Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

Posts

Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#1

Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

Barry Irby

>There has been much debate about sharpening bandsaw blades. I just did one (105" 3tpi) in about fifteen minutes by touching the outer surface of each tooth with a cut off wheel on a Dremel. It takes me more than fifteen minutes to change the blade. So I did it in "no" time. My stupid question is.....

What would happen if you set the Dremel to just barely touch each tooth and turn the blade back wards by hand so the teeth would sort of flip past the wheel? Might have to have a soft wheel such as a sanding disk.

My first thought was to turn the blade inside out and run it in effect upside down and stone the teeth with a sharpening stone. The problem with that is it would require removing and flipping the blade and then removing and flipping it back right. Way too much time.

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#2

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

RussFairfield

>You will still have to pull the grinding disc back away from each tooth after grinding it. The back rake at the top of the tooth and the cutting face have to intersect at a sharp angle. Anything that "flips" across the teeth will drag over the tip and round it slightly, and making it a sharper duller tooth.

I use a Dremel too with a little right angle attachment on the end. That allows me to touch the top of the tooth with a little twist of the wrist at each tooth. That is a lot smoother and faster motion for me.

I began sharpening this way by thinking that I had to swing the grinder from side to side to keep it perpendicular with the set of the tooth. This proved to be a waste of time, and holding the grinder disc perpendicular to the blade for every tooth, regardless of which direction it was set, worked just as well.

There is less chance of breaking the disc if you put 2 discs on the Dremel mandrel.

As for the time it takes to grind the tops of 315 teeth (105" X 3tpi), I can do a blade in about 8-minutes, and can grind the blade 2 times before I have removed enough set from the teeth to render the blade useless. - There was a guy here a couple years ago who claimed that he could do a blade in 2-minutes and get 8 sharpenings on a blade. Doing either is an impossible dream to me.

I remember a long discussion that was on the Main Board several years ago on how good it was to pull the blade backwards while holding a stone flat against the blade. The only reason for doing it by hand was to avoid the safety hazard of the moving blade. Without thinking about what I was doing, I tried it, and it didn't work. If anything the blade was duller than before. And it should be, because I was grinding a flat across the top of the tooth, removing the back rake, and making a duller tooth. The longer the stone is held to the blade, the wider the flat on top of the tooth, and the duller it gets. Someone will have to draw me a picture if they are getting a different result.

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#3

What Russ said and ...................

Ruth Niles

>I've sharpened a lot of blades a lot of times. I found, exactly what Russ said, I don't have to angle the Dremel to sharpen the blade really good. What I did just learn from Russ is to use two cut-off blades so they don't break as easily. Thanks, Russ.

I remember that guy saying he could do one in 2 minutes and I'd love to watch him do it. I have 103" blades and it takes me more than 8 minutes, probably closer to 20 min. but for the cost of a new blade, that's fine. The 4 tpi are a tad bit more work.

I also tried cutting 60 grit sandpaper because someone once said cutting sandpaper sharpened scissors. It doesn't work for either. At least it didn't work for me.

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#4

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

Jim King

>Sorry for the bad photo , I just found it in an old file. This is a band mill blade being sharpened and the flat wheel just touches the inside of the tooth and with each pass deepens the throat the same amount that the heigth of the tooth was reduced. These blades start at 10 inches wide and are resharpened several times daily until they reach about 4 inches wide and are then cut and rewelded to size for the resaw . After each sharpening the teeth are set. I dont know if this will help or not , a bit different scale but the same theory.


img

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#5

What type of disc are you using?

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#6

Re: What type of disc are you using?

david

>My understanding is that the discs are the thin cutting discs that are available(50 pcs.in a small cylinder package)for the Dremel and Proxxon type tools. The flat part of the discs is used as the abrasive surface and hits nearly parallel to the TOPS of the teeth. At least that is the method promoted by Stephen Russell. The flat discs are easily broken, and the next time I attempt this, I will certainly try two discs at a time as Ruth said she learned from Russ. Jim King's post said that the bottom of the teeth was sharpened on that large blade.

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#7

Thanks

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#8

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>It may be useful to flatten all the tips evenly in preperation for actual sharpening, as in the old process of "jointing" a handsaw with a stone. Then use the Dremel to grind the back edge of each tooth until the flat spot disappears. I've not tried it yet, but would think this makes the bandsaw blade cut more efficiently, if all the teeth are even.

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#9

I'm having a brain fart, can someone

Doug Littlejohn

>post some sort of pictures or drawings that show what you're talking about here?? I just can't seem to get just what you folks are talking about on just how you are sharpening the teeth.

Thanks,

Sherwood

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#10

Re: Does this help??

RussFairfield

>Here is a picture for those who don't know what we are talking about.

This might be the worst possible way to sharpen a bandsaw blade. The teeth can be uneven, it is taking away the set, and it changes the tooth profile. But, for a blade being used for cutting wet wood for bowl blanks, it's cheap, it's fast, and it cuts better than some of the new blade that we can buy.


img

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#11

Re: Does this help??

john lucas

>Russ I don't know if I can describe what I do but it works for me. I use a sort of cone shaped abrasive wheel and hit each gullet doing all the left facing ones first and then the right facing teeth. Then I go back and hit the topside of each tooth tilting left or right depending on the set. This doesn't take very long, never timed myself, but it seems to work well. I don't mess with it anymore because my local source is so cheap it's easier to replace the blade but sometimes you need to finish a job on a Sunday and your on your last blade, well you know the rest. I like your flat wheel for the outside of the tooth. I'll give that a try. My method probably changes the profile of the blade but since I would only do this once or twice it's not enough to matter.

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#12

I kind of do it as Ken says

Don Henthorn

>except that I don't flatten the tips. I made a jig that fastened to my work bench that would hold about twenty inches of blade in a vertical poistion with the teeth and gullets sticking out. Then I used a chainsaw type sharpening stone to lightly follow the gullets down and up to the tip. By doing it lightly and continuing the motion straight up after passing the tip i was able to get a good sharp tooth without rounding over. A little pratice and I could get quite a few sharenings out of blade. However there is caveat to tryng to prolong blade life too long. As the blade ages it also becomes brittle and will break more often. I silver soldered broken blades but after they get so brittle it is better to send them the band saw blade grave yard and get another.

Re: Really Stupid Bandsaw Sharpening Question

#13

Ric Taylor

Russ, Thank You Thank You !!

Ric Taylor

>