Dom ! I wrote my response while you were posting yours -- I'm glad we agree !

Take Care,

Brad

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#33

Go Slow

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>On the multi-bar deal, Dom. Have to disagree with Jorge's general statement that you can always go to a 24" bar. Once you get over 20" the torque and power requirements for chainsaws start escalating, in part because of the number of cutters you will have engaged at any one time. Power heads have been engineered for both fuel economy and weight balanced with output and torque. Put a 24" bar on a Stihl designed to run an 18" bar and you may be back at the dealer buying a new saw after you find the warranty would not cover your blown engine. Seen a Stihl burnt up 'cause the hot shot self-ground his chain rakers down to take big bites.

Every saw will have a max rating on both bar length and chain pitch and type. Your dealer or the factory website will let you know what those are; don't exceed them. You can always go shorter on the bar, but not necessarily longer. For instance, my 372XP Husky pro saw is rated for up to a 36" bar. I use a 28" and full-skip chain so the saw almost loafs through the wood. My Stihl 023 is rated for an 18" bar, but I've run a 16" with stock pico chain for 16 years and it continues to run strong.

See Ya

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#34

I'll only use what they recommend

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Hey Mark,

Remember, you're talking to an Engineer here. I always follow the manufacturer's recommendations and never try to push any of my tools to the lim......ACK!..of their... COUGH! HACK! maximum rated capacity! [sputter!]

Sorry. Started to choke on my own words there. :>)

Truthfully. I don't want to go through this whole ordeal again. So I'm going to be mighty careful with the chainsaw I eventually buy. Hopefully the one I buy will be able to handle a 18" and a 24" bar. If not, you won't see me using one.

Later,

Dominic

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#35

Yeah. CRS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Did forget you're one of Them. Didn't mean to preach to the choir.

Go try Grumbine's 260Pro. Stong feeling that's your saw.

|;-}}

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#36

That what I meant Mark

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Dom,

get a saw that can handle the ocassional long bar and get the everyday (shorter) use bar, it will be overpowered but that is not a problem like underpowered and I would not get the long bar unless I have a job to justify it.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#37

What You Actually Meant

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>was what I expected from someone with your experience, Jorge. Just figured what you typed was a bit too general, and took the opportunity to let others know a little more detail.

Too easy for newbies to read something here, go do it, and then get into trouble.

|;-}}

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#38

Right You Are!, Thanks

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>