We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>For those of you that saw my first goblet attempt posting, here is my second attempt.
From square blank to finished piece was 4.5 hours, but I was very pleased with the result. Thank you Chris Wright, Gary Ljostad and John Williams for the inspiration and Eli Avisera for the Demo and instruction.
Just under 12� tall, ~2.25� diameter cup and base, 1/8� diameter stem. Wood is Mahogany, comments and critiques are welcome.
Wow! What a lovely goblet. I don't see a thing I'd change on it. Mahogany is such a non-descript wood, but you have made this piece a visually exciting object to look at. The cup has a beautiful bell shape and the stem looks flawless from here. The details under the cup and above the base are simple yet elegant. A very nice job indeed. I'm sure this was a heart pounder to get off the lathe, but when it finally came off....I'm imagining a Snoopy Dance was in order :)
>Chris Very good job. It takes skill to do that sort of thing. Like other turners I'm always impressed with the skills it takes to do that sort of thing. My only critic would be that it's hard to use one of these, or to sell them. I know we all like to do them and you certainly did a good job (and I like to turn them also) but now what do you do with it? It kind of reminds me of the time someone asked John Jordan about wall thickness on a vessel. He said turn a really thin vessel and then get over it. In other word, turn one so you know you have the skills to do it, but then make it the wall thickness that is appropriate for that piece. I think the same is true for goblets. We all need to make one really thin, and with a really long stem, but then we should put that under our belts and make goblets that fit the need of that goblet.
Anyway I hope you don't take this the wrong way, I'm simply pondering why we do these things (me included). Keep up the good work. I look forward to seeing more.
Wow that is alot. I guess I am a goal oriented person. I set a goal to learn to turn a goblet like this. Since I havent found my own voice or style of turning I am working on skill and trying different things to build a base to grow from. Also I found it fun like you mentioned.
As to what to do with it? I like looking at them. What do we do with hollow forms? I think there is utilitarian turnings and more "art" or less functional peices. I dont me to call my peice art but it does nothing but look pleasing to me and maybe a few others. So it sits in my display cabinet for people to see and for me to realize that I acheived one of my goals.
Does this answer your question? I am interested in what others think.
>Chris I ask because I get that question from all of my fellow employees everytime I bring something in that isn't obviously useful. You could bring in the most beautiful burl hollow vessel and someone would ask, what do you do with that. As woodworkers we often work withh wood simply because it's beautiful. I kept a carefully sanded offcut hanging on my wall for a while until I gave it away to a friend. That's how woodworkers think. Turners on the other hand will try to make things that test our skill and impress your fellow turners. Take my miniature goblets for example. Exactly the opposite of what you are doing but functionally not very practical.
Out of necessity I now sell most all my work and so I tend to look at some things as, will this sell or not. I could sell a goblet like this but it would sit on the shelf much longer than other products and in my market would not bring the money equal to the time involved. Some markets could probably get the money for a piece like this. Stewar Batty sells his for $400 and up. Maybe I need to change my name, I'd be lucky to get $40 for it around here. That may explain where my comment came from.
I'm always impressed with the skill it takes to turn anything long and thin and love to look at them and I think most readers of this board feel the same. My hat's off to you. Wish there was a way we could show the public how hard it is to do that sort of thing. Unfortunately by the time you develop the skill to turn something like that you also tend to make it look easy so no one understands how delicate those cuts are.
I understand what you are saying. I turn as a hobby and thinking about selling anything is way down on my thoughts or priorities when turning or thinking of a piece (at least for now). I am more inclined to trade with other turners that I admire. This allows me to enjoy work that I am not inclined to do etc.