Re: Coring- Oneway vs Mac, Donna/Robo
RussFairfield
>I think a lot of how we see the tools will depend on how and why we use them. There are those who use the coring tool as a means to remove the inside of a bowl more quickly and to save the wood for other uses. Others want to cut multiple bowls from a single piece of wood. There are still others who want to remove the core from tall vases and other shapes that are different from that of a bowl.
They both cut a circular arc in the wood. The McNaughton should be the more flexible because the Oneway cuts a captured arc about a fixed center point, while the McNaughton has no physical restrictions. The reality is that, for the SAME ARC RADIUS, there is little to no difference between them because you still have to push or pull the tool into the wood and remove the core after it has been cut.
The captured Oneway tool will cut a more accurate arc and a narrower slot than the McNaughton in the hands of an inexperienced user. It has been argued that the average woodturner can relate the narrower slot to making them closer together and realizing more bowls from a singkle piece of wood. That might prove true for the inexperiences user. In the hands of an expert, it doesn't make any difference.
The Oneway is easier to use because every movement is in a fixed path, and only requires setting it up and pulling on the tool handle to make a cut. It is possible to core a bowl the first time.
Since the tool is both guided and powered by the person standing behind it, the McNaughton is more difficult to use and it takes more time and pracrice to learn how to use it well. I doubt that most woodturners will cut a successful core the first time they us the McNaughton tool.
The big difference between them is that the McNaughton has no physical restrictions on the arc of the tool. That means that the McNaughton's tool can have a very large atc, or can be straight, both of which are impossible with the Oneway.
The McNaughton is also cheaper than the Oneway, simply because there is less there.
If I were only turning salad bowls, I would have selected the Oneway because it is easier to use. I chose the McNaughton because there are more options available for less money, including large radius tools and a straight tool that would be impossible with the Oneway. I also have the additional option of making my own tools for the McNaughton. It is also important that I was willing to spend the time, and waste the wood, to learn how to use it. Someone else wwould have made a different choice for different reasons.