Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Posts

So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#1

So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Carole Valentine

>My chain was not dull at all since I touch it up frequently with a file but the rakers needed to be taken down a bit so I decided rather than hassle with that I would have it "professionally" sharpened at the local Stihl dealer. Bring it home and put it back on the saw, noticing after the fact that I did not have to go get my gloves to protect my hands like I normally do while handling a sharp chain. Fired up the saw and started to cut up a maple log. What the heck??? Did I manage to put the chain on backwards or something??? Nope. Chain is on correctly but the darn thing will hardly cut butter! I look at the teeth and they have been ground to a dull, straight, flat edge about 1/32" thick! No cutting edge AT ALL. Could not believe it. No wonder I did not need gloves! I took it back to them and the guy insists that that is as sharp as it will get, that I won't get an edge like a new chain and that I probably needed a new one and needed to have my bar "ground"! When I recovered from my astonishment, I said if that's the case how come I can get a like-new edge with my file and the chain cuts great??? He just shrugs. I snatched the chain back and told him that if that was his way of selling new chains, he was not going to sell one to me and he certainly was not touching my bar! Fortunately I had a spare chain at home. I really don't think this one can be saved. Oh, and how often do you guys dress (or grind, as he put it) your bars? My bar only has about 5 hours of use on it and looks fine. How do you know if it needs dressing?

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#2

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

john lucas

>Carole I have never had my bar ground. I've had this chainsaw for 8 to 10 years. I took my saw in for a tune up one time and asked them to sharpen the chain figuring they would put it in some sort of state of the art chain saw sharpening jig. The guy stuck the bar in a vise and filed it by hand. It cut so,so. I put my husky guide on the bar and sharpened it again and it cut much better. I'm not an expert chainsaw sharpener by any means but I sure expected them to do a better job than I do.

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Keith Tompkins

>Carole, over time the bar will wear, a groove will form where the chain rides. A quick remedy, and something that will help even out the bar wear, is to flip the bar over. (upside down)If you are pretty good with a file, you can dress the bar yourself, try to maintain an even surface, 90 degrees to the side of the bar. A worn bar will make your chain pull to the side.

I don't get my chains "professionally" sharpened, they always grind away far too much material. Two sharpenings, the chain is toast. By hand, with a file, many years.

You can hit the rakers with a file every other time you sharpen the chain, that will maintain the proper distance.

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#4

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Ed Moore

>Carole,

I sharpened five or six chains yesterday with a Dremel tool. I put one on the saw this evening and took a slice off a piece of red oak like it was butter. Now a Dremel tool doesn't do well in the woods, but it works great in the shop. ;^D

Ed

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#5

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Jerry Whitaker

>I have had a chain sharpened professionaly 3 times....it took that many times to learn my lesson. I can do a far better job than the professionals with my Dremel sharpening attachment. Maybe we should all go into the chain sharpening business as a $$$ generating sideline.

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#6

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

RobinCorell

>I bought my saw from a tree trimmer who showed me a few sharpening tricks. before sharping the dull teeth take a pass at all the rakers. one good swipe with a flat mill file and a second swipe rounding over the leading edge to keep it from becoming square. I use a mill file He used a the same round file, but I never have mastered that move. This is safer to do with dull teeth and if you nick the teeth it is no big deal since they are already in need of sharpening. This keeps the cutting depth pretty close to factory specs. On my ripping chain I will check it every three or four sharpenings with a straight edge and feeler guages and it is usually dead on.

Robin Corell

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#7

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

TDaniel

>Carole, I do not know of any sharpening service that I would use. Most of them use a grinder to sharpen and they go too fast and burn the teeth. Sometimes after the teeth are burned they get so hard that you cannot cut them with a file afterwards. I have ordered a few of the Husky file guides and will demo how to use it at our Gathering. As far as the bar wearing, that happens after a few hundred hours of cutting...not after 5 hours. Running a dull blade and creating excessive heat will cause premature wear on the bar as will running too little bar oil or the wrong kind of bar oil. Proper chain tension is also important. Some areas have trees that have a lot of silica and this will also have an effect on wear. Bring your saw to the Gathering and we'll take a look at it.

TD

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#8

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

jared

>I have a john deere/echo chain saw. It is at least 15 years old. I use it a fair amount for cutting firewood, general clean up around the farm and now cutting turning blanks. In that period of time I have reworked the bar just once. It is probably due to be trued up again. I did it with a file the last time and it didnt really take that long. I cant believe that in five hours you could be that hard on one that it needs to be reworked. Maybe time to look for a new place to get your chain saw work done. Jared

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#9

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Carole, I would contact Stihl and let them know what that dealer did. I figure that they would like that kind of feedback.

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#10

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Carole

I will add a little to what has already been written here. Whoever you talked to obviously does not know his business. Some of the things he mentioned are true, but only for bars that have many hours of use on them. Every time you put a new or resharpened chain on the saw, you should flip the bar. That evens out wear. After you have used it for a long long time, you may need to concern yourself with filing the edges to clean it up a bit and smooth it out. This can be done at home by you the owner. Again after a very long time the bar can become worn and loose, and you can decide whether or not to buy a bar closer, which is a simple tool to squeeze the groove snug again. With the number of hours on your saw, these things are not even close to being a reality.

Bill

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#11

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Carol,

I strongly recommend you take this incident to Stihl directly, even to the point of sending them the subject chain. Sounds like what you've just been through amounts to attempted fraud by a franchised dealer. Stihl will likely replace your chain for free, and could yank the guy's dealership so he doesn't harm others.

I now sharpen both my own chain and all of my friends' chains as well. Lawnmower shops and such around here will ruin a chain about 50% of the time and the rest will over-grind them. I had a little HF chain grinder that went south fairly quickly, so I bought a "real" chain grinder from Madsen's. For $230 I can custom grind the chains to suit the cutting job we're doing. My friends say they now cut better and longer than when new.

If you're satisfied with your file sharpening, just get a flat filing guage to match your chain's specs (usually .025" for safety chain), and use a flat file to lower your rakers which you can do on the saw. As far as bar dressing, I've had the same bar on my little Stihl 023 for 16 years. When I noticed it developing a slight valley, I dressed it flat and square on my shop bench grinder; took all of about 10 minutes.

Mark

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#12

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

OB OBrien In Pensacola

>Carole, that guy at the Stihl shop ruined your chain, didn't know what he was doing and/or was just trying to sell you a new one. I suggest you go back and see the owner/manager and demand a new chain and an apology. I was in the Land clearing business for over 30 years and ran nothing but Sthil saws. I still have 4 saws, two of them are over 25 years old and still have compression and run great. I touch them up in the field with a saw file with the same diameter as the chain. (there are different sized chains). The rakers can be taken down with a flat mill file made for chain saws. This file has no teeth on the sides of the file. This prevents taking off the sharp edge of the tooth. As far as the bar needing to be ground, I don't think so. If it has been run a long time it will develop a slight burr on the edges that you can feel with your finger. You will also notice that it just dosen't feed into the wood as it should when your cutting. A couple of swipes with a file will clean it up. There is a 12 volt tool like a dremel that holds a chain saw sharpening bit (also the same size as your chain) to use in the field. I have one but find it's quicker and less hassel to just touch up the chain with the file. Good luck OB

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#13

Time for a refund.

Rick Davenport

>I think you and Bill Grumbine should go to your "chainsaw sharpener" and negotiate a refund of your money.

Somehow I think he will gladly do so.

Rick

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#14

Chainsaw sharpening 101

Dale Sherman - Manlius, NY

>It is worth going to the Madsen's website just for all the info they provide on chainsaw sharpening. I had two chains ruined by the local Husky dealer. That got me looking into power sharpeners.

As Mark mentioned, HF sells an inexpensive

sharpener
for $39. I bought one and found it easy to use once set up. I'm sure it will die eventually, in which case I'll go buy Madsen's Tecomec for $269, now that I'm convinced that power sharpening my own chains is the only way to go. It's quick, easy, and I can do it with a light touch. I still use a file for touchups in the field, but nicking an embedded stone takes way too much filing to correct.

Dale

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#15

Re: Chainsaw sharpening 101

Carole Valentine

>Well, it won't do any good to go to the owner - that WAS the owner. And he owns the only two Stihl dealerships on the Shore. Actually, I guess it was my own fault. I had been warned to stay away from that place, but I figured they were just isolated incidents, so I didn't pay any attention to the warnings. Apparently they have ruined more lawn mower blades and chains that you can shake a stick at. I was also told NEVER to take my saw to them for repairs and I will certainly heed that advice! I looked at that chain again today to see if there was any way to salvage it. I also compared it to my other chain (which has been used more than the one they sharpened) I was totally shocked to see how much of the tooth they removed! They also blued the tooth with the grinder.


img

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#16

Re: Chainsaw sharpening 101

Bill Crommett

>I never realized it before, but I am very fortunate to have a Stihl deler who is first rate and honest. He does a great job for $3.00 and doesn't grind away more than is needed (some times I hit the gravel). By the way, he tells me that Stihl does not want the dealers to grind down the rakers --- some sort of a liability thing. So I get out my Dremel every so often and do it myself. My old 031 is still going strong, and is getting to be all I can handle, but it still is the easiest one of the four in my collection to start.

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#17

Re: Yes!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Tecomec is the one to get. The clamp and the the stop will need a bit of initial fine tuning, but once set, they stay dead-nuts on, and keep the grinds symetrical for both left and right cutters. This is something the HF never did. I always had fuss to reset and mic the grind for each cutter set to keep the chain balanced. It paid for itself, but I wasn't all that unhappy to see it go.

M

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#18

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Barry Turner

>I bought a new Stihl 361 last Spring. I had not used it much until a couple of months ago. Its one sweet saw. The chain does not need sharpening yet, but I did stop by my local Stihl dealer a few weeks ago to talk about the best way to keep a sharp chain on the saw at all times. He suggested that I buy an extra chain. When the one on the saw gets dull, put on the sharp one and bring in the dull one for sharpening. He says they send all their chains out to be ground. The cost...$5.00. He didn't really recommend buying a file jig and learning to do it myself. Sounded like a good deal to me. Now, after reading your post, I'm having second thoughts.

Don't you just hate it when someone screws something up, then tries to cover up their ineptitude and blame you for it?

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#19

Yikes!

Peter Teubel

>That "sharpened" chain looks like its FAR past its life now. I've never seen teeth that short on an active chain. You really should send that pic to Stihl with a full explaination.

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#20

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

Barry Irby

>I bought a new Stihl saw and a spare chain. I almost immediately hit a piece of metal in a tree and mangled about eight inches of chain. I bought a third chain and had them repair the mangled one. They put in a new section about ten inches long. Back to the woods. Imagine my confusion trying to put the chain on when some of the teeth went one way some the other. We finished up the day with the two good chains. Went back to the dealer and showed them the chain. They were closed for the day and I slipped in when someone else was leaving. Boy did they eat crow. They stayed late to fix the mangled chain and then asked where my others were and sharpened them for me for free and were still eating crow and gave me a new chain to boot. They literally turned that around and made a customer out of me.

I would think Stihl would rather hear this story than your's Carol and I bet they wlll give you a new chain.

Re: So much for prof chain sharpening :((

#21

Re: Carole- it should take 10 yrs. ....

JamieDonaldson

>.... of hand sharpening to remove that much tooth! Contact Stihl now!