Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

accident with glove

Posts

accident with glove

#1

accident with glove

JKJ in East TN

>There were discussions here once or twice about the safety of wearing a glove while turning.

A gentleman in our woodturning club tonight displayed his bruised and swollen hand along with a beautiful ambrosia maple turning that was shattered on one side.

He said his hand was getting hot while reaching inside to sand so he put on a glove to continue. The wood caught the glove and whipped and twisted his hand around hard enough to smash the turning and break out a large segment which appeared to be 1/2" thick or so at the bottom. This piece looked like it would be hard to break with a hammer. I don't think he broke any bones but I think he said he dislocated a finger joint and certainly smashed his entire hand up pretty bad. The hand and all fingers appeared swollen. After several days he's starting to move some finger again but with a lot of pain.

This gentleman is a very experienced and creative award-winning turner, careful and safety conscious. He stood up and told the story as an example of, in his own words, a very stupid thing to do.

A good reminder.

JKJ

Re: accident with glove

#2

Re: accident with glove

Bill Dotten

>My finger is still stiff a year after I wore rubber gloves to apply a friction finish to a spindle turning. the finish turned tacky with friction, wound the glove into a tight spiral and jammed my fingers.

It happened in a flash. Now I may wear a vinyl glove to carefully finish a spinning bowl but not a spindle or narrow vase.

Re: accident with glove

#3

Re: accident with glove

RussFairfield

>I am sorry this message didn't get any traction.

My personal opinion is that, anybody who sticks their hand inside of a spinning piece of wood while wearing a glove is a damn fool, not an experienced woodturner.

Our previous discussion about gloves stressed that the fingers, whether gloved or bare, should never be put between the spinning wood and the tool rest.

Re: accident with glove

#4

Re: accident with glove

David Breth

>In December, or January, I was working on a bowl, and put on a golfing glove that was in the basement. It was the first time I had ever done so, and I did it because this bowl was so dry and unbelievably hot that, for the first time, I couldn't take it anymore. I did so while working on the exterior of the bowl only, and then took it off for the interior. I've probably done so two or three times since.

So - recognizing that it isn't a safe practice - what, if anything, can be done to alleviate the hand-burning?

David B.

Re: accident with glove

#5

Re: accident with glove

Scott C

>Duct tape. Just enough to cover the spot that's taking the heat.

Re: accident with glove

#6

Turning with glove vs sanding with glove

T Daniel

>A while back we dicussed wearing gloves while roughing the outside of a piece to prevent discomfort caused by bark and hot chips hitting our forward hand; we emphasized that the gloves be tight fitting leather gloves without a loose cuff; we never suggested sanding the inside of a vessel with gloves. Personnally, I feel that if the sanding paper is getting too hot to hold then the lathe should be slowed down. Russ's suggestion of folding the sandpaper 3 time(3 layers) is a good one. In his video he suggests that if you feel heat through 3 layers of paper then you are sanding too fast.

Re: accident with glove

#7

Re: accident with glove *LINK*

JKJ in East TN

>>Our previous discussion about gloves stressed that

>the fingers, whether gloved or bare, should never

>be put between the spinning wood and the tool rest.

I was thinking mostly about the "Turning Glove" thread Oct 22 '05 which did mention that but had a wider scope. The link is below for anyone interested.

Dawn Adams was injured by a splinter and wanted general discussion about the safety aspects of wearing gloves while turning. Some people reported wearing gloves without problems (the old anecdotal evidence), some cited safety rules (OSHA and others), and some had injury stories. One person made the distinction between tailstock and faceplate turning. (BTW, the accident I mentined above was with a large bowl/vessel, the opening perhaps 4" in diameter.) Some had the opinion that woodturning was a high risk activity, and using a glove was just another aspect to be considered. There were discussions of the relative hazards of cloth vs leather vs rubber gloves.

Some discussion was about snagging a glove with a chuck, some was more concerned with catching a cloth glove on rough wood, and one guy (hey, it was you!) gave the good advice to not get fingers caught between the work and the tool rest, glove or not!

I thought it was an excellent discussion and like all safety topics, worth reviewing on occasion. The gentleman at the club last night had decided that he will no longer wear gloves while turning.

JKJ


"Turning glove" thread

Re: accident with glove

#8

Re: Turning with glove vs sanding with glove

JKJ in East TN

>>...if the sanding paper is getting too hot to hold...

Another thing that one guy recommended which seems to work well: cut a small square of foam abrasive pad (such as Scotchbright) and fold a strip of sandpaper around it. The pad makes a good insulator and conforms nicly to the curves.

However, I don't use this method. I agree with you - if it gets hot, slow the lathe down. Even better, I tend to do most of my sanding with the lathe turned off so I can sand with the grain instead of round and round.

JKJ

Re: accident with glove

#9

Re: accident with glove

georgetroy

>We have had accident reports over a period of time even by a so called old pro like me. Hope I didn't start anything with my red eye special saying wear your helmut or else. I do wear a golf glove on my left hand. Glue chips and splinters hitting it is no fun. I do not wear a glove while sanding. Even then that right hand has been beat many more times than I hate to admit. We are all working with machines that can cause injury and take risks when we shouldn't. We are responsible for our own actions, and sometimes those actions are not the best choices. Safe turning all. GT

Re: accident with glove

#10

Re: accident with glove

albertabob

>"Good judgment comes from experience, and a lot of that comes from bad judgment." Will Rogers

I thought this was appropriate in the light of discussing this topic agian.

Perhaps we need to determine what uses are appropriate before we go on to condemn the practise.

Bob

Re: accident with glove

#11

Did you see the GLOVE?

Keith Newton

>JK, it is hard to make me wince, but this did. I would like to know more about the nature of the piece. Was it a smooth round opening, or was it irregular. If it was smooth and round, I can see how the heat of sanding could cause a check to start and the splinter of one side could pierce any gloved hand.

Did the glove get caught on top, or back-side? If it was just a matter of the opening closely matching the size of the hand, and the force of the friction causing it to suddenly ride up then jamb into the limited space, it really doesn't matter whether he are wearing a glove or not. I am not sure that blaming the glove with the buckshot approach is the right way to go here, if the same thing could happen to a bare hand.

He is lucky he didn't loose a hand. sometimes we may do things that we should not do, and things go wrong. It is good that he was willing to share his mistake with the club, but if he misdiagnosed the cause, then nobody benefits by learning from his mistake.

I think it would be great for you to post photos of the broken turning, the glove and the hand.

Re: accident with glove

#12

Re: Did you see the GLOVE?

JKJ in East TN

>Keith,

I didn't have my camera, but I'll call and ask if he can send a picture of the piece and more information. I'm like others here - I want to learn as much from the bad judgement of someone else rather than my own experience! I'll certainly think twice before putting my hand in a rotating cavity, glove or no glove.

I didn't measure and I'm not good at estimating dimensions, but I'm guessing the vessel was maybe 14-16" in diameter, perhaps 5-7" high. It was beautiful ambrosia maple and a lovely form, narrowing to perhaps 4" or so at the opening. The outside, inside, and lip appeared smooth to me and the outside appeared either finished or final sanded. The lip was not flared. It looked like there was plenty of clearance for hand and wrist in the opening, but I'll try to find out if the catch was in the opening, inside the lip, or what. I thought he said the glove caught inside the lip, but I was in such empathy shock I may have misunderstood. (Talk about wincing!) He did say this accident happened two days earlier and the swelling was starting to go down a bit.

Since a large chunk of the turning was missing out of one side, it was easy to see the thickness profile. He was a little embarassed by the lack of uniform wall, which was thin at the top and much thicker nearer the bottom. The injury could have been much, much worse if the top had been as thick as the bottom.

The gentleman very much wanted everyone to learn from his mistake so I suspect he'll gladly give us more info. I didn't want to mention his name, but perhaps he would be willing to visit here and post directly to get the facts straight.

JKJ

Re: accident with glove

#13

Didn't see the glove...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>did see the hand. He's lucky he didn't break some bones.

My understanding of the incident is that the opening was just small enough that he had burned his hand a couple of times while trying to sand under the rim. Thus, the glove.

Evidently, he had just started to sand with the glove on when it got jammed up in the opening, whipped his hand around and knocked the side out of the form. The side wall was at least 1/2" thick where it broke, so you can imagine the force that his hand absorbed. The worst part was when he related how he had to reset his index finger which had dislocated at the middle joint. That finger was green last night. Ouch!

Gary

Re: accident with glove

#14

Re: "Green"!!!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Gary,

You'd best get hold of your friend and make sure he's getting real medical attention immediately if he doesn'r want to lose that hand or possibly the arm. Too often people don't know they have peripheral circulatory problems until an injury like this tips over into gangrene with little or no warning. What you guys are describing sounds like a very serious injury.

I use an open-finger glove for some rough turning, but never for sanding. In fact, if the abrasive is uncomfortable to hold, it means that you're pressing too hard. But reaching inside a spinning hollowform to sand the interior just seems a bad idea to me, glove or no glove. If I had to sand the interior of a piece, I'd do so with a flap-wheel on a stick or by hand OFF THE LATHE. Wouldn't stick my hand in a blender either, and it's about the same thing.

Hope you friend heals okay.

M

Re: accident with glove

#15

Re: accident with glove

Rick Davenport

>Man that hurts my hand just thinking about it!

It sounds like this guy should see a doctor as soon as possible.

Being a knife sharpener in the daytime, I bought large quantities of Costco bandaids just in case.

I seldom cut myself while sharpening, but now I use the bandaids (the cloth, stretchy kind) on my index finger while sanding.

It gives me a bit of abrasion protection on my digit and I can still feel it if the heat builds up so I can back off on the speed or pressure.

I still have a couple hundred more before I run out.

Rick

"Life shouldn't be dull."

Re: accident with glove

#16

Re: accident with glove

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Re: your comment on left hand vs. right hand. I mostly do spindle turning. Sometimes I hold the tool handle with the left and and guide the cutting edge or dampen vibrations with the right hand. I often reverse hands, sometimes without even thinking about it, holding the handle with the right hand, and guiding with the left. It depends on the cut. I know some people are strongly right handed, and can't even think about doing that, but since I'm left handed and lathes are designed for right handed people, I get along the best I can.

Sometimes, I pick up sand paper or ScrotchBrite pad without thinking much about changing tools. For me, ever wearing a glove on either hand I feel is way too dangerous. For the same reason, before I turn on the lathe, I roll both sleeves up tight, well above my elbows.

Re: accident with glove

#17

Re: "Green"!!!!

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Mark,

When I say green, I mean it was the color of a two day old black eye. A greenish tinge around the edges. You could tell it was well bruised.

Gary

Re: accident with glove

#18

Keith Tompkins

Gruesome! warning

Keith Tompkins

>This is a true incident...I did not post about it previously because it is truly gruesome. It does show why we call machines "power tools." A woodworker where I worked was operating a drill press while wearing work gloves, despite warnings that it was unsafe...he did this for YEARS. He realized the error of his ways when his glove contacted the 1/2" diameter drill bit.

The glove was instant wrapped around the bit, and his thumb peeled back to his elbow. He spent eight hours in surgery...he still has the thumb, but it doesn't work.

Re: accident with glove

#19

Re: Gruesome! warning

JKJ in East TN

>...his thumb peeled back to his elbow

Yeowll. Reminds me of some tractor PTO stories I've read about and heard from eyewitnesses. Except there is usually no need for surgery afterwards.

Thanks for this illustration. I appreciate the reminder about my perfecly safe and happy little drill press. As we become overly familiar with our machines, we (at least I) tend to think of them more as shop furniture and concentrate more on what they are doing to the material than on what they can do to the flesh.

JKJ (who once drilled through his finger with a cordless drill)

Re: accident with glove

#20

Drill Press?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Do you mean:

DRILL PRESS: A tall upright machine useful for suddenly snatching flat metal bar stock out of your hand so that it smacks you in the chest, then exposes the outer tendons of your left thumb for easy daylight inspection, and finally flings your beer across the room.

That Drill Press?

Re: accident with glove

#21

"The Glove Man"

Ralph Watts

>Yep, the goofball who was sanding with a glove... More of the story:

I have been using a tight fitting smooth leather glove for some time while sanding the outside and inside of open bowls--without any problem. I also use a glove on my left hand, as do many others while turnig wood that flings things at you. I have a drill with extension rod and 2" round disk that I mostly use for the bottom of bowls. I also have a homemade set of wood forcepts in which I grip a sponge wrapped with sandpaper for the insides that are difficult to reach. These items work quite well but neither is very useful for sanding the underside of an almost flat top opening.

I started sanding the inside lip bare handed but a light touch of the rim on the heal of my hand made me want to protect myself from a burn. So, I put on a glove and continued to sand the inside. As I sanded toward the center, my hand got too far in and the rim grabbed the glove about the middle of the heel. One quick spin and out it came through the side of the bowl. I'll try to post a picture tomorrow.

Bottom line... I'm going to make a curved set forcepts so I can reach anywhere inside. No glove use while sanding for me. However, It might be possible to make a glove that would not catch but is probably best to simply not stick your hand inside a spinngin thing. I'll leave the glove experiment to someone else.

Brusing is going down, color is a light shade of green with overtones of blue and purple. It only hurts when I try to bend the disjointed joint beyond 90 degrees... not a real big deal but I'm lucky

Re: accident with glove

#22

Re: "The Glove Man"

Keith Newton

>Ralph,,,,, Man as bad as this was, I think you were darn lucky. When I first read about this incident, I assumed that there was a split or a splinter that grabbed the glove, but then I started wondering if it was just a matter of putting your hand into too tight of an opening that if the drag of the paper torqued your hand up and back into a jamb situation which just gets worse the farther it rotates. It happens so fast you can't react fast enough to just turn loose. I have scolded myself harshly a few times, knowing how easily it could happen.

I am not so sure that the glove should be taking the rap here. Without the glove, it could have been worse. You may have been faced with the skin and tendons getting torn away along with the dislocation of joints.

Re: accident with glove

#23

Re: "The Glove Man"

Ralph Watts

>Keith,

The glove probably did prevent any flesh cutting but the glove was made of a soft, pliable, and slightly tacky leather (work gloves from Sams). That makes for a far more grabby situation than bare skin. I was simply hoping that no one else had the same experience.

Re: accident with glove

#24

Re: "The Glove Man"

Ralph Watts

>Here is a pic of the "hand formed bowl". The bowl is about 12" dia and 5" tall. It was a lousy turning anyhow--way to thick on the bottom.


img

Re: accident with glove

#25

Re: "The Glove Man"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ralph,

There was a somewhat spirited running discussion here or on the AAW forum about using a glove for turning. I, as the proponent of limited glove use, was much in the minority. While I would not use a glove like you did, your experience argues for me to reexamine my position.

I truly hope you make a full recovery.

Mark