Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

Posts

My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#1

My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Well not long ago I went over to one of our club members shop to pratice finials. We were both lacking severely and decided to give it a shot after reading Cindy's article in the latest (I think) issue of the AAW magazine. We hung the magazine up over the lathe so we could see the picture of her diagram and the photo and away we went. We felt like we were cheating...but we forged ahead anyway. Ned turned his first and then I took a shot....but I took the magazine and turned it a 1/4 turn clockwize so the picutre was oriented horizontaly like it was on the lathe. Hee-he. I was cheating big time!

Anyway...here's the finial I made that day. I didn't have anything turned that it was intended for, but when I got home I set it inside this little piece that I had made right after buying my burner, and it sort of fit, so there is sits. It's much too big for it, obviously. I'll have to make something else for it to sit in.


Now that I'm looking at this photo closely, it appears that I didn't even sit it in here straight! Ugh....I was in a rush :(

These finials are really difficult for me to make. It seems like I would adjust one thing and then have to re-adjust something else. They are very finicky.

One down....much more practicing to do!

Jen :)

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#2

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.

>Jennifer, It may be to big for that cool piece it is sitting on, but it and the combination of both do look fine to me.

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#3

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Jen, The best way to get to the finial you want is to start. This looks to me like a pretty decent start.

My first finials were no where near as good as this one. We just have to keep on turning them because the next one will be better than the last, and so on, and so on.

keithz

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#4

Thats a fine attempt Jen, but...

Jamie Donaldson

>... for my recently acquired finial taste the upper section is a tad too thick in proportion to the lower section.

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#5

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>I just returned home after spending 4 days with Cindy Drozda. 2 days seminar and 2 days hands on at Lyle Jamieson's shop. I think that Jamie had it right about the top being too thick. Cindy's approach is to have the finial flow upwards. I think it is a nice looking finial but might possibly look better if the taper below the Onion was much thinner. Just my 2 cents.

Mike

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#6

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Jen

Great first finial. I was afraid to make the top thin on my first ones as well. I remember Cindy telling us at our club's demo not to make any two elements the same size.

Terry

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#7

May I suggest????

Barry Irby

>First, take my criticism with a grain of salt, I am certainly no expert on style or design, but I am well intentioned.

I would suggest that the bell or trumpet above the onion should be smaller than the one below. The shaft or spire above the onion should be smaller or thiner and the teardrop or flame at the top should be slightly larger. This is a nice finial and you are within millimeters of even better.

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#8

Thanks everyone...!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thanks to all for the help with this. Each comment or suggestion really opened my eyes to what is wrong and what is okay with this attempt. I find them challenging but when I saw it come to life on the lathe...I really got a charge out of it. It would be nice to understand the dynamics of design with these and then discover a style of finial that wasn't a complete "rip off" of Cindy's. I feel like her finials are practically "trademarked". I consider her one of he Queens of finials.

Thanks again for the comments. I'm going to try more of these.

Jen

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#9

Re: Thanks everyone...!

Molly Winton

>This is an excellent post Jen. I am finial challenged, and a bit intimidated, but I'm going to continue to try. Your first attempt is quite good, and the suggestions/critiques following it, so very helpful. This is the type of feedback I like, not a bunch of 'way-to-gos', but some very helpful insight.

Thanks for the post!

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: My Attempt at a Finial-post Drozda Article

Brad Vietje

>Jennifer,

This is an excellent start in the thin-finial world ! I agree with the posts so far -- I like to see the details get progressively smaller toward the tip. I feel the same way about "icicles", or upside-down finials on ornaments and the like -- each element should get smaller, and the central "shaft" ought to progress through them in a tapered fashion, from larger to smaller diameter. You did an excellent job on the captured ball as the central element, and all other comments are about proportions.

Another source for real neat finial design is Robert Chapman's book, Woodturning: A Fresh Approach, published by GMC in Great Britian.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT