We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>How long should a 1/2", 3 TPI Timberwolf blade cut before it gets dull to the point where you really have to struggle with the cut?
I just used one for most of one day and a little while on two others before I was having problems with a 6" piece of green hackberry. Granted, the blade is designed for green wood and I used it to rip some fairly dry cherry into 2's and 3's to start out, but it hasn't lasted half as long as the McMaster Carr 1/4", 4 TPI that it replaced.
The saw is an old Delta 14" with riser. The guides are new CoolBlocks and thrust bearings which were carefully adjusted when the blade was installed. The blade was tensioned according to the manufacturer's instructions and is riding on new blue urethane tires.
If this is the performance I can expect from a premium blade, I may have to switch back to the generic variety for half the price.
>Gary I have gotten "lemons" before in blades. The teeth can be sharpened easily with a dremel tool and a flat cutoff disc. Just touch the top of the hook gently and you can get many more hours of cutting. I have resharpened 3-4 times before junking the blade. Dennis
>You didn't mention whether you increased the motor HP or not. Believe it or not, but a seriously under-powered tool will dull a tool prematurely. When everything else about the cutting geometry for the wood is correct, a saw tooth needs to take a large enough chip for the chip to take the heat generated by the cutting action out with it. If you can't because of under-power, the kerf becomes so hot that you destroy the temper of the tooth, making it softer. You know how it goes, you start having to feed slower and slower, pitch starts building on the side of the teeth, which increases friction, smoking starts, and the blade is toast.
I have an old 36" saw which had a 5 HP motor on it when I got it. It cut pretty good up to about 10", and I used it that way for about 15 years, and finally got around to replacing with a 7.5 HP motor. OH my-gosh what a nice difference that 2.5 HP made. I can only cut 16" under the top guide, but while studying the change, I found that a general rule of thumb is to have 1 HP for each 2" of thickness that you plan to cut.
To put this in another perspective, if you have a 1/2 HP motor on your saw, I can cut 14" at about the same speed as you can one inch with the same blade, as long as there is a deep enough gullet to clear the chip on the thicker cut.
Tannowitz, by the way puts a 10 HP on their 36" BS but they will cut about 20 - 22" of thickness.
>it's the silica that dulls the blades. Some wood has a lot more silica than others. Sycamore that grows near water will dull blades very fast. Some cedar has a lot of silica. The other thing that affects blade life is "set". The teeth for green wood have a lot of set. If you make tight turns with a blade you will reduce the set in the teeth which will make it cut slower. Keep the wood moving as you make a turn...if you stop moving the wood and turn you will straighten the set from the teeth. My blades are lasting a lot longer since I stopped letting anyone else use my bandsaw. Now, my students watch me saw and they can go home and practice with their own blades. My current blade has been on my saw for at least 6 months.
>What Dennis said is true.I use those blades-I get three or four sharpenings on them.You only have to hit one little spot of dirt to take off the edge.
>Gary I quit fiddling with the premium blades. I can buy blades from a local sharpener for $6 and they seem to last me a pretty good while. Granted I don't come anywhere near cutting the volume you do but I ruined 2 expensive blades when they got caught in a green chunk. The cheap blades don't bend as easily and seem to cut quite well. They don't resaw anywhere near as good as the good blades but then I don't do very much of that.
I was hoping to get a several more blanks out of this thing before I had to resort to the dremel. It's a good thing I traded for this blade instead of paying cash. I'd really be steamed.
I'm running a 1.5 HP Baldor. It seems to have plenty of oomph for what I'm cutting. I had tried to get a 3/8" blade instead of the 1/2", but they didn't have one available at the time. I know the smaller the blade, the less power to pull it through the wood.
I was looking hard at that 5HP 3PH motor in the classifieds the other day. With a VF drive, I could cut metal occaisionally if the need arose.
I've been cutting cherry, spalted pecan, slippery elm, ash, black locust, hackberry, river birch and box elder. All were green except some of the cherry. The dry cherry has the pencil figuring though. Maybe the penciling is caused by silica?
I probably won't be doing much resawing, either. I've gone through most of the 2" and 3" cherry that I had. I think it's back to the cheap seats for me. 8^]
By the way, thanks for the handout you sent me. It's just what I was looking for.
T Daniel, Is this your experience, or a manufacturer's recommendation? Maybe this is true for some specific blades or those with very little set. I've seen a variety of recommeded minimums but never that large for a 1/2" blade. I've personally cut many 7" diameters with my usual 5/8" blades (even cut 6" diameter but that takes more care, especially when the wood is green and very thick).
Here are some references:
Bandsaw Handbook (Duginski), pg 87: minimum radius for 1/2" blade is 3 inches (6" diameter). Same data (and same diagram) on the back of a Woodcraft blade in my shop.
On an Olson AllPro blade box in my shop, minimum radius chart: 2-1/2" (5" diameter) for 1/2" blade. This is the same recommendation in Lonny Bird's book "The Bandsaw Book" (pg 74).
A General power tool web page (http://www.general.ca/pagemach/acces_g/bandsaw.html) indicates 1-1/4" minimum radius for a 1/2" blade (which is hard for me to believe), but reminds us that "Specifications on minimum cutting radius are given as guidelines only and may vary depending on type and thickness of material."
I've read other advice that a wider blade can give more control in the cut. For example, Lonnie Bird states: "So why not just mount a narrow blade and cut all curves with that? The difficulty is that cuts tend to wander more with narrow blades." Another author described how the back of the blade can be used against the kerf to "steer" and steady the cut. (Sorry, I can't find the reference right now)
>Anytime that you twist the blade you risk changing the set in the teeth of the blade. If you make a quick correction after wandering off the cut line or whatever you can bend the teeth. The bandsaw books are written primarily for people doing flat work, sawing dry wood at max thicknesses of under 4" usually, and quite frequently those do not saw to the line all the way around an endgrain piece of wood. We must remember, turners do things with bandsaws that bandsaws were not designed to do. Example: when sawing an endgrain log to make a goblet there will be an area where you will be sawing in alignment with the grain structure. This will load the blade with long fibres and the blade will appear to be dull until you begin crossing growth rings at which time it will suddenly clear itself and start cutting again. Pushing hard at the time that you are sawing parallel with the growth rings will damage the blade. This is equivalent to ripping a log with a chainsaw with the chainsaw parallel to the bark. The long fibres just will not eject from the gullets of the teeth. To observe this better just put a log in your bandsaw mill 90 degrees to the way it would normally be sawn and try cutting.
>I used to believe the books and tables printed on the band saw blade boxes and all I got was a bunch of frustration.
It's a pretty straight forward geometry problem. The minimum radius is a function of the blade width (front of teeth to back of blade), the blade thickness and the kerf width (which is determined by the set of the teeth). With the current popularity of narrow-kerf blades, the minimum radius had changed drastically for the worse.
Another item, many books say to position the circle-cutting pivot at the front of the teeth. That is aboslutely 100% dead wrong. The optimum position is about 1/3 of the way back (measured from tooth edge to back of the blade). This is the same geometry problem. The solution isn't exact (unless you're better with trig than I am), and requires iteration to get a more precise solution.
Try sketching the problem and solving it yourself. It's really not that bad.
Good advice all around. Forcing things, either by pushing or trying to cut a too sharp of a curve can't be good for the machine or the blade. Usually the machine will let you know immediately. For wandering off the line, rather then force it I either back up carefully and recut or just contine at a tangent out the side of the blank and then start again.
I think Brian's comment about narrow kerf blades is a good one. The amount of set changes everything.
BTW, I finally broke down and bought a Starrett blade tension gage which came today. Although I haven't yet had any trouble cutting sharp radii in thick green wood, I was surprised at how much too low my tension was set. After putting in new spring from Itura and better tensioning, my first cuts were encouraging. I hope to test more tomorrow.
Good observation on kerf width. A question for you: in your note on sharpening last August, you said you were "still working" on refining a technique for setting teeth, citing problems with hard and brittle teeth breaking. Do you have further experience and advice on this? When setting teeth for cutting thick green wood, do you widen the set?
Do you have any updates on your sharpening technique, for example, do you still grind off every other tooth of a 3tpi blade for resawing? How about for thick green wood?
You note on the optimum pivot point is very interesting. I cut by hand, usually with a 5/8" blade, but I've wondered about the pivot point. I'm trying to visualize the geometry and what factors determine the optimum position - besides the blade width, does the pivot position not also depend on the amount of the set? Can you possibly post a quick diagram?