Re: Should turners study ART?
RussFairfield
>The answer to your question is "Yes", and "No". Which answer applies depends on where we want to go with our woodturning.
If we are satisfied with being proficient in the tool skills and techniques (the swordsmanship of woodturning), and we are happy with copying the forms and shapes of others, then the answer is "No".
If we want to do things that are uniquely our own, the answer is "Yes" because we must think in shapes and forms, and develop our imagination. That ability to think "artistically" comes from the study of art. There are a few who are fortunate to have it naturally, but most of us have to learn it.
To answer your other questions.
"Are the artist types raising the bar, or are they ruining the craft of turning?"
If by "the craft of woodturning" you mean the techniques and swordmanship, the answer is Yes, they are raising the bar, and NO, they are not ruining the craft. New forms and shapes have forced us to develop new tools and techniques. An example is the "hollow form". If someone had not made the first hollow form, we wouldn't have had the need for boring bars, captured hollowing systems, and laser beams. And, the development of those tools is still going on.
"Do you enjoy turnings that are highly embellished, or are these artistic pieces making it impossible to appreciate a well turned pure form?"
This question is the same as asking if I can like Italian opera, jazz, classical, and rock music all at the same time. Of course I can, because I appreciate the talent and artistry to do all music well. However, when it comes to sitting down and creating my own music, it is straight ahead jazz all the way. Woodturning isn't much different. YES, I enjoy looking at the highly embellished, and NO, they don't make it impossible to appreciate a well done "pure form".
"Is it still possible for a "pure" turner to break into the "big-time"?"
This question reminds me of the lie that I heard all of my working life - that there was equal opportunity and compensation in the separate tracks of management and technical proficiency. The truth is that they are nowhere near equal, and management always paid better and had more opportunities for advancement. Woodturning is no different. The artists get the attention of the press, the fame, and their work in the "Big Time" Galleries; and the skilled swordsman has to be satisfied with being the teacher. Teaching might pay well, and often better than the art, but there is nowhere near the same recognition.
While most of the recognition goes to the "artists", but every once in awhile someone who has stayed true to the "pure form" gains recognition. Bill Luce is a recent example. Bill still makes "pure" bowl forms. He is in Del Mano, and his work is invited into many art exhibitions. That ain't bad for a bowl turner, and I congratulate him for that.
"Have you personally studied art or design topics? Would you consider it?"
Two questions that I don't know how to answer. All of life has been a learning experience, and I have managed to remember a few things. Other than that, NO I have never studied art, and probably never will.