Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Ethics question - seek opinions

Posts

Ethics question - seek opinions

#1

Ethics question - seek opinions

Ed Moore

>It is well-known that Rude Osolnik popularized his walnut candlesticks and they are identified with him. I am considering making some candlesticks in the style in the picture below, and they may have some visibility. They are similar in shape to Rude's, but they are laminated so that they have the contrasting hyperbolic cross-section as shown. I do not believe Rude ever made them in this laminated form, but I could be wrong. These candlesticks are ash with wenge and sometimes I use ash with bubinga.

QUESTION: If one were to make candlesticks as are pictured below, is there a problem with plagiarism?

I truly seek your honest opinion. Thanks,

Ed


img

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#2

Steven Antonucci

I'd say no.

steve antonucci

>Rude's work was similar, but I'd say your necks are longer and thinner, and that the mix of materials makes it "derivative" instead of a knock off.

We all take influence from somewhere. I might credit Rude's work in the description of your work, but I'd say it would be obvious to a well trained eye that these are not from his hand.

Steve

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#3

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Absolutely no plagiarism there. They are same style but are quite different.

Norm

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#4

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

David

>A bit of personal integrity helps here. Did you have an actual piece or photo of someone else's work that you constantly referred to as you developed your own forms? If not, you know that person's work may have been an influence, but you know in your heart that you did not copy anyone else. Your conscience is clear,and that is what counts.

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#5

Re: There is no conflict.....

JamieDonaldson

>...here- Rude was identified with this candlestick shape, but he didn't "invent" the shape. It was used by others before Rude adopted it as a signature piece, so have at it! It is admirable that you recognize Rude's influence, but this is a proper derivitive and I like it.

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#6

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

Ed Moore

>David,

I was certainly aware of Rude's candlesticks when I made some like these -- and I have no problem saying that Rude popularized the general form. The question is -- does the non-symmetric lamination that produces the hyperbolic cross-sections yield a candlestick that differs enough from Rude's to avoid the accusation of a knock-off?

Certainly no effort was made to produce the exact form of Rude's candlesticks, but even an undiscerning eye will note the similarity of form.

I appreciate the responses we have gotten so far.

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#7

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

Fred Bearman

>My thought is that you have pretty well expressed the heart of the matter very well - we all see things and are influenced by them, consciously or unconsciously. I may have seen a piece several years ago and not even consciously noticed it, but today may be turning something that, in fact, is quite similar - no conscious intent, just being influenced by things that we encounter every day. Oh, and BTW, I think that the candlesticks that started this thread are pretty nice!

Regards,

Fred Bearman

Port Huron, MI

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#8

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

George (Oxford, NC)

>I didn't post any response when this subject came up a couple of months ago, but I will now. It is my belief that there are no new forms, shapes or styles that have not somewhere, by someone, at some time in the past been produced. I think that so long as you do not represent them as someone else's work and do not proclaim that you have just discovered this form, you should not worry. If you start to get publicity and interviews then you can mention that you were influenced by Rudi's style.

I am just a beginning turner and there is no way that my work could ever be confused with someone else's. But I do look at pictures and in my inept way try to make things that look sorta' like what I have seen. Your pieces are no exception, someday I may laminate some stock and try to make something that half-way looks like yours, thats the way I learn. It would be my goal that someday someone will look at my work and say "that looks just like so-and-so's work".

George

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#9

Thanks, and, keep 'em coming.

Ed Moore

>Thanks to each who has contributed. I agree with the responses, but you would have expected that. The question seems to boil down to "Close, or too close?" and the opinions are that they are not too close. I have neither heartburn nor hesitancy in saying that sticks of this general form were popularized by Rude. But any that I make will have my name on the bottom, not Rude's.

And back to my earlier thread, I think that a darker background would have been better because of the lightness of the ash. Right, Jamie?

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#10

Ric Taylor

Imitation is the Sincerest Form of Flattery

Ric Taylor

>No one owns any shapes. Many people have done shapes similar to these, and many more will make some in the future. Go for it, and enjoy.

Ric

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#11

Greatest Old Book says...

W.C. Turner

>The greatest, and the best selling BOOK in the world, says "There is nothing new under the sun."

W.C.

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#12

Ecclesiastes 1:9

Ed Moore

>

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#13

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

bob davis

>probably hundreds of people have turned rhudys candlesticks.when he was alive he considered it flattery

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#14

Re: Bob-I don't know if...

JamieDonaldson

>... you knew Rude, but he did NOT consider copying his candlesticks as flattery! Rude had a mean streak once in a while, and knew some old sailor language for subjects like this that made him mad! Been there, done that!

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#15

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I'm not going to be the first to say yes, because my answer is also "no problem". I would consider that "style" or design to be so widely popularized by now that it is public domain. However, it is nice to identify your influence.

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#16

Re: In this case about any.....

JamieDonaldson

>....background from white to black would work- the problem with this image is lack of contrast, which could be improved with proper exposure, then enhanced with saturation manipulation using software. What you want is visual separation between subject and setting, and that can be handled in several ways, including increased physical distance between candlesticks and backdrop.

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#17

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

georgetroy

>No Ed this subject has been beat to death. I took Rude Osolink classes at Arrowmount in 1986-87 and he showed us how to make the sticks. He encourged us to do so. I have made many of these and I do not in anyway feel like I'm Plagiarizing. I have showed my work and drawings all over the web for years, if you see something you can use, go for it. GT

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#18

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

adrien

>"However, it is nice to identify your influence." I like that...

BTW, the front cover of Craft Supplies' catalog for fall,2004/2005 has pictures of rather similar candlesticks by Eli Avisera.

At $35 a pair of these candlesticks, Rude put 4 (or was it 5?) kids through college, making 4 pairs every morning before going to work teaching.

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#19

Re: In this case about any.....

John Lucas

>I agree with Jamie. The need two things. More 3 dimensionality and more seperation from the background. Try to adjust your lights so that one side of the candlestick is noticeably brighter than the other side. This requires move one light further away or aiming it less directly at the pieces.

The candlesticks are too close to the bacground so the background won't have any fade. If you can move the background further away it will get darker and then you also have room to shade the background so less light hits it.

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#20

IF . . . . *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>. . . . you're ripping Rude off, you're in good company.

|;-}}


Candlesticks

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#21

Didn't the AAW Higher-ups say (LONG)

Doug Trembath

>that they were only concerned about living artists? Kind of a specious argument, IMHO. I see no conflict, and wouldn't say too much if they were identical in shape and size, as a matter of fact. You aren't trying to usurp anyone's "niche" to consciously trade on their style or success, are you? This whole plagiarism thing is WAAAAAAYYYYY out of hand. Craftsmen have been influenced for millennia by those that came before. Did the Romans rip off the Greeks? Did the Greeks rip off the Pheonicians and all who came before them? (I forgot the name of the civilization I was thinking about. Senior moment)

Let's try to keep this issue out of the ozone, and maybe maintain a little perspective. Rude wasn't worried that someone would copy his forms as I understand it. He was too prolific to be too concerned. I think he was such a down to earth person that he might very well have laughed at the stands some of the more famous turners have taken lately, many of them students or contemporaries.

Here's one for you. Know Cindy Drozda's work? Beautiful stuff. Did she rip anyone off? I was selling stuff in very much the same configuration a couple of years before I knew she existed. The very first outside sale I made was a pedestal hollow vessel with a finial top. Does Cindy own that particular shape or configuration? Do I?

Hell, no! Only the living legends are having trouble with this issue, because the market has become diluted significantly through the advancement of turners taught and tutored by these folks, and I firmly believe it's their own fault. They are reaping the rewards of their own philosophy, IMHO. Craftsmen did not always share their techniques with anyone who would listen. They closely guarded them with Guilds, secrecy, and subterfuge, because they had the advantage. In most cases, I believe, they didn't have any recourse when someone did much the same work by inventing a process that made what was once quite difficult very easy, therefore maybe even destroying the first guy's livelihood.

When you share so generously, you are bound to develop people who can do the same things you do. To claim ownership of a style of piece is okay, but think about it, has anyone seen a ceramic piece that is similar to Ellsworth's wonderful pots with the necks turned into the body? Of course! Does he own that shape? For a more applicable example, Keith's rose is really unique because of the material he uses, right? Anyone seen anything similar in another medium? Of Course! Did Keith rip anyone off?

I believe there is one true test for an individual in this debate. Is your conscience clear or cloudy? Did you consciously try to make money by copying someone else's work and passing it off as theirs?

Derivation is natural and healthy and results in honest competition. Who invented the spin move on the football field? Can he be upset when someone else does it to succeed? Get real.

I have sounded off before on how little credence I give someone who, after taking money for teaching someone how to do a particular technique, complains when a student uses it. This has just about come full circle again.

Go forth, young turners, and replicate! Just don't pass it off as someone else's work. Take and give credit freely. Your turn will come if you follow Rude's own advice. To paraphrase what has been widely reported in magazines and discussion groups, when asked how someone becomes a better turner, he responded they needed to spend more time at the lathe.

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#22

Richard Allen

Re: Didn't the AAW Higher-ups say (LONG)

Richard Allen

>A lot of folks appear to be missing the point. The point is why would you want to be producing work that is like someone elses work?

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#23

Ethics question - Thank you!

Ed Moore

>I would like to thank each of you for your contribution to what can be a sticky problem. We may note that in the link Mark provided, Eli Avisera had a line attributing the form of the candlesticks to Rude Osolnik. It has been my opinion that the candlesticks are now considered to be public domain and that variations such as in the picture I posted are sufficiently different that they pose no ethical problem. That said, there may be other views and I wanted to know about them from my WC friends rather than step in something that would never seem to come off one's shoes.

And I thank my photography friends for their tips. Actually, the picture was three years old and was taken by someone else. But I am about to jump into the photography pit and try to take some photos of my work that are suitable for public consumption, so your tips were timely. Following suggestions I got here at WC I purchased a Canon A620. Unfortunately my wife and I got new cell phones at about the same time. Information overload and too many menus did me in. I will start over in a few days. (I like the comment of the lady who described her technical skills as "Amish". I hope that doesn't describe me.)

Thanks,

Ed

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#24

Re: Didn't the AAW Higher-ups say (LONG)

Kevin Gerstenecker

>Very well stated Doug, and I couldn't agree more!

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

#25

ebd

Re: Ethics question - seek opinions

ebd

>BullHuckey. EVERY form has been done before, at some time, in some medium, by some body, somewhere. Form cannot be owned. Try and copyright or patent a form. Wallmart could hire turners to produce Ellsworth-like pieces and sell them with absolutely no problems as long as they didn't put Ellsworth's signature on them.

As far as who would want to copy someone elses idea, perhaps they like it, perhaps the person who originally "plagerized" the form doesn't sell in their area or at prices that arn't exhorbitant. Grow up. You are engageing in a craft. You are selling your SKILL, not the conceptualized form. Take a look at flatlanders. Sam Maloof, and others are copied extensively by the home craftsman. They all publish books and articles to aid those endeavers. They don't bitch and whine if someone makes a piece that resembles theirs unless the person tries to pass it off as being an original Maloof, for example.