Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

Posts

Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#1

Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

Russ Fairfield

>I must be doing something wrong. I am missing out on all of the fun of having to tear a drill apart. I have a Sioux angle drill that is going on 15 years and a Milwaukee that I bought 7 years ago as insurance after learning that the old Sioux was way past living on borrowed time. I had the chuck fall apart on the Milwaukee, but I have never had a bearing failure on either of them.

Am I doing something wrong?? I have never been able to understand why some folks replace their bearings every couple years, and I don't. Maybe I don't sand as much wood? Maybe they aren't making them as good as they used to? Maybe the bearings are shot and I don't know the difference.

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#2

Now you did it..

Harvey Meyer in Atlanta

>You just put the curse on both drills. Expect to replace bearings real soon. I've been using my Sioux for about 5 years and I know the rear bearing needs to be replaced since it screams at me every now and then. I blow it out and keep on sanding. When I get arountuit, I'll replace the bearing.

Harvey

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#3

Its in the use of the tool...

Peter Teubel

>Folks who have to replace the bearings frequently use the drill for sanding...almost EXCLUSIVILY. They rarely see a drill bit or anything BUT a sanding disc in the chuck.

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#4

Re: Its in the use of the tool...

robo hippy

>I just had my Milwaukee drill fail on me after about 6 months. That is the usual life expectancy for the S/M drills in my shop. Most likely bearings, again. I do a lot of bowls, and use them hard, with 3 inch sanding pads. I had one of the $29.95 drills, and it lasted about a month and a half. I am now out to see how long it takes me to wear out one of the pneumatic Sioux drills. It does keep the compressor running continuously while in use, so the electric bill will go up a bit. The air flow switch is hard to fine tune, and the max rpm is 2200. Other than that, I like it. Now, how long will it last??? I like a challenge.

robo hippy

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#5

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Russ, I sort of wondered that myself. I have been using my drill as a sander, with occasional use as a drill for three or four years now, and no one has ever accused me of being easy on things. But, it is running just fine, and does not seem to be in any stage of failure (yet).

Bill

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#6

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

John Lucas

>I have a $69 Dewalt straight drill and have been using it a lot for both sanding and drilling operations and I'm guessing it's around 5 years old. I wonder if it has to do with how much pressure you put on the drill while you sand. I don't sand at full speed. I slow the wood down to a crawl and then run the drill at about 1/2 speed.

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#7

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

david

>Mine was running fine after about two years, but I bought a sealed bearing as insurance against the original one failing in the future. Decided to take the drill apart to replace the bearing, and my mechanical ineptitude resultled in the drill not running after I put it back together. Now, unless TD is able to solve the problem, it will end up in the trash. Morale of the story? If it aint broke.....

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#8

Re: Low mileage??

Russ Fairfield

>These 2 drills have never seen a drill bit. Both are 1200 RPM. I sand at slow RPMs with nothing but 2" discs. I blow the dust out of the cooling slots when the drill starts running hot. Other than that I don't know that I am doing anything different from anyone else.

I have no idea whether I sand more or less wood than those who are having bearing problems. I know that I am not the worlds most prolific woodturner, but I have sanded 1200 salad bowls and 400 plates and platters that I can account for in the past 15 years. I have no idea of the quantities of other things in that same time.

If the number of sanding discs is any measure, I just took an inventory, and I will be soon ordering more of the of the 36" X 39" sheets of flannel backed paper for the 4th time in the 10 years since I have been cutting my own sanding discs. I have no idea how many pre-cut discs I had use before that. That equates to about 6000 sanding discs (2") in various grits from 60 to 400. To me, that is a lot of sanding discs. Others must have higher and rougher mileage on their drills.

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#9

Chinese bearings are standard now

TDaniel

>In the past couple of years chinese bearings have been use. They are good for about 2 years max. The ones sold by Enco are the same quality made in the same place. I change mine out to a higher quality bearing and so far, none of these have failed.

TD

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#10

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

Bob Fawcett

>I wonder if its the amount of pressure used for sanding. I see advice that you don't need much pressure to sand efficiently. I wonder if some don't overload their bearings by applying more pressure.

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#11

Re: Chinese bearings are standard now

DWFII

>TD,

Wheere do you get the "higher quality" bearings?

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#12

Better bearing part number:

TDaniel

>Koyo EE 1 1/2 2RSM3GSR Japan

You should be able to get this or an equivalent from any industrial bearing supply.

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#13

soon

TDaniel

>Don't give up David, I'll tear into it shortly. I had put so many things off til after the Gathering that I just can't seem to catch up. After this week-end things will be back to normal.

TD

Re: Milwaukee/Sioux and failing bearings

#14

Re: Better bearing part number:

DWFII

>Thanks TD

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon