Small Maple Bowl
Scott Hurley in N. VA
>Small maple bowl. It's about 7" wide and 4.5 high. Is it too tall for the width?
Scott
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Small Maple Bowl
Scott Hurley in N. VA
>Small maple bowl. It's about 7" wide and 4.5 high. Is it too tall for the width?
Scott
Re: Small Maple Bowl
George Van in WI
>Scott, I do not think you are too tall at all. I like a deeper bowl like this. I do think a smaller foot would allow you to create a more flowing curve to the rim, which would make the height concern disappear.
Re: Small Maple Bowl
GaryG in MD
>Hey Scott,
It is what it is. I like it. I think life would be pretty dull if every bowl is designed with the same proportions (golden dimensions or rule of thirds, etc.) and with the same curved sides. It's nice and thin and I like the outward slanted rim. The "straight" sides have just enough subtle curve to make it flow. I think it's a nice shape. I really like the flaws. They add a needed focal point. Is that coffee grounds? ;-)
I can appreciate George's comment about the foot size (since this is a decorative bowl), but, again, it is what it is. If you had done that, it would be a different bowl. This one is just fine.
Nice job, Gary
Re: Small Maple Bowl
Keith Tompkins
>I have to disagree a bit Gary. The beauty of this site is we share information and knowledge that helps many turners improve... sometimes far more rapidly than they expect.
George makes a very valid point that will certainly help Scott improve....after all he appears unsure about the results of his work, and a smaller foot really would help.
I very much agree about one thing, however. This piece is what it is. I think Scott should be proud of his efforts, yet still strive to improve each following piece.
Re: Small Maple Bowl
Scott Hurley in N. VA
>Thanks for the comments.
Scott
Keith, please read (long)
GaryG in MD
>Hi Keith,
I agree with everything you said. My initial reaction was also that the foot could be smaller, and I actually wrote that -- and then deleted it and rewrote it to what I sent.
I started to think: how would I make the foot smaller. Would I keep the sides the same shape and just make the foot smaller, or would I curve the sides in at the bottom to match up better with the smaller foot. Obviously, I would do the latter. But then, I said to myself, the bowl would have a different shape altogether -- it wouldn't be the same bowl. Indeed it would look more like the same old "classic" shape that we often strive for.
That gets me back to my initial comment -- and I would like to get a broad discussion going on this -- are we trying to force bowl design into an increasingly small envelope of "accepted", classic shapes? It often seems that way to me. At least, the comments I read in critiques seem to be aimed along the same, very restrictive avenues.
As a novice turner, I appreciate the "rules", and I'm certainly still striving to make a classic shape, with, perhaps, only marginal success so far, but I also enjoy seeing a variety of different shapes. Frankly, I'm beginning to feel that a little too much emphasis is being put on the variously expressed "rules". While I agree that they result in very pleasing shapes, and that design is very important, I also like to let the size and shape and grain of the hunk of wood, and my mood at the time, have voices in the outcome -- while accepting that without years of practice, finding the bowl in the block without a definite design plan can often lead to some less-than-attractive results. So I try to do both. Not always easy -- not supposed to be.
IMHO, a bowl or HF does not have to have the same width-to-height ratio, the same foot-to-width ratio, the same max diameter height to total height ratio, and the same differential equation for the shape of the sides to be attractive. This is similar to what happened in French painting in the Salon era of the 19th century, and it eventually led to Impressionism. We all know how that turned out. I find the typical Salon paintings completely forgettable, and I rarely look at them even if I'm already in a museum, but I'll drive hundreds of miles to see an exhibition of Impressionist works. (Speaking of which, you should come down and catch the current Cezanne exhibit at the National Gallery! It's marvelous! You have a place to stay if you can find the time.)
It seems to me that today most of the emphasis in bowl art is in carving and decoration. That's very understandable, and leads to wonderful works of art, but I would also like to see more interest in stretching the boundaries for variations in the basic shapes of simple bowls. While "rule" bowls are often lovely, I can't agree that to be "beautiful", a bowl has to subscribe to these various "rules". That said, I also agree that it's all too easy to create a bowl that is less attractive than we might like it to be (put your own colloquial phrase here). The differences between 'attractive' and 'not attractive' are often very subtle. Indeed, that's where critiques on WC can be very valuable, and I enjoy reading through them in the rare occassions when they actually get into some serious conversations.
Having said all this, it's funny, because I'm in the same boat with Scott right now. I've got a walnut bowl roughout with a fairly large foot, and I'm trying to decide if I want to make it "classic" or leave it 'out of the box'. Maybe I'll post a pic and ask your opinion -- which, I might add, I value highly.
I would enjoy hearing your thoughts on my ramble.
Regards, Gary
Re: Keith, please read (long)
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>Gary, I agree with most of what you've said. I recommend the book 500 Wood Bowls. It really illustrates how much a bowl turner can push the envelope in designing bowls.
I teach classes and a lot of my students are beginners. Right from the beginning I try to instill the "rules" of good design on the students. I try to get them to understand why a well turned bowl is pleasing to look at and pleasing to hold. I stress the use of curves, and good proportions to create good balance. I think that anyone can learn the techniques of using the tools, but not everyone understands why one piece is more pleasing to the eye and touch than another.Too many turners go through life turning ugly pieces. I think that beginners would be well served to stay within the "rules" until they understand them. When I'm teaching more advanced students, we work on ways to go beyond the "rules" and still create a piece with beauty and integrity.
I feel that anyone who is a beginner and posts a piece here and asks for comments, is shortchanged if the more experienced turners don't give an honest assessment of how the piece could be improved and why. In the old days of the Badger Pond site there were a number of turners all beginning turning at the same time. It has been great, there, and here on WC to watch their progress. They all posted their work and asked for advice. One of that group is Jennifer Shirley.
Wally
Re: Keith, please read (long)
Ed Karch
>Right on Wally. Jennifer can break the wall thickness "rule" with her bowls and still have a very beautiful art piece. Last time I tried that same style it looks like a thick buffalo chip. It is in knowing those clasic shapes well and how to make changes that don't upset the proportion and balance. But first you need to understand proportion and balance.
Re: Keith, please read (long)
Keith Tompkins
>Hi Gary, Thanks for the reply. I really enjoy this kind of debate. Like Wally stated, I also think new turners should adhere to some strict guidelines. There are several reasons for this...one of the most important reasons is the pace that a turner can advance from a raw neophyte to advanced levels of turning. By seeking good form right from the beginning, the turner won't waste time (sometimes years)turning poor forms. turning poor forms don't imho lead to creating good forms...striving to turn GOOD forms does. Another reason: bad habits developed early-on are hard to overcome....in an extreme case, a turner came to me for lessons...armed with only scrapers. That's how he was taught...he's still turning with only scrapers, refusing to change or try something new. His forms are still the same forms he started with as well.
I understand your frustration of being forced into a box, where all turnings seem the same, cookie-cutter duplicates of each other. However, once you can turn good forms on a regular basis, you will have a good foundation to build upon. If you decide to experiment and push the boundaries a bit, then you can easily understand WHY a particular new piece works or not...and you will know what changes would make it work. Like Wally, I have seen dramatic advances in the work of people who have come to my classes and demos. It is rewarding to make a difference.
I like to push the boundaries a bit too, both in my technical skills and my design skills. I posted this previously, a method of visualizing turnings based on triangular shapes... I call it the "Tompkins Triangle". I use it in my classes, and it will appear in "Woodturning Design" magazine's next issue. I will also demonstrate this method in Louisville this June in my form and design demo. BAsically, it helps a turner visualize what shapes can be derived from a block of wood (in advance). The nice thing about this approach is that you are not locked into a set formula....the shape and size of the wood is taken into account, yet, if the final piece "fits" the triangle, the form almost cannot fail. Also, using the triangle as a guide, you will find that pieces that don't fit somewhere in the triangle are usually lacking something visually. I would be interested in your thoughts on this method...it may be of some help. I would be interested in your thoughts, Keith
sound advice
TDaniel
>
Re: sound advice
Keith Tompkins
>Thanks Terry....I'm giving away all my secrets.LOL
Re: Keith, please read (long)
Keith Tompkins
>Almost forgot...Gary, your analogy of impressionist paintings is very good. Monet is one of my favorites..although he may have seeming broken all the rules, his use of color, balance, composition, emphasis, etc. shows he indeed had a thorough understanding of his art...and used it very well indeed.
Re: Keith, please read (long) *LINK*
RussFairfield
>Gary,
Read what I have to say about what does and doesn't make a good salad bowl at the link below. There is nothing in the artcle about "rules" or proportions
http://www.woodturner-russ.com/SaladBowl.html
Re: Keith, please read (long)
Ed Karch
>Impressionist Turner?? Check out Stephen Hogbin.
Re: Keith, please read (long)
Carole Valentine
>Oh great...now I am probably going to spend the evening superimposing triangles over pics of my pieces to see if they fit! LOL
Re: Keith, please read (long)
GaryG in MD
>Hi Wally,
Yeah, that's a great book; it's my favorite -- I keep it on my coffee table. It has a lifetimes-worth of inspiration in it (including one of Keith's). Another book that I like a lot is "Turning Wood into Art: The Jane and Arthur Mason Collection" (c2000; pub Harry N. Abrams, Inc.). It's a beauty -- large format and great photography.
I certainly agree with you (and with the following posts) that teaching design is critically important, and that the "rules" are a good way of getting many important concepts across to the students. I also agree that critiques are not valuable if they're not honest. I think it's clear that most people on WC want true honesty, not pats on the head. I guess what concerns me is that decent, rule-bending pieces may occasionally fall prey to critiques based on preferences for conventional, rule-based shapes. I guess we'll have to take those as they come and hope they generate a good discussion.
It's funny, because I looked at Scott's bowl again to see if the foot could be made smaller without significantly altering the basic shape of the bowl. I believe it can! So I'm back in agreement with George and Keith (and my initial reaction) after all. I just didn't think it would be fair to Scott's original vision to change the whole shape of the bowl to make the foot a little smaller. So in one way it's a "never mind", but a good discussion like this is never a waste.
Regards, Gary
Re: Keith, please read (long)
GaryG in MD
>Keith, Certainly true. I love Monet too -- and Cezanne, Van Gogh, Renoir, etc. FYI, there are nine (!) Monets here (in DC) in a private collection that you can tour. Check out www.kreegermuseum.com and click on "The Collection". ...Gary
reply (long)
GaryG in MD
>Hi again Keith,
I figured you'd enjoy this thread -- I've followed your earlier posts on design. Indeed, I recommended to Bob Pezold, the current CAW program director, that he ask you to come down and do a demo for us. He says you'll get together to discuss it at the Convention. I hope you're able to agree on a calendar slot. I would like to see some of your out-of-the-box techniques, as well as some in-the-box. Too much to learn; too little time. ;-)
I understand your (and Wally's) thoughts on design and education and agree that it is valuable and important to learn how to make pleasing shapes. On the other hand, I think I find some shapes pleasing that some others might not. Let me make a further art analogy. Some people go preferentially to MOMA and the Hirshhorn, and some go to the Met and the National Gallery. It's all a matter of taste. There are no absolutes in art. As they say, "you can't teach taste". That, of course, is a two-edged sword. ;-) I enjoy the classic shapes very much and want to learn how to make them well, but not all of the time.
I'll look forward to your article on triangles with interest. I remember seeing your earlier posts on the subject. I think I'd have to hear you discuss the details at some length, verbally, to get a better understanding of your points -- I have to admit that I had a hard time understanding it as a broad generalization.
There's no question that this (triangle) approach yields one (IMHO 'limited') family of pleasing shapes. Without hearing your thoughts in more detail, however, I wouldn't go quite so far as to say that "pieces that don't fit somewhere in the triangle are usually lacking something visually". Here's what I'm getting at. Technically, you're not wrong, by definition, because ANY form can be surrounded by a triangle. So it's a matter of how closely it has to fit, or, better, if the bounding triangle expresses the essence of the form.
Let me list a few of what I would consider as counter examples, and you tell me how these fit into your thinking. Take Wally's classic SW forms, for example. It would seem to me to be a bit of a stretch to say that their bounding triangle expresses their basic shapes very well. Perhaps you disagree. I could go farther and propose that the same could be said to be true for all forms with incurved rims (e.g., '500 Bowls' pages 163, 211, 228, etc. Again, you may disagree. To me, a triangle does not express the essence of these forms although it may contain them. Ditto with Christian Burchard's basket and gourd forms. Same for vertical-sided bowls (e.g., '500 Bowls' pages 209, 214). I would say the same for our own (CAW's) Phil Brown's trumpets (e.g., '500 Bowls' page 310). Again, you may disagree -- to me, it's all a matter of the whether one believes that the bounding triangle expresses the truth of the form. For me, without hearing more of your thoughts, these forms don't fit well enough into their bounding triangle for me to accept this as a basic design criterion.
I certainly respect your idea, and believe that there must be something to it, or you wouldn't be talking about it, so I'll be very interested to hear your further thoughts.
Regards, Gary
thanks Russ
GaryG in MD
>Good idea. I remember seeing this some time ago, but it's time to review it and see how much I may have forgotten.
Mostly, right now at least, I'm striving to make pieces aimed more for display than for use, and the "rules" are a little different for utilitarian pieces -- mostly for stability and durability. My problem, as a novice, is that my skills (wall thicknesses) are more applicable to durability. ;-)
Thanks for your reminder. Regards, Gary
Re:Don't worry....
RussFairfield
>Don't be concerned about wall thickness. The more walls you turn, the thinner they will become, automatically. They will also become more uniform in thickness
Re:Don't worry....
GaryG in MD
>Russ, You're right! I roughed a 7.5"D x 4"H (w/tenon) wet cherry bowl today with 0.75" walls. I did the interior completely from rim to center and never touched a scraper. The walls are nicely uniform all the way from rim to bottom. I did the rotation and handle swing of the BG from left wing to tip to right wing through the transition zone while listening very carefully to the cut and adjusting as necessary before getting into trouble. Not even close to a catch. Lovely piles of shavings. [I can see how it would have been easier with a bowl lathe -- the bed of the 1236 restricts the handle swing a bit. NBD.] This gives me the confidence to tackle taking some dried roughouts down to reasonable thinness. (Unfortunately, several are red oak, so it's going to be slow going and lots of sharpening. That's ok -- I'm still at a point where I need to be going slowly anyway. Thanks for your encouragement. Regards, Gary
Re: thanks Russ
Mike from St. Clair Shores
>As a fairly new turner, I have enjoyed this discussion immensely. I look forward to this WC type of knowledge sharing and feel that my turnings have been getting better because of it. Thanks to all of you for the contributing to this forum and I look forward to meeting many of you in the future.
Mike
Re: reply (long)
Keith Tompkins
>HI Gary, I should qualify my answer a bit. One of the biggest arguements I get when I do a design demo or class is: Not all turnings fit into the Golden Rectangle. AND.. they are absolutely correct. Too many demonstrators pronounce "Use the Golden Rectangle as a guide when making and designing your work."....and that's it. They don't follow up with concrete examples. They also do not acknowledge that there are other ways to design a piece that don't fit into a certain category. That's where my triangle method comes in...it helps to visualize attractive pieces that don't fit into the golden rectangle. I posted it in response to your first response as an alternative method of design. To me, it's just another addition to my bag of tricks.
The other problem I encounter when teaching is that many turners cannot visualize a piece in advance...but they can see the form develop as they turn it. Too often, by the time they arrive at a form that pleases them, it's too late....they've removed too much wood. By using the triangle method, they can see a good form, and try to achieve it. A goal to shoot for. In fact, by making a cardboard template, it's easy to exactly recreate the form they are striving to create. Give it a try..using a pleasing triangular form, design a bowl within it, then turn that shape. Then, as an experiment, bring it to a club meeting. You will be pleasantly surprised by the comments.
Try this....hold a length of fine chain by each end, and notice how it hangs. Gravity is affecting the chain in a uniform way. The resulting curve is perfectly symetrical, with no variations in line. Isn't this exactly what we are trying to achieve as turners? Now, move your hands closer together, then further apart. The result is always the same.....just beautiful to look at. This effect is known as a catenary. This is a whole different approach to design, where things like the golden rectangle can be pretty much ignored. Yet, some of the most stunning results can be achieved. A Bert Marsh piece would be a prime example of this. Funny, During my demo, I draw one of my triangles, and then hold a chain over it, placing each end at the top of the triangle....and then let it hang to fill the triangle...NOW you know why my triangle method works: it mimics the catenary effect.
I have experimented with stacking rectangles, combining rectangles with triangles, etc. in an effort to achieve some pleasing forms. I haven't even discussed some of those yet....It's important to remember, we are only dealing with overall proportion so far! We could spend even more time on principles such as balance, rythem, emphasis, and so forth. I think your appreciation of art is a great asset, and I'm sure it will be reflected in your work.
Do I always design using some formula or another when I turn? No, I compare my turning style to a jazz guitarist...practice my scales, practice my scales, practice my scales! Thoroughly understand the relationship of one key to another on the fretboard, and learn to play any scale anywhere on the instrument. Then, forget all I know about practice and scales when I play....Let it flow from somewhere within.