Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Ellis Walentine

>Well, folks it's time again to tempt you with a tantalizing woodworking topic. As always, your answers will be distilled to our "News & Views" column in the next issue of Woodworker West magazine.

Lately, as I've been wrestling with a major home carpentry project (renovating our back porch before it self-destructs), I've gotten to thinking about how much carpentry I've done in my life, along with all the finer woodworking projects. It seems to me that the thing these activities all have in common is that they are essentially design problems; that is, they all start with a need to create something or make something happen, and they all require us to use our tools and our wits and whatever skills and materials are appropriate to solve the design problem at hand.

The skillsets involved in carpentry and fine woodworking are surprisingly similar, if you think about it; it's mostly the materials and degree of refinement that differs. In every case, it comes down to our mechanical and problem solving abilities to get the job done.

Okay, enough philosophizing; let's toss this chestnut around for a while: How many of you engage in the full gamut of woodworking activities, from rustic carpentry to the finest furniture and accessories, or if you don't, where is your area of greatest interest? (I know you all are turners, but are you limited to turning?)For that matter, how far afield do you go with your creative and mechanical pursuits? Metalwork, other crafts? How do you think they relate to and/or complement each other?

This is a pretty open-ended question, so I'm hoping we get a wide range of replies. Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#2

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Jim Rutten

>Interesting that you post this question about design, but I don't think you should limit it to just woodworking. For example, our mailbox is on our post with just a friction fit and lately it has been loose. I have been kicking around fixing it with a couple pieces of tin with holes through them to put a bolt through the already existing hole in the post or building a wooden cage to go on the post with a bolt through it. I talked to my wife last night and she sees a wooden platform on the post with a couple of cargo straps going around the mailbox. There are as many different design opportunities as there are people and that is what makes it great. Otherwise, we would all be turning the same size of bowls out of the same would in the same way. Isn't variety wonderful?

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#3

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Keith I - East Tn

>Ellis, I think you are right on the money when you say it's just a design problem. In my case, I ended up turning for fun because of a progression of "design problems".

For example, We needed more room so I added an addition on to our house. I then needed some bathroom cabinets so I built some. I then needed some new bedroom furniture so I built some. Somwhere along the line I needed spindles for somthing so I learned to turn. I am continually presented with problems and am required to solve

them the best way I can. It usually means developing a new skill or improving an old one.

To answer your question, I do about everything as the need arises. Everyone should do one thing well, but wouldn't life be dull if we never did but one thing? Have fun with it, Keith

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#4

Funny you should ask....

TDaniel

>I was just talking to someone yesterday about this same subject. I met a man in our local arts guild whose father was in the same Carpenter's Union as I was in. My woodworking experiences began when I was about 12 years old and was hired by a neighbor to clean up salvaged lumber that he brought home from remodelling jobs. This same man had an old Dunlap lathe that he taught me to turn on. As I ventured into various woodworking projects and carpentry projects all of them seemed to merge; my shop is basically a big cabinet with mortise and tenon joints, etc. and my bowls feature molding at the top and bottom. In 1994 I bought a Woodmizer sawmill and became like a kid in a candy store as I found beautiful lumber in "scrap" logs. I was hauling more slabs home than I could ever turn so I began using spalted lumber for panelling, persimmon for chair rails, etc. I think it is inevitable that all forms of working with wood merge as you gain experience.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#5

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>Life in working with wood as been that I learned how to do what I needed to do when I needed to do it.

It all started with the purchase of my first home. It was a 120 year old house that had not been touched for over 30 years. As I did each room, I learned about framing, then roofing, then taught myself to use a router to recreate baseboards and door and window trim. I built custom cabinets for my kitchen and a custom vanity for my bathroom. I've built decks and a shop, along with all the benches I needed and started turning because I thought it was cool. Boy, was I ever right about that.

Now, in addition to turning, I'll occasionally build a piece of furniture such as bookcase or a shelf cubby, etc.

I feel that the experience I have gained throughout the years allows the me the benefit of being able to build whatever I need, whenever I need it. It is a good feeling to know.

keithz

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#6

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

don in central illinois

>I have to agree with Mr. Zimmerman. When my son and son in law ask how did you learn to do that, I reply, I was too poor to have it hired done so I learned how to do whatever needed to be done. Especially, carpentry, shelves, bookcases, etc. From building additions to homes, remodeling. Turning, for me, is another avenue for a creative outlet and the more I see of the postings here, I realize I have a long way to go. But having a ball doing it.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#7

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Being in the final punchlist stages of a complete gut and makeover of our master bed and bath, I had to chuckle at your post, Boss.

Yeah, I suppose I do most everything (except roofs) in light construction, framing, plumbing (SWMBO = plumber's daughter so I re-plumbed the entire house), electrical (with license back-up), in addition to having built/made most of the furniture in the house. It is, indeed, a question of design and tolerances, but it's also knowing the materials that will render a proper and lasting result. The members of my self-help group (we work on each other's homes since good tradesmen here will tell you to call back next year if you can reach them at all) kid me because I take too much time and work to excessively close tolerances. They kid me, but then turn around and do the same even though I keep telling them that the clock doesn't have to actually run.

Then there's the matter of having trained as a sculptor so welding, metalwork, moldmaking and casting, are also called into play when needed. Of course, there's not much welding or casting involved with home remodeling |;-}.

My furniture making was and is directed to the personal needs of my family; I have no interest in commission work or selling furniture. Turning is almost pure relaxation. Carpentry and construction skills allow me to shape my environment to my personal taste at a price which I can afford. The more skills that are acquired, the more opportunity there is to approach a given situation from different angles.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#8

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

john lucas

>Ellis I started woodworking by building the needed essentials around the house. Eventually I bought a shopsmith with the idea that I would build all of our furniture. I forgot about the learning curve necessary to build the quality of work I desired. Eventually I got there by learning all I could about the different styles of woodworking from Adding a room to the house to building fine furniture as gifts for the family. I still don't have any fine pieces for myself. Some day perhaps. Now I'm into woodturning big time but as I look back on all of this it comes down to one love. I love to figure things out. I think I like the design and problem solving as much as working with the wood. I'll spend as much time building a jig to do the job right as I will on some projects. Even my shop is a design in progress. Always trying to find a better way to store something or make the shop more functional.

I love tuning the machinery and hand tools so they work more accurately. All of this has also led to working with metal. I started by making carving tools and turning tools and then modifying and tuning cheap planes. Eventually it turned into modifiying and tuning the bigger machines. Now I'm taking up blacksmithing and jewelry making to learn those skills because I want to add metal to my woodworking. I have always wanted a metal lathe and mill because I have a need to make even better tools and parts for my woodworking.

I've learned all these skills to support my need to design and build things. I hadn't thought of it that way before but looking back I can see how I spend all my spare time at work designing a new way to build something in my head. I can't wait to get home to see if my ideas actually work.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#9

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Ruth Niles

>Like a the other respondents, I learned how to do what was needed. I got divorced 82 years ago and raising 4 kids alone left me with 0 dollars for anything so I learned how to make what I needed. My first project was a sandbox for my first 2 kids (now 44 and 45 yr.), I would buy old chairs or dressers at yard sales and fix them up to re-sell. You really learn how something is built by tearing it apart. My kids bought me a Craftsman monotube lathe in 1990. Then an antique dealer asked if I could reproduce chair spindles for 150-yr. old chairs and I said, "sure".......I had to get a book on how to do it. I loved turning and branched out. My turnings are almost all utilitarian; must come from my "poor" years when everything had to have a use!

I love people who try to make something they need, it's the best learning experience there is.

Quick story: When I had an antique shop, at an auction I bought a neat, wooden, obviously homemade something. All the other dealers were trying to figure out what it was used for. I said "I know exactly what it is, about 50 years ago a little old woman said to her husband 'I need something about this high and this wide with a hook ........' " and everyone agreed that's what it was.

People who make things because they need them are also the people who grow their favorite vegetables, paint their own houses and are the best role models for the next generation.

Don't know if I stayed on track, Ellis, but it was fun posting. : )

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#10

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Ellis,

When I came to this country I was a filmaker/photographer, living in the big apple, then I got divorced and moved upstate, where my film and photo skills could not feed me, so I started building houses, I had a few years of architecture, but did not graduate. A few wooden ships, a couple of skiffs and over a hundred houses later, I am still doing carpentry, and sometimes do interesting stuff like doors, fancy windows, stairs, cabinets, I do some furniture too, a begginner in woodturning.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#11

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Allen Neighbors

>Ellis, I learned how to use most woodworking tools from my Dad. He was a maker of fine furniture. He was always building something. I began woodworking in ernest in 1972 when a lady asked me to build her some custom cabinets in her kitchen. I paid for my first tools with that first job. When I retired from the Army, I built my shop. Did a lot of flat work for years, and then saw some hollow forms in Lawton, OK. I thought, "I can do that". For two years I used only homemade tools, after the Oland style. (Thanks to Darrell Feltmate)

Through making my own tools, I've had to learn a little bit about working with metal. As you said, one compliments the other. I'd also like a small metal lathe.

I like to make things that make my shop more efficient, and that always leads to some sort of design possibilities.

Thanks for asking.

Allen

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#12

Dick Hines

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Dick Hines

>I will jump on most anything that need doing around the house. Some of it fun and some, working under a sink, are a pain in the butt. I will useily give it a try and if I fail then and only then will get a pro.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#13

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Bill Crommett

>When I had my cataract removed, I gave the surgen a small bowl of spalted Maple in appreciation for getting my eyesight back to better. He asked me "how did you learn to do that? " My reply was "The same way you learned to cut open eyes --- just pick up a knife and start

cutting " Well, I must have misjudged his sense of humor, because he changed the subject real quick.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#14

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>A lot of my early furniture looked carpentry :>).

Some of the things I do, Turning, furniture (I've started making Mission furniture to sell), tool making, blacksmithing, weaving and braiding, building looms, etc. for the weaving and drawing. I'm just getting started on carving.

A lot of it is due to people needing something oddball and asking me to make it. Once I start researching something it tends to take on a life of it's own. I have a fascination with how people in the past accomplished the things they did with such meager resources.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#15

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Dale Sherman, Manlius, NY

>As a kid I helped my Dad do bodywork on cars as well as fix or build any number of things. I still have the finely crafted 60's style shelving unit he built (ands us kids helped sand). I wish I still had the gravity gokart he built for us. It was all wood except for the sophisticated steering frontend. I was amazed to see how he took common raw materials and built this mechanical marvel.

I was about seven when my Mother showed me how to do 3D drafting on a Cheerios box, cut it out, fold and tape it up to end up with a toy truck. After that, I saw the possibilities for any material to morph into anything. I'm talking about much more than beer can shims for a motorcycle.

Since that time, I've made a hang glider out of tent materials, a ski jack out of a bicycle and barrel staves, dinner out of condiments, and yes, most anything you can imagine out of wood.

Wood being the miracle medium that it is, it's no wonder that it is a primary material for almost any creative endeavor.

I've made houses, log homes, treehouses, fine furniture, rustic furniture, model planes, bicycles, Rube Goldberg machines, toys, puzzles, sculpture, tools, arbors, clothing, musical instruments, bowls, plates, spoons, and educational displays; all using wood. Designing with wood is a wonderful experience of combining left and right brain functions into a facinating process of problem-solving. While the various types of wood provide an endless array of possible design applications, marrying wood with other materials exponentially adds to the design possibilities.

Currently my work involves making interactive energy education displays, custom furniture, tool innovation, and designing voice research equipment. I find my broad spectrum of work experience enhances my design forays in all directions.

As far as my favorite, I find anything where I get to work out a design problem, whether for aesthetic or functional considerations, is my preferred activity. It could be making a record player tone arm look like a 10d nail through a 2x4, a rustic chair so comfortable you fall asleep, or a bowl with that WOW factor.

Oh yeah, about my mailbox out front? It's sitting on top of a PT 1x6 bolted to the side of a RR tie that is upended in the ground. It's ugly. But as I explore the design options, they pop up faster than I can wade through them. Do I make it swing-away in case the snowplow hits it, Dr. Seussian in style, Mission, or just utilitarian(nah)? Whatever my new mailbox mount looks like, I will certainly have fun with it, and I'll be sure to post pics.

Dale

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#16

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

David Breth

>I tackle those kind of jobs as the great unknown. I replaced a faucet the other day. Days. Whatever. First stage is assessment - can I actually pull this off successfully, or will I get stuck and have to call a professional? I'm slow at household repairs, and cautious in my assessment/planning. Always have to make multiple trips for supplies, always costs 30% more than I thought, always takes double the time, but at the end of the day, I did it. Usually pretty Well. And next time it will be better. And that's the appeal. Same goes for woodworking, in particular turning. The critical eye involved with fine woodworking (I can not credibly call my turnings "fine") that makes you see the flaw in a bowl, and move one more step up the learning curvce for next time, is the same eye that remembers the pitfalls you encountered under the blank blank blank sink and remembers it for next time.

Although it will take awhile for me to forget how uncomfortable, compromising, and painful it is to lay under a sink and deal with ornery connections, poor visibility, and slime.

David B.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#17

Re: Slime

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>David,

It just makes the compression rings turn a bit easier |;-}}

m

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#18

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Bob Fawcett

>I took apart the telephone and reassembled it in working order at age 4. I have always been interested in how things work.

I helped my dad refinish furniture at a young age. He taught me a lot about tools of all kinds and how to use them. One of my first jobs was in a machine shop in a small town in Florida.

After a failed first attempt at college, I got a job as an auto mechanic. I worked for several dealerships, and later had my own shop for 4 years. I moved back to Georgia, went back to school, and changed careers. I put myself through college welding at Great Dane Trailers.

These days I am a computer network engineer. I have been doing woodworking for as a hobby for a number of years. I have built furniture. I have built speakers for stereo and pro sound applications. I very recently got into turning.

I find problem solving is what I do best. It helps me in all of these things. Most of it requires some amount of design work.

I have done some metalwork, woodwork, automotive, computer related, audio electronics, speaker design. As you can see my only limit is what interests me.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#19

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Rick Davenport

>I must say that I do not fit the mold of any of the survey respondents so far.

I am not particularly handy around the house.

I will gladly pay a plumber to do what he does.

Multiple attempts, multiple leaks and multiple trips to the hardware store just don't seem like a good use of my time.

I haven't personally changed the oil in my car in decades.

My carpentry skills are minimal.

But I love wood.

I always have.

The look, the touch, the warmth, the unending variety.

After 30 years in the work force as a successful (and quite unorthodox) salesperson, sales manager, marketing manager and general manager of a variety of businesses I decided to make a change.

A year and a half ago I bought a delta midi and a Tormek sharpening system. Then a bandsaw and drill press. And a bunch of tools. Read a lot of books, viewed a lot of videos, bought more tools, turned a lot of crappy stuff, took a few classes, joined the local AAW, bought a new PM3520, dust collector, and more tools, etc. etc. etc.

I am hooked.

Unlike some of you more analytical and precise types, I treat wood turning as a process of discovery; the wood usually dictates to me what should be done. I seldom have preconceived notions of the outcome.

My wood sources have been questionable until recently and I have turned a lot of stuff most of you wouldn't touch.

Resulting in one of a kind pieces that occasionally are quite cool (to me).

I have set up my Tormek in my van and have a reasonably successful mobile sharpening business that finances my turning habit.

I am enjoying my late career change immensely.

Just don't ask me to do any wiring or plumbing.

Rick

"Life shouldn't be dull."

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#20

Brad Vietje

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Brad Vietje

>Within the field of woodworking, I do very little flat work -- almost exclusively turning, though I've also been renovating a small house and building an office and shop in a large barn. For other creative and/or hands-on outlets, I also grind and polish telescope optics by hand, and build telescopes (www.stellafane.com). My turning of fine details has been greatly aided by fine motor skills I developed doing microscopic surgery and dealing with the really, really tiny (electron microscopy) in my first career as a neuroscientist.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#21

Stellafane!

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Wow Brad,

I don't grind lenses, but have been to a few Stellafane gatherings and enjoy them enormously. Hope I can come stargazing this year and meet you too.

Jorge

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#22

Roger in MO

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

Roger in MO

>Woodworking experience has ranged from doll furniture (grandma says Sally needs a table and chairs) to furniture for our home to building sheds and small barns to Habitat for Humanity houses. Plumbing, wiring, roofing all were learned. Metal experience has included forging, sand casting, investment wax casting, welding. From a forged cold chisel to a small backhoe. A VW bug was overhauled because son needed transportation.In almost every case a perceived need for something and a need to minimize cost have been the motivation.

Regardless of the type of work, plans and work sequences must be developed, tools obtained by borrowing, buying or making, and skills must be learned.

Books, magazines, observation, classes, as well as "I wonder if this would work or if I could do such and such" play a big part in the process.

At 69 years young, necessity is less of a motivator than the challenge of learning something new. I got back into turning about a year or so ago after several years of flat work after retirement. The contributors to this forum do some fantastic work and are a great source of ideas. Hopefully my skills with continue to improve.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MAY ***

#23

Brad Vietje

Re: Stellafane!

Brad Vietje

>Jorge,

Never thought someone here at WC would know about Stellafane !

WoodCentral and Badger Pond have their enthusiasts, but Stellafane has a nearly cult following going back 80 years. Hope you can come this summer (last weekend in July). We now have a 60' x 100' pavilion that will be unveiled this summer -- no more leaky tents !

If you want to come for a pretty neat camping experience, contact me about coming a few days early, during what we call Pre-Con. That's when we usually get the best observing, and this year I may even bring down my new/old Comet mini lathe and mess around making tops and boxes and all when the days work is done. Coming early means you might have to help paint a building, hang parking signs, or something like that, but its a great group, and a small price to pay for a better and longer Stellafane experience. Its pretty neat looking through a 36" telescope when there's only a dozen or two people hanging around, and 2 observatories there to play with too ! Contact me directly for more info...

Brad Vietje

Woodturning Addict

STM Prez., too...