Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

Posts

Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#1

Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

David

>When I was a beginning turner, I had some pieces that really turned out great--actually beyond my expectations. Now that I know a little more and have more turning under my belt, I am experiencing a lot more failures--going through bottoms, walls too thin, wood with a mind of its own, etc. Yes I can look back and say that I am a better turner, and I know a lot more thanks to my lurking on the Pond and the great generosity and helpfulness in this great group. With a new lathe I guess I am expecting a lot more from myself, but as we all know, there will not be a success each time out. There may be a lot of strike outs now, but wait, I am still swinging, and there may be some home runs in my future yet...

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#2

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

Bert Smith

>David,

It's great to see that you are handling these recent problems with a good attitude.

Sometimes you need to just lay down your tool, grab a broom and sweep up the shop. Sharpen your tools or rearrange your wood supply. These things always help me when I start having problems.

When you are ready to step back up to the plate, you may be surprised at how things will begin to flow.

Good luck and keep swinging!

Bert

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#3

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>David, I agree with Bert. There are times that I have to walk away from the lathe because I am not in the right frame of mind or trying to speed things up.

Just take your time.

Norm

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#4

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>David, there are times when I contemplate selling my lathe and all its tools and sitting down on the couch to finish my days watching TV and drinking beer. I think anyone who pushes himself (or herself!) to be a better turner is going to go through stuff like this. On the other hand, there are people who have been doing the very same thing that they did 20 years ago and are perfectly content. Keep on pushing and you will see quantum leaps in your skills and accomplishments.

Bill

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#5

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

David Breth

>I'm also a beginning turner (14 months and counting), and am experiencing the same kind of blues. For a little while there, I was Midas. But recently, everyhthing has been "turning" to......not very well.

Fortunately, the turning addiction is a strong one, so I keep coming back for more. I've also made it a point with this hobby to be very patient with myself in developing. Result is that I don't get too annoyed when a few hours of work goes flying. Sounds like you have done the same.

David B.

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#6

Time to change the lucky shirt

Raymond Overman in SC

>This type problem always reminds me of the movie "Tin Cup". When Kevin Costner's character got the dreaded "shanks" he was told to move his change from his left pocket to his right pocket. This seemingly mundane thing gave him a mental edge that let the trained muscles do what they were supposed to do.

I think it's like this alot with my turning. I know what's supposed to happen and I push towards it not realizing that I'm not keeping my head down or not following through (to keep with the golf analogy). It's not that I don't know how to get the job done, sometimes I let my head get in the way of it while I try to improve the cut.

The key of course is to reign those new ideas in a little and get back to the fundamentals when you run into these problems. You'll work through them and be back on track to be the world class woodturner you're striving to be!

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#7

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

Carole Valentine

>David, I am having the same problem! I bet I have destroyed (or had to redesign) more wood in the past month than during my entire first year of turning. A few pieces I can *maybe* contribute to uncooperative wood but the rest are just me. Most of it is due to my feeble attempts to to turn thinner and improve the consistency of wall thickness on hollow forms while working through smaller openings. I just keep plugging away though and it's getting better. I figure it's just another of the many plateaus I have to slog across in this journey. :) Keep at it!

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#8

Re: So ask yourself these.....

JamieDonaldson

>.......questions: 1. Am I now going too fast because I have some experience with the tools? 2. Am I attempting projects that may exceed my newly imagined mastery of these tools? 3. Am I playing with all these new and different tool/toys rather than really mastering a few? 4. Am I really paying attention and having fun?

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#9

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

Bill Howatt

>Hang in there David! Part of the problem is that you now know too much. You know what makes a good shape, what a good wall thickness is for the desired design, what a good finish is, what a ... I show my pieces to friends and neighbours and they all ooh and aah and I babble on about uneven wall thickness, too much thickness, slight sanding mark, finish too dark, poor curvature, ...

I recently posted about wood for end-grain turning because even though I don't consider myself anywhere near a great bowl turner, what I was doing was seemingly very repetitive. I have started making some goblets and practicing spindle techniques and it has given me a refreshing and different perspective on using my lathe.

Sometimes when you are in a slump you have to do what us male woodworkers have borrowed from the fairer sex, and I might add, do extremely well - go shopping (for more tools).

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#10

Re: So ask yourself these.....

John Lucas

>Jamie nailed it with the last statement. Are you having fun. We get carried away(make thatI get carried away) with trying to fill this need to make the next masterpiece and forget to just have fun. My best pieces were all done because I had an idea and it was really fun developing the piece. I wasn't necessarily a master of the tools it took to make the piece, nor was a I a master of design. It was just a desire to create, so I took my time and used each tool to the best of my ability. I changed tools if that one wasn't working for me and just took my time and finished it. So let's just get out there and have fun turning.

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#11

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

RussFairfield

>We too often feel the need to be making something useful everytime we turn on the lathe. We forget that mastery of the tools and techniques requires practice, practice, and more practice. Just as a musician practices their scales, or a basketball player practices the fundamentals of the game, spending more time making cuts with the tool, and not making "things", will prove beneficial.

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

Keith Tompkins

>Dang it Russ, you just beat me to the punch! Practice isn't a tedious procedure...that's where I have the most fun. Just pop a hunk of wood on the lathe and go for it. No goal at all as to the shape.

Sometimes I try to see how fine of a shaving I can take, sometimes I see how much wood the same tool can hog out in one pass. I try to learn the limits of both the tool and myself. Did you know some tools cut pretty well upside down? Then when I turn a real piece, I have far less trouble.

Are you turning with a white-knuckled death grip? Many turners I encounter turn that way. Practicing will allow you to have a comfortable, easy style, and mishaps become a rare surprise. You may be focusing so much on tool control and avoiding catches that you are not paying attention to things like wall thickness.

Last, you may be ready for a lesson with a turner you respect...you'll be mentally ready to absorb all the new info.

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#13

Oh yeah! I'm definitely having fun! :)

Carole Valentine

>And when I do get a big catch (not too often anymore) or go through a wall, it just adds a little more knowledge to the database and then the next time gets a little easier. Sort of like when I used to ski(looong ago, in another life!) Practicing the slalom was always wipe-out time as we pushed the envelope on the practice course but with each crash, we learned a little more about our abilities and techniques. It was almost a sure bet than anyone who never crashed never won a race either.

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#14

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

Ed Kelle

>Your "failures" really are just are opportunities to experiment and get creative. You can try new finishes, decorative techniques, texturing.. lots of things. You might even be able to save the piece. I've had a few "failures" that I let sit for months before I decided to have some fun with them and they have led to some of my best works yet. So don't go throwing them away. You're much more likely to take some chances with a work once you have deemed it a "failure". either way it can be a great learning experience.

And I bet your standards are much higher than they were a year ago

Happy turning

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#15

Amen, Bill...

Doug Trembath

>In learning and applying yourself to anything, you're gonna get better. But the journey for me was a series of plateaus. Now, don't get the feeling that that's an original thought. I read it a long time ago, and was reminded of it only upon reflection.

I would reach a point, and just not get any better. I struggled for a while, and because I didn't have adequate concentration, I blew up everything. Then, I would just throw the ugliest piece of wood I could find on the lathe, and find inspiration. That's when I would take that next leap. But only, be assured, after bleeding profusely and wasting a ton of really beautiful wood.

Bummer, but it did lead to the next step. And the next...

Don't lose heart...

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#16

Re: Using what tools upside ......

JamieDonaldson

>......down- only one I can imagine working at all would be a parting tool????

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Using what tools upside ......

Keith Tompkins

>AHA! One that works really well is a bowl gouge with a conventional grind....riding the bevel, works well, nice clean cut. Skew...long point up, long point down...that works well too.

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#18

Thanks for the kind words...not alone when

David

>you have the generosity of this group.

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#19

Re: Using what tools upside ......

RussFairfield

>I was having visions of Keith running the lathe in reverse and supporting the tool on the bottom of the tool rest.

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

#20

Re: Going thru a Sophomore slump, I guess.

Ed Moore

>No formula fits all of us when it comes to learning and some topics require different learning procedures/approaches. Sometimes we should just keep plugging away at something until we succeed and sometimes we need to set the blade of our bulldozer a little higher and not try to take such a deep cut. Repeated passes may succeed where trying to do it all at once may fail.

You have received a LOT of good advice in the posts that precede this one in this thread and now you must try to figure out which remedy suits you. As a former director of tutoring programs at a major college, I particularly liked Jamie Donaldson's post here. The first thing I did with a math student who came for help was see what they had done and HOW they were approaching problems. My perception of your situation is that of a bulldog. You are determined to succeed and will do whatever it takes. Whenever you get a catch, do you turn the lathe off and analyze WHY you just got that catch? You should. And maybe it all started with fatigue. Or maybe you are trying so hard that you have a death grip on the tool.

There are times when we should turn off the machine and walk out of the shop and not return until the next day. I know a fellow who was trimming the edge of a door with a power planer. He dropped the planer and then CAUGHT IT! He planed off the fingerprint on a couple of fingers, realized what he had just done, set the planer down, unplugged it and did not return until MUCH later.

My suggestion to you is to occasionally back off and think about what you are doing, analyze where you are and where you want to go, and take a break so that you can come back in fresh. And then apply Keith's advice and do a little practicing without trying to make a finished piece.

My two cents worth, and you get change,

Ed