Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Should turners study ART?

Posts

Should turners study ART?

#1

Keith Tompkins

Should turners study ART?

Keith Tompkins

>A previous post brought up a topic I encounter frequently...should turners study art? There seems to be two schools of thought: Turners don't need all this artsy stuff, with enough practice, our work will improve steadily. The second school of thought (one that I prescribe to) is that by studying art, we can improve our work at an accelerated pace, by applying known design principles.

Are the artist types raising the bar, or are they ruining the craft of turning? Do you enjoy turnings that are highly embellished, or are these artistic pieces making it impossible to appreciate a well turned pure form? Is it still possible for a "pure" turner to break into the "big-time"?

Have you personally studied art or design topics? Would you consider it? I would like to start a dialog, pro or con...

Re: Should turners study ART?

#2

Good topic

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I think it depends on what you want to get out of turning. Some turners are happy doing production work or making furniture parts and making copies of items someone else designed. They take satisfaction in producing these parts in the highest quality. Other turners like to make objects that barely resemble traditional turnings and even are hard to identify as turnings. Their primary satisfaction is in creating something different. There is nothing wrong with either camp. I think most of us fall somewhere in between. I think it is very hard for a traditional turner to make it big time in venues like the A.A.W. or Art and Craft circles. There is just too much demand on creativity there. Maybe, they could make it big in the furniture and architectural camps by doing impeccable work. Studying art should help and shouldn�t hurt. The art world has it�s own pitfalls though. My daughter is an Art major at Kent State University, (ceramics). I see so much done in the art field to please other artists and art critics and not to make art for the general public. I see this in some of our turnings too! We turn what will please other turners sometimes or jump on the bandwagon of what is popular. I don�t think any of us can avoid that completely. A well-done simple bowl is going to be pleasing to most people. It takes a fair amount of skill to do well, but not a lot of creativity. A piece like Keith�s �Skippin School� takes more skill and a great amount of creativity, but there are some people that just will not like it and wonder why he wasted all that time. (I like it very much by the way) I think that there is greater risk in the creative pieces, because the rewards of success seem to be higher, and failure is a rejection of both turning skill and the idea presented in the piece. I�ll try both and try to learn from every turning and piece of Art I see.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#3

Re: Should turners study ART?

RussFairfield

>The answer to your question is "Yes", and "No". Which answer applies depends on where we want to go with our woodturning.

If we are satisfied with being proficient in the tool skills and techniques (the swordsmanship of woodturning), and we are happy with copying the forms and shapes of others, then the answer is "No".

If we want to do things that are uniquely our own, the answer is "Yes" because we must think in shapes and forms, and develop our imagination. That ability to think "artistically" comes from the study of art. There are a few who are fortunate to have it naturally, but most of us have to learn it.

To answer your other questions.

"Are the artist types raising the bar, or are they ruining the craft of turning?"

If by "the craft of woodturning" you mean the techniques and swordmanship, the answer is Yes, they are raising the bar, and NO, they are not ruining the craft. New forms and shapes have forced us to develop new tools and techniques. An example is the "hollow form". If someone had not made the first hollow form, we wouldn't have had the need for boring bars, captured hollowing systems, and laser beams. And, the development of those tools is still going on.

"Do you enjoy turnings that are highly embellished, or are these artistic pieces making it impossible to appreciate a well turned pure form?"

This question is the same as asking if I can like Italian opera, jazz, classical, and rock music all at the same time. Of course I can, because I appreciate the talent and artistry to do all music well. However, when it comes to sitting down and creating my own music, it is straight ahead jazz all the way. Woodturning isn't much different. YES, I enjoy looking at the highly embellished, and NO, they don't make it impossible to appreciate a well done "pure form".

"Is it still possible for a "pure" turner to break into the "big-time"?"

This question reminds me of the lie that I heard all of my working life - that there was equal opportunity and compensation in the separate tracks of management and technical proficiency. The truth is that they are nowhere near equal, and management always paid better and had more opportunities for advancement. Woodturning is no different. The artists get the attention of the press, the fame, and their work in the "Big Time" Galleries; and the skilled swordsman has to be satisfied with being the teacher. Teaching might pay well, and often better than the art, but there is nowhere near the same recognition.

While most of the recognition goes to the "artists", but every once in awhile someone who has stayed true to the "pure form" gains recognition. Bill Luce is a recent example. Bill still makes "pure" bowl forms. He is in Del Mano, and his work is invited into many art exhibitions. That ain't bad for a bowl turner, and I congratulate him for that.

"Have you personally studied art or design topics? Would you consider it?"

Two questions that I don't know how to answer. All of life has been a learning experience, and I have managed to remember a few things. Other than that, NO I have never studied art, and probably never will.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#4

Re: Should turners study ART?

georgetroy

>Short and sweet no. It's too late for me to study Art. However I enjoy drawing on the computer and making designs for segmented turning. I could care less about the so-called golden rule of proportions. I also enjoy drawing cartoons on my computer. GT

Re: Should turners study ART?

#5

Re: Should turners study ART?

Carol from AZ

>Best class I ever took was an Art Composition class. Learning something about color, space, mass, weight, balance, and shape has pushed me to think outside the box and try designs not printed anywhere.

I just finished a pulpit. I built most of it in a friend's shop because my tools are packed away while I am in school. He is a paper plans kinda guy. After 2-1/2 weeks with me working with just pencil sketches, he came away with saying, he learned more about woodworking in that short span of time that he had over twenty years. I didn't teach him anything about technique. If anything we swapped a few good ideas. What he learned was a new way to think about what he was building and what might be possible.

All in all, not a bad thing.

One of the reasons I got a mini lathe and need to get back to it, is because turning allows that out of the box designing on the fly. Easier to do that when working flat stuff. Exciting stuff.

Also why I took some lessons from Wally. ;-)

Re: Should turners study ART?

#6

Re: Should turners study ART?

Ed Kelle

>I am biased. Though I come from the reverse of what you ask, artist getting into turning. I still struggle with both but I tend to trust my judgment on the art side even if it does not always meet eye to eye with other peoples points of view.

Turners don't have to study art, not if they don't want to, but they should at least be willing to know what to look for when they look at their works in progress. Yes in progress, before it is too late to change a piece. Take it off the lathe and look at it upright, it makes a big difference, no matter if you have a solid background behing the piece while turning.

Our design chats made a huge difference in how I look at pieces and for that i am grateful to all who particiated.

I might get artsy more often that not, but still I do appreciate pure forms that are done well. They might look easy to many non turners, but to those who know, they are anything but simple.

Everyone can benefit from even basic art knowledge, but it can be worked around. Just like musicians who play by ear.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Good topic

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Tom, You bring up many good points. I previously worked in the furniture industry, and afterwards as a self-employeed cabinet maker. My biggest frustration was that I was designing and making things for others, to suit their needs. I built many things I designed myself but they were not the things I FELT. There was no joy in making these pieces.

In my turning, I feel free. I can make anything I please; nobody is setting limits or guidelines. AND, I feel no obligation to stick with just lathe work; again, I'm free to do as I wish. What a great feeling! I can take some of the design stuff I learned during my flat work, and apply it to my turning.

Is there risk in producing artistic pieces? Last year, I sent two of my pieces to Del Mano Gallery for their Small Treasures show...something they expected. I also sent a "Rose" piece...something completely unexpected. It turned out to be a very good decision. Keep in mind that the galleries as a rule do not want surprises....they can sell signature pieces and may have difficulty selling something new. A risk that paid off.

This year, I decided to make the "fish" pieces for the same exhibit, completely unannounced. I felt great about it until I shipped them...then I started getting some doubts about the wisdom of my decision. What if the gallery didn't like the new pieces? Should I have played it safe and sent some rose pieces instead? Did I just derail my turning career? After all, my pieces would be among the work by some of the best turners in the world. Then, I got the DREADED phone call. "Listen Keith, we have a serious problem with your pieces." I KNEW IT! My heart was pounding. This is not going to be a good call at all. It turns out, that on opening night, one of my pieces was sold to two different people. AND someone else ordered the same piece online. WHEW, a good kind of problem to have...and, now more orders.

I think you are right Tom, the rewards can be great as well. My fish received such a good reception that it was moved to its own place right at the entrance to the gallery. The topper is if I can complete another one done on time, it's scheduled to be shown in SOFA NY...as good as it gets. Another is going to "Design in Wood" juried competion in California. My other galleries want pieces as well, so I'll be making fish for some time to come. I took a chance here, but I think the risk paid off. It easily could have gone the other way. (I don't intend this as a gloat, I am trying to keep that kind of message to a minimum. )

You are correct that some people won't like artistic pieces like "Skippin' School". I don't think it's easy for anyone to deal with negative comments about their work...I try not to let those comments get to me, and focus on the positive part.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#8

Re: Should turners study ART?

Rick Davenport

>Absolutely!

The most valuable thing I have ever learned is how much I DON'T know.

Understanding the fundamentals of form, color, space, shape, etc. will make me a better turner.

Just as going to every turning demonstration I can get to will make me improve (not to mention practice, practice, practice).

I plan to NEVER stop learning as long as I am alive.

There is an old saying: "A tree that stops growing is dead."

It applies to life, turning, marriage, religion, politics, you name it.

Okay I'm done rambling now.......

Rick

Re: Should turners study ART?

#9

Re: Should turners study ART?

gary s clarke

>Each turner should answer for him/her self. Today I don't care to, but tomorrow I might if the class or book sounds interesting. Get up in the morning and instead of sitting in a rocking chair do what you feel like, maybe even rock a little :o)

Re: Should turners study ART?

#10

Re: Should turners study ART?

Donna Banfield

>I lean sort of in Rick's direction...I try to keep an open mind with most things, believing that knowledge is power. I may hear an opinion that I disagree with, but if I don't listen or hear that person out, my own opinion is narrow-minded.

Like Russ pointed out earlier in this post (and which he's pointed out in previous postings -- I've read them), some people are born with the talent, and some have to work at it. I'm one of those people that have to work at it..and work at it...and work at it...

So, I fall on the side of wanting to learn from other artists, wherever there talents may be. If I pick up a thing or two from them, I might find a way to incorporate their knowledge and ideas into something that I'm working on ...or might work on in the future.

So I say, bring it on...all of it...saturate me with the knowledge that you have. I may forget some of it, but hopefully retain most of it.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Should turners study ART?

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Russ, I love your music analogy...I frequently compare turning to playing and creating music. Bill Luce is one of the few pure turners to make it big recently that I can think of. He is who I was thinking of when I posed the question.

I think the fact that the artistic guys get all the glory must annoy many excellent turners; many of them deserve the same publicity but don't receive it.

I don't think it's that important to have formal training as an artist, but it's good to be aware of the fundamentals...

Re: Should turners study ART?

#12

Brad Vietje

Absatively !

Brad Vietje

>Absolutely -- if they want to produce the best work they can.

Even a turner who only turns chair parts should study the history and the art of making chairs. Designing a newel post or a table leg can be done willy-nilly, and we are free to express whatever moves us -- which can be a lot of fun, and very satisfying. However, if you are making a table of a certain style, perhaps studying the masters of that style and time would be helpful. I'd consider that studying art, or at least good design.

"Studying" art can take many forms -- even participating in discussions and debates here at WC might qualify. WHY do we like one piece so much, and why DON'T we like another ? What is it about the size of the foot, the weight of the finial, or the balance of the figure that works, or doesn't. What is proper Victorian convention in spindle design elements, and how does that differ from Louis XIV, Colonial, or other periods...

We can all study art by just looking at images of ceramics, glass, sculpture, architecture, and more. There's a lot to be gained from studying the old masters.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Should turners study ART?

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Should turners study ART?

Keith Tompkins

>HI CArol, that's great! I think that's the best part...creative ideas almost explode as the work progresses. Your friend was fortunate to work with you. I bet it changed his whole outlook.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Absatively !

Keith Tompkins

>I agree Brad. I enjoy turning a perfect windsor chair leg or stretcher as much as anything else I do. Proportion and balance are just as important in flat work as in turning. DO you think the old masters considered design? You bet they did! I don't think I'll ever create anything approaching the perfection of the queen Anne leg with the ball and claw foot. Study the classics....

Re: Should turners study ART?

#15

Re: Should turners study ART?

Spindle turner ticked off

>I see something on this forum. We have the all knowing philosopher that's you, Keith. The number one problem with turning, its broad. There's 10 different categories of turners, pens, bowls, spindle, etc. That's it though, they are different. By one person trying to be the almighty and saying "people copy the shapes of others." Is it satisfying, yes, to use my skew all day when I would probably have to give you a beading tool to roll a bead! You make a mistake or a bad cut, you change the shape or fill it with CA and some filler. A spindle turner makes a bad cut, its done. Start over. It isn't take some more off, they no longer match, its junk. Is it "art?" It is more that a picture of a pile of crap on newspaper which just sold for 12,000 dollars in NYC. While you're saying everyone should be "artists" what's a artist someone with the discipline of the craft for turning or someone who hollows out a ball and paints it for 1200 dollars.

For someone with great ideas, I haven't seen your DVD in any catalog lately. For all of these stones your throwing.

Art is in the eye of beholder. Art is defined as easily as love. My two year calls herself an artist. The term is used too much!

Get off the platform you're on and turn something.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#16

Yes...and no.

Peter Teubel

>Depends on your goal. If you want to become an artist (regardless of the medium used), yes. Personally, I'm far too left-brained for the conceptual part of "art". I prefer to excel in the technical aspects of the craft of woodturning. I get the same satisfaction from making a nice one-off bowl as I do from rolling the perfect bead on a 50 piece spindle order. Is my work "Art"? Hell no. Sometimes artisic, but never "Art".

Re: Should turners study ART?

#17

My two cents...

David

>It is my belief that you are the product of your environment, whether it is what you choose to do in staying home and never leaving, or traveling the world and seeing all sorts of things. Your mind or brain internalizes your experiences, and this affects what you do, consciously or unconsciously. Then what you do all comes down to taste. Your finished product will be done when your brain tells you that you have achieved the goal you had set out to do. The final product also has to be internalized with the sum of all you have been exposed to. A crudely finished weed pot may look great to you, until you see the beauty of one of Wally's trademark forms, and you will then realize that you have a long way to go. This is where taste comes in. Taste will tell you whether you measure up. Taste will guide your quest for the near perfect form of one of Bill Luce's bowls. I firmly believe that you will develop taste only when you are exposed to a broad range of products where you will then have to make a choice of what you accept as good versus what is mediocre. Studying art is one way to get there, but not the only way.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#18

Re: Should turners study ART?

RK in Milw

>Keith, I really enjoy the threads you start regarding design and art.

I have been a commercial photographer for 30 years and although I never took formal art training, I sure did have to study art. I went to seminars and lectures and read books. Working with art directors taught me a lot as well. I have always felt that I had an advantage in not going to college in that I got to choose my instructors and they were the best in the business.

I have been turning for two years, and my art background has definitely accelerated my learning curve. I can visualize form, shape, line and texture. I understand balance and proportion but I have to work darn hard at achieving these things. I am a strong proponent of copying other artists to begin with as a way of studying or self teaching the artistic side of this pursuit.

I still believe that every child in grade school should study art and music. Art enhances the quality of life for everyone and it has already been proven that kids who study art and music do much better at overall acedemics.

I like spindle turning; peppermills and finials, I like hollow vessel turning and I like turning bowls; artistic and utilitarian. Truth be told, I just love making shavings and many evenings are spent do just that. I often like to pop a stick on the lathe and practice with a skew and spindle gouge.

Do I think every turner should study art. No. Some turners and woodworkers like to putter or make craft items and I think that's wonderful. They also have much to teach. They may turn for relaxation, to make a few bucks, make furniture parts; whatever. If we could get more kids building something, antything, they wouldn't turn to destructive outlets. I think we can trace the decline of American society to the day they took the woodshops out of the junior high schools and high schools.

I have what I call a low boredom threshold and so I have to be learning new things all of the time. Lately, I have been challenging myself to loosen up at break away from the expected or norm. After all, I have a kid studying art in college and she is damned good at it, so I have to keep up with her.

Whatever your approach to turning, however, I do think that you should insure adequate fiber in your diet. Makes you less crabby, you know:)

Ron Nelson

Re: Should turners study ART?

#19

Re: Should turners study ART?

john lucas

>Wow did we get up on the wrong side of the bed. I don't think Keith or anyone else is trying to get on a high horse. I think we can discuss the use of art principals when we talk about spindles just as well. It isn't necessary to follow any of these ideas it's simply a language to allow you to discuss such things as negative space, line, form etc so that each of us are talking the same language. We are simply trying to discuss what makes something beautiful and it has been learned a long time ago that there are principals that can be applied to common objects that everone finds successful. The "artists" are simply trying to understand why this and then apply it to thier work.

I have studied lots of spindles and you can make very subtle changes that seperate a really good spindle from a mediocre one. Understanding the Golden rule is simply one of these things. If you look at a windsor chair designed by Curtis Buchannan you will see this. The legs of his chairs have rally pleasing shaped compared to most others. The difference is very subtle but his chairs sell so well they are back ordered most of the year.

By the way I think Keith was simply posing a question for us to ponder. I don't see how that can be miscontrued into thinking he's high and Mighty. I see nothing wrong with turning hundreds of spindles a year, architectural turners make good money but some of us don't enjoy production work and want to make one of a kind "artsy" pieces. I don't see a problem with that either.

As far as studying Art which was the original question. Why not. I'm not narrow minded enough to think I know it all. I have the choice to accept or reject anything they teach me in an art class so what can possible be wrong with it. Will it help my work. Maybe. Will it hurt my work. I doubt it. I will have a visual language that allows me to hold an intelligent discussion with other turners of like mind.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#20

Re: Should turners study ART?

john lucas

>RK as a photographer myself I am surprised how much is translated woodturning. Just the visual accuity of having to study shapes and spaces really makes me look at my turnings with more care. It's almost like putting a frame around things like we do in the camera. I see the negative spaces and how the form fills the rectangle. I think this has really helped me in my turning. In fact if you take a photo of a piece and then print it out on paper you can make sketches on the paper to see how you might improve the shape.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#21

Brad Vietje

Re: Should turners study ART?

Brad Vietje

>Good Morning, Spindle Turner Pissed Off,

I hope the iron isn't quite so hot as last night. I agree with John's reply, that Keith is posing a question, and while he gives the answer for HIM, that may not be the answer for you or me.

My response was more along the lines of being the best we can be. I learned a lot from a pretty well-known production spindle turner, and really, it was just enough to know how much I don't know!

There's a heck of a lot to really high quality spindle turning, so I'll bet you already have studied art -- though you may not have called it that. In designing and executing a pair of end tables from a certain period of history, we need to study the proper, authentic form to get it right. What's the central figure, and the spacing between the elements, and so on. Getting 8 legs and all the other elements exactly the same is no little walk in the park, and it requires great skill, developed over thousands of hours of practice. Getting just the right shape requires knowledge of the art of furniture design, which requires a study of that art form, whether by hands-on practice, years of apprenticeship, or time spent at a drafting table.

I'm betting you're more "studied" in "art" than you let on, and could teach the likes of me a thing or three.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Should turners study ART?

#22

Re: Should turners study ART?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I think it is important to study lots of things, not just art. I really hated school when I was a kid, but I always enjoyed learning. I took a class to learn Spanish a couple of years ago at the local community college. I got a mental picture of me returning to Art 101 or something like that - crammed into one of those stupid desks again listening to some professor drone on and on, and having to look at a bunch of stuff that I absolutely detest because some egghead thinks it is important.

I think we need to be observant to what is going on around us. I like order and beauty in art, not a lot of the political stuff that passes for art. I get more out of sitting on the porch and looking at the plants growing in the yard, even the weeds, to learn more about the shapes that God put into creation. Even the catenary curves of the telephone lines right outside my window give me ideas.

Maybe this approach limits me somewhat, but there is a lot that passes for art these days that should not see the light of day. So with all this, I will close with this time worn phrase: I may not know art, but I know what I like. ;-)

Bill

Re: Should turners study ART?

#23

Open mouth insert foot

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Are you serious or just trolling? Keith comes from a furniture background. He can turn matching spindles and turn beads with a skew. Don't degrade his skills if you don't know what they are. You do make some good points. There is a lot of schlock passed on as art. Does that mean we have to throw out the good art and artists with the posers? I don't think so. Real art takes a lot of hard work. We would have a pretty bleak world without good art. Some of these people that do pass off bad work as art should get salesman of the year awards. Good art will pass the test of time. Bad art will be forgotten except maybe by those who it really pisses off.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#24

Re: What a difference the capital.....

JamieDonaldson

>...letters in ART makes!? I believe art is around us everywhere, but when a proponent of ART tries to post a definition the subject begins to draw lines in the sand that many resist crossing. The term "design" could perhaps be better used and less baggage encumbered than big letter ART, even though the underlying principles and perceptions are the same.

Re: Should turners study ART?

#25

Re: Should turners study ART?

Rick Davenport

>One thing for sure.....

No matter what I'm doing, whether it be turning wood, playing tennis, making love or making a sales call - I will do it poorly if I'm ticked off.

Anger sucks the spirit, creativity and joy out of anything I do.

In the words of Dr. Sidney Friedman (from the MASH TV show)

"Loosen up, take my advice, drop your pants and slide on the ice."

Rick