Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Posts

Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#1

Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Hello Everyone,

Several days ago my friend and fellow woodturner Andy DiPietro stopped by to take some of that BIG maple tree I had in my back yard. He had a 24" Husqvarna chainsaw that made short work of the logs.

While I was trying to cut up some of the "smaller" (read that as 18" diameter and smaller) pieces, my POS 18" Homelite chainsaw started to make some funny grinding noises. After some inspection, I found that the flywheel was in the process of self destructing. Some people would be depressed. However, I see this as an opportunity to purchase a more powerful, and more reliable chainsaw. While the 18" Homelite I purchased 6 years ago has served adequately (and that's being generous), IMHO I've come to realize the false economy of purchasing "homeowner brands" from the big box stores.

After searching through the archives and reading all the reccomendations, I've narrowed it down to either a Stihl, or a Husqvarna. I need a saw that is dependable, reliable, and built to take abuse. I use my chainsaw for cutting firewood, tending the trees in my yard, as well as harvesting turning stock. As far as bar size goes, 18" is minimum, while 24" is the max I see myself needing (at this moment). As far as price goes, we're talking in the $400 to $500 range here. I can't go any higher without risking severe reprisals from the "Accounting Department" (ie: my wife).

Now that I've stated my criteria, I'd really appreciate some reccomendations, as well as an answer to some questions about several models.

I checked out some of the Husqvarna chain saws on Amazon and read some reviews. I was apalled to read a review where several owners panned the 445 Rancher. Forgive me for sounding cheap, but I expect a $370 chainsaw to perform better than this! If you read all the reviews, one person suggests purchasing the Husqvarna 359. However, Amazon was out of stock so I was unable to get a price on this. Speedway sales has it for $485. So,....$115 difference and I get a much better saw? Tell me I'm wrong, but this sounds like a no brainer to me.

Q:Is the 359 that much better of a chainsaw?

And as far as Stihl chainsaws go, I was unable to get prices on them via the Internet. A fact finding mission to a local Stihl dealer (in Tax Free Delaware) is in order.

Q: Does anyone have a recomendation for a comparablly priced Stihl Chainsaw that will meet the criteria I mentioned above?

See ya around,

My ugly mug


Dominic

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#2

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Raymond Overman in SC

>I have a Husky 350 and find that it is adequate for the size work I do. If I had the money and needed to work with a 24" bar I would go with the 359 for the extra power. As for recommendations you will hear, "As long as you buy an orange saw(Stihl, Husky, Echo), you can't go wrong," and, "Buy as much saw as your budget can handle and that you can safely operate." I'd agree with both these statements. Just weigh the second one carefully and know your limits.

I like the fact that I bought my saw from a local dealer. I can walk in with a good conscience and ask a few questions about self-maintenance of my saw without feeling like I'm taking something for nothing. I also know I can depend on the guy to back his product. You may want to take that into consideration before buying over the Internet.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#3

The Stihl dealer is part of the product...

Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay area

>I know nothing about Husky saws. The Stihl dealer has been selling me power tools for my home, garden & (hobby) shop for over 20 years. The Stihl chainsaw I bought from him last spring has been a real gem for me.

You ought to at least see if you can find a guy fairly local to you, and see what they have to say/sell. I would worry less about sales tax than the local part. Over twenty years, $35 is a minor issue for me.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#4

Stihl MS390...

Peter Teubel

>I have an MS390 with 20", 24", and 28" bars. I cannot say enough about the saw. Powerful, handles well, dependable. Put a full chisel chain on it and it'll eat thru wood F-A-S-T. With a sharp chain (Stihl chains last a LONG time), I never have to push the saw...simply the weight of the saw is enough to plow thru hardwood and an amazing pace.

Another choice would be the MS290. Same saw (same weight, too) but a little less power and less expensive. In fact, I borrowed a friend's 290 for a week and that's what made me decide to get a Stihl.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#5

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

RobinCorell

>I have a Stihl 038 Magnum. a year or two after I purchased it the model #'s were all redone and I think it is the same or similar to a 440 Magnum. It is 70cc and I think rated for up to a 26" or 28" bar. I run a 32" bar and use it for milling, not a problem since 4" at the ended are not in the log. I have even used this saw with the full 32" bar buried in a log and it still has the power to pull the chain.

For me the real advantage of owning a stihl over a husky is that I can count on it starting right up if it has been sitting for a year. I have had my saw for 10 years and it has NEVER been in the shop, nor have I needed to do any repairs.

Robin.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#6

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

RobinCorell

>didn't mean for than last post of mine to be a response to Ray's post. I agree with his comment about orange saws, I just happen to own a Stihl flavored one.

Robin

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#7

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Mac

>Dom, If possible buy from a dealer near you that you can talk with. The difference in price will not be an issue when the saw breaks down and you can get it fixed quickly.I've owned a few brands over the years,and have found that the dealer is the most important factor in buying a saw.I now have had a Husky for the last 8 years and couldnt be happier with the saw or the dealer.....

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#8

Steven Antonucci

2 opinions...

steve antonucci

>Spent the weekend in your neck of the woods with you-know-who and he had a strong like of the Husky, and a dislike of the Stihl.

That being said, I've had a Stihl O17 for years and my next "big saw" will be a Stihl... great power to weight, and I've only put gas and oil into it (not another penny.)

Steve

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#9

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Congratulations... Buy the new saw but repair the old one. You never could have enough tools.

My vote is for the Stihl.

Good luck,

Doug

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#10

Re: Opportunity *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Dom,

If you're going Huskly, consider the 346xp with a 20" bar. Saw is blazingly fast at 15,000 rpm but it won't pull a 24" bar and it is .325 pitch chain. The 359 will put a 24" bar, although it would do better at that length with a skip chain.

Also suggest you take a ride up to Bill G's and try his Stihl 260Pro (now MS260-Pro). 20" bar with very good balance and excellent power-to-weight at only 10 lbs. Sweet saw that more than makes up for the missing 4" although it does have the juice to pull a 24" bar.

Good prices on Huskies at the link.


SW-Husky

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#11

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Bob Fawcett

>I was at Lowes today and the store hear in Georgia carries the 359. If I remember right the price was $380, maybe it was $480. See if your Lowes has it.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#12

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Bill Crommett

>Don't be too concerned about the brand, be ultra concerned about the dealer ! I run an older Stihl 031 and am well satisfied.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#13

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Dom

I have two comments.

1. You have seen my Stihl's in action.

2. You have seen how fast we got the big one back in action after the E clip broke because of the Stihl dealer just down the road from your house.

Service and the availability of it are at least as important as anything else in the saws you are considering. As a side note, in the almost seven years I have owned my two Stihls, that clip is the only thing I have had to replace other than normal stuff like filters, chains, etc.

Bill

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#14

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

eaglesc

>A local dealer is a plus on whatever you get.

In the price range your are looking at I would also add echo to the mix but any of the Saws you mentioned would serve you well.

Dealers don't make much per saw but they are worth their weight in gold when you need service or parts.

Which one of the guys(with the blue or orange vest) at the Borg would you trust repairing your saw or ordering the parts you need for it?

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#15

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Bill Neddow

>As others have said, go with Stihl or Husquvarna -- and make the choice based on the dealer. He is the key. I have a Stihl 039 and a 660 and love both of them. They get rough usage and stand up well. My buddy has two Husquvarnas. He lives in the other end of the city and liks his Husky dealer there. We often work together -- and the saws seem to be equally good.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#16

Stihl 260Pro/ MS260-Pro?

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Bill,

I gotta say, that was pretty impressive how fast that chainsaw of yours went through that maple. And how fast it tore through that massive cherry tree a couple years back. Seeing it in action is a major reason I'm favoring Stihl. That, and I was pretty freaked out about the Amazon review stating how terrible Husky service was! Now I know that all dealers are different. But that still weighs on my mind. I've heard NOTHING but good things about the Stihl. Makes you wonder.....

Mark was saying you have the Stihl 260Pro. I'm pretty terrible with remembering model numbers. So if you could confirm this, I'd really appreciate it.

Thanks,

Dominic

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#17

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Raymond Overman in SC

>Just as a note, I looked at Stihls first but our local Stihl dealer decided that he would ignore my budget, try to sell me much more saw than what I could afford or needed, and generally talked me out of buying a chainsaw from him. There are three Husky dealers within 10 miles of the house which was my next stop.

The Stihl dealer is out of business now. It wasn't his product that put him there.

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#18

Thanks for all the input

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Thank you all for the input. So far, I'm favoring the Stihl. We'll see how this pans out after I stop in and check out the prices.

I do have a Stihl dealer very close to where I live. I've been driving by his location in Southampton PA (right off of Street Road) for years before finally realizing he was there! I stopped in last week to buy plastic wedges. He seems like a nice guy.

But I have also dealt with the dealer in Delaware and was pretty impressed with their service. I ended up buying a Honda snow blower and Stihl leaf blower from them.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#19

Only Remington/Poulan chainsaws

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Thanks for the heads up. But I was just at Lowes this afternoon and I only saw Remington and Poulan Chainsaws for sale.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#20

Re: Only Remington/Poulan chainsaws

Mac

>Just one more good reason to stay away from the big box stores.....

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#21

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Ricco G

>Hi DOM

I have a SKILLSAW chainsaw (as in the circular saw brand) I bought it new in 1980 so far it has served my purpose, mostly cutting fire wood for the woodstove I had in the early 80's from the first gas crisis,now it used for cutting firewood for the getaway cabin. I didn't use it for about 4 years it sat in the basement at the cabin,about 2 weeks ago I brought it home,it still had gas in it ,(mostly oil) I drained the tank put in fresh gas, cleaned the plug gap w/sandpaper sprayed some starting fluid in,after about 6 or so times with the starting fluid and the air filter off it was running fine as if it never sat for that amount of time. I thought I'd just add in a chainsaw story. thanks Rick

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#22

I Vote For Stihl

Barry Turner

>I bought a Stihl 361 with a 20" bar last year ($539.00). It has proven to be very satisfactory. My previous experience with chainsaws was with big box store stuff, a couple of borrowed Homelites and a McCulloch that belongs to my brother-in-law. All were homeowner saws with 38 to 40cc displacement and 14" and 16" bars. The Stihl 361 has 58cc and there is no comparison. I'll never go back!

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#23

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

Walter Ahlgrim

>When I began shopping for a chain saw I was sure I would buy a Sthil saw. After shopping I found that you can�t buy a new Sthil over the internet or big box stores. This lack competition allows Sthil to maintain a large network of small dealer. To my eye similar power and weight Sthil saw cost more than Husqvarna.

The 445 rancher and 429 farm boss are aimed at a different market than 359 - 357 Husky 260 - 361 Sthil. The farm � ranch saw what the arborist would call a pig, they are heavier than the pro saws, by a few pounds doesn�t sound like much until lift it 100 times an hour for 10 hours a day.

My 359 is a great saw I wish I had gotten it before the EPA required catalytic converters.

I paid 425.00 last year. At this link 419.00

http://store.baileys-online.com/cgi-bin/baileys/991

This is a link to a sight that live for there saws look in �forum � chainsaw�

http://arboristsite.com/forumdisplay.php?f=9

Walt A

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#24

Stihl MS361

Joseph

>Best saw I have ever owned!!!!!

Re: Chainsaw self destruction = Opportunity

#25

Husky

W.C. Turner

>Hi Dom,

Based on my experience, I wouldn't pay too much attention to that negative review on Amazon. My Husqvarna warranty experience was A-OK. I purchased my Husky 350/20" bar, over the internet, but, wouldn't buy from that dealer again. In the end, I got from them what was promised me. Free Husky gloves, extra chain, plus, the custom service rep, at the Husky warranty 800 #, was extra nice to me. He sent me a free chain, and a free bar.

After I had the saw for a short while, I carried it to the Husky dealer, about 25 miles away, since we don't have a dealer here. He did all the maintenance on it, set timing, etc., under the warranty, at no charge, even though I didn't buy the saw from him.

I think the Amazon reviewer just had an unfortunate experience. I wouldn't hesitate to buy Husky again. Stihl is more expensive, but, from my research, the Husky cuts Faster, but, Stihl has more power.

Anyway, you can't go wrong with either of these saws.