Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Maple Bowl

Posts

Maple Bowl

#1

Maple Bowl

Chris DiCiaccio

>I hope I have done better on the base of this one. Please critique the bottom for me, I'm trying to get better at finishing bowl bottoms. (Tell the truth, I can take it)


img

Re: Maple Bowl

#2

Re: Maple Bowl 

Chris DiCiaccio

>


img

Re: Maple Bowl

#3

Re: Maple Bowl 

Chris DiCiaccio

>


img

Re: Maple Bowl

#4

Re: Maple Bowl 

Chris DiCiaccio

>


img

Re: Maple Bowl

#5

Re: Maple Bowl

david

>Chris: As far as the shape goes I think you have done a great job. As for what I would improve if I were to critique this form, I would try to get the bottom to come in a little more, or to make the foot smaller. Some people like to make a foot, and some people don't. If you don't like to make a foot, check out Bill Luce's website and look at his bowls--I consider his forms hard to beat. As for the top shot--unless the photo is distorted, you seem to have some thick and thin issues there.

Re: Maple Bowl

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Maple Bowl

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Chris, in this photo of the base, I can see two circles that are close together....if you added another 1/4" to the diameter of these circles, that would be the perfect size base, imho. Another way to look at it, one third the overall diameter, or less is a good rule of thumb.....hope this helps, btw, nice looking piece!

Re: Maple Bowl

#7

Re: Maple Bowl

Bill Howatt

>Like the curvature of the side although a touch flat near the top. Biggest issue, IMO, is the bottom is too wide. I usually try for the 1/3 dia rule but I will make it a bit larger for a bowl that I think will be used rather than sit on a shelf.

Bill

Re: Maple Bowl

#8

Re: Maple Bowl

Carole Valentine

>Hi Chris. Looks like you are making progress. As others have said, a smaller base would be more appealing and allow you to have a more continuous curve. I seem to see two flat spots..the top third and the lower third going into the base (the lower one is not as flat as the top one). I personally would have made this bowl a little shallower so the curves could be better refined, but that's just me. I am not one to keep all the wood I can at the expense of form. I tried to draw a curve line on the picture but I can't find my tablet pen and using the mouse just doesn't get it, but maybe you can get the general idea. Looks like you need to fiddle with your camera focus a bit...the blurry pics make it hard on us old folks. :) Keep on turning!


img

Re: Maple Bowl

#9

Carole

Chris DiCiaccio

>You are right. I wanted to use all the blank instead of going with a shallower bowl. I need to discipline myself to go with form rather than saving wood. Also, I need to adjust to the approx. 1/3 rule of thumb on the bottom. Thanks for the illustration.

Re: Maple Bowl

#10

Nice one Carole

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Great visual Carole. A great learning tool.

Jen

Re: Maple Bowl

#11

Saving wood

Bill Howatt

>Chris,

I have made that mistake many times and I have to admit I still seem to work at getting the biggest bowl out of the wood. I wonder if it is because when we make our first bowls and show them to family and friends they seem to make more comments about the big ones and seem more impressed by them.

We know now that the big ones aren't necessarily the best ones but something still lingers in our brains about not making it smaller.

Bill