Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Another Pet Peeve....

Posts

Another Pet Peeve....

#1

Another Pet Peeve....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>This has been posted before but it needs to be done again.

Most folks who post a question or a problem and ask for answers and solutions will acknowledge the replies, usually with a thanks.

My rant is with people who post questions and problems, get numerous answers and solutions, and never post any sort of reply or a thank you. Sometimes the people who offer answers and solutions go to some lengths to give help. If there is no acknowledgment no one knows if the answers were helpful or not, or if they were even read.

What do you think?

Wally

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#2

Thank you one and all.......

Rick Davenport

>Gee Wally, I'm sure glad I responded to your private message with a thank you!

Being one of those new pests who are constantly asking questions, I hope I have made it clear on every occasion that I appreciate the thoughtful and varied responses to my sometimes smart, sometimes dumb questions.

This group is a wonderful source of information and I am constantly amazed at the willingness to help and share.

One thing that helped me become successful in the corporate world was the simple hand written thank you note.

It's amazing how few people actually take the time to send them, but they always got the attention of whoever got one.

Once again,

THANK YOU ALL

Someday, when I accumulate enough turning wisdom, I promise to continue the tradition.

Rick

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#3

Ellis Walentine

I would agree, Wally

Ellis Walentine

>I also realize that some folks can't get back here in a timely way, and it may seem that they are unappreciative. There's not much we can do about that. (I myself am sometimes lax about following up on various threads that I've weighed in on, to my great chagrin.)

The other way to look at this is to recognize that any question posted is an invitation to discuss a topic. If the discussion involves and edifies many people, it has been worthwhile.

Forum etiquette would prefer a reply from the original questioner.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#4

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

RussFairfield

>Perople generally live up to our expectations. I get almost no acknolegements from forum messages and don't expect any. That might not be the way it should be, but that's the way it is.

And then everyone wonders why people get tired of answering questions and just drop out of these forums.

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#5

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

JKJ in East TN

>I moderated a technical forum for many years and got used to the fact that not everyone posted followup or thank you messages. The forum regulars were more likely to respond, but even then we are all human and get busy or forget (and I'm as guilty as anyone), so it's easy to forgive.

It bothered me more when someone joined the forum, posted a question, then NEVER even logged in again to check for responses! (Each login was logged) This happened more times than I could count. This was especially frustrating after I invested an hour researching, testing, and composing a comprehensive answer to their question accompanied by example files and images. :(

However, as Ellis pointed out, even then all is not lost. I figured for everyone who asked a question, 10 other people around the world had the same question but didn't ask, and 100 others were interested and helped by the answer. (We had several thousand readers per day) And like that forum, I'm sure many people here even keep files of potentially useful responses for future reference - I certainly do.

Those who answer questions for the joy of helping others can be sure that they help SOMEONE, even if they don't see a response from the original poster!

JKJ

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#6

JL

Re: I always read a Russ post..

JL

>even if it's not for me. You are one of the gurus.

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#7

Re: Thank you one and all.......

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Rick, I wasn't targeting you specifically, but thank you for responding.

Enjoy your trip. Bring back some wood.

Wally

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#8

Me too!

david

>Because you DA MAN, Russ. Also read the circumferencially challenged Bill G posts, because he is DA BIG MAN!

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#9

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

john lucas

>John I think you nailed it. When you answer a question who knows how many others you help. I know this is true when I read posts. I didn't ask the question and consequently don't need to answer but I do learn from many of them. A good example was Al's answer to cutting screw threads. I didn't ask that question but boy did I have fun reading the responses. I think I did respond to that one. I think I'm more interested in whether the response I gave was actually useful to the person I tried to help. Not necessarily looking for a thank you just hoping that I actually gave useful advice.

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#10

Bingo!

Carole Valentine

>I try to say thank you or at least acknowledge replies to my questions in some way, but I am sure I am guilty of forgetting sometimes. I am always fiddling with my preferences and on occasion, I simply lose the thread if it's more than a few days old. It doesn't mean I appreciate it any less. Like JKJ, the thing that bugs me the most is when a newcomer pops in, asks a question then disappears without out another word. Even then I am sure someone benefits from the replies. I have found that the older I get, the easier it is to shrug off minor annoyances like this. Life is just too short.

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#11

Thank You

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Russ, for all the posts current and archived that I have read of yours, I graciously say thank you :)....I do make it a point to read your responses here on the forum as they are usually full of great survival tips for learning and getting better at what we all love to do.

Jen

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#12

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

Gil Jones

>I agree with your intent, Wally, though sometimes I ask a question and by the time I get back to see the answer, I cannot find that string. There may be a way to search for it, but ???

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#13

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Wally,

Yes I agree....some times I think it's just that some people forget to come back, but I have a 24 hour thing, at that time I think I have gained as much exposure to an answer as possible and usually summarize and make my thank you's then.....

Most peopel are curtious here, part of the reason why WC is my Forum home...

Take care,

Jim

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#14

finding threads

JKJ in East TN

>>I cannot find that string. There may be a

>way to search for it, but ???

Gil,

I lose threads all the time, but I hunt for them with the browser rather than the forum search feature. I set the preferences to display a sufficient number of messages, press Ctrl-F, and search for my initials JKJ or some word I remember being in the thread. If looking for responses to my posts, searching from the bottom up is easier since each hit will be at the top of the screen and I can see any follups below.

There is another, perhaps better, way to keep up with important threads, at least in Windows/IE (I don't Mac). In the upper frame, right click on any message title in the thread that you want to follow, then right click and choose "Copy shortcut". Then right click on the desktop or in some folder, right click and choose "Paste shortcut." This will make a shortcut linking to that thread. (Making a folder on the desktop just for these thread shortcuts is handy) Then to check the thread, just double click on the shortcut.

JKJ

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#15

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

George Van in WI

>Wally, and all others that respond, as I said at the Dessert Roundup, I hope that you never got the feeling that any of your responses went unappreciated. I too may have inadvertently missed acknowledging help but I try not to. Living in a remote area, I did not know what direction to �turn� when I found this site, even the videos and the books and magazines I now read for information were recommended on this site and from PM from members of the site. I like the fact that the people who post regularly take the time to respond and give the best advice they are capable of giving if they have knowledge on the subject.

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#16

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Some interesting replies. I think that what prompted me to make this post was that some time ago, a post with a question, was addressed specifically to me. I answered the question at some length. I received no reply or acknowledgment that my answer had even been read. Kind of ticked me off.

Wally

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#17

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>No one likes to get taken for granted. If they specifically asked for you and they didn't reply, I think that is just plain rude. My manners aren't always the best, but my momma did teach us to thank others for their help.

Tom

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#18

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Thanks for that thoughtful response, John. I know I didn't ask the question, but I have read and appreciated all the responses. Thanks also to Wally for bringing this important issue to our attention.

When I see a question on any WC forum from someone I do not recognize, especially a not very well thought out question, my first impulse is to ignore it, because I figure there is not much chance my response will be read or understood or acknowledged. However, I often change my mind when I realize that my answer will be read by several others, and it might help some of them.

Comments and thanks are always appreciated, but when you have been doing this for a long time, you sometimes have to settle for the feedback you get from one simple statistic: the number of times people have read your response.

Maybe we need to put a short "Community Policy Statement" at the top of the "Post Response" page. What should it say? Maybe it could include something like,

"This is a community. We are real people who are here to help you. Please treat us with respect, by reading our responses, and thanking us if we have helped you. We also appreciate real names, your general location, and even an e-mail address that you will read. "Thanks in advance" is not the way to get the help you need, nor is hiding behind a cute nickname. If you want to be known by your nickname, just write it at the end of the message, instead of in the Your Name field."

JKJ, we know who you are, and we know why you don't use your real name, due to possible confusion with another big name Tennessee turner, so you are excused. Similarly, everyone on one or another of the other Forums knows BugBear, Chico and several others by their nicknames, because they have been members of the online woodworking community for so long and have so consistently contributed.

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#19

Re: finding threads

Gil JOnes

>I know there is a search function here, which I used to no avail (and for a good reason). The question that I asked was directed to Carole Valentine, and was about buffing Waterlox finish (I mistakenly thought that Waterlox was a water-base finish). As it turns out, Carole kindly answered my question on the WoW site, which is exactly where I had asked it, and not on WC, where I THOUGHT I had asked it. This problem seems to be caused by a few too many birthdays on my part.

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#20

Re: Thank you one and all.......

Chris K in MD

>There are private messages here? what am I missing?

I always try to say thanks, if I miss someone I am sorry for it. In some cases I try not to post multiple times on a thread. This thread made me post more replies to the thread I started then ever before.

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#21

Re: Thank you one and all.......

Rick Davenport

>Wally sent me a detailed explanation via my e-mail address.

Thanks again Wally.

Rick

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#22

Re: Thank you one and all.......

Chris K in MD

>Whew thanks for keeping me sane! Thought I had really missed something there...

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#23

not the other John Jordan

JKJ in East TN

>>JKJ, we know who you are, and we know

>why you don't use your real name, due

>to possible confusion with another big

>name Tennessee turner, so you are excused

Thanks! I'd much rather use my name (not ashamed of it in the least), but I got so many emails and so much confusion. It didn't help that we are both the same age and both live in TN. I was even careful to always use my middle initial, but that didn't help.

Some people wanted to reminisce about old times, say how much they enjoyed some event or demonstration, a couple wanted to come visit, some asked turning questions, one was really ticked about something!

And not just here - when I first went to a turning club meeting one person asked me twice to confirm I wasn't the John Jordan from Nashville. I always told them that besides other distinct differences, he charges $8000 for a turning while $8 would be too much for one of mine.

Maybe I should use my full name occasionally and with a disclaimer, but heck, that's a lot of trouble.

John K Jordan, enjoying life and turning just for fun here in East TN

Re: Another Pet Peeve....

#24

ebd

Re: Another Pet Peeve....backwards

ebd

>What bugs me is when someone asks an explicit question and posters don't bother to answer the question (did they even read it?) but instead stroke their own egos with a reply that doesn't even relate to the question.